Literaturny Kritik and the 'Current'
《문학비평가》와 ‘흐름’
Refers together to Literaturny Kritik (The Literary Critic), a monthly journal of literary theory and criticism published in Moscow from 1933 to 1940, and to the group of critics who gathered around Mikhail Lifshitz and György Lukács in its pages. Opponents called the group the "Current", the Techenie. Against the vulgar sociology of the 1920s they defended classical realism and the value of the great heritage, but they faced political accusations in 1939–1940, and the journal was closed by a Central Committee resolution in 1940.
In depth
Why did a criticism journal become history?
Some journals close after a few years and are still talked about long afterwards, because the people gathered there asked the questions of their time differently. Literaturny Kritik (Литературный критик) was such a journal. After the Central Committee resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" of 23 April 1932, which dissolved RAPP (the Russian Association of Proletarian Writers) and other literary groups, it was founded in Moscow in 1933 as a monthly of literary theory, criticism and literary history. Its first editor was the philosopher Pavel Yudin.
This entry covers the journal together with the people gathered around it. Where this dictionary's entry "Marxist Aesthetics (Lifshitz)" covers Lifshitz's thought, this entry covers the group and the struggles in which that thought appeared in Soviet letters of the 1930s.
Who belonged to the Current?
In the 1930s literary critics and scholars gathered around Lifshitz: Vladimir Grib, Vladimir Aleksandrov (born Keller), Yelena Usievich, Igor Sats and others. The writer Andrei Platonov was close to them too and published several articles in the journal. Opponents called the group the "Current", in Russian Techenie (Течение), and Lifshitz later used the name himself, with irony.
Оппоненты называли этот круг «Течением». Его печатным органом стал журнал «Литературный критик» (1933—1940).
At its centre was the collaboration of Lifshitz with György Lukács, the Hungarian philosopher who came to Moscow at the end of 1929. Lukács published a series of essays on realism in the journal. From 1936 to 1941 a supplement for reviews and criticism, Literaturnoe obozrenie (Литературное обозрение), also appeared.
What did they argue?
The Current's enemy was the vulgar sociology that dominated Soviet art theory in the 1920s. Vulgar sociology saw works as codes concealing the author's class interests and found the task of criticism in deciphering and exposing them. Of this tendency Lifshitz wrote: "This literature was consistent to the point of madness." The Current held, on the contrary, that great writers go beyond the limits of their class and reflect the truth of reality. Lenin's calling Tolstoy, in "Leo Tolstoy as the Mirror of the Russian Revolution", was often used as the ground. Lifshitz's 1936 "Leninism and Art Criticism" is counted a decisive text in this debate.
Эта литература была последовательна до безумия
So they set classical realism such as Balzac, Tolstoy and Shakespeare high and were sceptical of 1930s Western modernism. The debate Lukács waged at about the same time in German exile journals, criticising Expressionism, belongs to the same line. At the same time they kept their distance from the embellished heroics promoted by the official literary establishment. Their high regard for Platonov's prose is an example.
Why were they attacked?
In September 1939 the critic Vladimir Yermilov published "On the Harmful Views of Literaturny Kritik", opening the decade's second great literary debate. The occasion was Lukács's book Toward the History of Realism, edited by Lifshitz. The attackers did not hesitate to use political charges, accusing the group of justifying Thermidor and of departing from Marxism and Leninism.
С сентября 1939 г. разворачивается вторая литературная дискуссия десятилетия
The accusations also went to party bodies. On 10 September 1939 Yermilov wrote to Andrei Zhdanov, and on 10 February 1940 the Writers' Union secretaries Alexander Fadeyev and Valery Kirpotin sent the Central Committee secretaries a report "On the Anti-Party Group in Soviet Criticism". On 9 March Yermilov sent another report to Stalin and others. In these documents Lukács, Lifshitz and Usievich were named as an anti-party group that collaborated with Platonov and spread hostile views. After Yermilov's denunciation, Platonov's book of criticism was destroyed in 1939.
How did it end?
In 1940 the Central Committee issued the resolution "On Literary Criticism and Bibliography", which required all literary and socio-political journals to have criticism and bibliography sections and closed Literaturny Kritik. The Great Soviet Encyclopedia gave this administrative reorganisation as the reason for the closure, but scholars on Lifshitz's side see the decision as the outcome of the series of denunciations. Afterwards Lifshitz was increasingly isolated, and Lukács returned to Hungary in 1945. Grib died in March 1940, shortly before the closure.
«Л. к.» был закрыт по постановлению ЦК ВКП(б) «О литературной критике и библиографии» (1940)
How is it judged?
Judgements differ. Since the 1960s some Western and Soviet scholars have seen the Current as a rare voice that defended the humanist heritage against vulgar sociology and bureaucratic criticism in the middle of the Stalin era. Other scholars criticise their aesthetics, with classical realism as its standard, for having in the end propped up the official norms of socialist realism and for having become a ground for rejecting the avant-garde and modernism. That the first editor, Yudin, was a philosopher who made his name in the campaign against the Deborinites also shows that the journal did not stand outside the system. The Current was a group that fought the system's received ideas from within the system, and both sides need to be seen together.