Filipp Isayevich Goloshchyokin

Филипп Исаевич Голощёкин
Soviet Union state institutions Marxism–Leninism Soviet Union Russia (Jewish) 1876.3.9.–1941.10.28. ✕ Executed

The revolutionary who led Kazakhstan's 'Little October'

In December 1925, at the party conference in Kyzyl-Orda, he declared that "before my arrival, no Soviet power existed in Kazakhstan," opening his "Little October" course.

A dentist from a Jewish family in Nevel, he was elected to the Central Committee and its Russian Bureau at the 1912 Prague Conference and took part in the October uprising through the Petrograd Military Revolutionary Committee. As Ural military commissar he was among those who organized the execution of the tsar's family at the Ipatiev House in July 1918. As First Secretary of the Kazakh Regional Committee from 1925 to 1933 he drove radical collectivization and forced sedentarization of nomads under the slogan "Little October," leading to the Kazakh famine. Arrested in 1939 while Chief State Arbitrator, he was charged on Yezhov's testimony with membership of an anti-Soviet organization and sex between men, and shot without trial in 1941. He was rehabilitated in 1961.

Also known as: Shaya Itskovich

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

From Nevel Dentist to Central Committee Member

Goloshchyokin was born in 1876 into a Jewish family in Nevel, Vitebsk Governorate, under the name Shaya (Shai) Itskovich. According to what he told his interrogators in 1939, his father did small contracting work, ran the town slaughterhouse and traded in firewood. He attended the Nevel district school in 1894–1896 and lived on his parents' support until he finished his studies (up to 1904), working as a shop assistant for his brother, who kept stationery and book shops in Nevel and Vitebsk. He also worked as an assistant in a stationery shop in Saratov and for about a year as a clerk to a bailiff of the district court in Yekaterinoslav.

By profession he was a dentist. In 1903 he sat the dentist's examination at the Military Medical Academy in St Petersburg, then, after a short stay at home, went to Vyatka and practised there until the spring of 1905. Official biographies date his party membership to 1903, a year taken from his own autobiography. Under interrogation in 1939 he said that around the time of his examination in 1903 the revolutionary Strunsky had put him in touch with an RSDLP member, for whom he distributed leaflets to three district organizations in St Petersburg, and that he formally joined only in the spring of 1905, after settling in St Petersburg and meeting Strunsky and Piratinsky again. He also admitted that the line in his autobiography about being exiled from St Petersburg to Vyatka for revolutionary work in 1903 was untrue, calling it "bragging." The same record, however, also contains an answer that he joined in the autumn of 1903, so these statements should be read as extracted by investigators pressing him. Z. Piratinsky, a classmate from the Nevel district school who also became a dentist, told investigators that he remembered him as "a frivolous man" and that when Goloshchyokin approached him around 1904–1906 asking to be introduced to Social Democratic circles, he refused because he could not vouch for his convictions.

In 1906 he was a member of the RSDLP St Petersburg Committee and its Executive Commission. After attending the 1909 meeting of the enlarged editorial board of Proletary in Paris, he went to Moscow and led the Moscow Committee. In 1909 he was arrested with the entire committee, among them Yakov Sverdlov, Berta Perelman and Oborin, during a meeting at the flat of the engineer Temkin. At the Sixth (Prague) Conference in 1912 he was elected to the Central Committee and its Russian Bureau, and afterwards worked in Moscow, Petrograd and the Urals, suffering repeated repression.

Organizer of the Romanov Family Execution

In the summer of 1918, as Military Commissar of the Ural Region, Goloshchyokin was the principal organizer of the Romanov family's execution. On 29 June, the Ural Soviet resolved to execute the entire Romanov family, and Goloshchyokin traveled to Moscow on 3 July to deliver the decision in person. Only seven members of the Central Executive Committee's Presidium remained in the capital; at a meeting with Lenin, Sverdlov, and Dzerzhinsky, the execution was approved, with discretion over the details left to the Ural Soviet.

Yurovsky later recalled: "Since this act was one of the utmost political importance, the whole matter was entrusted to Comrade Filipp Goloshchyokin, who enjoyed the special trust of the Central Committee, and the responsibility for resolving the question in an agreed way was laid on him, since there were not a few supporters of a separate decision [without Moscow's consent] in the Ural regional organization... The former tsar Nicholas and his family were, so to speak, entrusted to Comrade Filipp Goloshchyokin, both personally and as military commissar." According to Yurovsky, it was Goloshchyokin who set the date of the execution and who first announced it publicly.

On the evening of 16 July, with White Army forces closing on Ekaterinburg, Goloshchyokin and Georgy Safarov sent a final coded telegram to Moscow seeking approval, but the direct line was down and the message was routed through Zinoviev in Petrograd. According to Yurovsky's memoirs, the execution order signed by Sverdlov reached Goloshchyokin around 7:00 PM.

