German-born American political thinker of The Origins of Totalitarianism, "the banality of evil" and the defence of councils
Born into a secular Jewish family in Linden near Hanover and raised in Königsberg, she studied with Heidegger at Marburg and took her doctorate under Jaspers at Heidelberg in 1928. Held by the Gestapo for eight days in 1933, she fled to Paris; in 1940 she got out of the Gurs internment camp and in 1941 reached New York. In The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951) she analysed Nazism and Stalinism together, in The Human Condition (1958) she criticised Marx's concept of labour, and in On Revolution (1963) she championed the councils. Her report on the Eichmann trial and its phrase "the banality of evil" set off a fierce controversy.
Also known as: Johanna Arendt
Activities and affiliations
-
1929–1975
Scholarship and theory
Career Timeline
- 1924Enters Marburg University; studies with Heidegger
- 1928Doctorate under Jaspers at Heidelberg
- 1929Marries Günther Stern (Anders)
- 1933.07Eight days in Gestapo custody; exile in Paris
- 1938.04Stripped of German citizenship
- 1940.01Marries Heinrich Blücher
- 1940.05Interned at Gurs; escapes about a month later
- 1941.05.22Arrives in New York
- 1951The Origins of Totalitarianism; US citizenship
- 1958The Human Condition
- 1961.04–06Covers the Eichmann trial for The New Yorker
- 1963Eichmann in Jerusalem; On Revolution
- 1963–1967Professor at the University of Chicago
- 1966.10"A Heroine of Revolution" on Rosa Luxemburg
- 1967–1975Professor at the New School Graduate Faculty
- 1968Edits Benjamin's Illuminations
Studies with Heidegger and Jaspers, Arrest and Exile
Arendt was born Johanna Arendt in 1906 into a secular Jewish family in Linden near Hanover, and before she was three her parents moved back to Königsberg, where she grew up. Her father, an engineer, died early, and her mother, a social democrat, gave her a liberal upbringing. In the last two years of the First World War her mother organised social democratic discussion groups and became a follower of Rosa Luxemburg, whose writings would later influence her daughter's political thinking. By fourteen Arendt had already read Kant's Critique of Pure Reason and Karl Jaspers' Psychology of Worldviews.
Entering Marburg University in 1924, she studied philosophy for a year with Martin Heidegger and Nicolai Hartmann and heard Rudolf Bultmann's theology lectures. Heidegger, a 35-year-old family man, and the 18-year-old student became lovers. He wanted the affair kept secret, and it remained unknown to the public until Elisabeth Young-Bruehl's biography of Arendt appeared in 1982. In early 1926, at Heidegger's urging, she spent a semester with Edmund Husserl in Freiburg and then went to Heidelberg, where in 1928 she took her doctorate under Jaspers with "Love and Saint Augustine". Her friendship with Jaspers lasted until his death. In these years, as she later wrote to him, the Zionist leader Kurt Blumenfeld gave her an understanding of the situation of the Jews.
In 1929 she married Günther Stern, whom she had known since Marburg; he later became known under the pen name Günther Anders, and he was a cousin of Walter Benjamin. Around this time Arendt turned towards politics, read Marx and Trotsky, and reviewed Karl Mannheim's Ideology and Utopia. When, shortly before the Nazis took power, Jaspers urged her in several letters to regard herself as a German, she always declined, pointing to her existence as a Jew. Germany, she replied, meant for her the mother tongue, philosophy and poetry.
In 1933, through Blumenfeld, she worked for the Zionist Federation of Germany documenting the persecution of Jews that had begun, and her Berlin flat became a way station for refugees. Her husband Anders fled to Paris in March. In July she was arrested and held by the Gestapo for eight days. In a 1964 interview with Günter Gaus she explained her motive: whoever is attacked as a Jew must defend himself as a Jew.
When Heidegger joined the Nazi Party, registered as of 1 May 1933, she broke off contact with him. After her release she left without papers by way of Karlsbad in Czechoslovakia, Genoa and Geneva for Paris, where she worked for Zionist organisations helping Jewish young people emigrate to Palestine. Her marriage to Anders ended in divorce in 1937.
