Сухановская особорежимная тюрьма (Сухановка, спецобъект № 110) · 1938.11–1953 (Set up from November 1938, opened January 1939; closed around 1953 (some records give 1954).)

Sukhanovka special prison

수하놉카 특별체제감옥

A secret NKVD–MGB prison that operated from early 1939 to about 1953 in the former St Catherine's Monastery near Vidnoye, south of Moscow. Internally it was "Special Object No. 110"; it became known as "Sukhanovka" after the nearby former estate of Sukhanovo. It held senior figures who were to be cut off completely from other prisoners and suspects whose testimony particularly interested the investigation's leadership, and extracted confessions by torture under a "special regime" to which the rules and time limits of other remand prisons did not apply. Among those who passed through it were Nikolai Yezhov, who had conceived the prison, and his subordinates, the diplomat Evgeny Gnedin and the intelligence officer Dmitry Bystrolyotov.

In depth

What and where was it?

About two hours by prison van south of Moscow, near the town of Vidnoye, stands St Catherine's Monastery, founded in 1658 by order of Tsar Alexei Mikhailovich and closed after the revolution. In early 1939 a secret NKVD prison opened in its buildings. Its internal designation was "Special Object No. 110". Because the former Volkonsky estate of Sukhanovo lay close to the monastery, the prison was called "Sukhanovka" or "Sukhanovo". Security officers called it "the dacha" among themselves, and among prisoners in jails and camps it was known as "the torture dacha".

The "special regime" (osoby rezhim) in its name meant that it ran by rules different from those of other remand prisons. In November 1938 Beria asked the government for the site to serve as a "specially isolated special-purpose prison". The biographer Aleksei Pavlyukov writes: "There were not even the internal regulations that existed in any other prison." There were no exercise walks, no letters and no parcels. Prisoners were known by numbers instead of names, and their families were told they had been sent to the Lubyanka, Butyrka or Lefortovo. The diplomat Evgeny Gnedin, held there for thirteen months from June 1940, testified that this was one of the very reasons people were sent there: the rules and time limits that still meant something in other investigation prisons did not apply in this one.

How did it come about?

In 1937, on the instruction of Mikhail Kalinin, the former monastery buildings and the land around them passed to the NKVD. Russian Wikipedia records that the idea of a secret prison for senior political prisoners there came from the People's Commissar of Internal Affairs Nikolai Yezhov. Pyotr Maltsev, a warder there from 1939, told a journalist in 1989: "We were proud, too, that it was Nikolai Ivanovich himself who founded our Sukhanovka prison."

But it was Yezhov's successor Lavrenty Beria who hurried the conversion. On 23 November 1938 Beria, formally still Yezhov's deputy, wrote to the Chairman of the Council of People's Commissars, Vyacheslav Molotov, that a special-purpose prison had to be set up under the Main Directorate of State Security by 1 January 1939, and asked for the grounds and buildings of the former monastery. On 29 November the deputy chairman Nikolai Bulganin ordered the buildings and a 100-metre zone around them handed to the NKVD within three days. Memorial names Yezhov's imminent fall as one objective reason for the haste: once he went, his whole circle would go with him. The conversion was finished in early 1939. A provisional staff of 161 was fixed by NKVD Order No. 0030 of 13 January 1939 and took effect on 15 January.

Who was held there?

According to Pavlyukov, the prison held not only the highest officials who were to be kept from any contact with other prisoners, but also prisoners of much lower rank whose testimony for one reason or another interested the NKVD leadership. Among its first inmates were Yezhov, who had conceived it, and his people. Yezhov's former first deputy Mikhail Frinovsky was arrested on 6 April 1939 and held there; four days later Yezhov himself was arrested. Pavlyukov writes that "this was exactly the kind of prison to which Yezhov was brought after his arrest on 10 April 1939". Nikolai Nikolayev-Zhurid, who had headed counterintelligence under Yezhov, was also held there. The writer Isaac Babel, who had been close to Yezhov's wife, was among the first prisoners as well.