Goloshchyokin personally arrived at the Ipatiev House alongside Peter Ermakov and Stepan Vaganov to direct the execution as a representative of the Ural Soviet. He did not take part in the shooting himself, instead pacing along the palisade outside to gauge whether the gunfire could be heard beyond the walls. As the corpses were loaded onto the truck, he stooped to examine the tsar's body and murmured, "So this is the end of the Romanov Dynasty, is it..." His comrade Mikhail Kudrin replied: "No, not yet; there is still much work to be done." On 18 July at the Ekaterinburg telegraph office, when British diplomat Thomas Preston attempted to cable London with "The Tsar Nicholas the Second was shot last night," Goloshchyokin snatched the message and struck through the words with a red pencil, rewriting: "The hangman Tsar Nicholas was shot last night — a fate he richly deserved."

First Secretary in Kazakhstan: 'Little October' and the Famine

On 19 February 1925 he was appointed First Secretary of the Communist Party in the newly created Kazakh Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic, and English sources record that from 1925 to 1933 he ran the Kazakh ASSR with virtually no outside interference. Russian sources put him as responsible secretary (First Secretary) of the Kazakh Kraikom of the VKP(b) from October 1925 to February 1933, while the appointment date itself is given as either 19 February 1925 or 12 September 1925. In December 1925, at the party conference in Kyzyl-Orda, he declared that no Soviet power had existed in Kazakhstan before his arrival, signaling that he would start from scratch. This was the opening of his 'Little October' course.

'Little October' was the name of the political course of the Kazakh authorities in 1926-1927, aimed at suppressing local national elites and strengthening administrative and economic control over the republic's life. For the tenth anniversary of October in 1927 he published two works justifying the escalation of emergency measures and effectively calling for civil war in the aul, and wrote to Stalin arguing for a 'Little October' in Kazakhstan and requesting approval, with the mass transition of Kazakhs to settled life as the next step. The first measure, in autumn 1928, was a confiscation campaign: 700 households were subject to confiscation, with about 150,000 head of livestock (converted to cattle) taken. By his own admission the original plans were twice as large, covering 1,500 households, but when the plan was approved in the Central Committee and the VTsIK the thresholds were adjusted (400 head for nomadic households, 300 semi-nomadic, 150 settled), cutting the total to 700 households. According to the Kazakh specialized article, land redistribution in 1926-1927 seized from wealthy households about 1,360,000 desyatins of hayfields and 1,250,000 of arable land for the poor and middle peasants, and the CC of the VKP(b) resolution of 3 May 1928 and the decree of 28 August 1928 'On the confiscation of bai households' required the confiscation and eviction of the largest stockbreeders, with 600 families to be evicted and their livestock confiscated.

Understanding that these measures would provoke protest from local communists, he fought party leaders who did not share his views. Saduakasov and Khodzhanov were accused of 'national deviation' as early as 1926, while Seifullin, Murzagaliyev, Nurmakov and Mendeshev were persecuted and many removed from the republic. From late 1928 the first arrests of his political opponents began (Baitursynov, Dulatov, Aymauytov, Zhumabayev), and two years later Tynyshpaev, the Dosmukhamedovs and many other representatives of the national intelligentsia were arrested.

After Stalin ordered forced collectivization, he ordered Kazakhstan's largely nomadic population to be forced into collective farms, which caused a deadly famine. The Kazakh famine of 1930-1933, also known as the Asharshylyq, began in late 1930 and lasted through 1933, and its victims were mostly ethnic Kazakhs. The frequently cited death range is 1.3 to 2.3 million, with other estimates around 1.75 million or above 2 million. Between 38 and 42 percent of all Kazakhs perished, the highest proportion of any ethnic group in the Soviet famines of the early 1930s, and Kazakhs fell from about 60 percent of the republic's inhabitants to 38 percent. English sources elsewhere give 1.5 million dead, of whom 1.3 million were ethnic Kazakh, with 25 to 42 percent of all Kazakhs having died or emigrated; Russian sources cite up to 1 million Kazakh victims on the official census; and the Kazakh-language article attributes about 3 million Kazakh deaths. The famine article documents the mechanism: herds were seized by the state, traditional migrations disrupted, communities forced into collective farms ill-suited to the steppe, and hunger intensified by requisitioning, excessive quotas and blacklisting of districts, while thousands of Kazakhs fleeing toward China were shot by border guards. Resistance was widespread, with 8 rebellions in 1930 alone.

