日本資本主義論争 · 1927–1937

Debate on Japanese Capitalism

일본 자본주의 논쟁

The debate among Japanese Marxist historians and economists in the 1930s over the character of Japanese capitalism. Narrowly it ran from about 1933 to about 1937, set off by the publication of the Lectures on the History of the Development of Japanese Capitalism (1932 to 1933); broadly it includes the dispute over revolutionary strategy between the Communist Party and the Rōnō-ha from about 1927. The Communist-aligned Kōza-ha stressed a semi-feudal absolutist emperor system and argued for a two-stage revolution; the Rōnō-ha saw the Meiji Restoration as an incomplete bourgeois revolution and argued for socialist revolution.

In depth

What was the quarrel about?

At its centre was the question of what the Meiji Restoration had been and what kind of state Japan had become since. The answer decided which revolution Japan now faced.

The Kōza-ha held that the political order under the Meiji government was absolutism and that the real social and economic order was semi-feudal landlordism. A bourgeois-democratic revolution overthrowing the emperor system therefore came first and would then pass over into a socialist revolution (the two-stage theory). The Rōnō-ha held that the Meiji Restoration, however incomplete, had been a bourgeois revolution and that Japan since then was a modern capitalist state with feudal survivals. The emperor system was a bourgeois monarchy and the target of struggle was the imperialist bourgeoisie centred on finance and monopoly capital, so the revolution would be socialist. Put in one phrase, the two sides differed over whether to confront the emperor system head-on.

Who were the two schools?

The Kōza-ha centred on Eitarō Noro, Moritarō Yamada and Yoshitarō Hirano, who compiled the Lectures, and it also included Shisō Hattori and Gorō Hani; its position meshed with the Comintern's 1927 and 1932 Theses. The Rōnō-ha formed when Hitoshi Yamakawa, Toshihiko Sakai, Kanson Arahata, Tsunao Inomata and others, who had stayed out of the party rebuilt after its 1924 dissolution, founded the magazine Rōnō in December 1927. Its economists included Tamizō Kushida, Hyōe Ōuchi and Itsurō Sakisaka. The Rōnō-ha was a loose group without a clear organisation or leadership; it regarded Leninism as a theory grown from Russian conditions and held that the revolutionary movement should not be directed from a single world centre.

How did it unfold?

In its broad sense the debate began about 1927 between the Communist Party and the Rōnō-ha (the debate on the Japanese democratic revolution). The points at issue were the assessment of the Meiji Restoration, the worker-peasant alliance and agrarian revolution, and how much of feudalism survived. The "Draft Political Theses" the party issued in 1931 came to agree in substance with the Rōnō-ha, but they were discarded when the 1932 Theses appeared and the party reaffirmed the two-stage theory.

In its narrow sense the debate was set off by the Lectures on the History of the Development of Japanese Capitalism, published by Iwanami Shoten in seven volumes from May 1932 to August 1933 and often censored or banned. When Sakisaka and others around Rōnō criticised it from the standpoint of socialist revolution, the authors of the Lectures came to be called the Kōza-ha and their critics the Rōnō-ha. The debate bred many smaller ones, on feudalism, on ground rent, on the "new landlords" and on manufacture. Moritarō Yamada's Analysis of Japanese Capitalism (1934) and Itsurō Sakisaka's Problems of Japanese Capitalism (1937) are the representative books of the two sides.

How did it end?

The debate ended when the Kōza-ha was rounded up in the Com-Academy incident of 1936 and the Rōnō-ha in the Popular Front incidents of 1937 and 1938. In the Com-Academy incident 32 scholars and researchers who had written for the Lectures were arrested together under the Peace Preservation Law on 10 July 1936. The Popular Front incident marked the point at which arrests, until then confined to the Communist Party, were extended to non-Communist Marxists with no connection to the Comintern.

How does it connect with the debates in China and Korea?

The same question was being asked at the same time next door. In China a controversy over the nature of Chinese society ran from 1928 to 1937. Among the Comintern's leaders, Stalin and Bukharin held that feudal forces still predominated in China and that a democratic revolution against feudalism and imperialism was called for; Trotsky and Radek held that China was already led by capitalism and that the revolution's aims must include socialism. The Sixth Congress of the Chinese Communist Party in 1928 defined Chinese society as semi-colonial and semi-feudal and the revolution as bourgeois-democratic. The pattern is that of the Kōza-ha and Rōnō-ha: weigh the feudal survivals heavily and a democratic revolution comes first, weigh capitalist development heavily and the revolution is socialist at once.

Korea too had a debate in the mid-1930s over the character of rural society. In Jeong-sik, who had been a member of the Japan bureau of the Communist Party of Korea in Tokyo in the late 1920s, argued with Pak Mun-byeong over the character of society and the agrarian question, and he is counted as the leading theorist of a "semi-feudal" thesis influenced by the Japanese Kōza-ha.

What did it leave behind?

After the war the debate resumed over how to judge the land reform: whether the occupation's reform had dissolved landlord landholding. The Kōza-ha view of history is said to have influenced the reform through Moritarō Yamada and others who sat on the farmland councils, and postwar scholars such as Hisao Ōtsuka and Masao Maruyama were influenced by Kōza-ha theory. In politics it survived as the difference between the Communist Party current, which argued for two stages from democratic to socialist revolution, and the Socialist Party left and others in the Rōnō-ha line, who argued for socialist revolution at once. The Rōnō-ha was continued after the war by the Socialist Association, the theoretical group of the Socialist Party's left wing.

Some credit the debate with deepening research into the nature of modern Japan; others note that the rivalry between Communist and non-Communist camps often reduced it to criticism for its own sake.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. ja.wikipedia.org
  2. ja.wikipedia.org
  3. ja.wikipedia.org
  4. ja.wikipedia.org
  5. ja.wikipedia.org
  6. ja.wikipedia.org
  7. ja.wikipedia.org
  8. ja.wikipedia.org
  9. zh.wikipedia.org
  10. Wikipedia (KO)