The Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change · 1989

The Condition of Postmodernity

포스트모더니티의 조건

A book published in 1989 by the British-born Marxist geographer David Harvey. It argues that around the early 1970s culture turned from modernism to postmodernism while the economy turned from Fordism to "flexible accumulation", and links the two through a change in the regime of capital accumulation and the "time-space compression" it produced. It is read as the leading attempt to back Fredric Jameson's "Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism" with economic evidence.

In depth

What changed all at once in the early 1970s?

Picture a Western factory of the 1950s and 1960s. Workers spend their lives on one company's assembly line, wages rise each year under collective agreements with the unions, and the firm turns out the same car model in huge numbers for years. The state props up demand with Keynesian policy. Cities fill with the clean-lined towers and large public housing estates of Le Corbusier's and Mies van der Rohe's international style. By the 1980s the landscape has changed. Firms split labour into subcontracting, part-time and temporary work, change products quickly to follow consumer fashion, and capital moves across borders to cheaper places. Architecture turns to decorative buildings mixing the styles of several periods, and film to works like Blade Runner.

Harvey's book argues that these two changes did not happen at the same time by chance. His central thesis is that from around 1972 there was a "sea-change" in political, economic and cultural practices, and that postmodernism is its cultural face. The book has four parts. Part one examines the cultural passage from modernism to postmodernism, part two the economic passage from Fordism to flexible accumulation. Part three follows the changing experience of time and space from the Middle Ages to the present in order to link the two passages causally, and part four weighs the promises and perils of postmodernity.

Harvey neither dismissed nor celebrated postmodernism. He accepted Jameson's idea that postmodernism is not a complete rupture with modernism but a "cultural dominant" in which elements already present in modernism appear with added emphasis. Where a modernist like Baudelaire tried to hold together the eternal and the transitory, postmodernism gives up every attempt to represent the immutable or ordered and revels in flux, fragments and difference. Harvey criticised postmodernism for avoiding the realities of political economy and putting aesthetics above ethics, yet he valued its concern with complexity, difference, otherness and plurality. He also thought postmodernists caricatured modernism. The 1972 demolition of the Pruitt-Igoe housing estate in St. Louis is often taken as the symbol of modernist architecture's failure, but Harvey objected to lumping the whole variety of modern architecture together with that debacle. He wrote that the "meta-narratives" the postmodernists reject, Marx's or Freud's, were far more open and nuanced than their critics admitted.

From Fordism to flexible accumulation: what changed?

Part two starts from "Fordism". For Harvey, Fordism is the system, going back to Henry Ford's attempt to give workers enough income and leisure to buy what they made, that meshed production with consumption and assimilated the working class to capitalism. It carried the long post-war boom, but together with Keynesian economics it was too rigid. Mass-production plant, long-term contracts, large unions and state welfare spending were all locked in together, leaving no room to move when demand fell and the rate of profit declined. On Harvey's account the regime crumbled with the recession of 1973.

What took its place Harvey called "flexible accumulation", a far more complex and supple structure in the labour process, labour markets, products and patterns of consumption. One of its marks is a great increase in the rates of commercial, technological and organisational innovation. Studies of post-Fordism describing the same period likewise point to more subcontracting and franchising, a rise in part-time, temporary and self-employed work, and the decline of regulation by the nation-state alongside the rise of global markets and corporations. Harvey deliberately avoided the term "post-Fordism", so as not to obscure the fundamental continuities between the two regimes as forms of capitalism.

He saw this economic change as directly tied to culture: when the turnover of capital and the pace of life itself speed up, cultural practice changes too.

The relatively stable aesthetic of Fordist modernism has given way to all the ferment, instability, and fleeting qualities of a postmodernist aesthetic that celebrates difference, ephemerality, spectacle, fashion, and the commodifications of cultural forms

The wider discussion of the economic concepts is under "Fordism" and "Regulation theory".

What is time-space compression?

