Philosopher of the not-yet: thinker of concrete utopia and human emancipation in The Principle of Hope
“The true genesis is not at the beginning but at the end, and it begins only when society and existence become radical, i.e. grasp themselves at the root.” — The Principle of Hope
German Marxist philosopher who formulated the philosophy of concrete utopia and the 'not-yet' (Noch-Nicht) in his magnum opus The Principle of Hope. Alongside Lukács, Benjamin, Adorno, and Brecht, he shaped a central current of Western Marxism. Moved to East Germany in 1949 to hold the chair of philosophy at Leipzig and received the GDR National Prize in 1955, but was forced into retirement in 1957 after the 1956 Hungarian uprising for his humanistic Marxism; defected to West Germany in 1961. His thought profoundly influenced liberation theology and the 1968 student movements.
Also known as: Ernst Simon Bloch · Karl Jahraus · Jakob Knerz
Activities and affiliations
-
1949–1957
East Germany state institutionsProfessor of philosophy, Leipzig UniversityMain
Education -
1953–1956
East Germany state institutionsCo-editor of the DZfPh journal
Scholarship and theory -
1961–1977
Germany state institutionsGuest professor at Tübingen
Education
Career Timeline
- 1905–1908Studies philosophy, physics, music at Munich and Würzburg; doctorate on Rickert
- 1912–1914In Heidelberg, associates with Max Weber, Simmel, and Lukács
- 1918Publishes The Spirit of Utopia — first major work
- 1920sFreelance journalist in Berlin; befriends Brecht, Benjamin, and Adorno
- 1921Publishes Thomas Müntzer as Theologian of Revolution
- 1933–1938Flees Nazi Germany for Switzerland, Austria, Czechoslovakia
- 1935Publishes Heritage of Our Times; analyses fascism's appeal through non-synchronism
- 1938–1947Writes the three-volume The Principle of Hope in US exile
- 1949–1957Chair of philosophy, Leipzig University; GDR National Prize (1955); Academy of Sciences
- 1957Forced into retirement for teaching humanistic Marxism after the Hungarian uprising
- 1961Defects to West Germany after Berlin Wall built; guest professor at Tübingen
- 1967Receives the Peace Prize of the German Book Trade
- 1968–1970sInfluences the 1968 movement and liberation theology; mentors Rudi Dutschke
The Not-Yet and Concrete Utopia
At the core of Bloch's philosophy lies the ontology of the "not-yet" (Noch-Nicht). For Bloch, being is not a finished substance but an open process constantly moving toward its own fulfilment, captured in the formula "S is not yet P" (S ist noch nicht P). The world is unfinished and carries the future within itself as objective possibility. Bloch finds this orientation toward the future even at the most fundamental layer of human consciousness. What he calls the "not-yet-conscious" (Noch-Nicht-Bewußtes) stands in direct opposition to the Freudian unconscious. If the unconscious is a storehouse of repressed past, the not-yet-conscious is the domain of expectation, longing, and dreams that have not yet been realised but push human beings forward. Everyone daydreams (Tagtraum), and these daydreams contain not mere fantasy but a practical drive to transform the world for the better.
For Bloch, utopia is not escapist illusion but "concrete utopia" (konkrete Utopie). Whereas abstract utopia ignores real contradictions and builds castles in the air, concrete utopia extracts the immanent tendencies and possibilities of reality itself and constructs an emancipatory prospect realisable within history. In this regard Bloch saw Marxism as the most complete theoretical expression of the utopian impulse. Socialism is not only scientific necessity but also the objective form of hope: the point at which humanity's oldest dream, that "a better life might be possible," finally rests on a rational foundation through historical practice.
Bloch's philosophy of hope is not simple optimism. Hope is not guaranteed fulfilment; the possibility of disappointment and betrayal is always open. What Bloch called "docta spes" (skilled or learned hope) is a practical attitude that soberly analyses history's objective tendencies while never missing the moments of possible liberation within them. Bloch's hope does not turn away from the world's dark realities; by facing them squarely, it seeks to discover the "Front" (history's sharpest point advancing toward liberation) even within that darkness. This thinking provided a deep philosophical foundation for late twentieth-century liberation theology (Moltmann, Sölle), critical theory, and the practical energies of the 1968 movements.
