Unternehmen Hannibal · 1945.01–05

Operation Hannibal

한니발 작전

Operation Hannibal (Unternehmen Hannibal) was the German navy's evacuation by sea, from late January 1945 to around the German surrender in May, of soldiers and refugees from Courland, East Prussia, West Prussia and Pomerania, which the Red Army's advance had cut off, across the Baltic to western Germany and Denmark. It began as an order to move the submarine training units at Gotenhafen (Gdynia) west and grew into one of the largest evacuations by sea in history: by English Wikipedia's count some 800,000 to 900,000 civilians and 350,000 soldiers, by Russian Wikipedia's more than two million people. Along the way Soviet submarines sank the Wilhelm Gustloff on 30 January, the Steuben on 10 February and the Goya on 16 April, each with thousands of deaths.

In depth

How did Operation Hannibal begin?

The Soviet East Prussian offensive began on 13 January 1945. According to English Wikipedia, Ivan Chernyakhovsky's 3rd Belorussian Front and Konstantin Rokossovsky's 2nd Belorussian Front cut East Prussia off from the rest of Germany between 23 January and 10 February; according to German Wikipedia, the Red Army reached the sea near Elbing on 27 January. With the land routes closed, the people of East Prussia and the Danzig area poured towards the ports. The flight over land is covered in the events "The East Prussian Offensive of 1945 and the Fall of Königsberg" and "The East Pomeranian Offensive of 1945"; what follows is the evacuation by sea.

The German navy had been preparing an evacuation since late 1944. According to English Wikipedia, the preparations were made quietly because Hitler opposed such measures, and by the end of 1944 the navy's shipping department had assembled 22 former passenger liners of over 10,000 tonnes. Overall responsibility lay with Admiral Oskar Kummetz, the naval commander in the Baltic.

When the operation began, and on whose order, differs by source. Russian Wikipedia says it began on 21 January on the initiative of the navy's commander-in-chief Karl Dönitz; English Wikipedia says Dönitz radioed Gotenhafen (now Gdynia in Poland) on 23 January to begin the evacuation. German Wikipedia, citing the war diary of the naval war staff, says that on 23 January Admiral Hans-Georg von Friedeburg used the codeword "Hannibal" to order preparations for moving the 2nd Submarine Training Division at Gotenhafen to the west. The division's men were to go aboard the Wilhelm Gustloff, and several thousand refugees boarded with them. Russian Wikipedia likewise explains that the core of the operation was moving the submarine schools west, 70 to 80 trained submarine crews and more than 3,000 officers and cadets, hidden for secrecy among the refugees. An order that began as a military transfer grew into a mass flight by sea. German Wikipedia treats this sailing as the start of the navy's and merchant marine's transports of wounded and refugees in the first half of 1945.

Why did the navy put refugees second at first?

According to German Wikipedia, Dönitz backed Hitler, against the advice of the Chief of the Army General Staff Heinz Guderian, in refusing to withdraw an encircled army group by sea. His reason was that the eastern Baltic had to be held at all costs as the last training area for the new Type XXI submarines, with which he hoped to turn the naval war against Britain and America. The same account judges that the plight of the East German civilians trapped with the army was wholly subordinated to an ideological war of "victory or ruin", and that the evacuation of civilians came second for military reasons and because of the fuel shortage.

Rations followed the same order. According to English Wikipedia, the collapse of German industry left food and medicine short; soldiers were fed first and the old, small children and the sick last, so that mortality among old and young refugees was high. The sea transports had only three weeks' supply of coal.

How did the evacuation unfold?

At first only 14 liners, 23 freighters of over 5,000 tonnes and a number of smaller craft were available. On 30 January the Wilhelm Gustloff, the Hansa and the whaling factory ship Walter Rau left Gotenhafen. The Hansa had to turn back with engine trouble, the Gustloff was sunk that night, and the Walter Rau reached Eckernförde. According to German Wikipedia, the heavy cruiser Admiral Hipper left Gotenhafen the same day with some 1,500 refugees and took them to Kiel.

