Ukrainian Soviet state-builder and scholar-politician, revolutionary bureaucrat across education, party, and control
As counting commission chair at the 17th Party Congress in 1934, he reported to Kaganovich that many ballots were cast against Stalin; according to his son Dmytro's testimony, he regarded this as signing his own death sentence.
A founding-generation Bolshevik Ukrainian statesman who helped create the CP(B)U and served as Chairman of the All-Ukrainian Central Executive Committee. He led the delegation of the Ukrainian People's Republic of Soviets at the Brest-Litovsk peace talks and signed the treaty establishing the USSR. Twice People's Commissar of Education (1922–1924, 1933–1938), he succeeded Mykola Skrypnyk in 1933 and implemented the rollback of Ukrainization. He was the first editor-in-chief of the Ukrainian Soviet Encyclopedia and a full member of the Academy of Sciences. He also served as CC Secretary of the CP(B)U and head of Workers' and Peasants' Inspection. Arrested in a cinema with his family in November 1937, he was tried on 29 July 1938 in a 20-minute hearing, sentenced to 'ten years without the right of correspondence', a euphemism for death, and shot that day; rehabilitated in 1956.
Also known as: Vladimir Petrovich Zatonsky
Activities and affiliations
-
1917–1918
Soviet Union state institutionsIdeology and propagandaMain
Ideology and propaganda -
1917–
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Ideology and propaganda
Career Timeline
- 1905–1917Joined RSDLP as Menshevik; graduated Kyiv University physics-mathematics, taught physics at Kyiv Polytechnic Institute
- 1917.03–11Switched to Bolsheviks; chairman of Kyiv Party Committee, led armed uprising in Kyiv
- 1917.12–1918.03Secretary of Education in People's Secretariat of Soviet Ukraine; headed Ukrainian delegation at Brest-Litovsk peace talks
- 1918.03–04Chairman of the All-Ukrainian Central Executive Committee (head of state)
- 1918.07–1920Commissar of shock detachment against Left SR rebellion; member of RMC of 12th, 13th, 14th Armies and Southern Front
- 1920.07–09Chairman of the Galician Revolutionary Committee (Halrevkom)
- 1921Participated in suppression of Kronstadt mutiny; awarded Order of the Red Banner
- 1921–1922Chairman of the All-Ukrainian Cooperative Union (Vukopspilka)
- 1922–1924People's Commissar of Education of Ukrainian SSR (first term); signed USSR formation treaty
- 1924–1925Member of RMC and chief of Political Directorate, Ukrainian Military District
- 1925–1927Secretary of CC CP(B)U, full member of Politburo
- 1927–1932People's Commissar of Workers' and Peasants' Inspection, Deputy Chairman of Sovnarkom, Chairman of CC Commission of Ukraine
- 1933–1937People's Commissar of Education (second term); first editor-in-chief of Ukrainian Soviet Encyclopedia
- 1934–1938Candidate member of CC of All-Union Communist Party (Bolshevik)
Related historical events
- 1905–1907The Revolution of 1905Menshevik activity
- 1917–1921Ukraine’s revolution and warsLed the armed rising in KyivAs Kyiv party chairman in 1917 he led the armed rising in Kyiv, and at the end of 1918 he was among the leaders of the Soviet advance into Ukraine.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionLed the Kiev armed uprising
- 1917.12–1918.11Brest-Litovsk and Germany’s eastern occupationHead of the Soviet Ukrainian delegationHe led the Soviet Ukrainian delegation at the Brest-Litovsk peace talks.
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionSoviet Ukrainian commissar and member of the South-Western Front's military councilWorked on the Ukrainian front as a people's commissar of the Soviet Ukrainian government and a member of the South-Western Front's revolutionary military council.
- 1921.03The Kronstadt RebellionPolitical commissar opposing the rebellionHe took part in suppressing the Kronstadt Rebellion in 1921.
- 1922.12Formation of the USSRSignatory to the treaty forming the USSRHe signed the treaty establishing the USSR.
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeUkrainian leadership targetA Ukrainian education commissar and Central Committee secretary, he was arrested in 1937 and executed in 1938.
1917–1918: The Kiev Uprising and the Brest-Litovsk Talks
Volodymyr Zatonsky was born in 1888 in the village of Lysets in Podolia Governorate, the son of a rural district clerk. At the gymnasium in Kamenets-Podolsky he joined the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party in 1905 as a supporter of the Mensheviks. He was expelled from school and university several times for revolutionary activity, yet graduated from the physics and mathematics faculty of Kiev University in 1912 and went on to teach physics at the Kiev Polytechnic Institute. He was a physics teacher before he was a revolutionary, which helps explain why he would spend so much of his later career running education and scholarship.
