コミンフォルム批判 · 1950.01.06–18

Cominform Criticism of the Japanese Communist Party (1950)

코민포름 비판 (1950)

The Cominform Criticism was the attack made on Sanzō Nosaka's theory of "peaceful revolution under the occupation" by the commentary "On the Situation in Japan", published on 6 January 1950 in the Cominform organ For a Lasting Peace, for a People's Democracy!, together with the upheaval it caused in the Japanese Communist Party. The commentary said the theory glorified American imperialism and had nothing to do with Marxism-Leninism. The party split over whether to accept it into the Shokan and Kokusai factions.

In depth

The commentary and the "Views"

The commentary targeted Nosaka's description of the occupation forces as an "army of liberation" and his claim that a peaceful transition to socialism was possible even under occupation. The Japanese Communist Party had defined the Allied forces as an "army of liberation" in its action programme of 1946, and Sanzo Nosaka had been saying that revolution could be achieved peacefully through parliament. The commentary rebuked part of the party for failing to fight for the withdrawal of American troops and for independence although Japan was completely subordinated to the United States.

The party at first took the report for a fabricated foreign dispatch. On 8 January the Central Committee and the Control Commission issued a statement saying that if such foreign telegrams were to be believed, Comrade Stalin would already have died twenty times. But once it was confirmed, the Politburo replied on 12 January with its "Views on 'On the Situation in Japan'", arguing that the commentary did not take sufficient account of conditions in Japan. Kenji Miyamoto and others objected to this reply and attacked Kyuichi Tokuda and his group as right opportunists and nationalists.

Why at this moment

The Cominform was the information bureau of European communist parties, and the Japanese party was not a member. That its organ nonetheless took up Japan reflected the change in Asia. The People's Republic of China had been founded in October 1949, and at the trade union conference of Asian and Australasian countries held in Beijing that year Liu Shaoqi had held up the road of the Chinese revolution as the model for liberation movements in colonial and dependent countries. A line that spoke of peaceful revolution in a Japan under American occupation did not fit this current. Few dispute that the commentary followed Stalin's wishes, and one reading is that it was meant to change the Japanese party's line ahead of the Korean War, which began half a year later.

The intervention of the Chinese Communist Party

When the Chinese Communist Party's People's Daily backed the Cominform on 17 January and demanded that Nosaka criticise himself, he did so on 18 January and accepted the criticism in full. The People's Daily article, "The Road to the Liberation of the Japanese People", followed Liu Shaoqi's report in saying that parliamentary struggle was only an auxiliary means in revolution. Criticised by both the Soviet and the Chinese party, the party mainstream changed its stance and "recognised the positive significance" of the criticism. The Chinese party went on involving itself in the Japanese party's internal strife. On 3 September the People's Daily published an editorial saying that now was the time for the Japanese people to unite and fight the enemy, which in effect was a call to rally under the mainstream's Provisional Central Leadership.

The split and the armed struggle line

But the conflict between the mainstream around Kyuichi Tokuda, which had stood by the "Views", and Kenji Miyamoto and others, who had urged acceptance, was not resolved, and the JCP treats the affair as the starting point of its "1950 Problem". When the occupation authorities purged the whole Central Committee from public life on 6 June 1950, Tokuda and Nosaka went underground and then crossed to China, where they set up a leadership in Beijing. In February 1951 the mainstream, under Soviet and Chinese direction, held the Fourth National Conference and adopted a military policy, which the Cominform endorsed in August. The 1951 Programme adopted by the Fifth National Conference in October defined Japan as a semi-feudal, colonial country subordinated to American imperialism and held that the national liberation democratic revolution could not be achieved by peaceful means. It was a definition that carried the experience of the Chinese revolution over to Japan. The party formed Mountain Village Operation Squads and Core Self-Defence Squads and took to struggle with Molotov cocktails, but it lost support and lost all its seats in the general election of 1952.

Koreans in Japan

Half a year after the commentary the Korean War broke out. Japan was the rear base of the American forces, and the Japanese party's military line was closely bound up with that war. Korean communists living in Japan were then members of the Japanese Communist Party. The United Democratic Front of Koreans in Japan, formed after the League of Koreans in Japan was dissolved in 1949, carried on legal activity together with the party, while the illegal Fatherland Defence Corps joined the Mountain Village Operation Squads and Core Self-Defence Squads in direct action to block the transport of war supplies bound for Korea. Around the time the Japanese party gave up the armed struggle line in 1955, the Korean movement in Japan parted from it and founded the General Association of Korean Residents in Japan.

Afterwards

The Sixth National Conference of 1955 criticised the armed struggle line as ultra-left adventurism and reunited the party. The experience of a single criticism from abroad splitting the party and changing its line became the ground on which the Japanese Communist Party later proclaimed a line of independence, refusing interference from either the Soviet or the Chinese party. The line took firm shape in the mid-1960s, as the Sino-Soviet dispute deepened.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. oisr-org.ws.hosei.ac.jp
  2. ja.wikipedia.org
  3. ja.wikipedia.org
  4. ja.wikipedia.org
  5. ja.wikipedia.org
  6. ja.wikipedia.org
  7. ja.wikipedia.org
  8. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  9. ja.wikipedia.org
  10. ja.wikipedia.org
  11. Wikipedia (KO)