Anatoly Vasilyevich Lunacharsky

Анатолий Васильевич Луначарский
Soviet Union state institutions Marxism–Leninism Soviet Union Russia 1875.11.23.–1933.12.26. ○ Natural causes

Russian revolutionary, first People's Commissar of Enlightenment, and literary critic

On 15 November 1917, eight days into his post, Lunacharsky resigned over reports that bombardment during the storming of the Kremlin was destroying St Basil's Cathedral. The next day he withdrew the resignation after the commissars judged it inappropriate, and stayed in office until 1929.

Born in 1875 in Poltava. His adoptive father Vasily Lunacharsky, from whom his surname and patronymic derive, is described as a nobleman of Polish origin, though no basis exists to assert Lunacharsky's own Polish ethnicity. He entered the Social-Democratic movement in 1895 while studying in Zurich, returned to Russia in 1898 to work for the Moscow committee of the RSDLP, and adhered to the Bolsheviks in 1903. After the Bolshevik leadership condemned god-building and removed Bogdanov in June 1909, he taught at the party school on Capri and co-founded the Vpered group at the end of that year. In 1917 he passed through the Mezhraiontsy and after the October Revolution became the first People's Commissar of Enlightenment, serving until 1929. Elected to the USSR Academy of Sciences in 1930, he died in 1933 at Menton, France, while preparing to take up the post of ambassador to Spain.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

Bolshevik and Idealist, 1898–1907

Lunacharsky's idealism did not arise in the years of reaction. In the preface to Religion and Socialism he said its basic ideas had taken shape in his youth and were first aired publicly in the 1898 lecture "Idealism and Marxism". In 1904 he contributed "Foundations of Positive Aesthetics" to the Russian Machists' collection Essays in a Realist Worldview.

He was at the same time at the core of the Bolshevik faction. In 1904 he went to Geneva and joined the editorial boards of Vpered and then Proletary, and at the Third Party Congress in 1905 he gave the report on armed insurrection. By his own account Lenin was irritated by his "philosophy of revolution" but felt that the group stood with both feet on an uncompromising proletarian position in politics.

Mikhail Lifshitz therefore rejected the textbook scheme of a Bolshevik of 1905, a fall in 1908 and a return in 1917 as contrary to the facts. In his account the Lunacharsky of these years carried two currents at once, a Bolshevik who held idealist views throughout.

God-Building — The Temptation of Revolutionary Religion

Lunacharsky's most controversial intellectual adventure was God-Building (богостроительство). In the two-volume Religion and Socialism (1908–1911) he argued that Marxism itself harboured a kind of 'religious' sensibility (a sense of cosmic solidarity, a divinization of collective humanity) and that the proletariat should not simply destroy the old God but worship the collective power of humankind itself. It drew on Feuerbach's religion of humanity, the empirio-criticism of Avenarius and Mach, and Nietzsche's idea of the creation of values. In the 1908 collection Studies in the Philosophy of Marxism, written with Bogdanov, Bazarov and others, he spoke of the "deification of the higher human potentialities" and of "religious atheism". In Materialism and Empirio-criticism, published in 1909, Lenin attacked this as a case of Machism, neutral on religion, ending in the service of fideism; Lenin's arguments are set out in the God-Building entry. The philosophical collision soon became a political rupture. In June 1909 the enlarged editorial board of Proletary declared God-Building a trend breaking with the foundations of Marxism and removed Bogdanov from the faction's leadership. At the end of that year Lunacharsky formed the Vpered (Forward) group with Bogdanov and taught workers at the party schools on Capri and in Bologna, pursuing an independent programme of revolutionary cultural education. By the First World War he had gradually retreated from God-Building, but his philosophical turn came far more slowly. In 1923 he still reissued "Foundations of Positive Aesthetics" with a note that the old view seemed right to him, and in 1925 he wrote in his memoirs: "Even now in aesthetics I remain more a pupil of Avenarius than of any other thinker." His formal statements about his earlier views came in the last period of his life. Yet the God-Building era's core insight (that revolution is not merely a political and economic transformation but a rebirth of the human spirit, with culture as its medium) left a deep imprint on his cultural policy as Commissar of Enlightenment.

