Philosophical Notebooks
철학 노트
Lenin's posthumous collection of extracts and notes made, mainly during the First World War, while reading Hegel, Feuerbach, Aristotle and others. It appeared as a single book in 1933, after his death. The conspectus of Hegel's Science of Logic and "On the Question of Dialectics" are at its centre. Unlike the earlier Materialism and Empirio-criticism, many of its notes stress knowledge as a dialectical process, and it strongly influenced the dialectics debates of the Soviet Union and China and the interpretation of Lenin.
In depth
Why did Lenin read Hegel in wartime?
In 1914–15, in the middle of the First World War, Lenin was in exile in Bern reading Hegel's Science of Logic. Why so difficult a book at so urgent a moment? The answer depends on how these notebooks are read.
The notebooks were not written with publication in mind. Reading books, he copied passages, added "NB" or exclamation marks in the margins, and jotted down passing thoughts. So they are hard to read as systematic claims, and sentences break off or end in question marks.
What do they contain?
First gathered in one volume in 1933, the book contains conspectuses of The Holy Family; Feuerbach on Leibniz and on religion; Hegel's Science of Logic, Lectures on the History of Philosophy and Lectures on the Philosophy of History; Lassalle on Heraclitus; and Aristotle's Metaphysics. Standing somewhat apart is the short piece "On the Question of Dialectics", a relatively finished draft, which can be read in this site's translation. The conspectus of the Logic is the longest and most influential.
Which notes are most often quoted?
The first links Capital and Hegel. "Aphorism: It is impossible completely to understand Marx's Capital, and especially its first chapter, without having thoroughly studied and understood the whole of Hegel's Logic. Consequently, half a century later none of the Marxists understood Marx!!"
Нельзя вполне понять «Капитала» Маркса и особенно его I главы, не проштудировав и не поняв всей Логики Гегеля. Следовательно, никто из марксистов не понял Маркса 1/2 века спустя!!
The second concerns the core of dialectics. "On the Question of Dialectics" says that the splitting of a single whole and the cognition of its contradictory parts is the core of dialectics. This phrase was later taken up in China as "one divides into two" and became a foundation of "On Contradiction". The same piece refuses to dismiss idealism as simply false and calls it a "sterile flower" on the living tree of knowledge.
The third is the relation of logic to the theory of knowledge. Lenin noted that "logic is the doctrine not of the external forms of thought but of the laws of development of 'all material, natural and spiritual things'", and left the idea of the identity of dialectics, logic and theory of knowledge: what are usually divided as three branches of philosophy are in fact one science. Soviet philosophy used this idea widely.
Логика есть учение не о внешних формах мышления, а о законах развития «всех материальных, природных и духовных вещей»
The fourth is practice. "Practice is higher than (theoretical) knowledge, for it has not only the dignity of universality but also of immediate actuality." This note carries the discussion of "Criterion of practice" further.
Практика выше (теоретического) познания, ибо она имеет не только достоинство всеобщности, но и непосредственной действительности.
How do they differ from Materialism and Empirio-criticism?
Scholars often set the two works against each other. The book of 1909 presses the point that the world lies outside consciousness and puts "Reflection theory" forward. The notebooks picture knowledge as a process of contradiction and movement, and even leave the bold note that "human consciousness not only reflects the objective world but also creates it". Here interpretations divide.
One side holds that there was a real change. Kevin Anderson argues that in these notes Lenin broke with the crude materialism of his generation and of his own earlier work, as part of rethinking his old categories in the face of the break-up of the Second International. The other side stresses continuity. The Russian account presenting the notebooks as a "direct continuation" of Materialism and Empirio-criticism, the earlier book focused on the theory of knowledge and the later on dialectical method, reflects that view.
How were they used later?
Interpretation of the notebooks was itself a battlefield. According to an English-language summary it played a major role in the Soviet "Mechanist" debate of the 1920s and in China's "One Divides into Two controversy" of 1964. Lenin's word that Hegel must be studied suited the Deborin school with its Hegelian emphasis, and after that school's condemnation the notes stayed on as citations of official philosophy. The Russian philosopher Subetto judges that Lenin was first to put forward the concept of the "core" of dialectics, while Kessidi regards the promotion of the struggle of opposites as a result of politicizing philosophical categories.
This entry treats the whole volume. The conspectus of the Logic can be read separately in this site's translation.