After the February Revolution of 1917 he broke with the Mensheviks and joined the Bolsheviks in March; in November he became chairman of the Bolsheviks' Kiev committee. He was one of the leaders of the armed uprising in Kiev that followed the October Revolution and sat on its revolutionary committee. Power in Kiev was then held by the Central Rada, a Ukrainian national council that stood for Ukrainian autonomy, and Zatonsky fought against it. Looking back on the end of 1917, he said that since there was as yet no split among Ukrainians and none in sight, the Bolsheviks had to wage war on the Ukrainian people, and they were only a handful. He also recorded that crowds visibly calmed down and grew interested when they heard Ukrainian spoken. Between them the two remarks capture the Bolsheviks' position in Ukraine: a party resting on urban workers and soldiers, up against the national feeling of a peasant majority.
When a congress of soviets in Kiev failed, most Bolshevik delegates moved to Kharkov, but Zatonsky stayed in Kiev. In the Soviet government set up by the First All-Ukrainian Congress of Soviets in December 1917 he became secretary (that is, commissar) for education. In January 1918 he met Lenin for the first time in Petrograd, sat in the Russian Council of People's Commissars as the representative of Soviet Ukraine, and for about a month acted in effect as Lenin's secretary. That winter, when Bolshevik troops took Kiev, his fluent Ukrainian nearly got him shot as a counter-revolutionary; he recalled that a mandate signed by Lenin himself saved his life.
In February 1918 he led the Soviet Ukrainian delegation to the peace talks at Brest-Litovsk, where Soviet Russia was trying to make peace with Germany and its allies and leave the First World War. The Central Powers refused to recognise his delegation. At the Fourth All-Russian Congress of Soviets that followed he backed Lenin's case for signing the peace. In March he was elected chairman of the All-Ukrainian Central Executive Committee, but once German troops occupied Ukraine he worked from April in the underground party organisation and the leadership of the insurgency. At this time he and Skrypnyk protested against Stalin's remark that Ukraine had "played at government and republic" long enough, and argued for a separate Ukrainian communist party. In July he was commissar of a strike detachment that put down the Left SR uprising in Moscow.
1918–1921: Commissar on the Civil War Fronts and at Kronstadt
In November 1918, as Germany's defeat brought the occupation of Ukraine to an end, the Soviet side prepared to march back in. From 17 to 30 November Zatonsky sat with Vladimir Antonov-Ovseenko and Stalin on the Revolutionary Military Council of the Special Group of Forces on the Kursk axis. Revolutionary military councils were the Red Army's command bodies, in which a military commander shared authority with commissars sent by the party. This one, based in Kursk, drew up the plan for retaking Ukraine and began filling the front with troops. From 30 November Zatonsky was a member of the Revolutionary Military Council of the Ukrainian Soviet Army and of the Provisional Workers' and Peasants' Government of Ukraine set up in Kursk.
In 1919 and 1920 he spent most of his time at the front. From June 1919 to May 1920 he acted as a member of the Revolutionary Military Council of the 12th Army of the Western Front. During the Soviet-Polish War in 1920 he took charge of the Ukrainian party's work on western Ukraine and in August and September chaired the Galician Revolutionary Committee, a provisional revolutionary authority set up in the part of Galicia the Red Army had entered. He then served in turn on the military councils of the 13th and 14th Armies of the South-Western Front and the 6th Army of the Southern Front. He has been accused of having hundreds of innocent Ukrainian intellectuals and peasants killed without trial on his direct orders in this period, but no specific cases or documents have been produced to confirm it.
As the man in charge of education he also acted by the logic of the civil war. In September 1920, when the Red Army took Kamenets-Podolsky for the third time, he sent a telegram to educational institutions across Ukraine saying that the professors of the Kamenets State Ukrainian University should all be dispersed and that in its current form the university compromised Soviet power. The university's teachers were intellectuals close to Petliura's Ukrainian People's Republic.
In March 1921 the Tenth Party Congress, the congress that adopted the New Economic Policy, sent about 300 of its delegates to help crush the Kronstadt rebellion, and Zatonsky was one of them. Kronstadt was the naval fortress off Petrograd where sailors, the backbone of the 1917 revolution, rose against the Bolsheviks. He fought as a brigade commissar in the 7th Army, and after the rising was put down on 18 March he received the Order of the Red Banner on 23 March. That the same man who believed the masses had to be won over in Ukrainian should have helped suppress the revolutionary sailors in the same months shows where a Bolshevik leader of the civil war years stood.
