The Principle of Hope
희망의 원리
Ernst Bloch's magnum opus, written in American exile between 1938 and 1947 and published in East Germany in three volumes in 1954, 1955 and 1959. It is an encyclopedia of hope that gathers "dreams of a better life" from everything people have made, from daydreams, advertising, fairy tales and travel to social utopias and architecture, music and religion. Beneath it Bloch laid a philosophy of the Not-Yet-Conscious, of objectively real possibility and of concrete utopia.
In depth
What does it mean to make hope a "principle" of philosophy?
Everyone daydreams: the trip after the exams, the window of the flat one will move into, the job one will one day quit, the better world one's child will live in. Such fancies are usually thought useless. Ernst Bloch saw them the other way round. In these little daydreams he found a force by which people lean towards what they do not yet have, and he held that weighing that force seriously was philosophy's business. The Principle of Hope unfolds this idea over more than 1,600 pages.
The preface tells readers who have come through the age of fascism and war that in the time just past it was all too easy to learn how to fear, and that a different feeling is now due.
"It is a question of learning hope. Its work does not renounce; it is in love with success rather than failure."
„Es kommt darauf an, das Hoffen zu lernen. Seine Arbeit entsagt nicht, sie ist ins Gelingen verliebt statt ins Scheitern.“
Bloch wrote the book in American exile between 1938 and 1947. According to German Wikipedia its title was originally to be the English "The dreams of a better life". In 1949 he went to East Germany as professor at Leipzig, and the book appeared in an enlarged and revised version in three volumes in 1954, 1955 and 1959. In West Germany Suhrkamp published it in 1959. English Wikipedia notes that Bloch came under attack for his philosophical unorthodoxy and his support for cultural freedom, and that publication was delayed for political reasons; that story is told in the Leipzig section of the "Ernst Bloch" card. Since the book, "the principle of hope" has become a stock phrase in the culture pages of German newspapers.
What do the five parts cover?
The book has three volumes, five parts and fifty-five chapters. The American critic Douglas Kellner sees the three volumes as roughly corresponding to Hegel's division of his system into subjective, objective and absolute spirit. Volume one contains "Little Daydreams" (report), the philosophical core "Anticipatory Consciousness" (foundation), and "Wishful Images in the Mirror" (transition). Volume two is "Outlines of a Better World" (construction), and volume three "Wishful Images of the Fulfilled Moment" (identity).
The first part is a literary piece of some twenty-five pages describing what people wish and long for from childhood to old age. It is typical of Bloch to address the reader first as an individual and then lead him through the complex history of philosophy.
In the second part Bloch takes on the psychology of his time. Where Sigmund Freud analysed night dreams and found the repressed past, the "no-longer-conscious", Bloch found the "not-yet-conscious" in daydreams. Daydreams do not merely chew over what is past; they picture and plan the future. On the basic drive, too, where Freud named the libido, Bloch named hunger, criticizing psychoanalysis for failing to take proper account of the material needs of ordinary people, such as the effect of hunger on consciousness. He was harsher still with Carl Gustav Jung and Alfred Adler.
Bloch then introduces the categories of Front, Novum and Ultimum. The Front is the present moment, the foremost place where the real future can be decided. He divides possibility into four layers: the formally possible, which does not contradict logic; the factually-objectively possible, which can be supposed on the basis of knowledge; the objectively possible in accordance with the nature of the object, which is open; and the objectively-real possible, which exists in matter as latency and tendency. Bloch equated this last possibility with matter, which for him was not an inert block but a self-creating process. He therefore called Marxism a "science of tendency", the mediated science of the future of reality plus the objectively-real possibility in it, for the purpose of action.
Where are the wishful images of everyday life?
The third part, "Wishful Images in the Mirror", is the most widely read part of the book. As Kellner notes, Bloch looks for utopian potential not only in the great works of the cultural heritage but in familiar and ordinary aspects of everyday experience. New clothes and grooming express a wish to turn oneself into something better. Shop windows and advertising invest commodities with magical powers. Fairs and the circus show the South Seas and the world of precise dexterity, and travel lets people dream of better lives. The fairy tale's "once upon a time" points not to the past but to the future, and its magic pictures the land of Cockaigne as utopia.
