Bolshevik who built the Soviet Air Force and ran foreign trade
After the Arcos raid of 12 May 1927 in London, Rozengolts submitted a seven-page protest memorandum denying military espionage, but on 24 May Prime Minister Baldwin disclosed the seized documents to Parliament, and on 25 May Britain severed diplomatic relations and expelled him.
A Bolshevik from 1905, when he joined at 16, he became a Civil War political commissar, helped take Kazan and served against Kolchak. He headed the Soviet Air Force from 1922 to 1924, then spent 1925–1927 in London as chargé d'affaires through the Arcos raid and the break in Anglo-Soviet relations. Returning home, he broke with the opposition and joined the Stalinist apparatus. People's Commissar of Foreign Trade from 1930 to 1937, he was dismissed, arrested, sentenced to death in the 1938 Trial of the Twenty-One and shot.
Also known as: Rosengolts · Rosenholz · Arkady Rosengoltz
Activities and affiliations
-
1925–1927
Soviet Union state institutionsForeign affairsMain
Diplomacy and international organization -
1930–1937
Soviet Union state institutionsEconomic management
Economy, finance and planning- People's Commissar of Foreign Trade of the USSR1930–1937
Career Timeline
- 1905–1917Joins Bolsheviks at 16, delegate to the 4th Congress; underground work as an insurance agent in Vitebsk, Kiev and elsewhere
- 1917Member of Moscow Soviet executive committee, Moscow Military Revolutionary Committee; takes part in October armed uprising
- 1918–1920Member of the Republic's Revolutionary War Council, commissar with 8th and 5th Armies; creates Tsektran transport committee
- 1922–1924Head of the Soviet Air Force; secret military talks with the German high command; signs the Declaration of 46
- 1925–1927Chargé d'affaires in London; Arcos raid (12 May), expulsion as relations break on 25 May
- 1927–1930Member and presidium member of the Central Control Commission; works in Rabkrin (Workers' and Peasants' Inspectorate)
- 1930–1937People's Commissar of Foreign Trade — directs trade during Five-Year Plans, clashes with Ordzhonikidze over equipment imports
- 1937–1938Dismissed 14 June, moved to State Reserves, arrested 7 October; sentenced to death in the third Moscow trial
Related historical events
- 1905–1907The Revolution of 1905joined Bolsheviks in 1905 and delegate to the 4th Party CongressHe joined the Bolsheviks during the 1905 Revolution and was elected a delegate to the 4th (Unity) RSDLP Congress in Stockholm the following year.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionMember of Moscow Military Revolutionary Committee
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionMember of the Revolutionary Military Council and political commissar
- 1921–1928The New Economic Policy (NEP)People's Commissar of Foreign Trade
- 1923–1927The Succession Struggle and the Left Oppositionsignatory of the Declaration of the 46He signed the Declaration of the 46, which called for intraparty democracy in 1923.
- 1928–1937The Five-Year Plans and the Soviet TransformationPeople's Commissar of Foreign Trade
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeTarget of the Third Moscow TrialThe former foreign-trade commissar was condemned in the Third Moscow Trial and executed in 1938.
How did a Vitebsk merchant's son become a Bolshevik at sixteen?
Arkady Rozengolts was born on 4 November (16 November, New Style) 1889 in Vitebsk, a city in the western Russian Empire, now in Belarus. His father, Pavel (Faivel) Rozengolts, was a Jewish merchant who traded in arms; his mother was Tsivya, née Frumson. Born in Rostov-on-Don, she married Pavel, who already had two sons, and bore him four sons and a daughter. She took up painting at forty, studied in Vitebsk under Yehuda Pen and then at the Vitebsk People's Art School under Mstislav Dobuzhinsky and Alexander Romm, and became a Cubist and Suprematist painter in the circle of Kazimir Malevich; some of her works are now in the Pushkin Museum in Moscow.
The family was full of gifted people. His sister Eva Levina-Rozengolts became a painter and married the writer Boris Levin; his brother German became a microbiologist and professor at the Molotov (now Perm) Medical Institute. One maternal uncle, Nokhim Frumson, was a tenor who sang at the Mariinsky Theatre under the stage name "Nikolai Rostovsky"; another, Aron Frumson, was a Social Democrat. The poet Elena Shirman was his cousin. Several members of this family would later be repressed along with Rozengolts.
Late in life Rozengolts recalled that he had been raised by a woman who was an active revolutionary, and that at ten he had to hide illegal literature during a police raid. In 1905, the year of the first Russian Revolution, he joined the Bolshevik faction of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party at sixteen and was arrested for the first time. In 1906 he attended the Fourth Party Congress in Stockholm as a Bolshevik delegate, the so-called "Unity Congress" at which Bolsheviks and Mensheviks briefly reunited.
