Albania's leader who made isolation and self-reliance state policy
The 1961 rupture with the USSR showed how far a small socialist state could take an ideological break.
He led Albania's communists and anti-occupation resistance, founding the postwar people's republic. He broke diplomatic relations with the USSR in 1961 and later with China, pursuing an independent Stalinist line.
Activities and affiliations
-
1941–1943
Party of Labour of AlbaniaFirst Secretary
Political and party leadership -
1944–1985
Albania state institutionsMain
Political and party leadership -
Political and party leadership
Career Timeline
- 1944–1985First secretary of the Party of Labour and leader of Albania
- 1961Breaks diplomatic relations with the USSR
- 1978Break with China
Related historical events
- 1944–1946Albanian liberation and establishment of the republicPartisan and new government leader
- 1944–1949The People's Democracies of Eastern EuropeLeader of the Albanian CommunistsHe led the Democratic Front's single-list election of December 1945 and the proclamation of the People's Republic in January 1946, and after the break with Tito in 1948 had Koçi Xoxe executed.
- 1956–1969The Sino-Soviet SplitAlbanian leader who sided with ChinaHe rejected Khrushchev's criticism of Stalin and approach to Yugoslavia, leading to the break with Moscow in 1961.
- 1968The Prague SpringCondemned both the reforms and the invasion; withdrew from the Warsaw PactHe attacked Dubček's 'socialism with a human face' as revisionism and also condemned the Soviet invasion as an expression of the Brezhnev Doctrine. Albania formally withdrew from the Warsaw Pact on 5 September 1968.
How did a French teacher from Gjirokastër come to lead Albania's communists and its liberation war?
Enver Hoxha was born in October 1908 in Gjirokastër, a town in southern Albania then still part of the Ottoman Empire. His father was a cloth merchant who travelled widely in Europe and America, and the family belonged to the Bektashi Sufi order; the surname Hoxha comes from the word for a Muslim teacher. On a state scholarship he finished the French-language lycée in Korçë and in 1930 entered the University of Montpellier to study botany, but his interests lay in the social sciences and humanities and he dropped out. In Paris he mixed with exiles opposed to King Zog, and in 1935–1936 he worked as a secretary at the Albanian consulate in Brussels. Back home, he taught French and morals at the Korçë lycée from 1937 to 1939.
In April 1939 Fascist Italy invaded Albania and set up a puppet kingdom. Hoxha, who refused to join the Albanian Fascist Party, lost his teaching post and went to work in a tobacco shop a friend had opened in Tirana, which soon became the base of a communist cell. Albania's communists were then split into feuding local groups. On 8 November 1941, with two envoys of the Yugoslav Communist Party acting as mediators, they were united as the Communist Party of Albania, and Hoxha, representing the Korçë group, became one of seven members of the provisional Central Committee. In March 1943 the first national conference elected him First Secretary.
At the Pezë conference in September 1942 the party created the National Liberation Movement to unite anti-fascists regardless of ideology or class, and in July 1943 it organised the partisans into the National Liberation Army, which also received weapons from Britain's Special Operations Executive. In August 1943 the communists agreed on joint action with the anti-communist nationalist Balli Kombëtar, but they repudiated the deal, which promised a "Greater Albania" including Kosovo, when the Yugoslav communists objected. The Balli Kombëtar then sided with Germany and the two forces fought a civil war. Whether this period should be called a war of liberation or a civil war is still debated in Albanian historiography.
In May 1944 the Congress of Përmet set up the Anti-Fascist Committee for National Liberation with Hoxha as chairman, and in October at Berat the committee became a provisional government with him as prime minister. On 29 November Albania drove out the German army without the direct help of foreign troops. Hoxha's own tally of the war's cost was 28,000 dead out of a population of one million and 850 of the country's 2,500 towns and villages destroyed. In December 1945 the communist-led Democratic Front, the only legal list, reported 93 percent of the vote, and in January 1946 the monarchy was formally abolished and the People's Republic of Albania proclaimed.
Why did postwar Albania break with Yugoslavia and side with Stalin, and at what cost?
Postwar Albania was the poorest country in Europe. The land reform law of August 1945 confiscated without compensation the estates of large landowners and beys, the local magnates of the Ottoman era, and gave them to peasants, cutting the large holders' share of land from 52 to 16 percent. From 1949 literacy classes were compulsory for citizens aged 20 to 40, and the literacy rate, about 15 percent in 1946, reached 70 percent by 1950. The campaign against malaria, the expansion of hospital beds and the ban on the blood feud also began in these years. At the same time the new regime secured its power from 1945 onward with extrajudicial killings and executions of anti-communists.
