Transgender Marxism
트랜스젠더 마르크스주의
Transgender Marxism is a current of theory and activism that uses Marxist concepts to explain the oppression of transgender and gender-nonconforming people and the way to their liberation. The name became established with Transgender Marxism, a collection edited by Jules Joanne Gleeson and Elle O'Rourke and published by Pluto Press in 2021. Before it came Leslie Feinberg of the US Workers World Party, whose 1992 pamphlet Transgender Liberation: A Movement Whose Time Has Come used "transgender" as a political umbrella term for everyone who crosses gender boundaries, and whose Transgender Warriors (1996) argued that transphobia arose with class society. The current today links questions such as the exclusion and hyper-exploitation of trans workers and the unpaid community care that makes transition possible to social reproduction theory, and overlaps with family and gender abolitionism.
In depth
What did Feinberg argue first?
Leslie Feinberg joined the Workers World Party in her twenties and long worked on the party paper Workers World. The pamphlet Transgender Liberation: A Movement Whose Time Has Come, published by the party in 1992, was one of the first works to use "transgender" in an expansive sense and gave the word a new "political charge". Feinberg used it as an umbrella term not only for people who change the sex assigned to them at birth but for everyone who challenges traditional ideas of sex and gender.
Transgender Warriors: Making History from Joan of Arc to Dennis Rodman (1996) extended the pamphlet's research into a popular history. Feinberg held that gender-nonconforming people had been considered sacred in religions around the world, and argued that transphobia developed alongside classism, patriarchy and homophobia as class societies concentrated wealth and power among wealthy men. The evidence offered included Joan of Arc's execution specifically for cross-dressing, the importance of cross-dressing in peasant rebellions and festivals, and the central place of trans people in Germany's Scientific-Humanitarian Committee and in the Stonewall riots. The book was well received in the LGBTQ community, but many reviewers found its historical analysis lacking in rigour.
What did Transgender Marxism (2021) cover?
The collection edited by Gleeson and O'Rourke is thought to be the first full-length publication of its kind. It contains fourteen essays, an editors' introduction and an afterword by Jordy Rosenberg. It puts forward no single theory or Marxist tradition, gathering instead the trans Marxist debates the editors had seen spreading through activist circles, book clubs, social media and zines. Two lines of inquiry stand out.
The first is work. Michelle O'Brien's "Trans Work" argues that non-normative gender expression excludes queer people from work, constrains the industries where they can find it and makes work dangerous. Kate Doyle Griffiths argues that trans workers are overrepresented in the sectors of social reproduction (domestic, health, sex and educational work) and are positioned to connect workplace organisation and social movements around class demands.
The second is social reproduction. Drawing on Gleeson's work, Noah Zazanis argues that transition is made possible by a community's informal, unpaid labour, for which Marxist analysis is particularly well suited. Nathaniel Dickson examines how trans people must prove their transness to parents, doctors and judges, and writes that interventions in the production of gender are admitted only if they leave intact the "integrity of gender" that capitalism needs. The editors close their introduction:
Our end is not just a more rigorous understanding of our social afflictions, but fuel for the abolition of what has long been intolerable
How was it received and criticised?
Reviewers credited the book with the first sustained union of trans studies and Marxist theory. The review in Tempest named as a weakness the very limited empirical data on trans work and lives, against which the theoretical advances stand unsupported. The review in Lateral suggested a genealogical project linking the current to earlier traditions such as Wilhelm Reich's "Sex-Pol" essays (1929–34).
The more fundamental objection within Marxism and feminism comes from the gender-critical side, which holds that women's oppression is rooted in biological sex, that sex cannot be changed, and which rejects the concept of gender identity. How the two sides use "abolition" in opposite senses is covered under "Gender abolition"; the debate within the Marxist movement as a whole is covered under "Transgender".
Can it be read in Korean?
A search of the Korean bookseller Aladin finds no Korean edition of Transgender Marxism or of Feinberg's books; the Korean titles in this entry are our own translations.