1941.10.16–12.30

Defence and Recapture of Tikhvin (1941)

Why did the German army strike east of Leningrad at Tikhvin, and what did retaking the town a month later mean for besieged Leningrad?

On 16 October 1941 the German Army Group North crossed the Volkhov and struck at Tikhvin, a railway town east of Leningrad. The aim was to cut the last railway to the eastern shore of Lake Ladoga and meet the Finnish army on the Svir, closing a second ring round the city. The XXXIX Motorised Corps took Tikhvin on 8 November but was stopped by swamp, frost, an over-stretched front and the counterattacks of the Soviet 4th, 52nd and 54th Armies, and Soviet troops retook the town on 9 December. By the end of December the Germans were back on the Volkhov line, and with the railway restored more freight reached the ice road across Lake Ladoga.

Why did the Germans turn east to Tikhvin instead of Leningrad?

When German troops reached Shlisselburg on the southern shore of Lake Ladoga on 8 September 1941, Leningrad was cut off by land. But the city could still breathe. Part of the southern and eastern shores of the lake remained in Soviet hands, a railway from the interior carried freight through Vologda and Tikhvin to the eastern shore, and from there boats, and later an ice road, reached the city. In Directive No. 35 of 6 September Hitler ordered Army Group North to isolate the Leningrad area along the lower Volkhov and, once the Soviet forces round Leningrad had been destroyed, to link up with the Finnish Karelian Army on the Svir. The Finns had reached the Svir, north-east of Lake Ladoga, on 7 September but advanced no farther south, so closing a second ring meant a German drive of several hundred kilometres to the east. 1 2

Field Marshal Wilhelm von Leeb, commander of Army Group North, at first opposed the offensive. He had just handed a panzer group and an air corps to the Moscow drive, some 60 per cent of the ground was swamp, and snow and the autumn mud were coming. Leeb proposed instead to destroy the Oranienbaum bridgehead west of Leningrad and to advance down the Volkhov to Lake Ladoga to crush the Soviet 54th Army. Hitler rejected this and ordered him to take Tikhvin and then turn north-west towards Volkhov and the lake. The Chief of the Army General Staff, Franz Halder, called the plan "pure fantasy" in his diary. The bauxite deposits round Tikhvin, needed for aluminium, were also counted as a target of decisive value to the German war economy. 1 3

As the Russian Wikipedia summarises it, the German plan had three prongs. The main force was to advance from the Volkhov to Tikhvin and meet the Finns on the Svir; the right wing was to push through Malaya Vishera towards Bologoye and join the left wing of Army Group Centre; the left wing was to strike north and pin the Soviet forces against the southern shore of Lake Ladoga. The Soviet command hardly expected the blow. About 70 per cent of its forces south of the lake were committed to the offensive at Sinyavino, in the north, that was trying to break the blockade, and the sector that was struck had been further weakened by sending divisions to Moscow. The Soviet 4th Separate Army held more than 50 kilometres of front as a thin chain, and the 52nd Separate Army held 80 kilometres of the Volkhov with two divisions. 4

What happened before Tikhvin fell on 8 November?

On 16 October the German 11th and 21st Infantry Divisions crossed the Volkhov at two points near Gruzino and widened their bridgehead against the Soviet 267th and 288th Rifle Divisions. On the 18th General Rudolf Schmidt's XXXIX Motorised Corps crossed. The 12th Panzer and 20th Motorised Divisions drove towards Budogoshch, while the 8th Panzer and 18th Motorised Divisions, with the 126th Infantry Division, made for Malaya Vishera. From the 20th the Soviet 52nd Army fell back east and south-east, opening a gap between it and the 4th Army, and the German armour drove into it. The English Wikipedia records that Aleksandr Vasilevsky, then head of the Operations Directorate of the Soviet General Staff, sharply reprimanded the 52nd Army's commander, Nikolai Klykov. The mud cost the Germans three days, but they took Budogoshch on the 23rd, and Malaya Vishera fell that evening (on the 24th by Soviet accounts). 4 5