On 19 February German forces reopened a corridor from Königsberg to Pillau, and great numbers of refugees waited for ships in the port of Pillau; according to English Wikipedia there were as many as 450,000 there on 8 April. In early March, while the cruiser Admiral Scheer and destroyers covered a bridgehead near Wollin, small craft took off more than 75,000 cut-off soldiers and civilians, and large liners such as the Deutschland carried up to 11,000 people each.

After Danzig and Gdynia fell at the end of March, the Hel peninsula was the last way out. On the night of 4–5 April small boats and landing craft moved over 30,000 people from the Oxhöfter Kämpe to Hel, and in April alone some 265,000 people were taken from the Danzig area to Hel. On 15 April a large convoy including four liners left Hel with more than 20,000 people, and the next day the Goya was sunk.

Dönitz, who succeeded Hitler as Reich President on 1 May, at first meant to carry on the war in the east. According to English Wikipedia he ordered that combat troops have priority in the evacuation from Courland, and gave up that plan only on the afternoon of 6 May, with British troops at his door. Between 1 and 8 May more than 150,000 people left the beaches of Hel, and at 9 p.m. on 8 May, the last day of the war, 92 ships large and small left Liepāja (Libau) in Latvia with 18,000 soldiers and civilians. Several hundred who boarded small craft on the last day or after were captured by Soviet torpedo boats, but evacuations to the west went on for at least a week after the surrender terms had prohibited all such movements.

How many people crossed the sea?

Figures vary widely with what is counted and who counts. English Wikipedia says that over fifteen weeks between 494 and 1,080 merchant ships and fishing boats, together with Germany's largest remaining naval units, carried 800,000 to 900,000 German civilians and 350,000 soldiers to Germany and occupied Denmark. English Wikipedia's article on the Steuben and Russian Wikipedia give more than two million, and Russian Wikipedia notes that about two and a half million civilians remained in encircled East Prussia. Either way it was far larger than the British evacuation of 338,226 soldiers from Dunkirk in 1940 and counts among the largest evacuations by sea in history.

The losses were heavy too. According to English Wikipedia, besides the Goya, the Wilhelm Gustloff and the Steuben, 158 other merchant ships were lost in those fifteen weeks. Russian Wikipedia puts the deaths from the three big sinkings alone at about 20,000.

What happened on the Wilhelm Gustloff?

The Wilhelm Gustloff, a ship of some 25,000 tons launched in 1937, was built as a workers' cruise ship for Strength Through Joy (KdF), the leisure organisation of the Nazi German Labour Front. She was named after Wilhelm Gustloff, leader of the Nazi Party's Swiss branch, who had been assassinated in Switzerland in 1936 by the Jewish medical student David Frankfurter. At the outbreak of war she served as a hospital ship in 1939–40, and from November 1940, painted grey, as an accommodation ship for the 2nd Submarine Training Division at Gotenhafen.

At 12:30 p.m. on 30 January 1945 she left Gotenhafen with two torpedo boats and the transport Hansa. When the Hansa and one torpedo boat dropped out with mechanical trouble, her only escort was the torpedo boat Löwe. Four captains aboard quarrelled over the course. According to English Wikipedia, the submarine commander Lieutenant Commander Wilhelm Zahn wanted to run without lights in shallow water close to shore, but the master, Friedrich Petersen, took her into deep water and, to avoid colliding with an oncoming German minesweeper convoy, had the red and green navigation lights switched on, making the ship easy to see. German Wikipedia says she was running blacked out when the torpedoes struck, so on this point the sources disagree.

Exactly how many were aboard is not known. The passenger lists named 6,050, but many people boarded without being recorded. Heinz Schön, a survivor who became the sinking's archivist, concluded that she carried 173 crew, 918 men of the 2nd Submarine Training Division, 373 women naval auxiliaries, 162 wounded soldiers and 8,956 civilians, 10,582 people in all. According to English Wikipedia, the passengers besides civilians included Gestapo personnel, members of the Organisation Todt and Nazi officials with their families, and besides Germans there were Lithuanians, Latvians, Poles, Estonians and Croatians aboard.

