Xi'an Incident
시안 사건
The incident of 12 December 1936 in which Zhang Xueliang of the Northeastern Army and Yang Hucheng of the Northwestern Army seized and detained Chiang Kai-shek, chairman of the Nationalist government's Military Commission, at Xi'an in Shaanxi and demanded an end to the civil war and resistance to Japan. Zhou Enlai of the Chinese Communist Party took part in the negotiations and the Comintern ordered a peaceful settlement. Chiang was released on 25 December, and the incident halted ten years of civil war between the Kuomintang and the Communists and opened the way to the second united front.
In depth
Zhang Xueliang was the son of the Manchurian warlord Zhang Zuolin; after losing his base to Japan in the Manchurian Incident of 1931 he was put to fighting the Communists under Chiang Kai-shek. When the Red Army reached northern Shaanxi at the end of the Long March in October 1935, Zhang's 130,000-strong Northeastern Army and Yang Hucheng's 40,000-strong Northwestern Army were sent against it under the Northwest Bandit Suppression Headquarters at Xi'an. Both armies were beaten in several major engagements. The Red Army treated its prisoners well, gave them a political education and sent them back to say that the Communists wanted an alliance against Chiang and against Japan. The offer struck home with officers and men whose homeland Japan had taken. On 9 April 1936 Zhang met Zhou Enlai at Yan'an.
The Communists' own line was changing. In the summer of 1935 the Seventh Congress of the Comintern formally adopted the united front against fascism, and the CCP delegation under Wang Ming issued the August First Declaration. The party leadership, cut off from radio contact with Moscow during the Long March, learned of this only in November and at the Wayaobu conference in December called for "the most broad national united front". Chiang, however, was still not included. On 15 August 1936 the Comintern criticised as unrealistic the CCP's plan for an anti-Chiang, anti-Japanese base in the northwest and ordered it to seek a united front under Chiang's leadership. The CCP adopted the new slogan of "compelling Chiang to resist Japan".
Chiang came to Xi'an in early December to press the campaign. On 9 December thousands of students demonstrated against Japan and the gendarmes opened fire. When Chiang gave Zhang an ultimatum, attack the Communists or be transferred, Zhang decided to arrest him. Before dawn on the 12th a Northeastern Army unit stormed the Huaqing hot springs where Chiang was staying. Chiang climbed a wall and fled up the hill behind, where he was caught in the morning, while Yang's troops seized the provincial government, the gendarmerie, the police and the airfield in Xi'an. The two generals telegraphed Nanjing and the whole country with eight demands: reorganise the Nanjing government so that all parties share responsibility for saving the nation; stop all civil war; release the patriotic leaders arrested in Shanghai; free all political prisoners; guarantee the people's freedom of assembly; guarantee the right to organise patriotic bodies and political freedom; carry out Sun Yat-sen's will; and convene a national salvation conference at once.
At Bao'an the CCP leaders at first proposed to put Chiang on trial as a traitor. In Nanjing He Yingqin argued for an immediate attack on Xi'an, while Soong Mei-ling and Kung Hsiang-hsi campaigned for a negotiated settlement. What decided the matter was Moscow. Pravda and Izvestia condemned the incident as a plot by "pro-Japanese elements". Stalin feared that executing Chiang or holding him captive would make the Nationalists more likely to align with Japan or fall to it. Chiang's most likely successor, Wang Jingwei, had just met Hitler to discuss China's joining the Anti-Comintern Pact. On 16 December the Comintern sent a telegram instructing the CCP to bring the incident to a peaceful conclusion. On the 17th the CCP announced that it desired a peaceful settlement, and on the 18th it withdrew its call for a trial.
Zhou Enlai reached Xi'an late on the 17th and joined the talks with Bo Gu and Ye Jianying; Soong Ziwen and Soong Mei-ling came from Nanjing. Chiang was released on 25 December without signing the demands. Three days later Mao Zedong stated that the terms Chiang had accepted were six: to reorganise the Kuomintang and the National Government, expel the pro-Japanese group and admit anti-Japanese elements; to release the patriotic leaders in Shanghai and all other political prisoners and guarantee the freedoms and rights of the people; to end the policy of "suppressing the Communists" and ally with the Red Army to resist Japan; to convene a national salvation conference representing all parties, groups and armies; to co-operate with countries sympathetic to China's resistance; and to adopt other ways of saving the nation. Zhang, who accompanied Chiang to Nanjing, was sentenced to ten years by a court-martial on 31 December and, though the sentence was commuted, was kept under house arrest for more than half a century, until 1990. The Northeastern Army surrendered in February 1937 and was dispersed to Hebei, Hunan and Anhui. Yang Hucheng, who went into exile and returned, was arrested and was killed in September 1949.
At a plenary session of its Central Executive Committee the following February the Kuomintang formally rejected the eight demands and put four conditions to the Communists: dissolution of the Red Army and of the "Soviet Republic", an end to communist propaganda, and the abandonment of class struggle. Japanese-language accounts record that this session resolved on the extermination of the Communists. Yet the ceasefire held and talks between Zhou Enlai and Chiang went on through the spring. In late September 1937, after the war with Japan had begun, the second united front was formally concluded, and on 22 September the Red Army became the Eighth Route Army. The alliance also changed the conditions of the Korean movement in China proper: in October 1938 the Korean Volunteer Corps was founded at Hankou on the initiative of Kim Won-bong and the Korean National Revolutionary Party.
The repercussions in Japan were large too. The first report of the incident came from Matsumoto Shigeharu, Shanghai bureau chief of the Dōmei news agency, which led Stalin to suspect Japanese involvement. On 14 December the navy minister reported the incident to the emperor together with a policy of restraint and watchful waiting. Japan's diplomacy, which had been urging China towards "joint defence against communism", collapsed, anti-Japanese feeling rose across China, and a clash between the two countries became unavoidable. Ozaki Hotsumi, an Asahi Shimbun journalist and Soviet agent, correctly predicted that Chiang would survive and an anti-Japanese national united front would be formed; this brought him to the notice of Konoe Fumimaro and into Konoe's Shōwa Research Association. Hu Shih later said that without the Xi'an Incident the Communist Party would soon have been extinguished.