Defending Expressionism and the Aesthetics of Montage
Stripped of his citizenship in 1933, Bloch moved between Switzerland, Vienna and Paris and lived in Prague from 1936 to 1938. Meanwhile Heritage of Our Times, published in Zurich in 1935, shook the exiled intelligentsia. He diagnosed that the Nazis had absorbed the old dreams and rage of peasants, the petty bourgeoisie and the young, and argued that the left should not discard that energy but detach it and "remount" it in a new context. That year, at the International Writers' Congress for the Defence of Culture in Paris, he mocked the habit of praising a castrated, recipe-book realism as the only true realism. In 1936 he quarrelled in Internationale Literatur with Hans Günther, a disciple of György Lukács, and in Prague he published dialogues on avant-garde art and the Popular Front with the composer Hanns Eisler in Die neue Weltbühne.
When Alfred Kurella attacked Expressionism in Das Wort in 1937 as a forerunner of fascism, Bloch at first wrote to the editor Fritz Erpenbeck that he would stay out of the discussion. In June 1938, however, his "Discussing Expressionism" went past Kurella to aim at Lukács directly. Lukács had dealt with not a single Expressionist painter or composer; his premise of reality as a closed totality was itself doubtful; and if reality is discontinuous, montage and techniques of interruption might be precisely the methods faithful to it. Lukács answered in the same issue with "Realism in the Balance". The whole story is told under "Expressionism debate".
In the same years Bloch publicly defended the Moscow trials, which the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy calls paying tribute to the Stalinist hysteria. The stance badly strained several friendships, including his trust with Adorno, and Bloch later admitted in interviews that his judgement had been wrong. In 1938 he emigrated not to the Soviet Union, as Lukács had, but to the United States, where in isolation he began writing The Principle of Hope.
The Leipzig years and the forced retirement of 1957
Bloch took up the chair of philosophy at Leipzig in May 1949. He never joined the Socialist Unity Party. Grebing sees his relation to the regime as a kind of coexistence. For the regime he was a representative ally, and in 1955 it gave him the National Prize and Academy membership. Meanwhile The Principle of Hope appeared in 1954 and 1955, its third volume in 1959. In 1953 he started the Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie with Harich and others.
1956 was the turning point. According to Prokop he proposed with Harich and Klaus that March's conference on the problem of freedom, and, deeply ashamed by the secret speech, regretted having defended the Moscow trials in the 1930s. His last lecture, on 17 December, was on "Problems of the Further Development of Marxism after Marx". Two days later his Leipzig colleague Rugard Otto Gropp opened the attack in Neues Deutschland, criticizing him as an idealist. Following the arrests of the Harich affair, in 1957 he was forced into retirement for political reasons, not because of his age. His colleague Emil Fuchs and Fuchs's grandson Klaus Fuchs-Kittowski, among others, protested publicly.
The critical volume Ernst Bloch's Revision of Marxism, published that year, set Leninist reflection theory against his philosophy. Kurt Hager ranked him with Max Adler as revisionism of the "highest" level. When the Berlin Wall went up in 1961 Bloch was travelling to Bayreuth and did not go back. He became a guest professor at Tübingen and in 1962 was expelled from the East German Academy. Rehabilitation came on 16 November 1989.
The Theory of Art in The Principle of Hope
The Principle of Hope, published in East Germany from 1954, was also the finished form of Bloch's theory of art. He defined art as Vor-Schein, "pre-appearance": beautiful appearance is not a false illusion but a light cast ahead on an objectively possible better world. Art takes up the daydreams that rise from lack in life and drives their themes through to the end in figures, situations and landscapes, so that even a perfect work remains an incomplete one, holding what has not yet come. The concept is treated in detail under "Vor-Schein".
The book's theory of art does not stop at high art. "Wishful Images in the Mirror" in the first volume surveys shop windows and advertising, fairs and the circus, fairy tales and adventure stories, travel, dance and the theatre, reading the broken or living wishes in them. In the section on the stage he wrote positively of Bertolt Brecht; the American jazz dances of the years after 1930, by contrast, he condemned more harshly even than Adorno. The second volume treats utopias in architecture, painting, opera and poetry, the third music. Since The Spirit of Utopia Bloch had seen music as the most utopian art, and in this book he stressed more its power to transgress its own social context.
The theory continued after he came to West Germany. In 1964 he discussed utopian longing on German radio with Adorno, with whom he had long been estranged, under the theme "Something's Missing". In February 1971 he held a seminar in Tübingen on "appearance and pre-appearance in art". His writings on literature and art were gathered in 1988 in the English selection The Utopian Function of Art and Literature. The structure and reception of the whole book are treated under "The Principle of Hope".