On 26 October the Stavka ordered the 4th and 52nd Armies to counterattack towards the Tikhvin road. Poor coordination made the attack fail, but it halted the German 12th Panzer Division for a time. The Soviet command stripped other sectors in haste: the 4th Guards Rifle Division came from Sinyavino, the 191st Rifle Division was shipped out of Leningrad by the Ladoga Flotilla and the 44th flown out, and the 92nd Rifle and 60th Tank Divisions reached Tikhvin. In the south the German 250th Infantry Division, the Spanish volunteer Blue Division, crossed the river at Udarnik north of Novgorod on the 19th to pin down the Soviet Novgorod Operational Group, but stiff Soviet resistance stopped it on the 29th. East of Malaya Vishera the German advance was halted by the Soviet 52nd Army on the 27th. 4 1

In early November frost hardened the ground and the Germans moved again. After the Soviet counterattacks stopped on the 4th, the Germans resumed their attack on the 5th, and on the 8th the 51st Regiment of the 18th Motorised Division entered Tikhvin in a snowstorm. The Russian Wikipedia says the regiment took the town without a shot on the night of the 9th; the loss is usually dated 8 November. The attack front had grown from 70 to more than 350 kilometres. From the 12th the German 12th Panzer Division pushed from Tikhvin along the railway towards Volkhov and by the 18th was near the Syas. Towards Volkhov, Herbert von Böckmann's battle group pushed north to reach the shore of Lake Ladoga but was stopped on 25 November six kilometres south of the town. In the four weeks after the Gruzino crossing the German 21st Infantry Division alone lost 79 officers and 2,522 men. 4 5

At the same time, further north, the German 21st and 11th Infantry Divisions pushed along both banks of the Volkhov towards the town of Volkhov. Losing Volkhov would have opened the southern shore of Lake Ladoga and the rear of the Leningrad Front's 54th Army. The Soviet command brought up the 310th Rifle Division from the Sinyavino sector and, in early November, the 6th Naval Infantry Brigade; the troops defending Volkhov were grouped on 28 October as the Volkhov Operational Group under the 4th Army and from 12 November under the 54th Army. On the 20th the Germans formed their units here into Operational Group Böckmann and fought for every village, but on 25 November they were stopped six kilometres from Volkhov. Sappers briefly cutting the railway east of Volkhov and a reconnaissance battalion briefly cutting the Volkhov-Leningrad road marked the furthest north the Germans reached in this sector. 4 5

What did the loss of Tikhvin mean for Leningrad and the people round it?

Tikhvin lay on the last railway from Vologda to the eastern shore of Lake Ladoga. Meretskov wrote in his memoirs that losing Tikhvin meant losing the last railway that supplied Leningrad. The Russian Wikipedia counts the fall of Tikhvin among the real causes of the cuts in Leningrad's rations and of the city's mass starvation that winter. In the city the bread ration fell on 20 November to 250 grams a day for workers and 125 grams for everyone else, and the ice road across the lake, opened at that time, had to begin as a long detour through the forest round the severed railway. 6 4

Meretskov recorded how German propaganda trumpeted the victory. As he quotes it, Hitler said in a speech in Munich on 8 November, the day Soviet troops left Tikhvin, that Leningrad "will raise its hands of itself" and was "doomed to die of hunger". A Soviet memoir quoting the German leader in this way fits the Soviet framing that tied the battle directly to the life and death of Leningrad's people. That the German command meant to starve the city into surrender rather than occupy it is confirmed by German records as well. Leeb ordered his artillery to fire on civilians trying to escape the encircled city, and in mid-November the army group's war diary noted that the artillery was keeping civilians away from the German lines. 6

The people of towns and villages near the front paid too. Units under Leeb killed Roma or handed them to the SS Security Service (SD), and in December, with the express consent of the 18th Army's commander Georg von Küchler, an SD unit shot 240 patients of the psychiatric hospital at Makaryevo. In October 1941 German aircraft bombed a train at Tikhvin station that was evacuating children from Leningrad; a memorial was raised on the spot in 2016. During its month of occupation Tikhvin lost many architectural monuments. Soldiers of the Spanish Blue Division quartered near Novgorod used the iconostasis of the Church of St Theodore Stratelates for firewood, and used the high cupola of the Church of the Transfiguration on Ilyina Street as a machine-gun nest, badly damaging the building and its icons by Theophanes the Greek. 7 8 9 3 10

