Союз писателей СССР (Союз советских писателей) · 1934.08.17–1991

Union of Soviet Writers

소련 작가동맹

The Union of Soviet Writers was the single organisation that brought together the professional writers of the Soviet Union from 1934 to 1991. The party resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" of 23 April 1932 dissolved the Russian Association of Proletarian Writers and other literary groups and decided to set it up in their place, and it was founded at the First Congress of Soviet Writers, held from 17 August to 1 September 1934. Its charter made socialist realism the basic method of Soviet literature. Because the union controlled the conditions of writers' lives, from publication to housing and holidays, expulsion from it in effect closed the way to publishing. It split into several organisations when the Soviet Union dissolved.

In depth

Why were writers brought into a single union?

In the 1920s Soviet writers were divided into many groups. Proletarian writers' associations, peasant writers, the pre-revolutionary writers the party called "fellow travellers", and literary groups such as Pereval and the Left Front of the Arts each published their own journals and fought one another. When the Russian Association of Proletarian Writers in effect took over Soviet letters from about 1928, writers outside it were attacked or pushed aside. Russian Wikipedia writes that by the mid-1930s the division of writers by social origin into proletarian, peasant, fellow traveller and ally no longer matched the actual work of writers such as Konstantin Fedin, Mikhail Sholokhov and Alexei Tolstoy.

The Politburo resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" of 23 April 1932 dissolved all these groups and decided to unite every writer who supported the platform of Soviet power in a single writers' union with a Communist fraction. Meeting Communist writers on 20 October that year, Stalin gave his reason: while the former association's people praised their own and hounded other writers, "right beside you there grew and multiplied a sea of non-party writers whom nobody led, whom nobody helped, who were homeless waifs".

Тут же рядом с вами росло и множилось море беспартийных писателей, которыми никто не руководил, которым никто не помогал, которые были беспризорными.

How was the founding prepared?

On 17 May 1932 the party Orgburo approved the membership of the organising committee of the union of Soviet writers for the Russian republic and decided to set up similar committees in the other republics. Maxim Gorky was elected honorary chairman of the all-Union organising committee, with Ivan Gronsky as chairman and Valery Kirpotin as secretary. Leaders of the dissolved Russian Association of Proletarian Writers, Leopold Averbakh, Alexander Fadeyev, Vladimir Kirshon and others, also joined the committee. On 23 May that year Gronsky first put forward the term "socialist realism" in Literaturnaya Gazeta, and on 26 October, at a meeting in Gorky's house attended by Stalin and Politburo members, the concept was discussed as the core of the union's charter.

People changed during the preparations. When Gronsky, secretary of the organising committee's party fraction who was preparing the congress documents, fell ill, Fadeyev took over and Vladimir Stavsky joined the secretariat. The article "On Socialist Realism" by Pavel Yudin and Fadeyev was approved by the Politburo on 6 May 1934 and published in Pravda. The congress was postponed several times, among other reasons because of the death of Gorky's son Maxim on 11 May 1934.

What did the First Congress decide?

The First Congress of Soviet Writers met in Moscow from 17 August to 1 September 1934. It was attended by 376 voting and 215 consultative delegates and more than forty foreign guests, and the speakers included Gorky, Samuil Marshak, Korney Chukovsky, Nikolai Bukharin, Yury Olesha, Ilya Ehrenburg and Alexei Tolstoy. The speech that Andrei Zhdanov gave on the opening day on behalf of the party Central Committee, "Soviet Literature: The Richest in Ideas, the Most Advanced Literature", can be read in full among this dictionary's documents.

The charter adopted by the congress defined socialist realism as follows: "Socialist realism, being the basic method of Soviet literature and literary criticism, demands of the artist a truthful, historically concrete depiction of reality in its revolutionary development."

Социалистический реализм, являясь основным методом советской художественной литературы и литературной критики, требует от художника правдивого, исторически-конкретного изображения действительности в её революционном развитии.

The 1934 charter also set the union's aim: "the creation of works of high artistic significance, saturated with the heroic struggle of the international proletariat and the pathos of the victory of socialism, reflecting the great wisdom and heroism of the Communist Party". Following socialist realism was a compulsory condition of membership.

Союз советских писателей ставит генеральной целью создание произведений высокого художественного значения, насыщенных героической борьбой международного пролетариата, пафосом победы социализма, отражающих великую мудрость и героизм коммунистической партии.

Who could join, and what did members get?

Under the 1934 charter a writer who wished to join needed at least two published books, applied with recommendations from three members, and had to pass votes in the local branch and then the central secretariat or board. Just before the congress, the admissions commission led by Yudin reported that practically every writer had applied, except Anna Akhmatova, who became a member only in 1939. In 1934 the union had about 2,500 members, about 1,500 full members and about 1,000 candidates. About a third were Communist Party members.

