The Indian Marxist who debated Lenin on colonial revolution
"You are so young! I expected a grey-bearded wise man from the East." — Lenin's first words to the 27-year-old Indian revolutionary upon meeting him at the Kremlin, 1920.
Indian revolutionary and political thinker from Bengal. Anti-colonial activity took him abroad, where he helped organize socialist and communist parties in Mexico. At the Second Comintern Congress he debated the colonial question with Lenin. He helped organize Indian communists in Tashkent and served as a Comintern representative in China in 1927. After breaking with the Comintern he returned to India and was imprisoned by the colonial authorities. He later joined Congress, founded an independent radical democratic movement and developed a philosophy of radical humanism centred on freedom and reason.
Also known as: Narendra Nath Bhattacharya · Naren Bhattacharya
Activities and affiliations
-
1927
CominternMain
Political and party leadership- Comintern representative during the Chinese Revolution1927Diplomacy and international organization
-
1936–1940
Social movements and organizing
Career Timeline
- 1917Co-founded the Socialist Party of Mexico, soon transformed into the Mexican Communist Party
- 1919Founded the Mexican Communist Party, the first communist party outside Russia
- 1920Presented supplementary theses on the colonial question at the 2nd Comintern Congress, debated Lenin
- 1920Founded the Communist Party of India (Tashkent group) in exile
- 1922–1929Member of the Comintern Executive Committee and Presidium; secretary of the Chinese Commission
- 1927Comintern representative during the Chinese Revolution
- 1929Expelled from the Comintern for siding with Bukharin's Right Opposition
- 1931–1936Arrested by British colonial authorities, imprisoned for 6 years on conspiracy charges
- 1940–1948Founded the Radical Democratic Party; supported the anti-fascist war effort
- 1947Published the New Humanism manifesto, articulating his Radical Humanist philosophy
Related historical events
- 1919–1921The founding of the CominternSupplementary colonial thesesDebated the colonial question with Lenin at the Second Congress.
- 1924–1927The first united front, the Northern Expedition and the catastrophe of 1927Comintern delegate in 1927Showed Stalin’s telegram to Wang Jingwei and hastened the break.
Mexico and Tashkent (1917–1920)
Roy, who first studied Marxism in the New York Public Library, fled to Mexico with his wife Evelyn Trent in July 1917, fearing extradition to Britain after the United States entered the First World War. German military authorities there gave him large sums of money. His articles in the newspaper El Pueblo won the regard of President Venustiano Carranza and other liberal thinkers.
Roy spent about two years in Mexico and threw himself into the local socialist movement. The Socialist Workers' Party he helped found in December 1917 renamed itself the Mexican Communist Party in November 1919, the first Communist party outside Russia. The Roys lodged the penniless Bolshevik Mikhail Borodin, and the friendship changed Roy's course: thanks to Borodin's grateful reports to Moscow, he was invited to the Second Congress of the Communist International in the summer of 1920, where he submitted supplementary theses on the colonial question and debated Lenin.
After the congress, commissioned by Lenin to prepare the East, and India above all, for revolution, he set up military and political schools in Tashkent in 1920 to train revolutionaries for Asia. There in October 1920 he founded the Communist Party of India, and he contacted his old revolutionary colleagues, who were then choosing between radicalism (Jugantar) and Gandhi's new programme.
The 1927 China Mission and the Stalin Telegram
In early 1927, the Comintern dispatched Roy to China to stabilize the First United Front between the left-wing Kuomintang and the Chinese Communist Party. After Chiang Kai-shek's April Shanghai massacre, only Wang Jingwei's left-KMT government in Wuhan remained. Roy argued for immediate agrarian revolution; Borodin, the veteran Comintern agent, prioritized preserving the Wuhan alliance. On 1 June 1927, Stalin's telegram arrived with contradictory orders: support peasant land confiscation while simultaneously backing the Wuhan KMT. Convinced he could persuade Wang Jingwei, Roy showed him the secret telegram. Wang realized Stalin had marked him as an 'unreliable general' for liquidation, promptly reconciled with Chiang Kai-shek, expelled Soviet advisers, and unleashed a purge of communists. The First United Front collapsed; an estimated 140,000 perished in the ensuing White Terror. Roy was blamed for this indiscretion, lost all standing in the Comintern, and was formally expelled in 1929.
Radical Humanism: Beyond Marxism
Roy's five years in British colonial jails (1931–1936) became a period of philosophical transformation. Supplied with books by his future wife Ellen Gottschalk from Germany, he produced roughly 3,000 pages of 'Prison Manuscripts': nine volumes re-examining Marxism from first principles. Roy rejected economic determinism, reformulated materialism in light of modern physics and biology, and argued that ideas and culture play an autonomous role in history. A philosophical revolution, he concluded, must precede social revolution.
After his release Roy rejoined the anti-colonial movement, but broke with Congress in 1940 to found the Radical Democratic Party. During World War II he broke with Gandhi by supporting the Allies against fascism, arguing that Indian independence could only be won in a free world. In rapid succession he published Beyond Communism (1947) and the New Humanism manifesto (1947), articulating his mature philosophy. The manifesto's '22 Theses on Radical Democracy' established individual freedom and reason as the foundations of social order, charting a 'third way' rejecting both bourgeois parliamentary democracy and Soviet communism.
Roy's humanism conceived the human being as a free, rational, and ethical agent, and defined genuine democracy not as periodic voting but as a social order in which ordinary people control the conditions of their own lives. In 1949 he renamed his journal The Radical Humanist and led the Indian Radical Humanist movement. Elected a vice-president of the International Humanist and Ethical Union in absentia in 1952, Roy died of a heart attack in 1954. His thought left a lasting mark on India's rationalist and secular intellectual tradition.