According to the German Wikipedia, Leningrad starved in complete isolation from 8 September to 20 November, when an ice road known as the "Road of Life" opened across frozen Lake Ladoga; but the food it brought in fell far short of feeding all the citizens, because the railway that should have carried goods to its eastern end was cut at Tikhvin. Meretskov wrote in his memoirs that liberating Tikhvin was "a question of life for Leningrad". By his account the Northern Operational Group had cleared the whole Tikhvin-Volkhov railway by 24 December, railway repair teams followed the troops rebuilding the track and bridges the Germans had wrecked, and at the very moment the last German soldiers were being thrown back over the Volkhov the first trains with food for Leningrad left Tikhvin. 6 11

How did Meretskov take over the broken 4th Army?

Kirill Meretskov then commanded the 7th Separate Army, which was holding the Finns on the Svir north-east of Lake Ladoga. He wrote in his memoirs that he took no direct part in the fighting for Tikhvin but followed it daily, because a breakthrough there would open his own army's rear. Contact with the 4th Army had been lost and the Stavka gave no exact information, so he had to send out his own reconnaissance. When he reported the situation to the Stavka by telephone on 7 November, he was soon ordered to go to the 4th Army and take temporary command. He kept the 7th Army as well, and both armies were tasked with holding the Finns on the Svir while stopping and destroying the Germans at Tikhvin. According to the German Wikipedia he became commander of the 4th Army on 11 November, and his predecessor, Vsevolod Yakovlev, took over the Southern Operational Group. 6 5

By Meretskov's account, the officers he found were dejected, and none of those who had retreated through Tikhvin could properly explain how it had been lost: units that had lost their commanders passed through the town without stopping, and the Germans, once in it, pushed on at once north towards the Svir and east towards Vologda. He wrote that he gathered the units scattered through the woods and along the roads and even had field kitchens flown in. On 10 November the 4th Army formed three operational groups north, east and south of Tikhvin: the Northern under Pyotr Privalov, the Southern under Yakovlev, and between them a tank and cavalry group under A. A. Pavlovich. 6 12

Early on 11 November the 46th Tank Brigade and the 1061st Rifle Regiment, sent from the 7th Army, attacked the Germans north of Tikhvin with the 44th and 191st Rifle Divisions and came within 12 to 13 kilometres of the town. Meretskov wrote that the episode taught him that new units, however urgent the need, must be put in order before they fight. On the same day Hans-Jürgen von Arnim, the new commander of the XXXIX Motorised Corps, ordered his troops to hold Tikhvin. On the 17th the German Army High Command (OKH) asked the Finnish headquarters whether it could attack from the Svir towards Tikhvin. General Waldemar Erfurth, the German liaison at Finnish headquarters, wrote in his memoirs that because the Russians were drawing troops even from the front facing the Karelian Army for their counteroffensive, he asked the Finns to tie those troops down; the Finns did not move. On 23 November the German command postponed the link-up with the Finns to 1942. 6 5 12

How did the Red Army retake Tikhvin?

The Soviet counteroffensive could not start all at once; troops and supplies were short, so the south moved first. On 10 November the Novgorod Operational Group of the North-Western Front and on the 12th Klykov's 52nd Army attacked round Malaya Vishera. The 52nd Army spread all four divisions in a single line on a 48-kilometre front and until the 19th threw two regiments of the 259th Rifle Division head-on at well-fortified Malaya Vishera without reconnaissance or artillery support. On the night of the 20th an outflanking move finally drove out the German 126th Infantry Division. Halder noted "very strong pressure" in this sector in his diary on the 16th. The OKH sent the 215th Infantry Division to shore up Bolshaya Vishera. 12 1

