Association of Artists of Revolutionary Russia
혁명 러시아 미술가 협회
The Association of Artists of Revolutionary Russia (AKhRR) was the largest Soviet artists' organisation, founded in Moscow in May 1922 and active until 1932. Continuing the realism of the nineteenth-century Peredvizhniki ("Wanderers"), it set out to paint the life of the Red Army, workers, peasants, revolutionaries and heroes of labour in a way the masses could recognise, under the slogans of "artistic documentarism" and "heroic realism", and it stood against avant-garde art with its abstraction and constructivism. Growing large with state backing, it renamed itself the Association of Artists of the Revolution (AKhR) in 1928, and was dissolved together with the other art groups by the party resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" of 23 April 1932. Its principles and painters carried over into socialist realist painting.
In depth
In what kind of pictures should the revolution be recorded?
Imagine a worker in early-1920s Moscow going to see an exhibition. In one hall hang pictures made only of fields of colour and geometric shapes; in another, people at work in a factory and soldiers of the Red Army are painted so that anyone can recognise them. Everyone agreed that the revolution demanded a new art. But artists split deeply over whether the novelty lay in changing the language of painting itself, or in painting the people and events of the new society so that they were easy to understand. The Association of Artists of Revolutionary Russia was the group that gave the second answer most loudly.
The currents that gave the first answer are covered in this dictionary's entries "Russian avant-garde" and "Production art". In the first years after the revolution the fine-arts department of the People's Commissariat for Education was headed by the painter David Shterenberg, who stood close to these "left" artists. The association's founder Yevgeny Katsman wrote in a manuscript and memoirs of the 1950s that the theorist Osip Brik claimed a little black or red square suited the revolution best and that easel painting was not needed, and that Shterenberg mocked realism as an "ichthyosaur".
О. Брик пытался доказать, что к революции больше всего подходит черненький или красненький квадратик, что станковое искусство не нужно
How did the association come about?
The occasion was the last exhibition of the Society for Travelling Art Exhibitions, the nineteenth-century realists known as the Peredvizhniki ("Wanderers"). At its 47th exhibition, held in Moscow in 1922, the society's last head, Pavel Radimov, gave a speech holding up the realism of the late Peredvizhniki as a model for painting the life of the Red Army, workers, peasants, revolutionaries and heroes of labour in a way the masses could understand. Avant-garde artists attacked the speech fiercely, and the dispute led to the founding of a new organisation.
The first organisational meeting took place in the flat of Sergei Malyutin, a portraitist well known before the revolution. In May 1922 the association was founded, its statute and name were adopted, and Radimov was elected chairman, Alexander Grigoriev deputy chairman and Katsman secretary. The "Exhibition of Pictures by Artists of the Realist Tendency in Aid of the Starving", opened on Kuznetsky Most in Moscow on 1 May that year, came to be counted as the association's first exhibition. The Peredvizhniki were in effect absorbed into the association and ceased to exist as an organisation.
According to Katsman, at a meeting in June 1922 in the flat of the painter Vasily Yakovlev he proposed "heroic realism" as the association's basic slogan. There were also proposals for naturalism and romanticism, he recalled, but after long debate the members chose heroic realism.
Я выдвинул основной лозунг для АХРР — „героический реализм“. Были предложения о натурализме и романтизме, но после долгих дебатов решили идти под лозунгом „героического реализма“
What did the association declare?
The association's declaration appeared in the catalogue of its 1922 exhibition. It made recording the revolutionary moment the painter's duty: "Our civic duty before mankind is the artistic and documentary recording of the greatest moment of history in its revolutionary surge. We shall depict the present day: the life of the Red Army, the life of the workers, the peasantry, the revolutionaries and the heroes of labour… We shall give a true picture of events, and not abstract fabrications that discredit our revolution in the eyes of the international proletariat."
Наш гражданский долг перед человечеством — художественно-документальное запечатление величайшего момента истории в его революционном порыве. Мы изобразим сегодняшний день: быт Красной Армии, быт рабочих, крестьянства, деятелей революции и героев труда… Мы дадим действительную картину событий, а не абстрактные измышления, дискредитирующие нашу революцию перед лицом международного пролетариата.
It was clear whom "abstract fabrications" was aimed at; the association called the avant-garde "harmful fabrications". Its two slogans, "artistic documentarism" and "heroic realism", summed up the declaration: observe and record events and people directly, but paint the revolutionary moment in heroic form.
How did the association work?
The association's painters did not stay in their studios but went out to find their subjects. From 1922 they sketched in Moscow factories, went into Red Army barracks and factories to observe the lives of their sitters, and later made a system of "creative assignments" in which painters travelled with Academy of Sciences expeditions, geological prospectors and builders. Exhibitions, too, were organised by theme. Shows such as "The Life and Everyday Existence of the Red Army", "The Life and Everyday Existence of the Workers", "Revolution, Everyday Life and Labour" and "The Life and Everyday Existence of the Peoples of the USSR" drew large audiences. According to the Great Soviet Encyclopedia, the association held some seventy exhibitions in Moscow and other cities.