In 1936 she met Heinrich Blücher in Paris. A self-taught Berliner from a working-class family, Blücher had joined the soldiers' councils in Berlin and the Spartacus League in November 1918 and became a member of the Communist Party of Germany in 1919. From 1928 he belonged to the "Conciliators" (Versöhnler), who rejected the theory of social fascism, and in November 1936 he was expelled from the party for "Trotskyist connections". The two belonged, with Walter Benjamin and others, to a circle of German refugees in Paris. In April 1938 Arendt was stripped of her German citizenship, and in January 1940 she married Blücher.
In early May 1940, when the French authorities ordered foreigners of German origin to report, Arendt was held with many other women for a week in the Vélodrome d'Hiver and then sent to the Gurs camp in southern France. After the Wehrmacht occupied Paris, the guards grew lax in the chaos, and after about a month she escaped from Gurs with a few others and found Blücher again in Montauban. In her essay "We Refugees" she remarked sarcastically that contemporary history had created a new kind of human being, "put in concentration camps by their foes and in internment camps by their friends". With affidavits from Anders and others and the help of Varian Fry in Marseille, the couple obtained American visas, sailed from Lisbon on 10 May 1941 and reached New York on 22 May.
When she visited Germany in 1949–1950 to recover Jewish cultural property, she met Jaspers and Heidegger again for the first time since 1933. Her relationship with Heidegger remained ambivalent. In a 1969 broadcast on Bavarian Radio for his eightieth birthday she honoured him, yet noted as striking and perhaps exasperating that Plato as well as Heidegger, when they entered into human affairs, had turned to tyrants and Führers.
Friendship with Benjamin, the Manuscript of "On the Concept of History" and Illuminations
In her Paris exile Arendt became a close friend of Walter Benjamin, then still largely unknown, and also helped him with money. Benjamin was a cousin of her first husband Anders, but their friendship flowered in Paris after she had separated from Anders. Blücher, too, was close to Benjamin in Paris and discussed the Moscow show trials with him.
In 1940, having fled to Marseille, Benjamin entrusted the German manuscript of his last text, "On the Concept of History", to Arendt. That September he died at Portbou on the Spanish border. Arendt took the manuscript to America and in 1941 in New York gave it to Theodor Adorno. The Institute for Social Research transcribed or photocopied it and returned it to her, and in 1942 it first printed the text in a mimeographed memorial volume of a very small run, Walter Benjamin zum Gedächtnis.
The question of the manuscript came back twenty-five years later. On 30 January 1967, preparing an American selection of Benjamin's writings, Arendt wrote to Adorno that the text printed in the 1942 memorial volume and in the 1955 Schriften differed in some not insignificant ways from the manuscript she held. Most variants could be explained as editorial interventions, but the seventh thesis contained a passage that was not in her manuscript, and she asked whether he had used another manuscript and whether it could be dated. Adorno replied that several copies had reached him from many places, that after more than twenty-five years he could no longer say which had served as the basis, and that the Institute had made no changes: where there were deviations, they were variants between versions. Arendt sent a photocopy of her manuscript for the Institute's archive. The six letters the two exchanged between January and May of that year give a vivid picture of the fight over who would edit and interpret Benjamin's literary estate.
Arendt had already tried in vain in 1945 to persuade Schocken Books to publish Benjamin. Only in 1968 did she bring out the English selection Illuminations, chosen by her and opened by her long introduction. Apart from "On the Concept of History" it concentrated on his literary criticism, and the introduction presented Benjamin as a "metaphorical" or "poetical" thinker, a "pearl diver" bringing back "thought fragments" from the depths of the past. Arendt also claimed that Benjamin's friendship with Brecht had endangered his relation to the Institute, and that fear of losing its support made him docile towards its editorial demands. Recent scholarship takes a more critical view of the Institute's handling of funds and support, partially corroborating her concerns. In the same essay she praised the friendship of Benjamin and Brecht as unique, a meeting of the greatest living German poet with the most important critic of the time; the essay was also included in Men in Dark Times (1968).