The 4th Army attacked Tikhvin on 19 November. The plan was for the Northern Group and Pavlovich's group to meet west of the town and form an inner ring while the Southern Group cut the escape routes farther out. But the Germans not only held but counterattacked, and the fighting became a series of meeting engagements from the start. Pavel Koshevoi's 65th Rifle Division, the mainstay of the Eastern Group, stopped on the outskirts, and the 44th Rifle Division took Lazarevichi and lost it again. Still, the Tikhvin-Volkhov railway was now under Soviet guns and useless as a German escape route, leaving only the dirt road from Tikhvin to Budogoshch. At the end of November the Germans brought the 61st Infantry Division from the Baltic, where it had been occupying the Moonsund islands, to reinforce Tikhvin. Meretskov wrote in his memoirs that retaking Tikhvin was then "a question of life for Leningrad". 12 6

After regrouping, Soviet troops attacked again on 5 December. On the first day the Northern Group cleared the right bank of the Tikhvinka and cut the Tikhvin-Volkhov road, Pavlovich's group cut the dirt road to Budogoshch, and by the 8th the Eastern Group had reached the edge of the town. Facing encirclement, Siegfried Haenicke, commander of the 61st Infantry Division and of the Tikhvin defence, decided on the 8th to give up the town "against the Führer's wishes", according to the Russian Wikipedia; the English Wikipedia says Leeb ordered the withdrawal on the night of the 7th, hours before Hitler gave his approval. The Germans counterattacked to keep a corridor open and got out, and on the 9th the Soviet 65th Rifle Division from the south and the 191st from the north-east drove out the rearguard, the 151st Infantry Regiment, and retook the town. The Germans left behind 42 guns, 27 tanks, 102 lorries and food stores. Meretskov wrote that the town lay "wounded and quiet", and admitted that for want of guns and shells, and because swamp and deep snow ruled out manoeuvre, the Germans could not be cut off and destroyed. 12 1 6

Meretskov set down in his memoirs what held the counteroffensive back. The ammunition sent by the Stavka arrived very slowly: when the counteroffensive began only seven of thirty-five expected ammunition transports had come, so the 120 mm mortars and 122 mm howitzers could fire an average of seven rounds a day and the 82 mm mortars fourteen. Meanwhile the Germans had turned Tikhvin's stone buildings into strongpoints, and in forest under deep snow the fighting could only follow the few roads, each guarded by an enemy strongpoint. From the bitter experience of November, he wrote, he made it a rule that however urgently troops were needed, newly arrived units first learned to fight in forest and swamp, to keep their bearings and to build positions and roads before being sent into battle. 6

How did the Germans fall back to the Volkhov?

On 15 December, with the Soviet counteroffensive before Moscow at its height, Leeb began pulling his northern wing back behind the Volkhov without OKH permission, and the next day he obtained Hitler's approval in person at the Wolfsschanze. The order the army group received authorised withdrawing the inner wings of the 16th and 18th Armies to the Volkhov and the railway running north-west from Volkhov station, but required that line to be held "to the last man" and the siege of Leningrad maintained. The Germans set up a temporary line in the swamps near Budogoshch to slow Meretskov's pursuit. At Christmas Leeb congratulated his army group on its achievements in the invasion, but on 15 January 1942 he asked Hitler either to give him freedom of action or to relieve him; Hitler chose the latter and gave the army group to Küchler, commander of the 18th Army. 7 1

In the north the Leningrad Front's 54th Army under Ivan Fedyuninsky came into play. Ordered by the Stavka to keep up its offensive towards Sinyavino, it could not at first strike the flank of the German drive on Volkhov, but on 3 December it attacked south of Voibokalo with a shock group of the 311th, 285th and 80th Rifle Divisions, the 6th Naval Infantry Brigade and the 122nd Tank Brigade. It stalled at first against German strongpoints, but the fresh 115th and 198th Rifle Divisions arrived on the 15th, the attack reached Olomna on the 17th, and on the 21st it met the 4th Army on the Lynka, 20 kilometres south-east of the town of Volkhov. The Germans hurried south along the Volkhov, and by the 24th the whole Tikhvin-Volkhov railway was clear. On the 27th the Soviet Information Bureau announced that the 54th Army had destroyed some 6,000 German troops and captured 87 guns between the 18th and 25th. 12 1