At about 9 p.m. the Soviet submarine S-13 under Captain Alexander Marinesko fired four torpedoes off the coast between Leba and Großendorf, and three struck the port side. The second hit the quarters of the women naval auxiliaries in the drained swimming pool; only three of the 373 survived. Most lifeboats were frozen to their davits and only nine could be lowered; the air temperature was between −10 and −18 °C and ice floes covered the sea. According to German Wikipedia, officers held about a thousand people at gunpoint in the armoured-glass winter garden to prevent panic, and part of the ship's original lifeboats, sized for her 1,900 passengers and crew, had been taken off in port and replaced with smaller boats. Less than forty minutes after the torpedoes struck she lay on her side, and she sank ten minutes later. German vessels rescued 1,252 people, 13 of whom soon died, so the number of survivors established by Schön is 1,239.

The death toll is still disputed. According to Russian Wikipedia the official figure is 5,348, while some historians put it as high as 9,985, including 5,000 children. Schön's research gives 9,343, and a computer evacuation simulation for a 2003 Discovery Channel programme estimated 9,600. Russian Wikipedia's article on Marinesko gives a range of 3,700 to 9,300 and says the overwhelming majority of the dead were refugees. On the higher estimates it is the deadliest sinking of a single ship in history.

How were the Steuben and the Goya sunk?

Eleven days later S-13 sank a second large ship. The Steuben (formerly the München and the General von Steuben) was a North German Lloyd liner that had sailed the North Atlantic from 1923, and from July 1944 she served in the Baltic as a transport for troops and wounded. German Wikipedia notes that she was not marked as a hospital ship. When she left Pillau for Swinemünde on 9 February, official reports listed 2,800 wounded soldiers, 800 civilians, 270 naval medical personnel and 64 anti-aircraft gunners among 4,267 people aboard; with unregistered refugees there were probably about 5,200. She sailed blacked out, escorted by the torpedo boat T196. Hit by S-13's torpedoes in the early hours of 10 February, she sank within 15 to 20 minutes; Marinesko at first believed he had sunk the light cruiser Emden. Some 650 to 660 people were rescued. German Wikipedia gives the dead as 1,100 to 4,200, English Wikipedia as about 4,500, and Russian Wikipedia's article on Marinesko as about 3,500, most of them wounded soldiers.

The Goya was a freighter built in Norway in 1940, seized by Germany after the occupation of Norway and used as a transport and then as a target ship for a submarine training flotilla at Memel. According to German Wikipedia, in February 1945 she received a modest anti-aircraft armament and a small military crew to man it, and on four voyages carried 19,785 people west. English Wikipedia says she was marked as a hospital ship and carried over a thousand beds for the seriously wounded, which German Wikipedia does not support. On her fifth voyage, on 16 April, she left Hel with wounded soldiers, refugees and 200 men of the 35th Panzer Regiment; the purser counted over 7,000 people at the gangway alone. At 11:52 p.m. the Soviet submarine L-3 under Vladimir Konovalov fired four torpedoes, two of which hit, and the freighter, lacking a liner's bulkheads, sank in seven minutes. Between 176 and 183 people are recorded as rescued, and the dead are estimated at 6,000 to more than 7,000. Konovalov was made a Hero of the Soviet Union for the sinking, yet according to German Wikipedia the Soviet Union long denied that it had taken place.

Were the Soviet submarine attacks lawful?

In post-war Germany the sinking of the Wilhelm Gustloff was often called a war crime. German Wikipedia, however, concludes that it was in keeping with the law of war of the time. To be protected, a ship carrying refugees had to be registered with and announced to the Red Cross in Switzerland, painted white with clearly visible red crosses, and sail fully lit so that the markings could be seen. The Gustloff did none of this: she flew the naval ensign, was commanded by naval officers, was painted in grey camouflage, was armed with anti-aircraft guns, was escorted by a torpedo boat and carried soldiers fit for combat. English Wikipedia likewise says that, since she had not been notified as a hospital ship and was carrying military personnel, she had no protection as a hospital ship under international accords. According to Russian Wikipedia, Heinz Schön too concluded that she was a military target and that her sinking was not a war crime. Russian Wikipedia adds that the Steuben, armed and escorted, was also a lawful military target.

