People of the Revolution and the USSR

Left critics of Bolshevism 1917–2000 ○ Natural causes

The Trotskyist theorist who defined the USSR as bureaucratic state capitalism and built Britain's Socialist Workers Party

The slogan the Cliff group raised in 1950, when a handful of supporters brought out Socialist Review: “Neither Washington nor Moscow but international socialism.” It was a refusal of both camps of the Cold War, and the sentence that defined this current for the next half century.

Born Yigael Glückstein. Raised in Palestine in a family of Polish-Jewish immigrants, he left the Zionist left in his teens for Trotskyism, served twelve months in a British Mandate prison for anti-war agitation, and moved to Britain in 1947. In The Nature of Stalinist Russia (1948) he defined the USSR not as a degenerated workers'' state but as bureaucratic state capitalism, breaking with Fourth International orthodoxy, and on that base he built the theory of the permanent arms economy, which explained the postwar boom by East-West military spending, and of deflected permanent revolution, in which neither bourgeoisie nor working class but intellectuals and officers carry the revolution out. The organization he started as the Socialist Review Group in 1950 became the International Socialists and, in 1977, the Socialist Workers Party. He left a study of Rosa Luxemburg and four-volume biographies of Lenin and of Trotsky, and, never granted British citizenship, remained stateless all his life.

Left critics of Bolshevism 1920–2003 ○ Natural causes

The exile historian of workers’ councils

In the resolution he recorded for 31 October, the workers' councils opened with 'The factory is the property of the workers.'

Balázs Nagy was a Hungarian revolutionary socialist and exile writer who documented how workers’ councils created an autonomous political and economic organisation outside the state apparatus and party bureaucracy during the 1956 revolution. He left a firsthand account of the formation of the Central Workers’ Council of Greater Budapest, its strike after 4 November, and its negotiations with the new government; the study was published in French in Brussels in 1961. His work shows both how working-class self-organisation functioned as an alternative political form amid defeat and the limits imposed on it by military intervention and repression.

Left critics of Bolshevism 1926–2005 ○ Natural causes

A committed historian of revolutionary movements

He read Spain’s revolution not as a side episode of the war, but as a defeated social revolution.

Pierre Broué was a French Trotskyist historian and teachers’ activist who studied communism and twentieth-century revolutionary movements. His 1961 history of the Spanish Revolution and Civil War, written with Émile Témime, interpreted the defeat of the revolutionary process through the clash of class forces inside the Republic and Stalinist policy. He combined political commitment with archival and editorial work on Trotsky and the Trotskyist movement.

Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks Left critics of Bolshevism 1939–1976 ✕ Executed

The naval officer who mutinied for Leninist principles against the Brezhnev regime

In his final letter to his son before execution: "Be strong and believe that life is beautiful. Be positive and believe that the Revolution always wins."

A Soviet Navy captain 3rd rank and political officer (zampolit) who, in November 1975, led a mutiny aboard the anti-submarine frigate Storozhevoy. Denouncing the corruption and stagnation of the Brezhnev era, Sablin aimed to sail from Riga to Leningrad and broadcast a call for a return to Leninist principles and a new communist revolution. The mutiny was crushed by Soviet air attacks before reaching its goal. Sablin was convicted of treason and executed by firing squad. His action, one of the most dramatic acts of Leninist dissent from within the late Soviet military, later inspired Tom Clancy's The Hunt for Red October.

Soviet Union state institutions Left critics of Bolshevism ?–1920 ✕ Killed by pursuing troops

Red Army division commander who raised the "Red Army of Truth" against grain requisitioning in 1920

From a peasant family of Novouzensk district, Samara province, he fought in the First World War and returned to Novouzensk in 1917 as a second lieutenant, becoming the first chairman of the district soviet. A Left Socialist Revolutionary, after the revolt of the Czechoslovak Legion he called himself a communist without joining the party. As commander of the Red Army's 22nd Division he held Uralsk through an 80-day siege in 1919, but was removed from the front "for inept command and a corrupting policy". In 1920, while forming the 9th Cavalry Division, he learned of his dismissal and on 14 July renamed the division the "1st Red Army of Truth" and rose in revolt. He was killed by a pursuing detachment near the aul of Koim on 6 September 1920.

Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks Left critics of Bolshevism 1888/1890–1937 ✕ Executed

The Left Opposition secretary whom Lenin called a 'brilliant worker'

According to his daughter Zorya's recollection, Lenin called him a "brilliant worker."

Born in Samara to a working-class family, he began working at nine and became a metal fitter and turner at the Hartmann locomotive works in Lugansk at fourteen. He joined the Bolsheviks in 1905, worked on the Lugansk committee, and as a delegate to the 1912 Prague Conference met Lenin before being arrested and exiled to Narym. During the February Revolution of 1917 he led his regiment out in Kostroma, then served as secretary of the Moscow Party Committee, a Central Committee member (1919–1921) and CC secretary (1920–1921). One of the leaders of the Left Opposition who signed the Declaration of the 46, he was expelled in 1927 and exiled to Semipalatinsk, reinstated in 1930, and shot in 1937 as a main defendant in the Second Moscow Show Trial.