In the south the Spanish Blue Division held a bridgehead at Possad and the Otensky monastery, reachable only by a 10-kilometre forest road and under constant partisan and Red Army attack. On 7 December a tank-led assault broke in, and the Spaniards threw it out with the bayonet, but the order to withdraw came that day and they left at night; on the 9th they abandoned the last positions of the bridgehead. According to the English Wikipedia the division lost 30 per cent of its combat troops in the operation. The Germans were driven from Bolshaya Vishera on the 16th and by the 23rd had crossed to the west bank of the Volkhov, though their bridgeheads at Kirishi and Gruzino remained. Meanwhile, on 17 December, the Stavka combined the 4th and 52nd Armies with the arriving 59th and 26th Armies into the Volkhov Front under Meretskov, and on the 22nd the forward units of the 4th Army began crossing the Volkhov without a pause. 1 12 10

The retreat was harsh for the Germans too. A German account quoted by the Russian Wikipedia describes exhausted, bleeding men who had gone days without hot food and froze from the slightest wound trudging back, winter clothing a rarity, while Soviet tanks, cavalry and riflemen dogged the columns and aircraft strafed them without pause. Meretskov recalled that the Soviet side gathered its newest aircraft into one formation and mounted submachine gunners on tanks to speed the pursuit, and that the Germans fell back in haste, abandoning their wagons and equipment. The Soviet pursuit averaged two to two and a half kilometres a day, and the counteroffensive advanced 100 to 120 kilometres on a front 300 to 350 kilometres wide. 12 6

What did the counteroffensive cost, and how is it judged?

According to the German Wikipedia the Red Army lost about 49,000 men in the counteroffensive, about 18,000 of them killed or missing, figures consistent with Grigori Krivosheyev's loss statistics cited in that article. On the German side, Army Group North lost 26,808 killed, wounded and missing between 10 October and 20 November, most of them in the Tikhvin offensive. The German 18th Motorised Division, about 10,000 strong at the start, had only 741 men when it withdrew behind the Volkhov. The Germans had to move five divisions from other fronts to this sector. 5 4 12

Soviet official history divides the fighting into the Tikhvin defensive and Tikhvin offensive operations and ranks the offensive, with the Rostov offensive of the same weeks, as the first large Soviet counteroffensives. Meretskov went so far as to write that the start of the Tikhvin operation was the enemy's first "serious defeat" on the Soviet-German front, a claim to be read as his own judgement given the retaking of Rostov and the Moscow counteroffensive at the same time. The Russian Wikipedia lists among the results the recovery of lost ground and of the railway, and a 115-kilometre winter motor road from Tikhvin to Novaya Ladoga that greatly shortened the haul to Leningrad. Tikhvin is remembered as the first town freed in the Red Army's winter counteroffensive of 1941-42, and in 2010 the Russian government gave it the title of City of Military Glory. 12 6 9

The same sources record the limits of the counteroffensive. Soviet troops tended to attack strongpoints head-on instead of bypassing them, coordination between arms was poor, and the planned encirclements, at Tikhvin and of all the Germans east of the Volkhov, never came off. The Germans, despite heavy losses and abandoned equipment, withdrew across the river in fair order and rebuilt their defence. The experience led the Red Army to conclude that it had to restore the corps level of command it had abolished. The English Wikipedia judges that the victory let Leningrad hold out and that Army Group North never again took the offensive in this sector. To finish Leningrad Hitler sent Manstein's 11th Army north in the summer of 1942, but it too was caught up in the Soviet Sinyavino offensive. The offensive across the Volkhov that followed directly from this counteroffensive was the Lyuban offensive. 12 1

Consequences

The Germans failed to join the Finns and close Leningrad off completely, and Army Group North never again mounted a major offensive in this sector. Nor did the Red Army encircle the Germans at Tikhvin or east of the Volkhov, and its counteroffensive ran without a pause into the Lyuban offensive of January 1942. The counteroffensive alone cost the Red Army about 49,000 men, some 18,000 of them killed or missing.

