People of the Revolution and the USSR

Raya Dunayevskaya

Raya Dunayevskaya

From Trotsky's secretary to founder of Marxist Humanism

“My real development only began after my break with Trotsky.” — from a 1980s interview

Born to a Jewish family in the Russian Empire, she emigrated to the US as a child. Starting as Trotsky's secretary, she broke with him over the nature of the USSR and co-developed the theory of state capitalism with C.L.R. James. She went on to found Marxist Humanism, fusing Hegelian dialectics with Marx's early writings, and led the News and Letters Committees.

Career timeline
  • 1922Emigrates with family to Chicago, USA
  • 1928Expelled from CPUSA youth organization for defending Trotskyism
  • 1929Joins independent Trotskyist group in Boston led by Antoinette Konikow
  • 1937–1938Serves as Trotsky's Russian-language secretary and stenographer in Mexico
  • 1939Breaks with Trotsky over the character of the Soviet Union
  • 1940Participates in SWP split → formation of the Workers Party
  • 1941–1943Forms Johnson–Forest Tendency with C.L.R. James; state-capitalist analysis of USSR
  • 1947Returns to the SWP
  • 1951Leaves SWP over Korean War; forms Correspondence Publishing Committee
  • 1953Studies Hegel's Phenomenology; advances interpretation of absolutes as 'philosophic moment'
  • 1955Splits with C.L.R. James; founds News and Letters Committees
  • 1958Publishes Marxism and Freedom (preface by Herbert Marcuse)
  • 1973Publishes Philosophy and Revolution
  • 1982Publishes Rosa Luxemburg, Women's Liberation, and Marx's Philosophy of Revolution
  • 1987Dies in Chicago aged 77

Grace Lee Boggs

Grace Lee Boggs
Left critics of Bolshevism United States China 1915–2015 ○ Natural causes

From first translator of Marx's 1844 Manuscripts to philosopher of Detroit's revolution

“We are the leaders we've been looking for.” — interviewed in her 90s in Detroit

Daughter of Chinese immigrants, she earned a PhD at Bryn Mawr but was barred from academia by racism and joined the Workers Party. With C.L.R. James and Raya Dunayevskaya she formed the Johnson–Forest Tendency triad, co-authoring State Capitalism and World Revolution and producing the first English translation of Marx's 1844 Manuscripts. In 1953 she married Black autoworker James Boggs, settled in Detroit, broke from Trotskyism, and turned toward community-based revolutionary praxis centered on Black liberation, writing into her 90s.

Career timeline
  • 1915Born in Providence, Rhode Island, to Chinese immigrant restaurateur Chin Lee; Chinese given name Yu Ping (玉平)
  • 1935Graduates from Barnard College, Columbia University
  • 1940Earns PhD in philosophy from Bryn Mawr College with dissertation on George Herbert Mead
  • 1940–1945Works as low-wage librarian at University of Chicago Philosophy Library; joins Workers Party through tenants' rights activism
  • 1945–1947Forms Johnson–Forest Tendency with C.L.R. James and Dunayevskaya; produces first English translation of Marx's 1844 Manuscripts
  • 1947Joins SWP with the tendency; writes under party pseudonym 'Ria Stone'
  • 1950Co-authors State Capitalism and World Revolution with James and Dunayevskaya
  • 1951Leaves SWP; helps form Correspondence Publishing Committee
  • 1953Marries Black autoworker and political activist James Boggs; moves to Detroit
  • 1962Breaks with C.L.R. James; leads Correspondence with James Boggs on independent Detroit-community orientation
  • 1964Attempts to persuade Malcolm X to run for US Senate, unsuccessfully
  • 1970Co-founds Detroit Asian Political Alliance
  • 1974Publishes Revolution and Evolution in the Twentieth Century with James Boggs
  • 1979Co-founds National Organization for an American Revolution (NOAR)
  • 1992Founds Detroit Summer, a multicultural intergenerational youth program
  • 1998Publishes autobiography Living for Change
  • 2011At 95, publishes The Next American Revolution with Scott Kurashige
  • 2015Dies in Detroit at 100; President Obama issues statement mourning her passing