Russian Wikipedia points out that German submarines and aircraft also repeatedly attacked Soviet transports carrying refugees and wounded. The Soviet transport Armenia, sunk in the Black Sea in 1941, was carrying more than 5,000 refugees and wounded, and only eight survived; the same account holds that the Armenia too had breached her hospital-ship status and was a lawful target.

Whatever the legal verdict, the Soviet Union treated the sinking with a mixture of glorification and silence. According to English Wikipedia, Soviet propaganda wrongly described the women aboard as "SS personnel from the German concentration camps". Marinesko himself had been facing a court martial before the patrol for drinking and breaches of discipline. He was put forward for the title of Hero of the Soviet Union, but his superiors reduced the award to the Order of the Red Banner, and at the end of 1945 he was demoted in rank and post and left the navy. According to Russian Wikipedia, late Soviet and some present-day Russian publications call the sinking "the attack of the century" and present Marinesko as "submariner No. 1". He died in 1963, and on 5 May 1990 a decree of President Mikhail Gorbachev made him a Hero of the Soviet Union posthumously.

Was it Dönitz's achievement?

Russian Wikipedia says the evacuation of millions is counted among Dönitz's merits, and that this is why many Germans regarded him favourably after the war despite his service in Hitler's government. German Wikipedia's account, by contrast, foregrounds, as seen above, that Dönitz opposed withdrawing an army group by sea in order to keep his submarine training waters, and put the evacuation of civilians second. English Wikipedia notes that even after becoming Reich President he ordered combat troops to be taken out of Courland first.

How did post-war Germany and the Soviet Union remember these waters?

In West Germany the Gustloff became a story standing for the suffering of flight and expulsion. Frank Wisbar made the film Darkness Fell on Gotenhafen (Nacht fiel über Gotenhafen), and the survivor Heinz Schön spent his life researching the sinking and published several books on it. In the Soviet Union the 1985 film Forget About Returning (O vozvrashchenii zabyt) retold the story of S-13, with the ship renamed "Tirol".

In 2002 the subject became a matter of public debate in Germany again. Günter Grass's novella Crabwalk (Im Krebsgang) wove a fictional family across three generations into two real events, the sinking of the Gustloff and the assassination of Wilhelm Gustloff in 1936. Its narrator, Paul Pokriefke, was born aboard the escort Löwe on the day of the sinking to his rescued mother Tulla. Tulla urges her son to write the story down, and when he will not, she passes it on to her grandson Konrad. Konrad sets up a website honouring Gustloff as a "martyr", quarrels online with a young man posing as a Jew, and finally shoots him dead, telling the police "I shot because I am a German", an inversion of the words "I shot because I am a Jew" attributed to Frankfurter in 1936. The book spent fourteen weeks at the top of the Spiegel bestseller list.

According to English Wikipedia, Grass believed that the failure to face the losses Germans suffered in the war had helped neo-Nazi movements grow. In a 2003 interview with the New York Times he said that one of his reasons for writing the novel was to take the subject away from the extreme right:

They said the tragedy of Wilhelm Gustloff was a war crime. It wasn't. It was terrible, but it was a result of war, a terrible result of war.

The sunken ships now lie off the Polish coast as war graves. The Polish Maritime Office in Gdynia has banned diving, anchoring and fishing within 500 metres of the Wilhelm Gustloff, and diving within 500 metres of the Goya. According to German Wikipedia, the Gustloff's bell, raised from the wreck, was lent to the Berlin exhibition "Forced Paths: Flight and Expulsion in 20th-Century Europe" but had to be returned early at the Polish government's request, and is now in the Museum of the Second World War in Gdańsk.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. Wikipedia (RU)
  3. de.wikipedia.org
  4. de.wikipedia.org
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. de.wikipedia.org
  9. de.wikipedia.org
  10. Wikipedia (RU)
  11. Wikipedia (RU)
  12. de.wikipedia.org
  13. Wikipedia (EN)
  14. de.wikipedia.org