Timeline & Map

Tikhvin Svir River Volkhov Kirishi Budogoshch Gruzino Malaya Vishera 10 South of Volkhov 6 Bolshoi Dvor 15 Lynka River 11 West of Tikhvin 5 Tikhvin 8 Tikhvin 12 Tikhvin 16 Volkhov River 4 Budogoshch 2 Gruzino 7 Malaya Vishera 9 Malaya Vishera 14 Malaya Vishera 3 Udarnik 1 Wolfsschanze 13 Wolfsschanze
  1. 11941.09.06Germany
    Directive No. 35

    In Directive No. 35 Hitler ordered Army Group North to isolate Leningrad along the lower Volkhov and link up with the Finnish army on the Svir.

  2. 21941.10.16GermanySoviet Union
    Crossing of the Volkhov

    The German 11th and 21st Infantry Divisions crossed the Volkhov at two points near Gruzino and built a bridgehead.

  3. 31941.10.19SpainSoviet Union
    The Blue Division crosses

    The Spanish 250th Infantry Division crossed the Volkhov at Udarnik north of Novgorod in a holding attack against the Soviet Novgorod Operational Group.

  4. 41941.10.23GermanySoviet Union
    Budogoshch falls

    The German 12th Panzer and 20th Motorised Divisions drove through the gap between the Soviet 4th and 52nd Armies and took Budogoshch.

  5. 51941.11.08GermanySoviet Union
    Tikhvin taken

    The 51st Regiment of the German 18th Motorised Division took Tikhvin in a snowstorm, cutting the railway towards Lake Ladoga.

  6. 61941.11.10Soviet Union
    Meretskov takes over the 4th Army

    Kirill Meretskov, commander of the 7th Separate Army, took command of the 4th Army as well and formed Northern, Eastern and Southern operational groups round Tikhvin.

  7. 71941.11.12Soviet UnionGermany
    The 52nd Army counterattacks

    Nikolai Klykov's 52nd Army opened its counteroffensive south and east of Malaya Vishera.

  8. 81941.11.19Soviet UnionGermany
    The 4th Army attacks Tikhvin

    The 4th Army's three operational groups attacked Tikhvin but were held by German counterattacks on the outskirts.

  9. 91941.11.20Soviet UnionGermany
    Malaya Vishera retaken

    In a night battle the 52nd Army outflanked the German 126th Infantry Division and drove it out of Malaya Vishera.

  10. 101941.11.25GermanySoviet Union
    German advance halted before Volkhov

    The German drive towards Lake Ladoga was stopped by the Volkhov Operational Group of the Soviet 54th Army six kilometres south of the town of Volkhov.

  11. 111941.12.05Soviet Union
    Second phase

    The regrouped 4th Army attacked again and its Northern Group cut the Tikhvin-Volkhov road.

  12. 121941.12.09Soviet UnionGermany
    Tikhvin retaken

    The Soviet 65th and 191st Rifle Divisions entered Tikhvin from the south and north-east and retook it from the German rearguard.

  13. 131941.12.16Germany
    Retreat behind the Volkhov approved

    Leeb, who had begun pulling his northern wing back behind the Volkhov without permission the day before, met Hitler at the Wolfsschanze and obtained his approval.

  14. 141941.12.17Soviet Union
    Volkhov Front formed

    The Stavka combined the 4th and 52nd Armies with newly arriving armies into the Volkhov Front under Meretskov.

  15. 151941.12.21Soviet Union
    4th and 54th Armies meet

    The right wing of the 4th Army met units of the 54th Army on the Lynka, 20 kilometres south-east of the town of Volkhov.

  16. 161941.12.30Soviet UnionGermany
    The Volkhov line restored

    Soviet troops regained the east bank of the Volkhov except the Kirishi bridgehead, and the Germans rebuilt their defence on the west bank.

Related people 10

Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12