The association enjoyed state backing. From the start it received material support from the Red Army leadership under Kliment Voroshilov, and the People's Commissar for Education Anatoly Lunacharsky wrote of its seventh exhibition: "The artist is clearly finding his viewer, and the viewer is clearly beginning to recognise in the artist his own artist."
…Художник явно находит своего зрителя, зритель явно начинает узнавать в художнике своего художника.
Membership grew fast. By the summer of 1923 there were already about three hundred members, and by 1926 some forty branches. Painters who had made their names before the revolution joined too: after senior figures such as Abram Arkhipov, Nikolai Kasatkin, Konstantin Yuon and Mitrofan Grekov came Isaak Brodsky, Boris Kustodiev, Kuzma Petrov-Vodkin, Ilya Mashkov and others, and Alexander Gerasimov joined in 1925. Other groups merged into it as well: members of the New Society of Painters in 1924, and in 1926 painters of the former Jack of Diamonds group and the whole of the Moscow Painters. It had its own publishing department, which printed colour reproductions and some eight hundred postcards, and in 1929–1930 it published the journal Iskusstvo v massy ("Art to the Masses"). In 1925 a youth organisation of art students, OMAKhRR, was formed.
Whom did it fight?
The association put its effort into defending the narrative picture painted at the easel. "Left" theorists argued that the picture was dying and that art should move into production and everyday life; the association opposed both this and "art for art's sake". Left critics such as Boris Arvatov, Nikolai Tarabukin and Nikolai Punin attacked the association and its leading painter Brodsky as "bourgeois", "backward" and "reactionary".
The association also policed its own ranks. In 1924 its re-registration commission expelled several painters from the former Jack of Diamonds group as alien to the association's ideology and comradely life. In May 1928 Brodsky was expelled for owning an auction hall and pursuing material gain. A study cited by Russian Wikipedia writes that the association "showed dictatorial tendencies too insistently", and that this, more than its artistic principles, provoked opposition from many artists and groups.
Its most persistent rival was the Society of Easel Painters (OST), founded in 1925 by graduates of the VKhUTEMAS with David Shterenberg as chairman. OST also painted Soviet reality, industrialisation and sport, but borrowed techniques from European expressionism. Because it was close to the association in defending easel painting, the rivalry between the two went on after the fight against the avant-garde was over.
What happened after 1928?
In 1928 the association held its first congress, adopted a new declaration and renamed itself the Association of Artists of the Revolution (AKhR), dropping "Revolutionary Russia" for "the Revolution". But according to researchers, by the end of the 1920s it was half disintegrated. Its youth organisation became independent in 1928 and mostly joined the Russian Association of Proletarian Artists (RAPKh), and several former leaders set up a separate "Union of Soviet Artists" in 1930. RAPKh, formed in 1931 partly out of the association, divided artists into "bourgeois" and "proletarian" and campaigned with crude administrative methods for the "purity of proletarian art".
The party resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" of 23 April 1932 dissolved all these groups. The Association of Artists of the Revolution, like the other art organisations, entered the new union of Soviet artists. An all-Union Union of Artists of the USSR held its first congress only in 1957.
What remained, and how is it judged?
What the association defended did not disappear. The Great Soviet Encyclopedia wrote that it played an important role in bringing Soviet artists together and spreading art among the masses, and Soviet art-history textbooks credited it with defending, against the formalist theories that proclaimed the "dying out" of easel painting, the principles of ideological content, realism and a form the people could understand, and so preparing the victory of socialist realism. Painters from the association stood at the centre of Soviet art from the 1930s. Gerasimov became known for "Lenin on the Tribune" (1930) and his portraits of Stalin, chaired the organising committee of the Union of Artists of the USSR in 1939–1954 and was the first president of the USSR Academy of Arts in 1947–1957. Brodsky headed the All-Russian Academy of Arts from 1934.
Judgements of the paintings themselves differ. Even the Great Soviet Encyclopedia wrote that alongside the realist tradition and heroic-romantic aspirations its painters showed tendencies toward genre description and naturalism, and Soviet critics noted that this often led to petty subjects and illustrative pictures. Clear storytelling, conservative "realism" and attempts to recreate events as heroic documents are named as typical of its painting. On the other hand, because its leading painters had been trained in the drawing programme of the imperial academy, their work is not weak in drawing, composition or colour, and is held to have not only historical but often considerable artistic value today. Seen from the avant-garde, the association turned the experiments of revolutionary art back to old techniques; seen from the association, it left the revolution in pictures the masses could look at.