After the 1905 revolution was crushed the party went underground again. Rozengolts made a living as an insurance agent while doing party work in Vitebsk, Kiev, Ekaterinoslav and Moscow. An insurance agent could travel between cities and meet strangers without arousing suspicion, which made it good cover for underground work.
After the February Revolution of 1917 he came to the fore in Moscow. He joined the executive committee of the Moscow City Soviet, and in October took part in the armed rising as a member of the Moscow Military Revolutionary Committee. Unlike in Petrograd, in Moscow officer cadets and officers fought back for more than a week, and much blood was shed. After the revolution he worked in many organs of the new power: the All-Russian Military Revolutionary Committee, the People's Commissariats of the Russian Republic and the commission that drafted the RSFSR Constitution of 1918.
What did Rozengolts do as a political commissar in the Civil War?
When the Civil War began, Rozengolts became a political commissar in the Red Army. Commissars were the party's representatives, watching over commanders drawn from the old imperial army and persuading soldiers of the revolutionary cause; a commander's orders took effect only with the commissar's countersignature. In the summer of 1918, after the Czechoslovak Legion and anti-Bolshevik forces seized the Volga region, he played a leading role in the recapture of Kazan, a key city that held the tsarist gold reserve; its fall in September was the Red Army's first major victory.
The battle brought him close to Leon Trotsky, People's Commissar for Military and Naval Affairs, who in September 1918 appointed him to the Revolutionary Military Council of the Republic, which directed the whole war. From December 1918 to March 1919 he sat on the Revolutionary Military Council of the 8th Army on the Southern Front. At the Eighth Party Congress in March 1919 he backed Trotsky's line against the "Military Opposition", which opposed the use of former tsarist officers as military specialists and the building of a centralised regular army. When the Revolutionary Military Council of the Republic was reshuffled in July 1919 he was removed from it, but he stayed on in the east as political commissar of the 5th Army in the campaign against Admiral Kolchak's White army in Siberia. The 5th Army drove Kolchak's forces across the Urals as far as Omsk, and in January 1920 he was awarded the Order of the Red Banner.
As the Civil War drew to a close, the Bolshevik government's gravest worry was the collapse of the railways and water transport. In 1920 Rozengolts moved to the People's Commissariat of Transport, and that August, working with Trotsky, he created the Joint Transport Committee, Tsektran, which merged the railway and water-transport unions. Tsektran brought military-style discipline and political departments into transport work and placed the unions under direct party control, provoking fierce opposition from the trade unions. Trotsky wanted to absorb the unions into the state apparatus and push through the "militarisation of labour", while the Workers' Opposition argued, on the contrary, that the unions should run production. The conflict grew into the party-wide debate of 1920–1921 over the role of the trade unions, and when Lenin's middle line prevailed at the Tenth Party Congress in 1921 the Tsektran approach was criticised and withdrawn.
It stayed with him as a label. In December 1923 Stalin wrote sarcastically in Pravda: "In the ranks of the opposition there are men like Rosengolts, whose 'democracy' was a misery to our water transport workers and railwaymen." His reputation as the man who had carried out Trotsky's military and transport mobilisation on the ground became material for Stalin's attacks once he sided with the opposition.
How did Rozengolts, as head of the Red Air Fleet, rebuild Soviet aviation and open secret cooperation with Germany?
Appointed to the Revolutionary Military Council of the Western Front in January 1922, Rozengolts became head of the Chief Directorate of the Red Air Fleet (Glavvozdukhflot) the same year, chief of the Red Army Air Fleet from July 1923, and from November 1924 commander of the Air Force and a member of the Revolutionary Military Council of the USSR. His task was to rebuild Soviet aviation, ravaged by the Civil War, practically from scratch. He set four priorities: institutionalising aviation science, building a state aircraft industry, creating a training system for pilots and technicians, and securing ground facilities. Rallying aviation enthusiasts, he turned their work into a national project, and by the summer of 1924 a new squadron named "Ilyich" had joined the Red Air Fleet. These years make him one of the first organisers of the Soviet air force.
At the same time Rozengolts was the key negotiator who gave shape to secret military cooperation with Germany. In April 1922 Germany and Soviet Russia restored diplomatic relations at Rapallo, and secret military talks ran alongside. In 1922 Rozengolts met the leadership of the German Reichswehr directly to discuss a framework for cooperation in aviation and armour; English-language scholarship notes that the Soviet side saw it above all as a shared military interest against Poland. In July 1923 he met Chancellor Wilhelm Cuno secretly in a private apartment in Berlin, but the talks stalled when Cuno's government fell soon afterwards.
