八月宗派事件 · 1956.08.30–31

August Faction Incident

8월 종파 사건

The affair of 30–31 August 1956 in which cadres of the Yan'an faction and the Soviet Koreans tried, at a plenum of the Central Committee of the Workers' Party of Korea, to criticise Kim Il Sung's cult of personality and economic policy, failed, and were branded "anti-party factionalists" and purged. Yun Kong-hum's speech was cut short and he, So Hwi and others fled to China that night, while Ch'oe Ch'ang-ik and Pak Chang-ok lost their party posts. In September Anastas Mikoyan of the Soviet Union and Peng Dehuai of China came to Pyongyang and had the punishments reversed, but the purge soon resumed. It is counted as the turning point after which Kim Il Sung and his guerrilla faction ran the party alone. Jongpa ("faction") is a term of abuse for a party faction.

In depth

Background

When the Democratic People's Republic of Korea was founded in 1948, no single group controlled the leadership of the Workers' Party. The guerrilla faction that had fought with Kim Il Sung in Manchuria, the Soviet Koreans, the Yan'an faction from the Chinese communist areas and the domestic faction that had worked inside Korea shared the posts. In the course of the Korean War the core of the domestic faction, the former Workers' Party of South Korea, was purged, and Pak Hon-yong was sentenced to death in December 1955. Kim Mu-chong of the Yan'an faction and Ho Ka-i of the Soviet Koreans were also removed during the war. Post-war reconstruction was another source of conflict: Kim Il Sung put heavy industry first, while Yan'an and Soviet Korean cadres wanted light industry and living standards attended to first.

On top of this came the Twentieth Congress of the Soviet Communist Party in February 1956. Khrushchev's criticism of Stalin's cult of personality sent waves through every socialist country. Leonid Brezhnev, the Soviet delegate to the Third Congress of the Workers' Party of Korea in April, asked the party to follow the new line. From June to July Kim Il Sung toured the Soviet Union, Eastern Europe and Mongolia in search of aid, with results that fell short of his hopes.

Preparation

While Kim was away, Ch'oe Ch'ang-ik (vice-premier), Yun Kong-hum (minister of commerce), So Hwi (chairman of the General Federation of Trade Unions) and Ri Pil-gyu of the Yan'an faction, and Pak Chang-ok (vice-premier) and Kim Sung-hwa (minister of construction) of the Soviet Koreans, began to move. They meant to criticise Kim's personality cult, his cadre policy and the stress on heavy industry openly at a plenum and to establish collective leadership. Some claim they prepared an armed rising, but no confirmed evidence exists. Ch'oe Ch'ang-ik met the Soviet ambassador Ivanov on 8 June, and in late July Pak Chang-ok, Ch'oe and Kim Sung-hwa one after another told the Soviet embassy of their preparations. The plan was hardly concealed, and Kim's side knew of it; his supporters visited the embassy just as often. On 13 August the Soviet chargé d'affaires delivered a letter from the Central Committee of the Soviet Communist Party saying that inner-party democracy must not be used to spread distrust of the leadership. Kim had it circulated in the party and seized the initiative.

The August plenum

The plenum opened on 30 August. Yun Kong-hum, at the rostrum, raised the personality cult and other problems in the party and criticised Kim Il Sung, Kim Chang-man, Pak Kum-chol, Pak Chong-ae and others by name. He was shouted down, and the meeting voted to allow him no further speech. Going home during the recess, Yun, So Hwi and Ri Pil-gyu found their telephone lines cut; that night, with Kim Kang, vice-minister of culture, they drove across the Yalu bridge. The Chinese border post sent them on to Beijing, where Premier Zhou Enlai heard their report. The next day the plenum adopted a decision "on the factional and conspiratorial acts of comrades Ch'oe Ch'ang-ik, Yun Kong-hum, So Hwi, Ri Pil-gyu and Pak Chang-ok", expelling those who had fled and removing Ch'oe and Pak from their party posts.

Soviet and Chinese intervention

The news reached China through the refugees and the Soviet Union through a letter to Khrushchev from Ri Sang-jo, the ambassador in Moscow. The Eighth Congress of the Chinese Communist Party happened to meet in September, with a Soviet delegation present in Beijing. The two parties agreed to send a joint delegation, and Anastas Mikoyan, Soviet first deputy premier, and Peng Dehuai, China's minister of defence, came to Pyongyang. At a plenum convened again (the September plenum) Kim Il Sung admitted that the August decision had been hasty and withdrew the expulsions and dismissals. It was a rare case of the two socialist great powers jointly overturning another party's decisions about its own personnel.

The purge

When the crises in Poland and Hungary broke out in October and drew Soviet and Chinese attention to Europe, Kim Il Sung turned on the opposition again. An exchange of party cards served to screen members' views, and Kim Il Sung University, where intellectuals were concentrated, became a main target. Sixteen or seventeen cadres of bureau-chief rank and above fled to China, and Ri Sang-jo sought asylum in the Soviet Union. When the "Anti-Party Group" affair took place in the Soviet Union in 1957, Kim argued that the August affair had been of the same kind, and in September he had Ch'oe Ch'ang-ik and Pak Chang-ok imprisoned. By July 1958, 3,912 members had been expelled, most of them labelled supporters of Ch'oe. Kim Tu-bong, who had taken no direct part, was purged as well. In March 1958 a party conference declared factionalism liquidated, and the Fourth Congress in 1961 confirmed the victory of the guerrilla faction.

Name and assessment

"August Faction Incident" is the name given by the winners; the party's official account calls the critics "anti-party, counter-revolutionary factionalists". Some scholars therefore use the neutral name "August Plenum Incident". What the critics stood for was opposition to the personality cult, collective leadership and better living standards, which linked them to the demands raised that year in Poland and Hungary. But they were a minority in the Central Committee and leaned on Soviet and Chinese support. Through this affair Kim Il Sung removed every rival group, and the experience of interference by foreign parties later became a ground for his stress on "Juche" and an independent line.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (KO)
  2. ja.wikipedia.org
  3. encykorea.aks.ac.kr
  4. encykorea.aks.ac.kr