Moisei Iosifovich Kalmanovich

Моисей Иосифович Калманович

Revolutionary-turned-banker who led Gosbank through collectivization

In 1919 he led armed detachments through the villages of Belarus, forcibly seizing grain from the peasantry. Eighteen years later the system he helped build shot him as a 'wrecker.'

Born to a Jewish merchant family in Siberia, he joined the Socialist Revolutionary Party in 1904 and switched to the Bolsheviks in July 1917. During the October Revolution he served as head of the Minsk garrison and on the Military Revolutionary Committee of the Western Front; during the Civil War he was food commissar in Belarus and Lithuania-Belarus, becoming one of the organizers of forced grain requisitioning expeditions. From 1930 to 1934 he chaired the USSR State Bank while serving simultaneously as Deputy People's Commissar of Finance, overseeing the credit reform of 1930–1932 that accompanied collectivization. He then led the People's Commissariat of Grain and Livestock Sovkhozes from 1934 until his arrest during the Great Terror; he was shot in November 1937.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

1904–1918: From Socialist Revolutionary to Head of the Minsk Garrison

Moisei Kalmanovich was born in 1888 in the village of Rybinskoye in Kansk district, Yenisei Governorate, into a Jewish merchant family. He never went to school and taught himself the gymnasium curriculum. In 1904 he joined the Socialist Revolutionary Party and was active in Tomsk, Irkutsk and Kansk. The SRs were a Russian socialist party that saw the peasantry as the main force of revolution, and in 1917 they were one of the largest parties in the country. He worked as a private tutor in Tomsk and Irkutsk from 1906 to 1909, served in the ranks from 1909 to 1912, and then clerked in a shop in Kansk until 1914. When the First World War broke out he was called up again and fought as a private on the Western Front from August 1914 to March 1917.

After the February Revolution, when soldiers at the front began electing their own councils, or soviets, he became a member of the executive committee of the Western Front soldiers' soviet in Minsk from April 1917. In the summer of 1917 he left the SRs and joined the Bolsheviks, and he also joined the Bolsheviks' North-Western regional committee.

During the October Revolution he was head of the Minsk garrison and a member of the Military Revolutionary Committee of the Western Region and Western Front. Military revolutionary committees were the bodies the Bolsheviks set up to direct the armed rising and take power over from the old authorities. As garrison chief, commanding the troops stationed in the city, he was responsible for holding Minsk, a large city behind the front, for the new regime. He was also food commissar of the regional executive committee of the soviets of workers', soldiers' and peasants' deputies of the Western Region and Front, known as Obliskomzap.

In January 1918 he became chairman of the Council of People's Commissars of the Western Region, and from 29 January he shared a collective chairmanship with Karl Lander and Fedenyov. From February to December 1918 he was food commissar of the regional government, which had moved to Smolensk, and a member of the Smolensk provincial party committee. This was the start of the food administration work he would do for the next several years.

1919–1924: Food Commissar in the Civil War

From 31 December 1918 to 4 March 1919 Kalmanovich was deputy chairman of the Central Bureau of the Communist Party (Bolsheviks) of Byelorussia and a member of the Provisional Revolutionary Government of Byelorussia, and in February 1919 he became deputy chairman of the Central Executive Committee of the Socialist Soviet Republic of Byelorussia. On 28 February he was made food commissar and a member of the Defence Council of the Socialist Soviet Republic of Lithuania and Belorussia, known as Litbel, and joined the Politburo of the Lithuanian-Belorussian party.

A food commissar's job under War Communism was to feed the army and the towns. War Communism was the emergency economic system of the civil war, in which the Soviet state cut back market trade and tried to take direct control of production and distribution. One of its pillars was prodrazvyorstka, the food requisition quota system, introduced across the country by a decree of the Council of People's Commissars on 11 January 1919. The state fixed quotas of grain and other produce for each area and took them from the peasants by force, continuing the "food dictatorship" in force since May 1918. At first the system actually operated only in the central provinces held by the Bolsheviks, and spread to Ukraine in April 1919, to Belarus in 1919, and to Turkestan and Siberia in 1920.