Even so, the cooperation materialised in the Lipetsk flying school (1926–1933), the Kama tank school and the Tomka chemical-weapons testing ground. Germany, barred by the Treaty of Versailles from keeping an air force, trained pilots and tested new aircraft on Soviet soil, while the USSR absorbed German technology and doctrine. The arrangement served as midwife to both countries' military reconstruction until it ended with the Nazi seizure of power in 1933. At the 1938 trial the prosecution seized on precisely these 1923 talks, claiming that he had passed military secrets to Germany on Trotsky's orders.
While heading the air force he also joined the party opposition. In the autumn of 1923 he signed the "Declaration of the 46", which demanded more democracy within the party and became the starting point of the Left Opposition. After Lenin's death in January 1924, as Trotsky was isolated, army officers counted as his men lost their posts one by one. Trotsky left the War Commissariat in January 1925, and in April 1925 Rozengolts too left the military on indefinite leave and was seconded to work outside the armed forces; in November he was transferred to the Red Army reserve. That autumn he left for the Soviet mission in London.
How did Rozengolts, as chargé d'affaires in London, live through the Arcos raid and the break in relations?
In 1925–1927 Rozengolts served as counsellor and chargé d'affaires at the Soviet mission in London. Sending prominent oppositionists abroad on diplomatic missions was a practice Stalin also used with Christian Rakovsky and others. When Rakovsky moved to Paris in November 1925, Rozengolts ran the mission until the new ambassador, Leonid Krasin, arrived in July 1926, and took charge again after Krasin died in London in November 1926. That December he reported to Moscow that Anglo-Soviet relations were deteriorating because of Soviet support for the British miners' strike and communist involvement in the revolution in China.
On 12 May 1927 the Special Branch of the London police raided the London headquarters of the Soviet trade delegation and of the All-Russian Co-operative Society, "Arcos", on the pretext of searching for a document allegedly stolen from the War Office. Rozengolts protested to the British government and submitted a seven-page memorandum stating that there was "no particle of evidence" that the trade delegation, Arcos or any of their employees had ever engaged in military espionage.
But on 24 May Prime Minister Stanley Baldwin told Parliament that the police had found a wealth of documents gathered by spies in a "subterranean photostat room". Baldwin placed the responsibility for espionage on the trade representative, Lev Khinchuk, and did not directly accuse Rozengolts of spying, but he implied that he was a liar. Among the seized papers was correspondence between the People's Commissariat for Foreign Affairs and Mikhail Borodin in China, whereas Rozengolts had earlier written to the Daily Telegraph that Borodin was a private individual with no connection to the Soviet government. Two days later the Home Secretary, William Joynson-Hicks, alleged that Rozengolts knew perfectly well what documents were passing between Moscow and London. Some Russian sources, including the Russian Wikipedia, state that he was in fact involved in espionage, but the evidence the British government made public was not aimed at him personally. The Soviet government denounced the raid as a breach of diplomatic privilege and a fabrication and denied the charges outright. On the other side, since the "Zinoviev letter" affair of 1924 there had been strong voices in Britain's Conservative government for breaking with the Soviet Union, and some read the raid as a political decision to find a pretext for the break.
Britain broke off relations with the Soviet Union on 25 May 1927 and expelled Rozengolts. Stopping in Warsaw on his way home, he witnessed the shooting of Pyotr Voykov, the Soviet envoy to Poland, by the young White émigré Boris Kowerda at the station on 7 June. The break with Britain, the collapse of the united front in China and Voykov's assassination, coming one after another in the spring and summer of 1927, set off a "war scare" in the Soviet Union, which Stalin also used against the opposition. By the time he was back in Moscow, Rozengolts had cut all ties with the opposition.
How did a former oppositionist become Stalin's People's Commissar of Foreign Trade?
Rozengolts came back from London a loyal supporter of Stalin. From 1927 to 1934 he sat on the Central Control Commission, the body responsible for party discipline and the expulsion of oppositionists (a member of its presidium in 1930–1932), and in 1928–1930 he worked in the Workers' and Peasants' Inspectorate, which audited state institutions. A man who had signed the Declaration of the 46 a few years earlier now sat in the machinery that drove the opposition out of the party.