Harvey's most widely used concept is "time-space compression". It starts from the claim that neither time nor space has an objective meaning independent of material processes, and that our very conceptions of time and space are created through the material practices that reproduce social life. Capital seeks to overcome spatial barriers in order to open new markets, shorten production cycles and reduce the turnover time of capital. As a result technologies of communication and travel, the telegraph, the telephone, the railway, the car and the jet, shrink distances; the long durations once needed for travel and communication fall almost to nothing, and the vast and disparate spaces of the planet are drawn into a homogenised "global village". The idea is rooted in what Marx in the Grundrisse called "the annihilation of space by time".

Harvey held that time-space compression began with capitalism but had intensified greatly in the previous two decades, and that postmodernism arose as a cultural response to its disorienting and disruptive effects. Scholars identify two periods of especially strong compression, from the mid-nineteenth century to the First World War and the end of the twentieth century. Harvey linked the earlier one to the revolution of 1848, the first crisis of capitalist accumulation of that era, and the emergence of cultural modernism that followed.

What did Harvey see in cities and films?

Two places where Harvey applied the theory to concrete works are cited most often. One is the chapter "Postmodernism in the city: architecture and urban design". There he explains that the industrial methods of Fordism, which established themselves in production in response to the crises of the Depression and the Second World War, were carried into architecture to solve the urgent problems of post-war urban renewal, and that the international high modernism of Le Corbusier and Mies was the result. When the falling rate of profit forced rigid Fordism to give way to flexible accumulation, architecture too moved from functional universalism to new forms of particularism. Harvey's examples were Trump Tower in New York, a monument to personal power, and the Baltimore City Fair, which marketed cultural difference to attract outside investors. The postmodern city rejects rational planning, large-scale development, social utility and purity of form for a locally grounded, fragmented and eclectic aesthetic, and treats space strictly as an aesthetic category.

The other is his reading of the films Blade Runner and Wings of Desire. Harvey read the robot "replicants" of Blade Runner as the ultimate in short-term, highly skilled and flexible labour power. In the film, photographic images serve as a tenuous link to history and personal identity in the Los Angeles of 2019. He also related Wings of Desire's concern with fragmentation, history and identity to the social conditions produced by flexible accumulation.

How was the book received?

Harvey wrote the book while a professor at Oxford, and it was a best-seller. The Korean edition is translated by Gu Dong-hoe and Park Yeong-min (Hanul). Reviewers noted that Harvey made an argument similar to Jameson's thesis but backed it with far more empirical material. His demonstration in the first two parts of a temporal correlation between culture and economy, including his point that neoliberal, social-democratic and Marxist economic studies all recognised a fundamental shift around 1970, was judged persuasive.

The criticisms took several lines. The reviewer Steven Best thought Harvey wrong to label Michel Foucault a postmodernist without qualification, and named two curious omissions: having analysed the conquest of nature, Harvey left ecology aside, and he offered almost no political strategy for the postmodern condition. Others found the mediations between economy and culture too simple. The reviewer John Abromeit argued that temporal correlation is not causation, that Harvey's attempt to generalise the correlation across the whole modern period, linking modernism to 1848, led to claims he could not support, and that the flowering of modernism in 1910–1915 cannot be explained by an economic crisis. The geographer Doreen Massey insisted that time-space compression "needs differentiating socially", since people are placed within it in very different ways. Moishe Postone criticised Harvey for treating time-space compression and postmodern diversity merely as reactions to capitalism, so that his analysis remained extrinsic to the deep structure of capital, value and the commodity.

Coming after The Limits to Capital (1982), which dealt with money, finance and the spatial moment of crisis formation, the book extended Harvey's work on space and capital accumulation into cultural analysis. Harvey went on to work on "accumulation by dispossession" and neoliberalism. Postmodernism in general and the assessments of other Marxists are treated under "Postmodernism".

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. pages.gseis.ucla.edu
  3. othervoices.org
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. aladin.co.kr