The warder Maltsev recalled that Beria interrogated Yezhov in person. Gnedin wrote that it was here, at confrontations, that Yezhov gave false testimony in a coarse and cynical manner that destroyed people who had not yet been broken. In January 1940 Yezhov's pneumonia worsened, and on 13 January Beria reported to Stalin that he would be transferred that day to the Butyrka prison hospital. According to the historian Lidiya Golovkova, after some treatment there he was brought back to Sukhanovka about ten days later. Marc Jansen and Nikita Petrov write that from then on the Deputy Chief Military Procurator, N. P. Afanasyev, interrogated Yezhov right in the Sukhanovka prison. On 1 February, the day the indictment was issued, Yezhov was taken to Beria's office at Sukhanovka and promised that his life would be spared if he confessed sincerely. The next day, 2 February, the Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court tried him behind closed doors in the office of the prison's chief.

Senior party, military and diplomatic figures besides Yezhov's people passed through it. Gnedin listed the prisoners whose names he learned: the diplomat Georgy Astakhov, Apresov, a former Soviet consul in the East, Chingiz Ildrym, an economic manager and friend of Kirov, Bulatov, a former head of the Central Committee's organisation department, and Yezhov. Memorial names, besides Gnedin and Yezhov, the generals Vladimir Tamruchi and Mikhail Belyanchik, the theatre director Vsevolod Meyerhold and Molotov's wife Polina Zhemchuzhina. Maltsev remembered that Zhemchuzhina was kept not in a cell but in an investigator's office. Filipp Goloshchyokin, a former secretary of the Kazakh regional party committee, was interrogated there for twelve months before being moved to Butyrka. After the war the intelligence officer Dmitry Bystrolyotov was brought from a Siberian camp in January 1948 on the orders of the Minister of State Security Viktor Abakumov and kept in solitary there until 1951. Alexander Dolgun, an employee of the American embassy, also passed through it.

What did prisoners endure?

Gnedin summed up the prison's purpose: "The Sukhanovka prison evidently had a twofold purpose: a torture chamber for torture and shootings, set apart outside the city, and an isolated, secret place of confinement for the 'preservation' of the victims of lawlessness."

Сухановская тюрьма, очевидно, имела двоякое назначение: застенок для пыток и расстрелов, расположенный в стороне, за городом, и изолированное, засекреченное место заключения для “консервации” жертв беззакония.

According to the warder Maltsev, it never held more than 150 people at a time; seventy men guarded the inside and a special company the outside. Six or seven investigators from the Lubyanka interrogated, mostly at night. The official time limit was two weeks. "The warder's main task at Sukhanovka was to make sure the prisoner did not kill himself," Maltsev said. He had eight to ten cells to watch, looking into each again every minute and a half or two, and wore soft-soled boots to approach the doors without a sound. The prison had a private office for Beria with a direct telephone line to the Kremlin.

The cells, converted monks' cells, measured 1.5 by 2 metres. According to Pavlyukov, no more than two people were put in a cell, one of them very often an NKVD informer, and the peephole opened almost every minute. Gnedin remembered the same: one warder watched three cells, and the slightest movement brought the rattle of the lock and the warder into the cell. Bunks were locked up against the wall during the day. Bystrolyotov wrote that only when he filled in a form at the reception desk did he learn that he had entered "a numbered special facility".

Alexander Solzhenitsyn, who heard the prisoner Dolgun's testimony, portrayed Sukhanovka in The Gulag Archipelago as the most terrible prison the MGB had. New arrivals were stunned in a standing punishment cell too narrow to do anything but stand, and the point of the watch on the cells, he wrote, was "to leave you not a minute of sleep, not a minute stolen for private life".

В том и цель беззвучной Сухановки: не оставить тебе ни минуты сна, ни минут, украденных для частной жизни, — ты всегда смотришься и всегда во власти.

Torture was literal. Gnedin was beaten in the empty church. Memorial lists the "conveyor" of relay interrogations without sleep, standing for days knee-deep in water, a barrel of icy water, a hot punishment cell and gassing. After Stalin's death, Order No. 0068 of 4 April 1953 recorded that under the former MGB leadership beatings, handcuffs locked on arms twisted behind the back for months on end, prolonged sleep deprivation and cold and hot punishment cells had been used, and ordered such rooms abolished and the instruments of torture destroyed.

Testimony is divided on whether executions took place there. Yuri Bogomolov, a retired Interior Ministry lieutenant colonel who toured the already empty prison in 1958, said he saw an execution site and a cremation furnace in the church, and the historian Lidiya Golovkova heard the same from an Interior Ministry colonel who visited in 1958. But no document confirming this officially survives, and the former warder and prison party secretary whom a journalist met in 1989 denied mass killings.

