Московский методологический кружок · 1952–1994

Moscow Methodological Circle

모스크바 방법론 서클

A Soviet school of philosophy and methodology that continued from 1958 around Georgy Shchedrovitsky, having split from the Moscow Logic Circle begun in 1952 by the young Moscow University philosophers Alexander Zinoviev, Boris Grushin, Merab Mamardashvili and Shchedrovitsky. At first it sought to build a "content logic" that studied thought empirically in scientific texts; later it moved to a methodology analysing thought as activity and to organisational-activity games. It was kept going for more than thirty years as a seminar outside official philosophy, and after the seminars stopped in 1987 it dispersed into a methodological movement.

In depth

How can the way people think be studied?

Suppose you want to know how an outstanding scientist solved a problem. You could ask, you could scan the brain, or you could compare it with the rules in a logic textbook. But the experience in his head does not transfer fully into words, a picture of the brain does not say what inference took place, and the rules of logic pick out correct inferences without explaining how a new thought arose. One material remains: what he wrote. To read scientific texts as traces of thought and extract the procedures of thinking from them was this circle's starting point.

It was begun in 1952 in the philosophy faculty of Moscow University by Zinoviev and his juniors Grushin, Mamardashvili and Shchedrovitsky. Officially the group was a seminar within the faculty's student scholarly society, and docents of the logic department in turn lent their names as heads, but in fact it was an initiative of postgraduates and students. This was around the time of Stalin's withdrawal and death. One memoir recalls these days of strolling along Gorky Street and the nearby boulevards. They declared that the concepts of formal logic were insufficient for the empirical study of thought, and rejected the psychologism that explains thought as an individual's mental ability.

A word on the name. The group from 1952 to 1957–1958 is the "Moscow Logic Circle", and the one led by Shchedrovitsky from 1958 after the split is the "Moscow Methodological Circle". Russian sources treat the latter as the direct continuation of the former, so this entry treats them together. The participants had the nickname "dialectical stankovists".

Why begin with Capital?

Their representative material was Marx's Capital. It was a book whose authority no one in the Soviet Union could deny, and also a long scientific text in which one could follow the procedures by which a complex object was theorised. Zinoviev's candidate thesis "The method of ascent from the abstract to the concrete (on the material of Marx's Capital)" is the representative work of the time. It failed twice before the faculty's academic council and passed on the third attempt at the higher attestation commission only in September 1954, with Teodor Oizerman among its examiners. Zinoviev himself later put it down to youthful enthusiasm, but some fifty years on, in 2002, he did not object to its publication.

Grushin's and Mamardashvili's diploma theses also dealt with the logical and the historical in Capital. In the same period Evald Ilyenkov was also holding on to Capital (see "The Dialectics of the Abstract and the Concrete in Marx's Capital"). But the direction differed. Where the "group of epistemologists" of Ilyenkov and Valentin Korovikov sought to revive dialectics as logic, Zinoviev's group wanted a content-genetic logic as an alternative to both official dialectical logic and formal logic. Sharp statements by both groups at the philosophical conferences of 1953–1954 were a part of the life of the philosophical world. The discussion "On disagreements over questions of logic" took place in early 1954. Zinoviev said that bourgeois philosophers used to explain the world and now Soviet philosophers did not do even that, a joke twisting the last line of Marx's "Theses on Feuerbach". The participants were called in by the KGB, but no repression followed.

Why did they split, and where did each go?

Failing to work out a shared research programme, the participants went their own ways in 1957–1958.

Zinoviev moved to non-standard logical calculi such as many-valued logic. When his satirical novel The Yawning Heights came out in Switzerland in 1976, he was expelled in 1978 and stripped of citizenship, living in Munich until his return in 1999. Grushin specialised from a methodologist of historical research into a sociologist and founded the Institute of Public Opinion at Komsomolskaya Pravda in 1960. Mamardashvili declared the organised form of work in circles and movements unacceptable to himself and defined himself as a philosopher of "Socratic" temperament. His Forms and Content of Thought (1968) carries traces of the inquiry of that time. And Shchedrovitsky set up a programme for studying thought as activity and organised the methodological circle around it.

What did Shchedrovitsky build?

Shchedrovitsky's work went through roughly three stages: the content-genetic epistemology and theory of thought of 1952–1960; the activity approach and general theory of activity of 1961–1971; and the system-thought-activity approach and general methodology from 1971. The result is what in Russian is called СМД, "system-thought-activity" methodology.

The word methodology sounds ordinary but the meaning is special. According to Pyotr Shchedrovitsky's explanation, the circle assumed that if the laws of thinking activity could be described, new technologies of thought could be built on them. As one describes natural processes and then builds engineering systems, so one should describe intellectual practices such as education, design, scientific research and management and produce normative prescriptions. In other words, philosophy sought to become an engineering of thought instead of interpreting the world. The seminar had a rule that "ideas have no ownership" and a policy of recording results as collective works.

Relations with the regime were uneasy. Shchedrovitsky worked as a school teacher in 1951–1958, went on to be an editor at a pedagogical publishing house and a researcher at a preschool education institute, moved among various research institutions, and late in life headed a laboratory at an institute of architectural theory. In 1968 he signed the "letter of the 170" defending Yuri Galanskov and Alexander Ginzburg and was expelled from the party. Collective works were blocked at the press or appeared in small numbers. The printing of Problems of the Study of Systems and Structures (1965) was seized, and the type for Pedagogy and Logic (1968) was broken up. Only in 1995–2007 did about twenty of his books appear, many of them from archive material.

From 1979 came a new form: the organisational-activity game. It is a form combining the character of educational business games with intellectual methodological discourse. Shchedrovitsky ran 93 such games up to 1993.

What became of it after the Soviet Union?

When the seminars stopped in 1987 he tried to preserve unity through methodological congresses. The first was held in Kyiv in January 1989 and there were five in all, but the circle soon turned into a methodological movement. In 1990 the almanac Kentavr began in samizdat form, and in 1991 came the journal Problems of Methodology, which he edited. After his death in February 1994 his students set up independent organisations and carried on the work in fields such as cultural studies, legal theory, the theory of sociocultural systems and the methodology of education.

This last branch divides opinion. English-language accounts stress the school's influence on Russian systems thinking through the Methodological School of Management, and report that Viktor Khristenko has acknowledged it. On the other hand, in 2022 the outlet Meduza published an article naming methodology as the school of thought that produced the idea of the "Russian world". This entry has confirmed only that article's title and not its text.

How does it differ from other Soviet philosophy?

Ilyenkov's "dialectical logic" looked for the forms of knowledge in social activity and history while keeping the language of dialectics. Alexei Leontiev's "activity theory" took activity as the basic unit of psychology. The methodological circle also spoke of activity, but its interest lay in organising more than in explaining. The biggest difference is that it saw thought as a procedure that can be described and redesigned.

Shchedrovitsky himself wrote much on psychology, yet in Russian psychology today his ideas remain marginal and his name is rarely cited. In pedagogy, on the other hand, he has many supporters.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (RU)
  2. Wikipedia (RU)
  3. Wikipedia (RU)
  4. Wikipedia (RU)
  5. Wikipedia (RU)
  6. Wikipedia (RU)
  7. Wikipedia (EN)