大正デモクラシー

Taishō Democracy

다이쇼 데모크라시

The collective name for the democratic and liberal political and social movements and currents of 1910s and 1920s Japan, roughly the Taishō era (1912 to 1926): the campaign for universal suffrage and for freedom of speech, assembly and association, and the movements for workers' right to organise and strike, for the liberation of burakumin and for equality of the sexes. Its high point is usually placed in the party cabinets of the 1920s, when the male universal suffrage law of 1925 was passed.

In depth

What years does it cover?

The name was first used in the historian Shinobu Seizaburō's History of Taishō Democracy (1954). Its span depends on what is counted as Taishō democracy. The start is put at the movement against the Treaty of Portsmouth in 1905 (the Hibiya riot), the first movement to protect constitutional government in 1912, or the end of the First World War in 1918; the end at the Great Kantō earthquake of 1923, the Peace Preservation Law of 1925, or the Manchurian Incident of 1931. All of them include the rice riots of 1918. English-language studies often date its start to the Hibiya riot, and trace a line through the constitutional movement in the Taishō political crisis of 1912 and 1913, the rice riots and Takashi Hara's party cabinet in 1918, and the second constitutional movement of 1924, to its peak in the suffrage law of 1925. Abroad, the same years saw the Xinhai Revolution of 1911, the Russian Revolution of 1917 and the German Revolution of 1918.

What ideas led it?

In 1912 Tatsukichi Minobe set out the emperor-organ theory in his Lectures on the Constitution, holding that the state is the subject of sovereignty and that the Diet has functions of its own, which gave party cabinets a basis. In January 1916 Sakuzō Yoshino of Tokyo Imperial University published "On the Meaning of Constitutional Government and the Methods by Which It Can Be Perfected" in Chūō Kōron, rendering democracy as minponshugi. It held two things, that the purpose of politics is the welfare of the people and that policy should follow the people's will, and its immediate goal was party government resting on universal suffrage and freedom of speech. Socialists criticised it as half-hearted for not asking where sovereignty lay, but as a theoretical weapon with which one could argue for a Diet-centred politics without being charged with ignoring the national polity, it served the movement greatly. Journalists and scholars such as Hasegawa Nyozekan and Ikuo Oyama argued along similar lines. In 1918 Yoshino founded the scholars' group Reimeikai with Fukuda Tokuzō and others, and he stood behind the Shinjinkai of Tokyo Imperial University and the Yūaikai.

What movements took place?

In politics there were the universal suffrage movement and the demand for freedom of speech, assembly and association; in external affairs, calls to stop overseas expeditions that weighed on the people; in society, movements for equality between men and women, for the liberation of the burakumin, and for the rights to organise and strike. The first constitutional movement of 1912, under the slogan "Destroy clique government, protect the constitution", brought down the Katsura cabinet in 53 days, and in September 1918, after the rice riots, Takashi Hara formed the first real party cabinet. In 1919 Hiratsuka Raichō, Fusae Ichikawa and others founded the New Women's Association, and in 1922 Article 5, paragraph 2 of the Peace Police Law, which barred women from political meetings, was amended. The Takaaki Katō cabinet brought in by the second constitutional movement of 1924 gave the vote to all men aged 25 or over by the suffrage law of 1925, raising the electorate from roughly 3 million to 12.5 million. The same Diet passed the Peace Preservation Law, which punished associations aiming to alter the national polity or deny private property, and accounts of the era weigh its gains against that limit.

How did it see Korea and China?

Applied to external policy, minponshugi became a rejection of militarist aggression on the continent, opposition to the assimilation of Korea, and support for international cooperation. Yoshino had gone to Qing China in 1906 as tutor in Yuan Shikai's household and spent three years there; he is credited with attacking militarist colonial rule and with a deep understanding of Korean and Chinese nationalism. When the March First Movement broke out in 1919, the Reimeikai devoted its lecture meeting of 5 June to an all-out criticism of military rule in Korea, and when the May Fourth Movement broke out in China it criticised the government's policy of aiding the warlord government. Yoshino defended the Korean independence leader Yeo Un-hyeong as a man who deserved moral respect, and sympathised with Sun Yat-sen's Xinhai Revolution. The Shinjinkai, too, exchanged visits with comrades from China and Korea. After the Kantō Massacre of 1923 Yoshino recorded the death toll he heard from a Korean relief team and wrote an article criticising the killings; the article could not be printed, and Yoshino himself is said to have been, with Sakae Osugi and others, on the army's list for assassination.

The limits were just as plain. Japanese Wikipedia notes that movements for Koreans' rights continued after the March First Movement, but that there was a difference in temperature between them and the Japanese advocates of minponshugi. In Taiwan a movement to establish a Taiwanese parliament ran from the early 1920s to the mid-1930s. The historian Andrew Gordon proposes the term "imperial democracy" for these years: its central contradiction was a movement that pushed for wider democratic participation while fervently supporting the emperor and the expansion of the empire.

How did it end?

Around the Manchurian Incident of 1931 the energy of Taishō democracy flowed into chauvinism and support for war. The Minseitō cabinet could not restrain the military, and a wave of popular nationalism isolated the proletarian parties and other anti-imperialist voices. After the assassination of Prime Minister Tsuyoshi Inukai in 1932, party cabinets gave way to "national unity" cabinets dominated by bureaucrats and military men. Later judgements differ. Many see it as a legacy that shaped postwar democracy, while others, such as Narita Ryūichi, stress the continuity between the 1920s and the 1930s: the opinions and demands of "the nation" turned chauvinist and so led into fascism.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. ja.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. ndl.go.jp
  5. kotobank.jp
  6. kotobank.jp
  7. ja.wikipedia.org
  8. ja.wikipedia.org
  9. kotobank.jp
  10. ja.wikipedia.org