How was it used during and after the war?

When the war with Germany began the prison was evacuated, and it reopened once the front moved away from Moscow. Gnedin remembered the evacuation as beginning before the war, in the spring of 1941. According to Memorial, high-ranking prisoners or those especially valuable to the investigation were brought there at first, but by mid-1941 it had become the investigation prison of the Directorate of Special Departments headed by Abakumov. In 1941 the staff grew to 188 posts with a ceiling of 225. From about the end of 1942 arrested servicemen and so-called "war criminals" were held there.

After the war the prison remained with the Ministry of State Security. Maltsev recalled that Abakumov came there often. Solzhenitsyn wrote that Abakumov's subordinate Mikhail Ryumin beat Dolgun with a rubber truncheon in the "generals'" interrogation office at Sukhanovka. Bystrolyotov's years in solitary also fall in this period. The prison closed around 1953. Maltsev said he worked there until the prison was abolished in 1953, and Memorial writes that a prison hospital was set up on the site after Beria's arrest and execution. A memorial at the site dates the prison to 1938–1954.

How is it remembered?

From April 1959 to 1965 the site housed the Moscow inter-regional prison hospital, and from 1965 the training centre of the Moscow regional police directorate. When the journalist Alexander Annin visited in 1989, the church was a warehouse, two prison buildings were being converted into dormitories, and twenty families lived in a third. Beria's office had become a changing room for building workers. In "The Sukhanovka Torture Chamber" Annin proposed turning the whole monastery site into a memorial to the victims of repression.

That same year the buildings passed from the Interior Ministry to the Ministry of Culture, and in May 1992 St Catherine's Monastery was re-established. A memorial to the victims of political repression now stands on the monastery grounds. Because the prison's records long stayed classified, research has relied on testimony and a few released documents. The historian Lidiya Golovkova published A Quiet Cloister (Sukhanovka) (1996) and The Sukhanovka Prison: Special Object 110 (2009), and Memorial's "Topography of Terror" project compiled an entry on it.

This site holds several testimonies about Sukhanovka. Gnedin's A Way Out of the Labyrinth gives the fullest account of the thirteen months he spent there. Bystrolyotov's "The Ordeal of Solitude" records his postwar years in its solitary cells. Pavlyukov's Yezhov: A Biography follows from the documents how the prison was set up and how Yezhov was held there, and Annin's "The Sukhanovka Torture Chamber" takes down the words of a warder and the prison's party secretary.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Marc Jansen and Nikita Petrov, Stalin's Loyal Executioner: People's Commissar Nikolai Ezhov, 1895–1940 (Stanford: Hoover Institution Press, 2002), ch. 8 «Enemy of the People»
  2. Wikipedia (RU)
  3. Wikipedia (RU)
  4. web.archive.org
  5. «Пыточная тюрьма Сталина», Новая газета, № 137, 9 декабря 2009 —
  6. Александр Аннин, «Сухановский застенок», Неделя, 1989, № 43 —
  7. Александр Солженицын, Архипелаг ГУЛАГ, т. 1 —
  8. Алексей Павлюков, Ежов. Биография (Москва: Захаров, 2007), гл. 38 «В застенках Сухановки» —
  9. Алексей Павлюков, Ежов. Биография (Москва: Захаров, 2007), гл. 38 —
  10. Алексей Павлюков, Ежов. Биография (Москва: Захаров, 2007), гл. 39 —
  11. Алексей Павлюков, Ежов. Биография (Москва: Захаров, 2007), гл. 39 —
  12. Д. А. Быстролётов, Пир бессмертных, кн. 8 «Испытание одиночеством» (Москва: Крафт+, 2011)
  13. Евгений Гнедин, Выход из лабиринта (New York: Chalidze Publications, 1982)
  14. Wikipedia (RU)
  15. Wikipedia (RU)
  16. Wikipedia (RU)
  17. Лидия Головкова, главы из книги «Сухановская тюрьма. Спецобъект 110» (М.: Возвращение, 2009) — «Пыточная тюрьма Сталина», Новая газета, № 136, 7 декабря 2009 —