In the first postwar years Albania was in effect a Yugoslav satellite. The 1946 treaty of friendship and a customs union tied the lek to the dinar and left economic planning to Belgrade. Hoxha later denounced the relationship as colonial, saying Yugoslavia kept Albania as a supplier of raw materials and sold it even needles and thread at inflated prices. Tito held that Albania was too weak to stand alone and would do better inside Yugoslavia, and within the party the interior minister Koçi Xoxe led the pro-Yugoslav faction. The anti-Yugoslav Nako Spiru, isolated, killed himself in November 1947. In early 1948 Hoxha himself was in danger of being pushed aside by Xoxe and his Yugoslav backers.
He was saved by the Stalin-Tito split of June 1948. Hoxha immediately sided with Moscow, expelled the Yugoslav advisers on 1 July and declared every treaty between the two countries void. Xoxe was expelled from the party and executed in June 1949. Albania joined Comecon in 1949, received $200 million in Soviet aid between 1948 and 1960, and hosted a Soviet submarine base on Sazan island off Vlorë. When Stalin died in 1953, Hoxha gathered the people of Tirana in the main square and had them kneel and take a 2,000-word oath of eternal loyalty to their "great liberator".
There were real outside threats. From 1949 American and British intelligence trained and infiltrated Albanian émigrés, but the Soviet double agent Kim Philby betrayed the plan and about 300 infiltrators were killed or captured. The regime also used these threats to justify repression at home: after a bomb was thrown at the Soviet embassy in Tirana in February 1951, 22 intellectuals and businessmen were shot without trial. The secret police, the Sigurimi (Directorate of State Security), grew into an apparatus watching the whole of society in the name of preventing counter-revolution. Hoxha's supporters remember these years as the defence of independence against annexation and imperialist subversion; his critics see them as the elimination of rivals and the institutionalisation of terror.
Why did Hoxha break first with the Soviet Union and then with China?
The seeds of the break lay in Khrushchev's change of course in 1955–1956. He travelled to Belgrade in 1955 to make peace with Yugoslavia, and at the Twentieth Congress of the Soviet Communist Party in February 1956 he condemned Stalin's personality cult and proclaimed peaceful coexistence. Reconciliation with Tito threatened to put Albania back under Yugoslav influence, and the demand to rehabilitate Xoxe was a challenge to Hoxha's own legitimacy. When delegates at a Tirana party conference in April 1956 raised the personality cult and the absence of inner-party democracy, Hoxha expelled and jailed the critics and called the episode a Yugoslav plot. That closed the door to Khrushchev-style reform in Albania.
Khrushchev's economic plans deepened the conflict. He wanted the Eastern bloc to specialise and assigned Albania the role of agricultural supplier, which to Hoxha meant giving up industrialisation. At the Bucharest meeting of June 1960 Albania took China's side in the Sino-Soviet dispute, and Khrushchev called Hoxha "that agent of Mao Zedong". Moscow cut grain shipments just as flooding threatened famine, and in July a coup plot allegedly organised by a Soviet-trained rear admiral was uncovered. In 1961 the Soviets withdrew their technicians and most of their forces at the submarine base. On 7 November Hoxha called Khrushchev "a revisionist, an anti-Marxist and a defeatist", and the Soviet Union and every other Warsaw Pact state broke off relations with Albania.
China then became Albania's patron. Its loans were interest-free and repayable whenever Albania could afford it, and in 1964 Zhou Enlai came to Tirana to sign a joint statement that relations between socialist countries large and small must rest on complete equality. Mao called Albania "the only Marxist-Leninist state in Europe". When the Warsaw Pact invaded Czechoslovakia in 1968, Albania condemned it and formally left the pact that September.
The Chinese alliance did not last either. When China agreed to receive Nixon in 1971, the Albanian party protested that Beijing had not consulted it before welcoming a "frenzied anti-communist", and China replied that its aid could not go on indefinitely. After Mao's death China made the Three Worlds Theory, which justified alignment with the United States against the Soviet Union, its official policy and in 1977 welcomed Tito to Beijing; Hoxha declared that China had become a revisionist state like the Soviet Union and Yugoslavia. In July 1978 China cut off all aid. Hoxha explained this chain of ruptures as a matter of principle against great powers that used aid as leverage to bargain away a small country's sovereignty, and small parties around the world that followed him called themselves "Hoxhaist". His critics see the same choices as making Albania the most isolated country in Europe in order to keep its leader in power.
Why did Albania declare itself the world's first atheist state in 1967?
