Third gender
제3의 성
Third gender, or third sex, is the category of people classed, by themselves or by society, as neither men nor women. Many gender systems recognise three or more genders rather than two. Common examples are the hijras of South Asia, the muxes of Zapotec Mexico, the fa'afafine of Samoa and fakaleiti of Tonga, and the bakla of the Philippines; gender diversity among Indigenous North Americans is sometimes grouped under "two-spirit", a term coined in 1990. These names differ in meaning and history from place to place and resist being folded into one concept. In nineteenth-century Europe Karl Heinrich Ulrichs and Magnus Hirschfeld described homosexuals as a "third sex". British colonial authorities registered and policed hijras as "eunuchs" under the Criminal Tribes Act of 1871, and today countries such as India, through a 2014 Supreme Court judgment, legally recognise a third gender.
In depth
What does "third gender" refer to?
Most cultures have a gender binary of men and women, but many societies recognise a third or fourth gender. "Third" here usually means "other" rather than a rank, and some societies have fourth and fifth genders. Some, like the māhū of Hawai'i and Tahiti, describe an intermediate state between man and woman; others involve special ceremonial roles. The examples below have separate histories, and the circumstances of one region should not be generalised to another.
Who are the hijras, and how did the colonial authorities treat them?
In South Asia, hijras are transgender, intersex or eunuch people who live in communities following the guru–chela (teacher–disciple) kinship system; in Pakistan they are also called khawaja sira. Most were assigned male at birth; few are intersex. Their identity originates in ancient Hinduism and evolved under the Delhi Sultanate and the Mughal Empire.
From the 1850s the authorities of British India tried to end hijra practices, which they saw as "a breach of public decency". The historian Jessica Hinchy describes the response to trials following the 1852 murder of a hijra as a "moral panic". Although hijras could already be prosecuted under "Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code", the authorities of the North-Western Provinces wanted a "special law" against them. The result was the Criminal Tribes Act 1871 (Act XXVII of 1871), titled "An Act for the Registration of Criminal Tribes and Eunuchs". Its Part II defined as a "eunuch" any person of the male sex who admitted to being, or on medical inspection appeared to be, impotent, and required registers of their names and property. Section 26 punished a registered eunuch
Any eunuch so registered who appears, dressed or ornamented like a woman, in a public street or place, or in any other place, with the intention of being seen from a public street or place.
The same section made dancing, playing music or performing in public or for hire punishable with arrest without warrant and up to two years' imprisonment. Registered eunuchs could not keep a boy under sixteen, act as guardian of a minor, or make a will or gift or adopt a son. The category "eunuch" lumped together many often unrelated communities, such as hijras, khwajasarais and kotis, because they did not fit British ideals of masculinity. The Act was repealed in 1949, but provincial laws using the same language survived it.
What are some examples elsewhere?
In the Zapotec culture of Juchitán in Oaxaca, Mexico, a muxe is a person assigned male at birth who adopts aspects of feminine gender roles in dress, behaviour and social standing. Muxes are commonly defined as a third gender, neither male nor female, and muxe identity also involves preserving Zapotec culture and customs.
The fa'afafine ("in the manner of a woman") of Samoa are natal males whose femininity emerges in early childhood; they enjoy relatively high acceptance across Samoan society. They have campaigned to repeal laws introduced under New Zealand colonial rule, and the Crimes Act 2013 decriminalised female "impersonation". The fakaleiti ("in the manner of a lady") of Tonga are likewise people assigned male at birth who express a feminine gender identity.
In the Philippines a bakla is a person assigned male at birth who has adopted a feminine gender expression and is often considered a third gender. In the pre-colonial Philippines feminised male shamans (asog) held high status, but during three centuries of Spanish rule (1565–1898) the Catholic Church persecuted shamans, and in the 17th and 18th centuries those convicted of homosexual relations were burned at the stake.
"Two-spirit" is an umbrella term for Indigenous North Americans who fulfil a traditional third-gender role in their communities. It was coined in 1990 at an inter-tribal gay and lesbian conference held near Winnipeg and is not found in the historical record. Its purpose was to distinguish Indigenous concepts of gender from those of non-Native lesbians and gays and to replace the pejorative anthropological term "berdache". It is not meant to replace the names Indigenous cultures already use in their own languages, and it is not accepted in all Native cultures.
What was the European theory of a "third sex"?
In nineteenth-century Germany Karl Heinrich Ulrichs described the "Urning", a female psyche in a male body, as a third sex in booklets of 1864–65 (see "Urning"). Later in the century Magnus Hirschfeld, John Addington Symonds, Edward Carpenter and others described homosexuals as an "inverted" or "intermediate" sex and argued for their social acceptance (see "Theory of sexual intermediaries"). For much of the twentieth century "third sex" was a common term for homosexuals and gender nonconformists, but after the gay liberation movements of the 1970s, as sexual orientation and gender identity came to be distinguished, it fell out of favour.
How does the law recognise a third gender today?
From the late twentieth century hijra activists sought official recognition as a third gender. Bangladesh recognised hijras as a third gender in 2013 without defining the term. In National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India (NALSA, 2014) the Supreme Court of India declared transgender people a "third gender", held that the fundamental rights of the Constitution apply to them equally, and gave them the right to self-identify as male, female or third gender. On 21 December 2007 the Supreme Court of Nepal, in Sunil Babu Pant and Others v. Nepal Government, ordered the government to legislate to protect LGBTI people, and the 2015 Constitution included the right to a citizenship certificate in accordance with one's gender identity. India, Pakistan and Nepal offer a third-gender option on passports and some official documents.
Legal recognition is not the same as liberation. Mauro Cabral of the human rights group GATE warned that if only trans or intersex people can enter the third category, or are compulsorily assigned to it, the gender binary grows stronger, not weaker. Research in India has also found that the hijra community continues to be shut out of its rights by bureaucratic gatekeeping since the NALSA judgment.