типичность / typical characters under typical circumstances · Concept

Typicality (literature)

전형 (문학)

In literature and art, the quality by which a character or situation, while individual, concentrates the essential features of a social group or an age. In Marxist aesthetics the yardsticks became Engels's phrases "a type, but at the same time a definite individual" (to Minna Kautsky, 1885) and "typical characters under typical circumstances" (to Margaret Harkness, 1888). In the Soviet Union Malenkov, in his report to the Nineteenth Party Congress in 1952, defined the typical as "the basic sphere in which partisanship manifests itself in realistic art" and always a political problem, and for a time it became a central word of official literary theory.

In depth

What does "there's always someone like that in my class" mean?

Watching a drama, we sometimes say, "there's a manager exactly like that at my office." The character is identical to nobody we actually know; name, face and story all differ. Yet we recognise in him what many real managers share. If, on the other hand, the character is a scarecrow with the label "manager" stuck on, we soon get bored. Being one living person and at the same time standing for many people: in literature this is called the typical.

In literary study a "type" (Typus) originally meant a character with fixed features, such as the miser or the braggart soldier of comedy. The concept of the typical was established in nineteenth-century realist aesthetics, by Vissarion Belinsky in Russia, the Dane Georg Brandes and others, and today the typical is generally understood as a vivid, concentrated embodiment of the general and essential in the individual.

Why did Aristotle call poetry more philosophical than history?

The idea goes back to Aristotle's Poetics. He said that poetry speaks of the universal and history of the particular, and distinguished them like this: "The universal is what kind of person happens to say or do what kind of thing according to probability or necessity, … the particular is what Alcibiades did or what happened to him." What a person of a certain character would plausibly do in a certain situation tells more than the record of one real individual.

ἔστιν δὲ καθόλου μέν, τῷ ποίῳ τὰ ποῖα ἄττα συμβαίνει λέγειν ἢ πράττειν κατὰ τὸ εἰκὸς ἢ τὸ ἀναγκαῖον […] τὸ δὲ καθ᾽ ἕκαστον, τί Ἀλκιβιάδης ἔπραξεν ἢ τί ἔπαθεν

How did Engels speak of the typical?

The typical became a central concept of Marxist aesthetics thanks to two letters of Engels. In 1885, having read a novel by the Austrian writer Minna Kautsky, he praised her sharp individualisation of characters: "each is a type, but at the same time a definite individual, a 'Dieser', as old Hegel would put it, and so it must be." Immediately afterwards he found fault with the hero Arnold, who was so good that the character dissolved into a principle (letter to Minna Kautsky). A type is not a principle made to walk.

jeder ist ein Typus, aber auch zugleich ein bestimmter Einzelmensch, ein „Dieser", wie der alte Hegel sich ausdrückt, und so muß es sein.

The idea connects with what Engels wrote to Lassalle in 1859: a person is characterised not only by what he does but also by how he does it (see the Sickingen debate).

What are "typical circumstances"?

In his 1888 letter to Margaret Harkness, Engels extended the typical from characters to circumstances: "Realism, to my mind, implies, besides truth of detail, the truthful reproduction of typical characters under typical circumstances. Now your characters are typical enough, as far as they go; but perhaps the circumstances which surround them and make them act, are not perhaps equally so."

Realism, to my mind, implies, besides truth of detail, the truthful reproduction of typical characters under typical circumstances. Now your characters are typical enough, as far as they go; but perhaps the circumstances which surround them and make them act, are not perhaps equally so.

What did Engels mean by less typical circumstances? In Harkness's novel the working class appears only as a passive mass that cannot help itself. That might have been true around 1800, but to portray the working class of 1887 so was to miss the essence of the age: "The rebellious reaction of the working class against the oppressive medium which surrounds them, their attempts - convulsive, half conscious or conscious - at recovering their status as human beings, belong to history and must therefore lay claim to a place in the domain of realism." Typical circumstances are not the most common scenes but those in which the forces moving an age show themselves.

In the twentieth century Lukács extended the idea to the historical novel, arguing that Walter Scott's novels use "representative" or "typical" characters to dramatise great social conflicts and historical transformations (see triumph of realism).

How did the typical become a political question in the Soviet Union?

In the Soviet Union the typical had already been stressed by Aleksei Stetsky at the First Congress of Soviet Writers in 1934, but it became especially prominent in 1952–57. The occasion was Georgy Malenkov's report to the Nineteenth Party Congress in October 1952. He said that the typical is not only what occurs most often but what expresses most fully and sharply the essence of a given social force, and that "in the Marxist-Leninist understanding the typical by no means signifies some statistical average". Holding that conscious exaggeration does not exclude typicality but reveals it more fully, he declared: "The typical is the basic sphere in which partisanship manifests itself in realistic art. The problem of typicality is always a political problem."

Типическое есть основная сфера проявления партийности в реалистическом искусстве. Проблема типичности есть всегда проблема политическая

The formula at once became a yardstick of literary theory. A. Simonova's article "On the Problem of the Typical", published in 1953 in the journal of the Armenian Academy of Sciences, used it to criticise L. I. Timofeev's textbook Theory of Literature, which made socialist characters in socialist circumstances the defining mark of the method of Soviet literature, as a demand to depict only positive heroes, and linked that understanding of the typical to the "theory of conflictlessness" condemned in the party press. A concept that began in Engels's letters had become a political measure telling writers what to depict. Because Malenkov's formula tied the typical directly to partisanship, discussion of the typical in these years could not be separated from discussion of partisanship in literature.

Related people

Sources

  1. Marxists Internet Archive
  2. marx-wirklich-studieren.net
  3. cyclowiki.org
  4. de.wikipedia.org
  5. perseus.tufts.edu
  6. arar.sci.am
  7. ritsumei.ac.jp
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. Wikipedia (RU)
  10. Wikipedia (RU)