Under the Ottomans Albania was divided into Muslim, Orthodox and Catholic communities, and even after the rise of nationalism Muslims were often classed as "Turks", the Orthodox as "Greeks" and Catholics as "Latins". Hoxha held that this religious division fed Greek separatism in the south and split the nation. Persecution began well before 1967: the 1945 land reform confiscated church property, and the regime, which regarded the Vatican as an agent of fascism and anti-communism, banned the Jesuits in 1946 and the Franciscans in 1947. Decree No. 743 on religion sought to set up national churches and forbade religious leaders to associate with foreign powers.
In February 1967, Hoxha ignited a sweeping anti-religious campaign as part of his "Cultural and Ideological Revolution." Under the official narrative that youth and students had taken the initiative, all 2,169 mosques, churches, and Bektashi tekkes across Albania were demolished or converted into secular facilities such as warehouses and gymnasiums. That November, Albania proclaimed itself the world's first officially atheist state. Article 37 of the 1976 Constitution banned religious activity outright, and town and personal names with religious connotations were forcibly replaced by secular alternatives. A state-published Dictionary of People's Names (1982) listed only 3,000 approved secular names. During fasts such as Ramadan and Lent, food was handed out on purpose in schools and factories, and those who refused it were denounced. In a 1968 speech Hoxha said that "religion is a fuel kindling fires of all evils". Mother Teresa, a Catholic nun of Albanian origin, was regarded as a dangerous agent of the Vatican and, despite requests from many countries, was never allowed to visit her mother and sister in Albania.
Clergy were arrested, executed, or driven underground: of roughly 300 Catholic priests active before the takeover, only about 30 survived into the 1990s. An entire generation grew up experiencing neither church nor mosque. Hoxha declared that "the only religion of Albania is Albanianism", a line taken from the poem "O Albania" by the nineteenth-century national poet Pashko Vasa, and the party defined religion as a foreign instrument obstructing national unity.
This radical state-atheism experiment formally ended only in December 1990, when the dictatorship collapsed after Hoxha's death.
What did Hoxha's Albania leave behind after its last decade of isolation and fear?
At the Fourth Plenum of the Central Committee in June 1973, Hoxha denounced Western popular culture, long hair, extravagant dress and "screaming jungle music", as "degenerated bourgeois culture" and declared a definitive break with it. That year he suffered a heart attack from which he never fully recovered. In 1974, when the defence minister Beqir Balluku judged an American or Soviet invasion unlikely and criticised Hoxha's bunker programme, Hoxha branded him a Chinese agent and coup plotter and had him executed. The one-man concrete bunkers built across the country eventually numbered more than 173,000, in a nation of three million people.
The 1976 constitution renamed the country the People's Socialist Republic of Albania and, in Article 26, banned joint ventures with foreign capital and foreign credits. Hoxha said that taking credits and aid from bourgeois or revisionist states was the road of betrayal and capitalist restoration. After the 1978 break with China, Albania had no major ally and no major trading partner. In December 1981 Prime Minister Mehmet Shehu, Hoxha's comrade of forty years, was announced to have committed suicide and was posthumously denounced as an agent of several foreign intelligence services; whether he was killed in a power struggle or took his own life is still unclear. In 1983 four of his associates, including a former interior minister, were shot.
Estimates of the scale of repression vary. A tally cited in the Russian-language encyclopaedia puts political executions over Hoxha's forty years at 5,000 to 7,000, prison sentences at more than 34,000 (about 1,000 of whom died in custody) and internment or deportation at 50,000. Other estimates put the number killed at at least 5,000 and possibly as many as 25,000. Some 32,000 people are thought to have been imprisoned in 1985, in six institutions for political prisoners and fourteen labour camps. Relatives of the accused were punished as "enemies of the people", and escaping abroad was treason punishable by death.
The record also shows achievements. Electrification of the whole country was completed in October 1970, fifteen years ahead of plan; no cases of malaria were reported after 1965; and literacy became nearly universal by the 1980s. Women's share of employment rose from 4 percent in 1938 to 46 percent in 1982, and the population grew from about one million in 1944 to about three million in 1985. But the economy stagnated in the 1980s, and Albania was the poorest country in Europe for most of the Cold War. Hoxha died of heart disease on 11 April 1985 and was succeeded by Ramiz Alia; the government refused all foreign delegations at his funeral. Judgements remain divided since the system's fall: in a 2016 survey 45 percent of Albanians said he had a positive effect on their country and 42 percent a negative one, with older generations more favourable. His widow Nexhmije said that "unpleasant and unwelcome things did happen, but that did not come from above, let alone from Enver".