1922–1932: Signing the Union Treaty and Policing the Party
Once the civil war was over, Zatonsky ran the All-Ukrainian Cooperative Union (Vukoopspilka) from December 1921 to October 1922; he later recalled that it took him a while to find his way in what at first looked like a muddle. At the end of 1922 he was one of the plenipotentiaries who signed the treaty forming the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics on behalf of the Ukrainian Socialist Soviet Republic. The treaty joined the Soviet republics into a single federal state, the USSR.
From October 1922 to March 1924 he was People's Commissar of Education of Ukraine; a people's commissar was the Soviet equivalent of a government minister. The minutes of the Ukrainian Politburo noted that the change of leadership at the commissariat must give no grounds for talk of forced Russification. Yet he worked hard to narrow the gap between the separate Ukrainian education system built under Grigory Grinko in 1920 to 1922 and the system of the Russian Federation. In early 1923 he opposed the principles for standard literary Ukrainian proposed by the Ukrainian Academy of Sciences, on the grounds that they were based on the dialect of the lands beyond the Dniester.
He then moved between top army and party posts. In 1924 to 1926 he was a member of the military council and head of the political directorate of the Ukrainian Military District; in 1925 to 1927 a secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party (Bolsheviks) of Ukraine; and in 1927 to 1933 chairman of the Ukrainian party's Central Control Commission, People's Commissar of Workers' and Peasants' Inspection and deputy head of the Ukrainian government. The control commission and the Workers' and Peasants' Inspection (Rabkrin) policed, respectively, the discipline of party members and the work of state agencies. From 1927 to 1934 he also sat on the Central Control Commission of the All-Union party. In the same years he edited the literary monthly Chervonyi shliakh (The Red Path) from 1927 to 1930, chaired the committee for the chemicalisation of the economy from 1928 to 1934, and in 1929 became a full member of the Ukrainian Academy of Sciences.
At the end of October 1932 he was put in charge of grain procurement in Kiev oblast, in the midst of the great famine of 1932 and 1933 in Ukraine known as the Holodomor. He is counted among the people who carried out the Holodomor in Kiev oblast and elsewhere. The nature of the famine, including whether it should be called genocide, is still argued over, but there is no doubt that in the famine year he was the party official responsible for collecting grain in one of its provinces.
1933–1938: Skrypnyk's Successor and a Twenty-Minute Trial
On 22 February 1933 Zatonsky became Ukraine's People's Commissar of Education for the fourth time. His predecessor, Mykola Skrypnyk, had led Ukrainization, the Ukrainian version of the 1920s Soviet policy of building up the language and cadres of each nationality in its own republic, which spread Ukrainian through schools, administration and publishing. Zatonsky's appointment opened the attack on Skrypnyk's "national deviation." He himself said the appointment caught him somewhat by surprise, so that he did not even have a list of the resolutions on which a critique of the previous leadership's handling of the national question ought to be based.
One of his first moves was to initiate, at the end of 1933, a decision to unify the Russian and Ukrainian school systems and write common textbooks, and Ukrainian schools gave more hours to Russian language and literature. He has been criticised for backing the unjustified 1933 revision of Ukrainian spelling and approving repression of "ideologically unreliable" educators. At the same time he disliked Great Russian chauvinism and stood for Soviet rather than Russian centralism, and it has been argued that under a leadership turning towards Russification this became one of the reasons for his arrest. In September 1933 he was appointed editor-in-chief of the Ukrainian Soviet Encyclopedia, and he directed the removal of the mosaics and frescoes of St Michael's Golden-Domed Monastery in Kiev. In 1934 he returned to the Ukrainian Central Committee and became a candidate member of the All-Union Central Committee.
At the Seventeenth Party Congress in 1934 he chaired the commission that counted the votes in the elections to the party's leading bodies. His son, Dmytro Zatonsky, testified that his father used to say that by telling Kaganovich how many ballots had been cast against Stalin's election to the Central Committee he had signed his own death sentence. This is family testimony, not a documented fact.
On 3 November 1937 he was arrested in a cinema where he had gone with his wife, daughter and son-in-law. That evening his flat was searched for physical evidence that he had spied for "bourgeois" Poland, and a few days later his wife Elena, a physician, was arrested too. He was charged with belonging to an anti-Soviet "Ukrainian national centre." Yet he was loyal to Stalin and belonged to no national current within the party. On 29 July 1938 a trial presided over by Ulrikh took twenty minutes. The sentence was ten years in prison without the right of correspondence, which during the Great Purge was a euphemism for death, and he was shot the same day. In 1956 he was posthumously rehabilitated and restored to the party. Rehabilitation was the procedure by which the Soviet authorities annulled a past verdict and restored the person's good name.