The NKVD chief who expanded the Gulag and became a purge defendant
On 15 September 1933 Yagoda sent Stalin a report on arrests of homosexual men. It ended by stating that investigation was continuing; Stalin wrote an instruction for separate legislation on its first page.
An effective chief of the OGPU and NKVD, he oversaw forced-labour projects including the White Sea–Baltic Canal. His report on arrests of homosexual men in Moscow and Leningrad in 1933 prompted Stalin’s instruction for separate criminal legislation; Roldugina finds no legislative proposal in the September report itself. He became the first USSR NKVD commissar in 1934, was replaced by Yezhov in 1936, and was shot after the Third Moscow Trial.
Activities and affiliations
-
1917–1937
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Security, intelligence and policing -
Soviet Union state institutionsState security agenciesMain
Security, intelligence and policing- People's Commissar of Internal Affairs of the USSR1934–1936
Career Timeline
- 1920sRises through Cheka/GPU/OGPU, managing camps and major forced-labour construction
- 1934–1935Handles expanding repression and early purge investigations after Kirov’s murder
- 1934–1936First NKVD commissar after the security organs are consolidated
- 1936Replaced by Yezhov and demoted to communications commissar
- 1937–1938Arrested and shot after the Third Moscow Trial
Related historical events
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionCheka officerJoined the Cheka in 1919, worked in its Special and Administrative Departments in 1920 and rose quickly under Dzerzhinsky after the war.
- 1918–1922The Tambov Rebellion and the peasant uprisingsSenior Cheka officialWas sent from the All-Russian Cheka to Tambov in spring 1921 for the suppression.
- 1920.11–1936.06.27The Soviet Legalisation and Ban of Abortion and the Recriminalisation of SodomyDeputy chairman of the OGPUDirected the mass arrests of homosexuals in 1933 and, casting an “association of pederasts” as spy cells, proposed a criminal law.
- 1928–1937The Five-Year Plans and the Soviet TransformationPeople's Commissar of Internal Affairs
- 1937–1938The Great PurgePredecessor and executorA former NKVD chief, he became a target of trial and execution during the terror.
The White Sea-Baltic Canal and the birth of the Gulag
Between 1931 and 1933, Yagoda's OGPU supervised the White Sea-Baltic Canal project, where over 12,000 of roughly 100,000 prisoners died: a project carried out with shovels and wheelbarrows, without a single excavator. On the back of this 'success', Yagoda institutionalised forced labour as a structural element of the Soviet economy. As the first NKVD commissar from 1934, he expanded the Gulag on a massive scale, perfecting the system of channelling prisoner labour into large-scale construction, logging, and mining. The title 'architect of the Gulag' is no exaggeration.
The 1933 arrests of homosexual men and the report to Stalin
In 1933 Yagoda effectively led the OGPU under its ailing chairman, Viacheslav Menzhinskii. In August the OGPU began a secret operation against homosexual men in Moscow and Leningrad. The first Leningrad arrests occurred on 4 August; 198 men were arrested altogether. Before the new sodomy offence existed, they were prosecuted as counterrevolutionaries under Article 58. Repeated interrogations transformed accounts of private life and social gatherings into a narrative of a counterrevolutionary organisation with German connections.
Yagoda’s three-page report to Stalin of 15 September depicted homosexual associations as corrupting youth and potentially serving espionage. Yet the full text examined by Irina Roldugina ends with “Further investigation is ongoing” and proposes no new criminal law. Stalin wrote an instruction to Kaganovich on its first page demanding exemplary punishment and new legislation. Roldugina distinguishes Yagoda’s selective repression under the existing Article 58 from Stalin’s decision to introduce a separate offence. Treating the September report as Yagoda’s direct proposal for that law obscures the distinction.
Roldugina interprets the Brown Book and Soviet press campaign associating homosexuality with fascism as a rationale Yagoda could exploit both for the operation and to demonstrate his effectiveness to Stalin. This is the historian’s explanation, rather than an explicit motive stated in the report; the report never names van der Lubbe. Its portrayal of noble leaders also conflicted with case files showing that most arrested men came from peasant or working-class backgrounds. The subsequent law should not be read backwards as proof of an initial, uniform plan to arrest all homosexuals. English article
The Third Moscow Trial and Execution
A memoir suggests that Yagoda's arrest also revived a quarrel from 1932. According to Fadeyev's story as retold by the linguist Vyacheslav Ivanov, right after RAPP's dissolution in 1932 Yagoda summoned the writer Alexander Fadeyev, who had hurriedly written an article renouncing RAPP, to his office and berated him for betraying his comrades in RAPP, and Fadeyev wrote a letter recounting the clash to the Central Committee. After Yagoda's arrest in 1937 Fadeyev was asked to reread the letter, although the matter was not mentioned at the trial. Jamie Allan, a researcher who cites the memoir, qualifies the story: "If Fadeev's account can be trusted".
In March 1938, Yagoda stood trial as a principal defendant in the Third Moscow Trial, the case of the 'Anti-Soviet Right-Trotskyist Bloc.' The charges included conspiring with Trotsky, Bukharin, and Rykov; organizing a fascist plot inside the NKVD; plotting the assassination of Stalin and Yezhov; and poisoning Maxim Gorky and his son Maxim Peshkov. On the Gorky killings, Yagoda claimed he acted out of 'personal considerations': his infatuation with Gorky's daughter-in-law Nadezhda 'Timosha' Peshkova. When prosecutor Vyshinsky pressed the espionage charge, Yagoda retorted in open court: 'No, I do not plead guilty to this. If I were a spy, I assure you, dozens of states would have had to disband their intelligence services.' He admitted most charges of treachery but refused the spy label. At dawn on 13 March, the court sentenced him to death. His appeal, 'My guilt before the Motherland is great. It is heavy to die', was rejected. On 15 March 1938, Yagoda was shot at Kommunarka, the special facility that had been his own former dacha. NKVD officer Izrail Dagin, on Yezhov's orders, beat him before the execution; witnesses claimed Yagoda was forced to watch the other condemned men be shot before he was killed last. In 2015, the Supreme Court of Russia refused to rehabilitate him, ruling that he had himself 'committed crimes against justice.'