Non-simultaneity (Bloch)
비동시성 (블로흐)
The idea that people living in the same age in fact live in different times: within one society, ways of life and forms of consciousness from different stages of development overlap. Ernst Bloch developed it in an essay of 1932 and in Heritage of Our Times (1935) to explain why Nazism captured peasants, the petty bourgeoisie and the young. It is widely known through the phrase "the simultaneity of the non-simultaneous", and was later taken up in theories of modernity, world-systems, postmodernism and postcolonialism.
In depth
Do people who share a date share a time?
On the same street in 2020s Korea there may be a young person working on a smartphone, an old farmer who has worked the same paddy all his life, and the owner of a failing corner shop. The calendar is the same. But their memories, fears and pictures of a desirable life may come from different ages. Looking at Germany in the 1930s, Ernst Bloch made exactly this the central problem of politics. The chapter on non-simultaneity in Heritage of Our Times opens with a famous sentence.
"Not all people are there in the same Now. They are so only outwardly, by virtue of being visible today. But that does not mean they live at the same time as the others."
„Nicht alle sind im selben Jetzt da. Sie sind es nur äußerlich, dadurch, dass sie heute zu sehen sind. Damit aber leben sie noch nicht mit den anderen zugleich.“
Bloch went on to say that each person has his times according to where he stands bodily and, above all, in terms of class. Many years sound together within the one year now counted, and those older times do not lie hidden but contradict the Now "very strangely, awry, from behind".
Where did Bloch get the term?
The first to use it was the art historian Wilhelm Pinder, who spoke of "the non-simultaneity of the simultaneous" in his 1926 book The Problem of Generation in the Art History of Europe. Pinder mocked the view of art history as a single file of Romanesque, Gothic, Renaissance, Baroque and so on as a "goose-march of styles". In real art old and new styles exist at the same time, and he explained this by artists' membership of different generations.
Bloch moved the concept into politics and social analysis. According to English Wikipedia his principal use of the term came in a 1932 essay that tried to explain the rise and popularity of Nazism in the crisis of the Great Depression; the essay became a chapter of Heritage of Our Times in 1935. Its title is "Non-simultaneity and the Obligation to Its Dialectics". The phrase "the simultaneity of the non-simultaneous", usually attributed to Bloch, is not in fact used in this essay. What Bloch worked out there is the distinction between contradictions simultaneous and non-simultaneous with "the Now".
Who is "non-simultaneous"?
For Bloch the simultaneous contradiction is the one capitalism itself generates, above all the contradiction between capital and the modern industrial proletariat. The non-simultaneous contradiction is the survival of an unfinished past that capitalism has not yet "sublated". The editors of the German journal INDES summarize what Bloch called the "objectively non-simultaneous": small individual property in house and land, rural feelings of community, the habit of thinking in categories such as "the people", in short the elements of an old society that have not yet died. To this corresponds the "subjectively non-simultaneous", lying as feelings of bitterness and dull resentment that break out in times of crisis as "dammed-up rage".
Bloch named three groups as bearers of this non-simultaneity: the young, the peasants and the impoverished middle strata. In the young it was enthusiasm, in the peasants rootedness in the soil, in the impoverished middle strata insecurity that turned them backward. The revolutionary proletariat, by contrast, he took to be "simultaneous", so that old contradictions posed no problem for it. Since workers too flocked to the Nazis, the INDES editors observe, this passage shows Bloch relying on a Marxist class scheme.
German Wikipedia notes that Bloch distinguished genuine from false non-simultaneity. Small peasants, small producers, small traders and, as a petty-bourgeois special case, white-collar employees are not merely backward; their anachronistic modes of production are intertwined with capital. Bloch called Germany "the classical land of non-simultaneity": from the Peasants' War through 1848 to the November Revolution of 1918 no revolution had won, so antiquated attitudes could survive. Unlike England and France, no bourgeois revolution had succeeded there before 1918, the nation-state came late, and the nobility kept its strong position far longer than elsewhere.
What did Marxism miss?
Bloch's target with this concept was not only the Nazis but the orthodox Marxism of his time. According to German Wikipedia he criticized orthodox analyses for seeing only the "simultaneous" contradiction between ownership of capital and the compulsion to wage labour while ignoring non-simultaneous, historical contradictions. Marxist analysis must not only coldly analyse the simultaneous contradiction but also take account of the "warm stream" of unsettled struggles and utopias.
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy notes that Bloch criticized the positivist tendencies in Marxism that Lenin had called "stupid materialism", which dismissed all "irrational" elements precisely at the point when it was critical to engage with them. Meanwhile the German fascists exploited the anti-capitalist, utopian tendencies of these strata and refunctioned them in their conservative propaganda. Bloch held that a more inclusive left had to win back the energy of non-simultaneity.
So instead of a view of history marching to a single beat, Bloch called for a dialectic of overlapping rhythms. English Wikipedia notes that he spoke of a "polyphonous", "multispatial" and "multitemporal" dialectics, not to deny the possibility of proletarian revolution but to gain additional revolutionary force from the incomplete wealth of the past. The unfinished contents of the past are not past because they were never quite attained, and Bloch likened them to the "gold-bearing gravel" in earlier labour processes.
Where did it lead?
In the early 1960s Bloch took up the concept again in his Tübingen Introduction to Philosophy. This time he dealt with the different progress of cultures and distanced himself from the reactionary "cultural-circle theory" that nails time to space.
"The concept of progress tolerates no 'cultural circles' in which time is reactionarily nailed to space, but instead of single-linearity it needs a broad, elastic, fully dynamic multiverse."
„Der Fortschrittsbegriff duldet keine 'Kulturkreise', worin die Zeit reaktionär auf den Raum genagelt ist, aber er braucht statt der Einlinigkeit ein breites, elastisches, völlig dynamisches Multiversum“
The concept spread far beyond Bloch. English Wikipedia places in this line Louis Althusser and Étienne Balibar, who in Reading Capital treated periods of transition between modes of production as the coexistence of several modes in a single "simultaneity", and Ernest Mandel, who described late capitalism as a hierarchy of different levels of productivity. In the mid-1980s the American historian Jeffrey Herf spoke of Germany's "reactionary modernism", in which technical progress and human and moral backwardness coexisted in one society.
The most famous use is the American critic Fredric Jameson's. In Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism (1991) he saw modernism as corresponding to an uneven moment of development, Bloch's simultaneity of the non-simultaneous, with handicrafts alongside the great cartels and peasant fields with the Krupp works in the distance; in postmodernity, he argued, such residues had been swept away without a trace. The postcolonial theorist Homi Bhabha replied that the non-synchronous temporality of global and national cultures opens a "third space".
In German historiography, meanwhile, Reinhart Koselleck used "the simultaneity of the non-simultaneous" differently. According to the INDES editors, Koselleck's interest was not political but in the theory of time: he built a theory of "layers of time" to measure the different speeds overlapping in history, and did not single out a German special path as Bloch did. The same phrase was for Bloch a diagnosis of class politics and for Koselleck a tool of historical writing.
Bloch himself showed what the concept means for aesthetics. He said that old dreams, folk art and popular literature should not be discarded wholesale but taken apart and remounted, and this was the ground of his defence of montage in the "Expressionism debate". The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy notes that in Bloch's interpretation works of art always transcend their immediate contexts and serve as "non-contemporaneous" indications of unrealized possibilities (see "Vor-Schein").