Santiago Carrillo

Communist Party of Spain (PCE) Eurocommunism Spain Spain 1915.1.18.–2012.9.18. ○ Natural causes

The Eurocommunist architect who lit a cigarette at gunpoint

23 February 1981: 200 Civil Guards under Lt. Col. Tejero storm the Spanish parliament, firing submachine guns. As every deputy dives for cover, 66-year-old Santiago Carrillo remains seated, takes out a cigarette, and calmly lights it.

Born in Gijón, the son of the Socialist leader Wenceslao Carrillo, he began working on the Socialist party paper at thirteen and became general secretary of the Socialist Youth in 1933. In 1936 he led its unification with the Communist youth into the Unified Socialist Youth (JSU), joined the Communist Party that November and served as Councillor for Public Order on the Madrid Defence Council; his responsibility for the Paracuellos massacres of that period is still disputed. After 38 years of exile he became the party's general secretary in 1960, made it independent of Moscow after 1968, argued for socialism through parliamentary democracy in Eurocommunism and the State (1977) and played a large part in the peaceful transition after Franco.

Also known as: Santiago José Carrillo Solares

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

The Unified Socialist Youth, the defence of Madrid and exile, 1936–1960

A member of the National Revolutionary Committee of the October 1934 rising, Carrillo was in prison until February 1936. Released, he travelled to Moscow in March with the executive of the Socialist Youth to meet the leaders of the Young Communist International and prepare the unification of the two youth leagues, which produced the Unified Socialist Youth (JSU). After the Civil War broke out, an executive of seven socialists and seven communists was named on 20 September with Carrillo as general secretary.

He joined the Communist Party on the day in November when the government left Madrid, and on 7 November was elected Councillor for Public Order in the Defence Council that took supreme power in besieged Madrid. During his term several thousand military and civilian prisoners were killed by Republican groups at Paracuellos del Jarama and Torrejón de Ardoz, the biggest mass killings by the Republican side in the war. Carrillo denied any knowledge of the massacres in his memoirs, but Fernando Hernández, Paul Preston and Ángel Viñas argue that he cannot claim ignorance, since he attended meetings where the removals of prisoners were discussed and received oral instructions; they place primary responsibility on Pedro Checa and NKVD agents, while Julius Ruiz argues that Carrillo provided logistical and political support.

When Madrid surrendered after Casado's coup in March 1939, his father Wenceslao was among the coup's leaders. Carrillo wrote him an open letter calling the coup counter-revolutionary and a betrayal and broke off contact. He then spent 38 years in exile, mostly in France, rebuilding the party. At the Fifth Party Congress, held in Czechoslovakia in 1954, he called for democratising the party, and in an article welcoming Spain's entry into the UN in 1955 he put forward the "policy of national reconciliation". The leadership, unaware of the article, issued statements against it and he came close to expulsion, but the line later became party policy. In 1960 he succeeded Dolores Ibárruri as general secretary, and she was given the honorary post of party chairman.

Eurocommunism and the State: Breaking with Moscow

The 1968 Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia was Carrillo's political and theoretical turning point. The PCE, with the Italian PCI, was among the West European communist parties that most firmly condemned the intervention, and Carrillo steered the party to full independence from Moscow while seeking a path to socialism suited to Western Europe's realities. Its summation was Eurocommunism and the State (1977). There he argued that the capitalist state apparatus could be democratised and converted into an instrument of socialist construction without being smashed by force; the scientific-technical revolution had plunged the ideological apparatuses into crisis, so winning hegemony for the "forces of labour and culture" would transform the state from within. On this basis he declared the renunciation of the dictatorship of the proletariat, a formula he judged valid when the working class was a minority but obsolete now that the forces of labour and culture formed the overwhelming majority, and proposed an economic democratisation that preserved a mix of public and private property over a long transition. An attack in the Soviet journal New Times turned the book into a cause célèbre, and the Madrid declaration Carrillo shared with Berlinguer and Marchais in 1977 marked the theoretical summit of Eurocommunism.