The Trotskyist theorist who defined the USSR as bureaucratic state capitalism and built Britain's Socialist Workers Party
The slogan the Cliff group raised in 1950, when a handful of supporters brought out Socialist Review: “Neither Washington nor Moscow but international socialism.” It was a refusal of both camps of the Cold War, and the sentence that defined this current for the next half century.
Born Yigael Glückstein to Polish-Jewish immigrants in Palestine, he left the Zionist left in his teens for Trotskyism, spent a year in a British Mandate prison for anti-war agitation, and moved to Britain in 1946. In The Nature of Stalinist Russia (1948) he defined the USSR as bureaucratic state capitalism, breaking with the Fourth International's view of it as a degenerated workers' state, and built on that analysis the theories of the permanent arms economy and of deflected permanent revolution. His Socialist Review Group (1950) became the International Socialists and, in 1977, Britain's Socialist Workers Party. He wrote a study of Rosa Luxemburg and four-volume biographies of Lenin and of Trotsky, and, never granted British citizenship, stayed stateless.
Also known as: Ygael Gluckstein · Yigael Glückstein
Activities and affiliations
-
1950–2000
Socialist Workers Party (Britain)Main
Social movements and organizing
Career Timeline
- 1917Born Yigael Glückstein at Zikhron Ya'akov in Ottoman Palestine, to Polish-Jewish immigrant parents
- late 1930sBecame a Trotskyist and an anti-Zionist; active in the small Palestinian Trotskyist movement
- 1931–1933Began in the youth section of Mapai, then Poale Zion, inside the Zionist left
- 1939Arrested by the British Mandate authorities and held twelve months in Acre prison
- 1945Married the South African socialist Chanie Rosenberg
- 1946Moved to Britain, was refused leave to remain, and worked in Dublin instead
- 1948Published The Nature of Stalinist Russia, defining the USSR as bureaucratic state capitalism
- 1950Founded the Socialist Review Group: neither Washington nor Moscow
- 1952Allowed back into Britain and settled in London
- 1959Published Rosa Luxemburg: A Study, first using the pen name Tony Cliff
- 1962–1963Renamed the group the International Socialists and formulated deflected permanent revolution
- 1975–1993Wrote his four-volume Lenin and four-volume Trotsky
- 1977Founded the Socialist Workers Party
- 2000.04.09Died in London after heart surgery, still a stateless person
The Nature of Stalinist Russia (1948): the break with the degenerated workers' state
In London Glückstein (Cliff), a supporter of the Revolutionary Communist Party (RCP) leadership around Jock Haston, joined the party's debate on the nature of the states dominated by Russia in Eastern Europe. Most Trotskyist groups then held that the Stalinist states, with their state planning and state ownership, were "degenerated workers' states" (the Soviet Union) or "deformed workers' states" (Eastern Europe), and Cliff became the main dissident from this consensus.
In the introduction to The Nature of Stalinist Russia, written in November 1947 and issued in 1948 ahead of the Fourth International's World Congress, he set out his starting point. The Fourth International had repeatedly said that the Stalinist bureaucracy could not stand the trial of an imperialist war or a proletarian revolution, yet the bureaucracy had come through the war, suppressed the revolutionary wave that followed through the Red Army and the "Communist" parties, and seen the rise of the "New Democracies". He argued that defining Russia as a degenerated workers' state was irreconcilable with fundamental elements of Marxism such as the self-mobilisation and self-conscious action of the masses, and contradicted the fundamentals of Trotskyism itself: permanent revolution, the Marxist theory of the state and the principles of October. Just as Lenin had discarded the slogan of "the democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and peasantry" after the February Revolution, renouncing this definition was now the prerequisite for rearming the Fourth International.
The core of the book is its analysis of the First Five-Year Plan as the turning point. For the first time, Cliff argued, the bureaucracy sought the rapid creation of a proletariat and the accumulation of capital, that is, to realise "the historical mission of the bourgeoisie" as quickly as possible. Rapid accumulation on a low level of production meant crushing mass consumption, and the bureaucracy, become a "personification of capital" for whom accumulation was everything, turned into a ruling class. The evidence was the change at that very moment in the relations of distribution, the legal rights of workers, forced labour, the peasants' relation to the means of production, the turnover tax and the structure of the army. He insisted that this theory of "state capitalism" owed nothing to Max Shachtman's "bureaucratic collectivism" or to Bruno Rizzi. The analysis became the theoretical basis of the Socialist Review Group founded in 1950.
On this state-capitalist analysis he built two further theories. In "Perspectives for the Permanent War Economy" (1957) he argued that Western and Soviet arms spending, by sustaining mass purchasing power, underpinned the postwar boom; the concept had first been put forward in 1945 by the American Trotskyist Ed Sard (pen name T. N. Vance). In "Deflected Permanent Revolution" (1963) he argued that where the proletariat could not take power, a section of the intelligentsia, neither bourgeoisie nor working class, could carry out the revolution in its place, and that the Marxism of leaders in China and Cuba was an ideology of power.
The International Socialists: Growth and Strategic Change
When the Korean War broke out in June 1950, The Club, Gerry Healy's British Fourth International group, gave uncritical support to North Korea. Cliff's supporters, who regarded the Soviet Union as state capitalist, took a "third camp" position supporting neither side. When Percy Downey of Birmingham put a resolution with that position to the Birmingham Trades Council, Healy called an emergency meeting, refused any political discussion, asked only whether Downey had broken discipline by moving it, and proposed his expulsion. When the vote was tied he suspended the branch, later brought in a loyalist to carry the expulsion, and expelled everyone who had voted with Downey as well. Cut off from The Club in this way, Cliff's supporters formed the Socialist Review Group (SRG). Its founding conference, held in London on 30 September and 1 October 1950, was attended by 21 of its 33 claimed members. The group was particularly exercised about the Korean War, and in 1951 it made "against both Moscow and Washington" its condition for unity with another Trotskyist group. Cliff's analysis of the Soviet Union as state capitalist provided the small group with its theoretical basis, and it sought to expand through work inside the Labour Party. It focused in particular on the Labour League of Youth (LLY), the party's youth organisation, and recruited a new generation of activists through nuclear disarmament campaigns and the Young Socialists. By 1964 the group had 200 members. This was a tactic for reaching workers and young people through activity inside the Labour Party.
In 1960, International Socialism began to replace Socialist Review, and the group adopted the name International Socialists (IS) in 1962. After Labour came to power, the IS withdrew from entryist work in the party around 1965 and shifted more of its effort toward trade unions and direct workers' organisations. A 1966 pamphlet by Cliff and Colin Barker opposed the Labour government's incomes policy and discussed how shop stewards could fight it. In 1968 the organisation adopted democratic centralism. Its involvement in the Vietnam Solidarity Campaign and the student protests of 1968 helped increase membership from 400 to 1,000, while the group also experienced splits.
From 1970 to 1974, the IS developed factory branches and rank-and-file newspapers and increased its industrial activity. During the 1972 miners' strike, miners took and sold copies of Socialist Worker. Membership rose from 1,000 in 1971 to about 4,000 in 1977. But the number of factory branches fell from 38 in 1974 to three or four by 1976, and the IS failed to organise significant solidarity during the 1977 firefighters' strike. Around 1978, Cliff concluded that the period of rising working-class militancy had ended and a downturn had begun. In January 1977, the IS had been renamed the Socialist Workers Party (SWP); by 1982 its leadership had abandoned the perspective of building rank-and-file organisations, refocusing on local branches and political propaganda.