Adventure stories show ordinary people defeating villains and oppressors; Bloch called them immature but honest substitutes for revolution. Yet he did not praise popular culture wholesale. These wishful images can be broken and twisted, leaving people open to seduction. He condemned the American jazz dances of the years after 1930 more harshly even than Adorno did, setting against them folk dance not yet turned into a commodity. In the section on the stage, on the other hand, he wrote positively of Bertolt Brecht, reading the joy of liberation, defiance and hope as the future at work in the theatre. The first volume ends with a piece on the happy ending whose title sums up Bloch's attitude: "seen through and yet defended".
How does a social utopia become "concrete"?
The largest part of volume two is a history of social utopias. Over nearly two hundred pages Bloch surveys the social wishful images of the past, from Solon and Diogenes through Thomas More to Edward Bellamy and William Morris. He held that they were not arbitrary but socially conditioned: social utopia worked as part of the power to wonder, to find the given so far from self-evident that only its change makes sense. The chapter ends with a plea for Marxist concrete anticipation.
The key concept here is "concrete utopia". Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels had criticized the early socialists for drawing only abstract utopias. According to Engels social progress becomes feasible not through the insight that the existence of classes contradicts justice, nor through the mere will to abolish classes, but through certain new economic conditions. Bloch sought to stop this critique from spreading into a rejection of all utopia. With the adjective "concrete" he turned around the everyday sense of utopia as the unrealizable. Its opposite, he said, is not the absence of utopia, which would be economism, but utopia becoming concrete. Concrete utopia is the process of realization in which the closer features of the future are produced by groping and experiment.
The attitude that suits it Bloch called "militant optimism", also an "optimism with crape", a tested hope set against both pessimism and reckless, untested optimism. His example was a slogan from the German Peasants' War: "Beaten we go home; our grandchildren will fight it out better!" Bloch also knew how rare it is in history for the oppressed majority to rise.
"For a thousand wars there are not ten revolutions; so hard is the upright gait."
„Auf tausend Kriege kommen nicht zehn Revolutionen; so schwer ist der aufrechte Gang.“
The "upright gait" (aufrechter Gang) became Bloch's favourite image of human dignity. In the chapter on technical utopias he also put forward the idea of an "alliance technology": in place of bourgeois technology, which sees nature only as something to outwit or exploit, a technology in which people who understand themselves as creators of value understand nature as creative matter and form an alliance with it.
The fulfilled moment and "home"
Volume three treats wishful images in morality, music, death, religion, nature and, finally, "home". Bloch held that we never fully experience the very now in which we live, so that no one has yet truly lived. The fulfilled moment is when that now at last shows itself.
The book's last sentences gather this thought into the word Heimat, "home". Bloch wrote that man still lives everywhere in prehistory and that the real genesis is not at the beginning but at the end. The root of history is the working, creating human being who reshapes and surpasses what is given. Once he has grasped himself and established what is his without alienation in real democracy, there arises in the world
"something that shines into everyone's childhood and where no one has yet been: home."
„etwas, das allen in die Kindheit scheint und worin noch niemand war: Heimat.“
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy stresses that Bloch's Heimat differs from Heidegger's. For Heidegger home is a lost foundation that precedes experience; for Bloch it lies ahead as the horizon of the utopian movement, something to be actively precipitated rather than passively awaited.
How has it been read?
In East Germany, where it first appeared, the book was very popular with students. But after Bloch's forced retirement in 1957 the third volume appeared only in 1959. In the West its most ardent readers were, unexpectedly, theologians. The Protestant theologian Jürgen Moltmann published Theology of Hope in 1964, placing eschatology at the centre of theology and defining its task in Blochian terms: to capture the future within the present. Dorothee Sölle belonged to the same current. English Wikipedia notes that the book became fundamental to dialogue between Christians and Marxists.
The criticism was fierce too. In a 1958 letter to the publisher Peter Suhrkamp, Theodor W. Adorno dismissed the book as a torrent carrying all sorts of junk, above all tin cans, in place of the real labour of the concept, rich in material but poor in intellectual content. The philosopher Hans Jonas criticized it explicitly in The Imperative of Responsibility, and the sociologist Helmut Schelsky devoted a whole book to attacking Bloch. Leszek Kołakowski, on the other hand, called it Bloch's magnum opus, containing all his important ideas.
An English translation appeared in 1986. In Korean the book appeared from Sol Publishing between 1993 and 1995, and a complete five-volume translation by Park Seol-ho followed from Openbooks in 2004. The book's theory of art, the idea that art pre-illuminates what has not yet come, is treated separately under "Vor-Schein".