Tony Cliff

Tony Cliff
Left critics of Bolshevism United Kingdom Poland 1917–2000 ○ Natural causes

The Trotskyist theorist who defined the USSR as bureaucratic state capitalism and built Britain's Socialist Workers Party

The slogan the Cliff group raised in 1950, when a handful of supporters brought out Socialist Review: “Neither Washington nor Moscow but international socialism.” It was a refusal of both camps of the Cold War, and the sentence that defined this current for the next half century.

Born Yigael Glückstein. Raised in Palestine in a family of Polish-Jewish immigrants, he left the Zionist left in his teens for Trotskyism, served twelve months in a British Mandate prison for anti-war agitation, and moved to Britain in 1947. In The Nature of Stalinist Russia (1948) he defined the USSR not as a degenerated workers'' state but as bureaucratic state capitalism, breaking with Fourth International orthodoxy, and on that base he built the theory of the permanent arms economy, which explained the postwar boom by East-West military spending, and of deflected permanent revolution, in which neither bourgeoisie nor working class but intellectuals and officers carry the revolution out. The organization he started as the Socialist Review Group in 1950 became the International Socialists and, in 1977, the Socialist Workers Party. He left a study of Rosa Luxemburg and four-volume biographies of Lenin and of Trotsky, and, never granted British citizenship, remained stateless all his life.

Career timeline
  • 1917Born Yigael Glückstein at Zikhron Ya'akov in Ottoman Palestine, to Polish-Jewish immigrant parents
  • 1931–1933Began in the youth section of Mapai, then Poale Zion, inside the Zionist left
  • late 1930sBecame a Trotskyist and an anti-Zionist; active in the small Palestinian Trotskyist movement
  • 1939Arrested by the British Mandate authorities and held twelve months in Acre prison
  • 1945Married the South African socialist Chanie Rosenberg
  • 1947Moved to Britain, was refused leave to remain, and worked in Dublin instead
  • 1948Published The Nature of Stalinist Russia, defining the USSR as bureaucratic state capitalism
  • 1950Founded the Socialist Review Group: neither Washington nor Moscow
  • 1952Allowed back into Britain and settled in London
  • 1959Published Rosa Luxemburg: A Study, first using the pen name Tony Cliff
  • 1962–1963Renamed the group the International Socialists and formulated deflected permanent revolution
  • 1977Founded the Socialist Workers Party
  • 1975–1993Wrote his four-volume Lenin and four-volume Trotsky
  • 2000.04.09Died in London after heart surgery, still a stateless person

Balázs Nagy

Nagy Balázs
Left critics of Bolshevism Hungary Hungarian 1920–2003 ○ Natural causes

The exile historian of workers’ councils

In the resolution he recorded for 31 October, the workers' councils opened with 'The factory is the property of the workers.'

Balázs Nagy was a Hungarian revolutionary socialist and exile writer who documented how workers’ councils created an autonomous political and economic organisation outside the state apparatus and party bureaucracy during the 1956 revolution. He left a firsthand account of the formation of the Central Workers’ Council of Greater Budapest, its strike after 4 November, and its negotiations with the new government; the study was published in French in Brussels in 1961. His work shows both how working-class self-organisation functioned as an alternative political form amid defeat and the limits imposed on it by military intervention and repression.

Career timeline
  • 1956Participated in Budapest’s workers’ council movement
  • 1956.11Documented the formation and resistance of the Central Workers’ Council of Greater Budapest
  • 1961Published the French study La formation du Conseil Central Ouvrier de Budapest en Brussels
  • 1964Published Budapest 1956: The Central Workers’ Council in International Socialism
  • 2003Died