On 10 September 1930 he became Deputy People's Commissar for Trade, a promotion and a sign of Stalin's confidence in his ability. The commissar was Anastas Mikoyan, a member of Stalin's inner circle; Stalin had concluded that Mikoyan could not deal with the trade deficit and decided to "prop him up" with an "outstanding deputy". When the commissariat was split that November into foreign and domestic trade, Rozengolts became People's Commissar of Foreign Trade and directed Soviet imports and exports until 1937. The First Five-Year Plan depended heavily on imported machinery and equipment, which had to be paid for with exports of grain and raw materials whose prices had collapsed in the Depression.
Under pressure to improve the trade balance he clashed fiercely with heavy industry, which needed imported equipment, and above all with Sergo Ordzhonikidze; one argument became so heated that Ordzhonikidze nearly hit him. Reporting back from a Politburo session in August 1931, Stalin's deputy Lazar Kaganovich noted that "the exchange of courtesies between 'Rozen' and Sergo was very unpleasant." The quarrel shows how industrialisation funds and equipment were allocated under the foreign-trade monopoly.
Judgements of him differ. Alexander Barmine, who worked in the Commissariat of Foreign Trade before defecting to the West, described him as "a bulky-shouldered, handsome Jew, with a heavy jaw and iron character", a born bureaucrat, and believed his skilful handling of foreign trade saved the USSR from economic catastrophe in the 1930s. The chemist Vladimir Ipatieff, who dealt with him in the 1920s, dismissed him as a pompous, conceited man, utterly worthless as an executive. He received the Order of Lenin in 1933 and became a candidate member of the Central Committee at the Seventeenth Party Congress in 1934. In 1932 he married Zoya Ryashentseva, with whom he had two daughters, Natalya and Zoya. Around 30 December 1934 he addressed the Seventh All-Union Congress of Soviets on trade and economic relations with the capitalist states, and the report appeared in Vneshnyaya torgovlya (1935, no. 3). He also wrote several pamphlets on the establishment of Soviet power and on Soviet foreign trade.
How did Rozengolts become a defendant in the Trial of the Twenty-One, and how is that trial judged today?
On 14 June 1937, as the Great Purge was gathering pace, Rozengolts was dismissed as People's Commissar of Foreign Trade. He was moved to head the Directorate of State Reserves under the Council of People's Commissars, while the NKVD built a case against him. He was arrested on 7 October 1937.
He became one of the twenty-one defendants at the third Moscow show trial, the case of the "Bloc of Rights and Trotskyites", held in Moscow on 2–13 March 1938, alongside former leaders such as Nikolai Bukharin, Alexei Rykov and Genrikh Yagoda. The accused faced a long list of capital charges, including plotting to kill Lenin and Stalin, espionage and sabotage. Rozengolts was charged with seeking an audience with Stalin in August 1934 as a member of a terrorist group in order to assassinate him, with passing military secrets to Germany on Trotsky's orders during the 1923 negotiations, and with embezzling large sums to finance the opposition. Like most of the defendants he confessed. In his final plea he declared that no man in the world had brought so much sorrow and misfortune to people as Trotsky, and cried: "Long live, flourish and grow in strength the great, mighty, beautiful USSR, advancing from victory to victory."
On 13 March 1938 the Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court sentenced him to death under several clauses of Article 58 (counter-revolutionary crimes) of the RSFSR Criminal Code, and on 15 March he was shot at the Kommunarka execution ground near Moscow. His wife, Zoya Ryashentseva, was also repressed and shot in 1938, and was rehabilitated only in 1957. Valery, his son from his first marriage, was also repressed. Elena, the elder daughter of his first marriage, died of a gunshot wound in Abkhazia in the mid-1930s; the official version was suicide, but the writer Anatoly Rybakov, who had been at the same school, gave a different account and modelled the character Lena Budyagina in his novel Children of the Arbat on her. His two daughters from his second marriage, Natalya, aged six and a half, and Zoya, aged four, were taken in by their aunt, the painter Eva Levina-Rozengolts, but when she too was arrested they were sent to a Moscow children's home. His brother German was released from the camps only in 1955.
Today the Trial of the Twenty-One is regarded as a fabrication resting on confessions extracted under coercion. The truth about the purges began to emerge after Khrushchev's Secret Speech of 1956, and on 4 February 1988 the Plenum of the USSR Supreme Court quashed the verdict and posthumously rehabilitated Rozengolts and his co-defendants; that year the Communist Party also acknowledged that the whole trial had been based on fabricated evidence and false confessions. By contrast, the 1943 Hollywood film Mission to Moscow presented the trial as a just reckoning with a real treasonous conspiracy; Rozengolts was played by Ivan Lebedeff.