There was a reason for the rush. The union's Literary Fund (Litfond) gave members, according to their rank, housing, places in writers' dacha settlements, medical and sanatorium care, passes to "houses of creative work" and scarce goods. The union ran newspapers and journals such as Literaturnaya Gazeta, Novy Mir and Znamya, the publishing house Sovetsky Pisatel and the Gorky Literary Institute, and members' trips abroad needed the approval of its foreign commission. One participant in an organising committee plenum compared the queue of those desperate to become members at any price to "the crush outside some canteen or closed distribution shop".

«…напоминает давку около какой-нибудь столовой или закрытого распределителя»

Who led the union?

Sources differ on who was its first head. English Wikipedia and the Russian biography of Alexander Shcherbakov list Gorky as chairman of the board in 1934–1936. Russian Wikipedia's article on the union, however, says Gorky declined the post and wrote to the Central Committee that with Panfyorov, Vladimir Yermilov, Fadeyev and Stavsky elected to the board, "poorly educated people will lead people far better educated than they". Both agree that the actual running of the union lay with its first secretary Shcherbakov, sent from the party Central Committee.

«таким образом, люди малограмотные будут руководить людьми значительно более грамотными, чем они»

After that the union was headed by Alexei Tolstoy (1936–1938, with actual control in the hands of general secretary Stavsky in 1936–1941), Fadeyev (1938–1944 and 1946–1954), Nikolai Tikhonov (1944–1946), Alexei Surkov (1954–1959), Konstantin Fedin (1959–1977), Georgy Markov (1977–1986), Vladimir Karpov (1986–1991) and Timur Pulatov (1991). English Wikipedia gives Stavsky rather than Tolstoy as chairman for 1936–1938. Members of the board were on the nomenklatura lists controlled by the party Central Committee. The writers' congress, the highest body under the charter, was not convened for twenty years after the first congress of 1934, contrary to the charter, and met for the second time only in 1954.

What did expulsion mean?

A writer could be expelled for "misdeeds that lower the honour and dignity of a Soviet man of letters" or for departing from the principles of the charter. In practice the grounds were criticism by the party leadership, publication abroad, publication in samizdat, open disagreement with party policy, and signing open letters protesting the persecution of dissidents. Expelled writers could not publish in the union's publishing houses and journals and were also thrown out of the Literary Fund, which cut off their living. At times criminal prosecution, loss of citizenship or forced emigration followed.

After Zhdanov's report and the party decision "On the Journals Zvezda and Leningrad" of 1946, Mikhail Zoshchenko and Akhmatova were expelled (see this dictionary's entry "Zhdanovshchina"). On 27 October 1958 Boris Pasternak, who had published his novel Doctor Zhivago in Italy, was expelled unanimously by a joint meeting of the union's leading bodies, the first expulsion on the ground of publication abroad. On 4 November 1969 Alexander Solzhenitsyn was expelled. Other writers expelled for political reasons include Andrei Sinyavsky, Lydia Chukovskaya, Vladimir Voinovich and Alexander Galich. When Viktor Yerofeyev and Yevgeny Popov were expelled in December 1979, Vasily Aksyonov, Semyon Lipkin and Inna Lisnyanskaya left the union in protest.

War and repression left their mark on the membership rolls. Of some three thousand members in 1941, more than a thousand volunteered for the front or worked as war correspondents, and 417 were killed. According to the 1954 count, 15 per cent of the original membership had died at the front since the first congress and 180 had been convicted of anti-Soviet activity.

What happened after the Soviet collapse?

With the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991 the union split into organisations in the various post-Soviet states. The International Community of Writers' Unions, long led by Sergei Mikhalkov, claimed to be its successor, but in 1993 the Moscow City Court ruled that it was not the legal successor. In Russia the Union of Writers of the RSFSR split over the "Letter of the 74": those who sided with the letter formed the Union of Writers of Russia, and writers of mostly liberal views the Union of Russian Writers.

How is the union judged?

Official rules treated the union as a voluntary body. The 1971 charter defined it as "a voluntary public creative organisation uniting the professional writers of the Soviet Union who take part through their work in the struggle for the building of communism, for social progress, for peace and friendship among peoples". The union was awarded the Order of Lenin in 1967. For writers it was also the basis of their livelihood, guaranteeing fees, housing, rest cures and publication.

Critics see the other side. A Russian dictionary of literary terms writes that the union was formally voluntary but in practice, like RAPP, could shape not only writers' creative work but their political and material lives and at times their private lives. In his memoir The Oak and the Calf Solzhenitsyn portrayed the union as one of the main instruments of the party-state's total control over literary activity, and in The Master and Margarita Mikhail Bulgakov satirised the Soviet writers' organisation as a society of time-servers under the name "Massolit". English Wikipedia sums up that membership was effectively obligatory for professional writers and that expulsion amounted to a ban on publication.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (RU)
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Wikipedia (RU)
  4. Wikipedia (RU)
  5. hist.msu.ru
  6. web.archive.org
  7. Wikipedia (RU)
  8. Wikipedia (RU)
  9. Wikipedia (RU)
  10. Wikipedia (RU)
  11. Wikipedia (RU)
  12. Wikipedia (RU)
  13. Wikipedia (RU)
  14. Wikipedia (RU)