The dispute over Benjamin's estate and its interpretation, chiefly between Arendt on one side and Adorno and Scholem on the other, flared up in the late 1960s and again in the early 2020s, and it still shapes Benjamin's reception.
The Origins of Totalitarianism and the Unfinished Marx Study
In New York Arendt wrote a column from October 1941 for the German-Jewish paper Aufbau, arguing repeatedly for an independent Jewish army on the Allied side; she worked as an editor at Schocken Books until 1949 and as executive secretary of Jewish Cultural Reconstruction from 1949 to 1952. Until Blücher began teaching philosophy at a college in 1951, she supported the household almost alone.
Right after the war she began a comprehensive study of National Socialism, and in 1948–1949 she extended it to Stalinism. The Origins of Totalitarianism, published in the United States in March 1951, has three parts: "Antisemitism", "Imperialism" and "Totalitarianism". In 1955 she brought out a German version, revised by herself, as Elemente und Ursprünge totaler Herrschaft, and she went on revising and enlarging the book through the enlarged edition of 1958 and the edition of 1966. In 1951 she also became an American citizen and so ceased to be stateless. Having experienced statelessness as exclusion from human society, she called citizenship "the right to have rights".
The book's central thesis is that totalitarian movements can seize any worldview or ideology and, through terror, turn it into a new form of state. In her view only Nazism and Stalinism had fully realised this in history. She did not count Italian Fascism, Franco's regime or one-party dictatorships such as the GDR as totalitarian, nor the Soviet Union after Stalin's death. Totalitarianism differed from ordinary dictatorship in seizing every sphere of life, not only the political, in placing a mass movement at its centre, and in aiming at world domination. She saw Nazism, ending with Hitler's death, and the Soviet system from 1929 until Stalin's death in 1953 as "variations of the same model".
She divided Soviet history into periods. Until 1928 the Soviet Union was a "revolutionary one-party dictatorship", which Stalin then turned into "full totalitarian rule". Arendt sharply criticised Lenin's role in establishing the dictatorship and stripping the councils of power, yet she saw in his New Economic Policy, which offered a way out of hunger and misery, emancipated the peasants, strengthened the working class and was accompanied by a far-reaching nationalities policy, the beginning of a reconciliation between the people and its government. Before Stalin's seizure of power, there was still the alternative of continuing Lenin's NEP.
What bound the two regimes together was ideology. In the German edition she wrote: "One could say that it is the essence of ideology to make a premise out of an idea."
Man könnte sagen, daß es das Wesen der Ideologie ist, aus einer Idee eine Prämisse zu machen
Totalitarian rulers governed by direct command, not by changeable positive law, claiming to execute "the laws of nature or history". The Nazi belief in racial laws rested on the Darwinian idea of man as a chance product of natural development; the Bolsheviks relied on Marx's idea of a gigantic historical process racing towards its end. Arendt distinguished dialectical materialism, which rested on the best traditions, from vulgar racism, but held that both ideologies came down to eliminating the "harmful" or superfluous for the smooth running of a movement. Into the enlarged 1958 edition she put "Ideology and Terror", published separately in 1953, as chapter thirteen, and she added a closing chapter on the Hungarian Revolution of 1956, which was later published separately.
Arendt warned that anti-communism, as the "official counter-ideology" of the Cold War, also tended to develop an imperial and potentially total claim to world domination. The book became one of the earliest standard works on totalitarianism, and political scientists built on its descriptions theories of totalitarianism that went far beyond her strict definition. At the same time it has drawn lasting criticism for portraying Hitlerism and Stalinism as equally tyrannical.
In 1951, the year The Origins of Totalitarianism appeared, Arendt submitted a proposal for a new book to the John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation. She wrote there that the most serious gap in The Origins of Totalitarianism was the lack of an adequate historical and conceptual analysis of the ideological background of Bolshevism.
