Praxis school
프락시스 학파
A Marxist humanist school formed in the 1960s by philosophers and sociologists in Zagreb and Belgrade, Yugoslavia. From 1964 they published the journal Praxis and held a summer school on the island of Korčula, criticising Stalinism and the bureaucratisation of Yugoslav socialism on the basis of the young Marx's concepts of alienation and practice. In epistemology they took practice as the central category of human existence and knowledge, against a dialectical materialism centred on reflection theory. Their activity was blocked in 1975, when the journal ceased and eight Belgrade professors were driven from the university.
In depth
Why the Greek word "praxis"?
"Practice" is a common word. Schools speak of "theory and practice", companies of "action plans". Yet the philosophy journal founded in Zagreb in September 1964 deliberately chose the Greek form "praxis" as its title. The first issue's editorial, "Why Praxis?", explained: the word best expresses practice, the central concept of Marx's thought, and the Greek form was used "to distance ourselves from the pragmatist and vulgar-Marxist understanding of practice".
da se ogradimo od pragmatističkog i vulgarno-marksističkog shvaćanja prakse
The vulgar-Marxist understanding here is the idea that narrows practice to a tool for testing whether theory is correct, or to carrying out the party line. For the Praxis school practice was the free and creative activity in which people make the world and themselves. Humans are beings of praxis, and knowledge, too, arises within that activity.
How did it arise?
The school arose in 1960s Yugoslavia. After breaking with the Soviet Union in 1948, Yugoslavia proclaimed a socialism different from the Soviet one under the banner of workers' self-management. This gave it more room for ideas than other Eastern European countries. English Wikipedia writes that amid the turmoil of the 1960s, reaffirming "authentic" Marxist theory and praxis, in particular its humanist and dialectical aspects, was an urgent task for Yugoslav philosophers.
The journal Praxis published the first issue of its Yugoslav edition on 1 September 1964. Its founders were Branko Bošnjak, Danko Grlić, Milan Kangrga, Rudi Supek, Gajo Petrović, Predrag Vranicki, Danilo Pejović and Ivan Kuvačić; Petrović and Pejović were the first editors. From 1965 to 1973 an international edition also appeared in English and French. In Belgrade Mihailo Marković, Ljubomir Tadić, Svetozar Stojanović, Zagorka Golubović and others took part. The journal's advisory board listed names from East and West such as Ernst Bloch, Erich Fromm, Jürgen Habermas, György Lukács, Herbert Marcuse, Leszek Kołakowski, Karel Kosík and Lucien Goldmann.
Following a symposium in Dubrovnik in 1963, a summer school was held every year from 1964 on the Adriatic island of Korčula. In 1966 it could not be held because of attacks by the League of Communists of Croatia. Bloch, Marcuse, Habermas, Henri Lefebvre, Fromm and others attended, and phenomenologists, analytic philosophers and even a priest from the Vatican came, so it was not a gathering of Marxists alone.
What did it argue?
The first issue's editorial defined the philosophy the journal wanted: "philosophy as the thought of the revolution: ruthless criticism of everything existing, a humanist vision of a truly human world, and an inspiring force of revolutionary action".
Želimo filozofski časopis u onom smislu u kojem je filozofija misao revolucije: nepoštedna kritika svega postojećeg, humanistička vizija doista ljudskog svijeta i nadahnjujuća snaga revolucionarnog djelovanja.
The school had two main features. The first was its focus on the writings of the young Marx, above all the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts and the concept of "Alienation". The second was its demand for freedom of expression in East and West alike, grounded in Marx's thoroughgoing social critique. The editorial insisted that criticising one's own country is a Marxist's first task: "The primary task of Yugoslav Marxists, for example, is to discuss Yugoslav socialism critically."
Primarni je zadatak jugoslavenskih marksista, na primjer, da kritički raspravljaju o jugoslavenskom socijalizmu.
In epistemology the school stood in the current of the "Philosophy of praxis". Petrović saw philosophy as a radical critique of everything existing and stressed the creative and practical nature of human beings. Marković stressed alienation and the dynamic nature of human beings, Kangrga the human being as a producer who humanises nature. For them Soviet-style "Dialectical materialism", which put first the "Reflection theory" that consciousness reflects matter and the dialectics of nature, turned people into objects and was an apologetic theory that, adjusted to the needs of the party elite, tolerated no criticism. The school did not criticise self-management as such. Rather it held that bureaucratic power had grown in the Yugoslav economy because workers' self-management had not been implemented sufficiently.
What opposition did it meet?
From the side of the League of Communists of Yugoslavia, the Praxis school was a force undermining the leading role of the party. Some party ideologues called its editors and authors "professional anti-Communists" and "enemies of self-managing socialism". In 1968, when Belgrade University students held mass demonstrations against poor living conditions, authoritarianism, unemployment and the Vietnam War and eight professors of the Praxis school supported them, Josip Broz Tito demanded their dismissal on the grounds that they were "corrupting" the students. On 8 June of the same year Petrović was expelled from the League of Communists of Croatia for supporting the students' demands; the official reason was "anarcho-liberalism".
The journal was banned on several occasions. Its last issue was dated 1974, and from 1975 it could no longer be published. Croatian Wikipedia writes that it closed in 1974 for lack of funds; German Wikipedia writes that it was banned in 1975. The last issue of 1974 and the de facto ban of 1975 thus came together. In January 1975 the "Belgrade Eight", Marković, Tadić, Golubović, Stojanović, Miladin Životić, Dragoljub Mićunović, Nebojša Popov and Trivo Inđić, were expelled from the Faculty of Philosophy in Belgrade by a decision of the Serbian Assembly.
What happened afterwards?
Members of the school held a "Free University" meeting secretly in private homes, and in April 1981 they launched Praxis International in Oxford, England, as a successor to the international edition. From 1994 the journal has continued under the name Constellations.
As ethnic tensions grew in the 1980s the school divided. According to English Wikipedia, some Belgrade members turned towards Serbian nationalism. In 1986 Marković, Tadić and Golubović, together with the writer Dobrica Ćosić, signed a petition in support of Kosovo Serbs, and Marković was a co-author of the SANU Memorandum. How a humanist Marxism centred on practice related to nationalism remains a point of dispute in assessing the school.