Independent Labour Movement (Taiwan)
자주 노조 운동 (대만)
The movement in which Taiwanese workers, around the lifting of martial law in 1987, broke away from the unions directed by the Kuomintang, founding their own unions or winning control of existing ones by election and striking for the rights the law already promised. It began with the bonus strikes of spring 1988 and was broken by the suppression of the Far Eastern Chemical Fiber strike in 1989. "Independent" meant autonomy from the KMT-sponsored unions.
In depth
The independent labour movement was the two years in which workers in Taiwan, once martial law had been lifted, first ran unions with their own hands. Most of what they demanded was already written into law: bonuses and allowances, and the right to elect their own union officers. To obtain it, however, they had to use means outside the institutions, strikes and street marches. The movement was broken in 1989, but the cadres and organisations it produced became the backbone of Taiwan's labour movement afterwards.
Taiwan's labour movement has a history that was once cut off. Under Japanese rule, in 1928, the Taiwan Workers' Federation, the first island-wide labour organisation, was formed with the help of the Taiwanese People's Party (1927), and the new Taiwanese Cultural Association led strikes of its own, but all were destroyed by the repression of the early 1930s. After the war the labour movement did not recover from the February 28 Incident, martial law, the collapse of the Taiwan Provincial Work Committee and the Taiwanese White Terror. The Chinese Federation of Labour, founded in Nanjing in 1948, came to Taiwan with the government and became the only national organisation, but it held its first congress only in 1976 and worked less as a body for workers' interests than as an unofficial department of the government.
Taiwan's unions operated under the Labour Union Law the KMT had drawn up on the mainland in the 1920s: the government could dissolve unions or replace their officers, and only one union was allowed per workplace. The Labor Standards Law of 1984 went largely unenforced, and that year opposition intellectuals founded the Taiwan Labor Legal Support Association.
The Labor Standards Law was passed under pressure that the United States applied on account of its trade deficit. In Ho Ming-sho's view the gap between what the law promised and actual conditions lit the first round of labour disputes after the lifting of martial law. There had been signs before that. At Far Eastern Chemical Fiber in Hsinpu, Hsinchu county, workers applied to set up a union from 1975 and were granted approval only in 1977; in 1986 workers took all the seats of directors and supervisors and then set up a strike fund. The magazine Hsia-chao (China Tide), founded in 1976, opened a left-wing discussion critical of imperialism and capitalism. When martial law was lifted in July 1987 the government upgraded the labour department of the Ministry of the Interior to the Council of Labor Affairs under the Executive Yuan in August, and on 1 November the Workers' Party, the first party to appeal to workers, was founded.
In spring 1988, the first lunar New Year after the lifting, strikes for a larger bonus spread spontaneously. In February the Taoyuan Bus union stopped the buses for five days and won a higher bonus; on 1 May railway engine drivers stopped work under the guise of "collective leave"; on 15 July the Taiwan Petroleum Workers' Union petitioned the Ministry of Economic Affairs. During the Miaoli Bus strike in August the independent unions formed a common front for the first time. The Far Eastern Chemical Fiber union, which voted for a strike fund and "brother unions," became the movement's vanguard.
People from beyond the island were involved in the movement too. Neil Magill, an Irish Catholic priest in Taoyuan, had worked as a missionary in South Korea before coming to Taiwan and had taken part in union organising there; in 1984 he set up a workers' centre in Taoyuan. In March 1989 the government deported him without warning. Through José Ellacuría, a Spanish priest who ran a workers' service centre in Hsinchu, the independent unions made contact with an international labour confederation.
1989 was the year of the counter-attack. Around the lunar New Year the government and employers together bore down on the bus unions of Taoyuan, Miaoli, Kaohsiung and elsewhere, dismissing officers and dividing the members. The Far Eastern strike began with the transfer of the union officer Hsu Cheng-kun. When the strike started on 15 May the company sent in security men and the government riot police and water-cannon trucks, and it ended in the union's defeat when the whole plant was back at work on 25 May. Three officers, Hsu Cheng-kun, Luo Mei-wen and Tseng Kuo-mei, were dismissed.
After the Far Eastern strike was crushed by riot police in May 1989 and the Hau Pei-tsun cabinet prosecuted activists from 1990, strikes largely disappeared. Estimates of those dismissed or indicted range from over 400 to some 200 dismissed and 20 prosecuted, depending on the source. The sociologist Ho Ming-sho sums the movement up as "struggle according to the law" and traces the later turn of the labour movement to legislative lobbying.
The organisations remained after the defeat. On 25 December 1989 twelve independent unions, among them those of Far Eastern Chemical Fiber and Taoyuan Bus and the Taiwan railway employees' association, formed the National Federation of Independent Trade Unions. It was the first general union body created outside the system, and Tseng Mao-hsing of Taoyuan Bus became its president. From 1994, using the gap that the Labour Union Law did not forbid general industrial unions at local level, such federations were set up county by county and city by city, beginning with Taipei county. Ho Ming-sho compares this with South Korea, where after the labour upsurge of 1987 unions set up eleven regional councils to coordinate activism beyond the firm, and with Japan, where the regional labour councils of Sōhyō took part in organising drives. The Taiwan Confederation of Trade Unions formed by these local federations was recognised by the government on 1 May 2000, and became Taiwan's first autonomous and legal national union organisation, set against the government-controlled Chinese Federation of Labour.