Kalmanovich's career follows exactly that path. He chaired the Special Food Commission of the Western Front in Smolensk from the autumn of 1919 to early 1920, was deputy food commissar of Ukraine from February 1920 to April 1921, and chaired the Siberian Food Committee in Novosibirsk while sitting on the Siberian Revolutionary Committee from April 1921 to April 1922. He was, in other words, one of the food officials who organised forced grain requisitioning on the ground during the civil war. Forced requisitioning provoked fierce peasant resistance and was replaced by a tax in kind in March 1921, at the start of the NEP.

From April to December 1922 he was again deputy food commissar of Ukraine, and from December 1922 to April 1923 he chaired the All-Ukrainian Union of Consumer Cooperatives (Vukoopspilka) in Kharkov, the post Volodymyr Zatonsky had held until October 1922. From July 1923 to May 1924 he was People's Commissar of Food of the Russian Federation and deputy food commissar of the USSR. After the food commissariats were abolished he became an economic manager, chairing the boards of the sugar trust (1924 to 1927), the USSR Industrial Bank (1927 to 1928) and the grain trust (1928 to 1930). A trust was the body that grouped and managed the state enterprises of one branch of industry.

1930–1937: State Bank Chairman and Commissar of State Farms

In December 1929 Kalmanovich became Deputy People's Commissar of Agriculture of the USSR; on 18 October 1930 he was appointed chairman of the board of the USSR State Bank, and from November he was also Deputy People's Commissar of Finance. The bank he took over was at the centre of the credit reform launched on 30 January that year. Until then Soviet enterprises had traded on credit with one another by exchanging bills (commercial credit). The reform abolished this: the State Bank was to lend to enterprises directly, and all payments between enterprises were to pass through State Bank accounts. The planners wanted to control the flow of money as well as goods. In the first months of the reform labour productivity fell, heavy industry output dropped and consumer prices rose; the leadership pressed on with the reform but replaced some of those responsible. The replacement of Bryukhanov by Grinko as finance commissar the same year was part of that shake-up.

During Kalmanovich's tenure the reform went through three more stages. In January 1931 automatic settlements were abolished and new forms of non-cash payment introduced; in July 1931 enterprises' working capital was split into their own and borrowed funds and bank credit became targeted, fixed-term and repayable; and in May 1932 the special banks were reorganised into long-term investment banks. The reform made the State Bank the payment and credit centre of the Soviet state.

On 4 April 1934 he became People's Commissar of Grain and Livestock State Farms. State farms (sovkhozes) were large farms owned by the state and worked by wage labourers, unlike the collective farms (kolkhozes) of peasant members. The commissariat had been split off from the Commissariat of Agriculture in October 1932 to run the nationally important grain and livestock state farms through their trusts. Shortly after it was set up, in December 1932, came a case blaming a "counter-revolutionary organisation of wreckers" for the failed grain procurement and the famine of 1932 and 1933, and in March 1933 thirty-six employees of the agriculture and state farm commissariats were shot. All of them were rehabilitated in 1957. "Wrecking" was the charge that recast economic failures and accidents as deliberate sabotage.

Kalmanovich was dismissed on 11 April 1937 and arrested by the NKVD on 11 June. On 27 November the Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court sentenced him to death for wrecking, terrorism and counter-revolutionary activity, and he was shot the same day. He was buried in a common grave at the Donskoe cemetery in Moscow. Several of his deputies were also shot in 1937, and with the execution of the heads of its main directorates in 1937 and 1938 almost the entire leadership of the southern grain and southern dairy and meat state farm directorates disappeared. He was posthumously rehabilitated on 19 May 1956 and restored to the party on 23 June.