横浜事件 · 1942–1945

Yokohama Incident (1942–1945)

요코하마 사건 (1942~1945)

The arrest, between 1942 and 1945 during the Pacific War, of some 60 magazine editors, newspaper reporters and researchers by the Special Higher Police of Kanagawa Prefecture on charges under the Peace Preservation Law. On the basis of an article by Hosokawa Karoku and a single commemorative photograph of a gathering he held in his home town of Tomari, the police fabricated a "preparation to rebuild the Communist Party"; four people died in custody under torture. About 30 were convicted just after Japan's defeat, but the Peace Preservation Law was abolished soon afterwards. In 2010 the Yokohama District Court awarded criminal compensation and in effect recognised their innocence.

In depth

What set it off?

Hosokawa Karoku was a researcher who had worked at the Ōhara Institute for Social Research. While studying in Europe and the Soviet Union in 1925–1926 he met Sen Katayama in Moscow, and he studied Japan's colonial question, publishing A Policy for the Peoples of Asia in 1940 and A History of Colonisation in 1941. He wrote in terms chosen to avoid suppression, but after the war these books were judged a sharp criticism of Japanese colonial policy. He had belonged to the same China study group as Hotsumi Ozaki, executed in the Sorge Incident, and was a consultant to the Tokyo branch of the South Manchuria Railway (Mantetsu).

In 1942 the general magazine Kaizō carried Hosokawa's article "Trends in World History and Japan" in its August and September issues. It argued that national self-determination based on democracy should be respected for the Asian countries Japan had brought under its sway, and it had passed prior censorship. On 14 September, however, the head of the Army Press Section, Yahagi Nakao, denounced it in a book review as "communist propaganda", and Hosokawa was arrested the same day on suspicion of violating the Peace Preservation Law.

Three days earlier, on 11 September, the Special Higher Police section of the Kanagawa prefectural police had arrested Kawada Hisashi, who had returned from studying the labour movement in the United States, and his wife, on the charge that they had "brought back directives from the Communist Party USA". Kawada had never been a member of that party. The police widened the arrests from the World Economy Research Association where he worked to a Soviet studies group around it, and then to the research office of Mantetsu's Tokyo branch.

How was a single photograph used?

In May 1943, searching the home of a Mantetsu research office employee, the police found a photograph. It was a souvenir picture taken in July 1942, when Hosokawa used the royalties from A History of Colonisation to invite editors and researchers he was close to for an overnight gathering at an inn in his home town of Tomari, Toyama Prefecture. The Kanagawa Special Higher Police declared it a photograph of a preparatory meeting to rebuild the Japanese Communist Party (the Tomari Communist Party reconstruction case).

With this photograph as the lead, about 60 people were arrested one after another, editors of Kaizōsha and Chūō Kōronsha and of the Asahi Shimbun, Iwanami Shoten and Nippon Hyōronsha among them. The police beat suspects with leather straps and bamboo swords, threw water over them when they fainted, and extracted false confessions. The Japanese Wikipedia writes that four died in custody and one just after release on bail; the Heibonsha World Encyclopedia that two died in prison and two after release. Because arrests were also made at the Shōwa Juku, a private school opened by an associate of Fumimaro Konoe where Hosokawa lectured, some surmise that the case aimed at bringing Konoe down. In July 1944 Kaizō and Chūō Kōron were closed and the two publishers forcibly dissolved. The incident takes its name from the Kanagawa police who handled it and held the suspects in Yokohama.

What became of the trial and the postwar retrial?

Judgments were handed down in haste just after the defeat, between late August and September 1945, and about 30 people received two years' imprisonment suspended for three years. The trial records were burned and do not survive. Hosokawa never admitted the charge; he was bailed in September, the Peace Preservation Law was abolished in October, and his case was dismissed in November. In 1947 the victims brought charges against 28 Special Higher Police officers who had tortured them. Prison sentences on three were confirmed in 1952, but they did not serve them because of the amnesty that came with the peace treaty, and no judge or prosecutor was ever disciplined.

The victims and their families sought a retrial from 1986. After two refusals the Yokohama District Court ordered a retrial in 2003, and in 2005 the Tokyo High Court found that the defendants had made false confessions under torture. The retrial judgment, however, was a dismissal that ruled on neither guilt nor innocence. In February 2010 the Yokohama District Court awarded criminal compensation and found that the convictions had "begun with the Special Higher Police's preconceptions and violent investigation and been completed by the judiciary's endorsement".

How does it look within East Asia?

The Encyclopedia Nipponica calls the Yokohama Incident the largest case of suppression of speech fabricated by the Special Higher Police during the Pacific War. The subject of the article that set it off was the self-determination of the Asian peoples under Japanese rule, and the links in the chain of suspicion ran abroad: the Communist Party USA, a Soviet studies group, the research organs of Mantetsu. The autumn of 1942, when the arrests began, was also when the same law was used in colonial Korea in the Korean Language Society Incident. That October the society was branded an independence organisation and its members arrested, and Yi Yun-jae and Han Jing died in prison after torture. In both cases the Peace Preservation Law was applied to researchers and men of letters unconnected with any Communist organisation, and guilt was manufactured by torture.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. ja.wikipedia.org
  2. kotobank.jp
  3. ja.wikipedia.org
  4. Wikipedia (KO)