As criticism mounted, in August 1932 Uraz Isayev, chairman of Kazakhstan's Council of People's Commissars, wrote to Stalin accusing Goloshchyokin of self-delusion and blaming kulaks for his own mistakes; the writer Gabit Musirepov reported corpses stacked like firewood in the Turgai district; and the West Siberian party boss Robert Eikhe complained about starving Kazakhs crossing into Siberia. On 11 November 1932 Goloshchyokin and Isayev ordered the mass arrest and deportation of peasants accused of impeding grain collection. In January 1933 he boasted of 'enormous successes' at a CC plenum, but a few days later he was suddenly sacked and publicly criticized for his handling of collectivization; Levon Mirzoyan was sent to head the party in Kazakhstan.

Assessment and responsibility remain contested. V. L. Burtsev, a historian of the revolution who knew him, called him a typical Leninist whom blood did not stop, 'the executioner, cruel, with some elements of degeneration', who 'did not count the Kazakhs as people at all'; statements that he never left the capital in seven years do not correspond to reality, since in April 1931 he personally toured ten districts of the republic. Some historians and scholars, including a Kazakh parliamentary commission chaired by Manash Kozybayev, have concluded the famine was genocide, arguing Moscow deliberately targeted Kazakhs; others see it as part of the wider Soviet famine driven by Stalin's push for industrialization and collectivization. In the early 1990s Abylkhozhin and Tatimov characterized the famine as 'Goloshchekin's genocide', attributing sole responsibility to him.

Arrest, Yezhov's Testimony and Execution without Trial

Goloshchyokin was arrested on 15 October 1939 while serving as USSR Chief State Arbitrator. His case file (FSB Central Archive no. 100203) stayed sealed for more than sixty years until the Chelyabinsk historian I. Nepein published parts of it for the first time in 2004. The charges were sympathy for Trotskyism, preparing a terrorist act and "excesses" in collectivization, and the file bound together testimony that he had spoken disloyally of the party leadership with testimony about sex between men.

The key statements against him came from Nikolai Yezhov, arrested before him. In a statement dated 23 April 1939 (some sources give 24 April), Yezhov wrote that when the capital of Kazakhstan moved from Orenburg to Kyzyl-Orda in 1925 he went there too, and that Goloshchyokin, who arrived as secretary of the regional committee without his wife, took him into his flat, where for about two months they effectively lived together and had a sexual relationship. In his interrogation of 14 October Yezhov said he had passed compromising material on Goloshchyokin to Polish intelligence: that Goloshchyokin disagreed with the party line and its present leadership, attacked the leadership sharply together with Bubnov and others, and was always circling among the literary bohemia, his closest friends including Pilnyak and Sergei Yesenin. Yezhov was himself a prisoner testifying under torture and pressure, so these statements show what picture the investigation was trying to assemble rather than establishing facts.

The same file holds the interrogation records of Boris Pilnyak (11 December 1937) and Isaac Babel (29–31 May and 3 October 1939), both already arrested as "Trotskyist writers." Babel testified that in 1924–1925 he met oppositionists such as Lashevich, Zorin and Smirnov at the Hotel National, where Alexander Voronsky, editor of Krasnaya Nov, lived, and that Voronsky introduced him to Goloshchyokin, who lived next door. Asked whether Goloshchyokin had also spoken from Trotskyist positions, however, Babel answered that Goloshchyokin had dropped in about twice in his presence, staying five or ten minutes, and that he had never heard Trotskyist remarks from him.

On 13 November 1939 Senior Lieutenant of State Security Shkurin, assistant head of the GUGB investigative department, charged him in case no. 842 with having been "a participant in an anti-Soviet organization, fighting against the Central Committee of the VKP(b), and also engaging in pederasty," under Article 58, points 7 and 11, and Article 154-a (sex between men) of the RSFSR Criminal Code. He was held without trial for about two years: twelve months under interrogation in Sukhanovka prison, then back in Butyrka, and in October 1941, as the Wehrmacht approached Moscow, he was moved to Kuybyshev. Under an order Lavrentiy Beria issued on 18 October, he was taken with other prisoners to Barboshina Polyana near the village of Barbysh outside Kuybyshev on 28 October 1941 and shot there. The Great Soviet Encyclopedia gives his date of death as 18 October. The death sentence came not from a court but from a joint decision of the NKVD and the procuracy. He was rehabilitated in 1961.

Nepein suggested he may have been eliminated as a witness to the execution of the tsar's family, but this is conjecture. Nepein meant to publish the whole file as a book, but the series ended with its first instalment and he died in 2008. In 2010 the Kazakh-language outlet Abai-aqparat reprinted the indictment and Yezhov's statement, using the homosexuality charge to disparage the man responsible for the famine, and put the Kazakh death toll at 2.8 to 4 million.