Commissar of Enlightenment — Architect of Cultural Revolution

Lunacharsky served as People's Commissar of Enlightenment from 1917 to 1929, laying the foundations of Soviet cultural and educational policy. He oversaw the literacy campaign (Likbez), school reorganization, and the nationalization of museums, theatres and publishing, keeping Soviet cultural policy open between avant-garde experimentation and preservation of inherited culture. Under his principle that 'culture belongs to all working people,' he funded avant-gardists like Malevich and Mayakovsky with state money while also taking charge of protecting the inherited treasures. In party debates he was closer to Bogdanov's Vpered group, yet retained Lenin's trust. He died in 1933 shortly after being appointed ambassador to Spain.

Protecting the heritage could not be taken for granted at the time. The titles of his newspaper articles of the 1920s show it: "Why Do We Preserve the Bolshoi Theatre?", "Why Do We Preserve the Romanov Palaces?", "Why Do We Preserve Church Valuables?" At a plenum of the Moscow Soviet in 1928 he said half in jest: "Everyone accuses me of protecting museum valuables." A company with twenty million dollars of capital formed in the United States in early 1918 to export Russian art, but the sale never took place. Mikhail Lifshitz judged that during his tenure, civil war and famine included, the Russian people lost a comparatively small part of their cultural treasures.

His response to attacks is judged in the same light. According to Lifshitz he was under constant attack, especially after Lenin's death, and one ultra-left theatre even mocked the commissar's private life. He did not answer with administrative measures, and for having no taste for using the stick in culture he was suspected of softness.

After Narkompros: Academy, Diplomacy, and the Last Years

In autumn 1929 Lunacharsky was removed from the post of People's Commissar of Enlightenment (held from October/8 November 1917 to 12 September 1929) and appointed chairman of the Academic Committee under the USSR Central Executive Committee, a demotion from the center of the cultural policy he had built for twelve years. On 1 February 1930 he was elected an Academician of the USSR Academy of Sciences, and in the early 1930s he directed the Institute of Literature and Language of the Communist Academy and the Institute of Russian Literature (IRLI) of the USSR Academy of Sciences, and served as one of the editors of the Literary Encyclopedia.

His late publications include Vladimir Mayakovsky, Innovator (1931), George Bernard Shaw (1931) and Maxim Gorky (1932); his best-known work was the memoir collection Revolutionary Silhouettes, portraying Lenin, Trotsky and eight other revolutionaries. He wrote dozens of articles on music and literature through 1925–1933, but a sharp worsening of his illness that threatened complete loss of sight occupied much of 1932, when he wrote nothing on music.

He avoided taking sides when the party split after Lenin's death, and almost became embroiled by accident when Revolutionary Silhouettes (1923) included portraits of Trotsky, Zinoviev and Martov but failed to mention Stalin; he also offended Trotsky with a remark at the Bolshoi Theatre. From about 1927 he was losing control over cultural policy to Stalinists such as Leopold Averbakh. In September 1933 he was appointed plenipotentiary (polpred) of the USSR to Spain, a post he could not reach owing to ill health; he was also deputy head of the Soviet delegation to the League of Nations disarmament conference, and in December 1933 died of angina en route to Spain at the French resort of Menton. His body was cremated and the urn placed in the Kremlin Wall; the Russian source dates the Spanish posting 20 August – 26 December 1933.

Sources conflict on the exact date of death. Russian and English sources agree on 26 December 1933, but the Ukrainian Wikipedia infobox prints 26 January 1933 while its own body text says he died in December of that year. The December date has source support; the January date stands as a documented alternative or error.

His posthumous trajectory was uneven. Burial in the Kremlin Wall was a rare honour in the Soviet era. During the Great Purge of 1936–1938, however, his name was erased from the Communist Party's history and his memoirs were banned. A revival came in the late 1950s and 1960s, when memoirs reappeared and many streets and organizations were named in his honour, and the Soviet intelligentsia came to view him as an educated, refined and tolerant Soviet politician.

The Last Turn: "Lenin and Literary Studies"

Lifshitz held that Lunacharsky's thought found its place only in the early 1930s. After the experience of Soviet culture in the 1920s and a new study of Marx and Lenin, "Lenin and Literary Studies", first printed in the Literary Encyclopedia (1932), showed a rare grasp of Lenin's philosophical legacy. When the late-1920s scheme of "proletarian psycho-ideology" collapsed, he sympathized deeply with the turn to the national and world classical tradition.

What came next, Lifshitz adds, he did not live to see: new one-sidedness replacing the old, up to the revival of antiquated historical lumber. The sentence "Who knows how his fate would have turned out had he lived a few years more" says what could be said in the USSR in 1967.