The book was first to be called "Totalitarian Elements in Marxism". But as she worked on it Arendt became convinced that the study could not be undertaken without examining the whole tradition of Western political philosophy: Marx stood firmly within that tradition, and with him it had come full circle, back to its origins. Her working title therefore became "Karl Marx and the Tradition of Western Political Thought". "Ideology and Terror" was also originally intended for this Marx book. The book was never finished; selections from the two manuscripts first appeared after her death, in the summer 2002 issue of Social Research. Meanwhile, in 1953, she published "Yesterday we were still Communists…" in Aufbau, distinguishing "former Communists", who had seen through the Moscow trials, the Hitler–Stalin Pact or the lack of inner-party democracy early and often withdrew into private life, from "ex-Communists", who turned their denunciations of communism into a springboard for new careers as experts of anti-communism and the Cold War.
The Human Condition on Marx, the Defence of Councils and Rosa Luxemburg
Much of the thinking from the Marx study flowed into The Human Condition (1958), which Arendt herself translated into German and published in 1960 as Vita activa. She divides the active life into labour, work and action. Labour is the activity that provides food and clothing for the survival of the individual and the species; its fruits are soon consumed and must be produced again, so it never ends. Work has a clear beginning and end and leaves behind durable things, such as tools or works of art, which make up the world people live in. Action takes place between people through words and deeds; it is the activity that founds and preserves political communities. In the Greek polis, labour belonged to the private realm of the household and action to the public realm of the agora. She held that finding the right word at the right moment is already action, and that only violence is mute, which is why sheer violence can never lay claim to greatness.
Her critique of Marx grows out of these distinctions. Ancient philosophers had ranked the contemplative life above the active one; Marx reversed the hierarchy, treating the contemplative life as a mere superstructure on the basic life processes of society. He defined man as animal laborans, a species set apart from the animals not by thinking but by labour. Yet Marx foresaw a day when production would allow the proletariat to throw off its shackles and be free from labour entirely. Arendt read this as a contradiction: by Marx's own lights, workers freed from labour would cease to be human. She worried instead that if automation abolished labour, freedom would lose its meaning without the contrast with necessity that labour provides. And as work turned into labour, even once durable things became consumer goods, so that chairs and tables are used up nearly as fast as clothes, and clothes nearly as fast as food.
Her struggle with Marx led on to her theory of revolution. Arendt saw the Hungarian uprising of 1956 as an attempt at a peaceful revolution containing the beginnings of a council system. On Revolution (1963) compares the French and American revolutions. In France, mass poverty, "the social question", entered the political stage, freedom was sacrificed to necessity, and the revolution ended in Robespierre's Terror. Calling Marx "the greatest pupil Hegel ever had" and "the greatest theorist of revolutions", she named his political interpretation of mass poverty his most effective and original achievement; but as a result, she argued, the aim of revolution became the overcoming of poverty and the production of goods rather than freedom from tyranny. In Lenin's formula "electrification and soviets" she saw both the technical solution to poverty (electrification) and the solution for freedom (the soviets), but Lenin, she wrote, gave power not to the councils but to the party.
The book's last chapter is about the council system. In Arendt's view councils arose spontaneously, without models, in almost every modern revolution. She saw in the 48 sections of the first Paris Commune of the French Revolution the first beginnings of a council republic, and noted that neither Marx nor Lenin had foreseen the councils of the "second" Paris Commune and the Russian Revolution. In the Russian February Revolution of 1917 and the Hungarian Revolution of 1956, councils of workers, soldiers, peasants, neighbourhoods, writers and artists, and students organised themselves within a very short time and linked up, building through regional and provincial councils a system from which deputies to a national assembly could be elected. Yet the parties, of every stripe, destroyed this system. In the German version she wrote: "No party … has ever doubted that it would not survive a real transformation of the state into a council system."
Keine Partei … hat je daran gezweifelt, dass sie eine wirkliche Verwandlung des Staates in ein Rätesystem nicht würde überleben können.
For Arendt the councils were political bodies in which every citizen could act freely, not administrative machines, and she put forward a federal council system built from the bottom up as a better form of freedom than representative parliamentary democracy. To show what one-party dictatorship leads to, she quoted at length the passage in Rosa Luxemburg's The Russian Revolution warning that life in the soviets themselves would wither under "the dictatorship of a handful of politicians". The council idea was one she shared with her husband Blücher, who as a Spartacist had taken part in the fighting of the German November Revolution and in building workers' and soldiers' councils, and who in Parisian exile argued for a "German soviet republic" and rejected the Communist Party's Popular Front line.
