Left-Right Coalition Committee
좌우합작위원회
The body launched on 25 July 1946 around Yeo Un-hyeong and Kim Kyu-sik to work for a unified provisional government through cooperation of left and right, under the auspices of the US military government after the first Joint Commission adjourned. The left's five principles and the right's eight clashed until seven agreed principles were adopted in October, but the Communist Party, the Korea Democratic Party and the followers of Syngman Rhee and Kim Ku all turned their backs on it. It was effectively over after Yeo was assassinated in July 1947.
In depth
Why was it formed?
When the first US-Soviet Joint Commission adjourned in May 1946, the road to a unified provisional government was blocked. Yeo Un-hyeong, Kim Kyu-sik, Ahn Chai-hong and others held that with two foreign armies in the country, cooperation of left and right was the only way through. The US military government also promoted a coalition, with a different aim. Its calculation was to split the left between Pak Hon-yong's Communist Party of Korea and Yeo Un-hyeong's centre-left and isolate the former, whereas the State Department wanted to exclude both far left and far right and build up the centre. From the adjournment the military government turned to repressing the left: the Jeongpansa counterfeit note incident broke in May, three left-wing newspapers were suspended in July, and in early September warrants were issued for Pak Hon-yong and Yi Kang-guk.
Who took part?
On 25 May Lieutenant Leonard Bertsch, an adviser to the military government, brought together Kim Kyu-sik and Won Se-hun with Yeo Un-hyeong and Hwang Jin-nam, and they met again on 30 May and 14 June. On 19 July five delegates were named for each side. The right had Kim Kyu-sik as chief delegate with Won Se-hun, Kim Pung-jun, Ahn Chai-hong and Choe Tong-o; the left had Yeo Un-hyeong as chief delegate with Ho Hon, Chong No-sik, Yi Kang-guk and Song Chu-sik. The left delegation included people from the Korean People's Party, the Communist Party of Korea and the South Korean New People's Party. The committee was launched on 25 July and held its first regular meeting the next day.
What were the opposing positions?
The principles clashed at once. The left's Five Principles were support for the Moscow decision, land reform by confiscation and free distribution together with nationalisation of major industries, exclusion of pro-Japanese collaborators, transfer of power to the people's committees, and opposition to a legislative body created by the military government. The North Korean land reform had been completed in a single month that March, so land was a point on which the left could not give way. The right's Eight Principles put off the trusteeship question until after a provisional government was formed and left the collaborators to a special court to be set up then.
What was in the Seven Principles?
Yeo went to northern Korea in late September to discuss the three-party merger and other questions, and on his return on 4 October pressed for a compromise. The Seven Principles of Left-Right Coalition, announced on 7 October, provided for a provisional government under the Moscow decision, a request to reconvene the Joint Commission, land reform and nationalisation of major industries, an ordinance on collaborators and national traitors, release of political prisoners and restraint of terror, the formation of a legislative body, and freedom of speech, assembly and association. The first and fifth read (in the modern Korean rendering of the National Institute of Korean History):
조선의 민주 독립을 보장한 삼상 회의 결정에 의하여 남북을 통한 좌우 합작으로 민주주의 임시 정부를 수립할 것
(To establish a democratic provisional government through left-right cooperation across north and south, in accordance with the decision of the three foreign ministers' conference that guaranteed Korea's democratic independence.)
남북을 통하여 현 정권하에 검거된 정치 운동가의 석방에 노력하고 아울러 남북 좌우의 테러 행동을 일절 즉시로 제지토록 노력할 것
(To work for the release of political activists arrested under the present authorities in north and south, and to work to stop at once all acts of terror by left and right, north and south.)
The land clause was a compromise: land obtained by "confiscation, conditional confiscation and purchase at a diminishing rate" would be distributed to the peasants free. Purchase at a diminishing rate meant paying a lower price the more land an owner held. Landlords would be paid but peasants would receive land without payment, which differed both from the left's uncompensated confiscation and from the right's distribution for payment.
Why did it fail to gain ground?
Nearly every force turned away. The Korea Democratic Party restated its opposition to trusteeship and firmly rejected the land clause, and in the aftermath of the coalition movement more than a hundred of its officers, Won Se-hun among them, left the party. Syngman Rhee said he supported the principles with some dissatisfaction; Kim Ku declared support but did not sign. The left's Democratic National Front formally rejected the Seven Principles on 11 October, and Pak Hon-yong warned Yeo not to be used in an American scheme. Politics now turned on the Autumn Uprising and the three-party merger of the left. The committee held a Korean-American joint conference on the causes of the uprising and the measures to be taken, and submitted its findings to Hodge.
On the basis of the legislative clause of the Seven Principles, the military government issued an ordinance on 12 October creating an interim legislature and, over Yeo's objections, opened the South Korean Interim Legislative Assembly on 12 December with 45 elected and 45 appointed members. Once the assembly existed, the military government lost interest in the coalition.
What was happening in China at the same time?
Korea was not the only place where the United States tried to broker a government of left and right in occupied or war-torn territory. In the same year, 1946, it had sent Marshall to China to mediate a unified government between the Kuomintang and the Communist Party (the Marshall Mission), an attempt that ended in failure in January 1947. The Korean coalition effort ended in the same year. In both places the plan to build up a centre lost its footing as the forces at either end grew stronger.
How did it end?
With the second Joint Commission opening on 21 May 1947 and Yeo's assassination on 19 July, the movement was in effect over. Kim Kyu-sik's side dissolved the Left-Right Coalition Committee and other centrist bodies into the National Independence Federation in December 1947, and that current led on to the North-South Joint Conference of 1948.