In October 1966 Arendt published "A Heroine of Revolution", a review of J. P. Nettl's two-volume biography of Luxemburg, in The New York Review of Books; it was included in Men in Dark Times in 1968. She held that Luxemburg had learned from the revolutionary workers' councils that "good organization does not precede action but is the product of it", and named her being "far more afraid of a deformed revolution than an unsuccessful one" as the major difference between her and the Bolsheviks. She then asked whether events had not proved Luxemburg right, and whether the history of the Soviet Union was not one long demonstration of the frightful danger of "deformed revolutions".
Arendt portrayed Luxemburg as an unorthodox, independently thinking Marxist who never belonged to the "believers" who treated politics as a substitute for religion.
The Eichmann Trial, the Banality of Evil and the Quarrel with Scholem
From April to June 1961 Arendt watched the trial of Adolf Eichmann in Jerusalem as a reporter for The New Yorker. Israeli intelligence had seized Eichmann in Argentina in 1960 and brought him to Jerusalem. Her articles became the book Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil, published in the United States in 1963 and soon afterwards in West Germany, with a revised and enlarged edition in 1964. The phrase in the subtitle, "the banality of evil", soon became proverbial.
In the introduction to the 1964 German edition Arendt explained that the phrase referred not to a theory but to a phenomenon she had met as a fact in the courtroom. Apart from an extraordinary eagerness to do whatever might advance his career, Eichmann had no motives at all; he was not stupid but "sheer thoughtless". That such remoteness from reality and such thoughtlessness could wreak more havoc than all the evil instincts inherent in man taken together was, she added, the lesson one could learn in Jerusalem. It was a lesson, she insisted, neither an explanation of the phenomenon nor a theory of it. In a 1969 letter to Mary McCarthy she wrote that "the banality of evil" stood in contrast to the "radical evil", after Kant, that she had used in The Origins of Totalitarianism. She also held "administrative mass murder" to be a more fitting term than "genocide", and spoke of crimes against humankind rather than crimes against humanity.
The book provoked fierce controversy. Many, Hans Jonas among them, attacked the use of the word "banality" for a mass murderer. Still stronger objections met her account of the Jewish councils (Judenräte). Arendt wrote that Eichmann had demanded "cooperation" from the Jews and obtained it to a truly astonishing degree, and that the members of the Jewish councils were given enormous power over life and death until they themselves were deported. Many Jewish organisations rejected this vehemently as a curtailed and unbalanced judgment. In a radio interview with Joachim Fest in 1964 Arendt said that the Jewish councils were "of course" victims and plainly stood on the other side.
Gershom Scholem, who had corresponded with her since 1939, sent her a sharp critique in June 1963, published soon afterwards together with her reply. Scholem missed a balanced judgment on the Jewish councils, protested that she blurred the line between victims and persecutors ("What perversity!"), and charged her with lacking love for the Jewish people (Ahavat Israel). After this exchange Scholem broke off relations with her.
In 1964 and 1965 Arendt gave a lecture several times in West Germany on "Personal Responsibility under Dictatorship", insisting that her book had been a "factual report" while her critics had argued about problems of "moral philosophy". She was appalled by the claim that "there is an Eichmann in each of us" and rejected the idea of collective guilt: human beings are free agents responsible for their deeds, and those who obeyed orders should be asked not "Why did you obey?" but "Why did you support?" She held that the trial had been conducted correctly and that Eichmann had rightly been executed. Her reflection on the attacks led to the 1964 essay "Truth and Politics", on the relation of rational truth and factual truth to politics.
Later research criticised Arendt from another side. Avner Werner Less, who had interrogated Eichmann for 275 hours, held that Arendt and many other observers had taken at face value the web of lies Eichmann spun to conceal his own role. Jacob Robinson objected as early as 1965 that she had ignored Eichmann's antisemitic worldview. The Sassen interviews, partly known at the time of the trial and used by the prosecution, and Bettina Stangneth's research based on them, also show Eichmann's fanatical antisemitism.