Epistemology of the Closet · 1990–present

Epistemology of the Closet

벽장의 인식론

A 1990 book by the American literary theorist Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, and the concept it put forward. Sedgwick argued that a chronic crisis of male homo/heterosexual definition dating from the late nineteenth century has structured many of the major nodes of twentieth-century Western thought and culture, and that an understanding of modern Western culture that does not analyse this definition critically is not merely incomplete but damaged at its core. In the book "the closet" is not only the place where sexual minorities hide their orientation but a structure of the "open secret" that governs who knows, and who pretends not to know, what. With Judith Butler's Gender Trouble it is counted among the founding texts of queer theory.

In depth

Why does the one who doesn't know win?

The American president Ronald Reagan meets the French president François Mitterrand. Mitterrand knows English; Reagan does not know French. One might expect the one who knows more to have the advantage, but it is the other way round. In the introduction to Epistemology of the Closet Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick put the scene like this:

If M. Mitterrand knows English but Mr. Reagan lacks — as he did lack — French, it is the urbane M. Mitterrand who must negotiate in an acquired tongue, the ignorant Mr. Reagan who may dilate in his native one.

With this anecdote Sedgwick showed that ignorance can be not merely a lack of knowledge but a way of exercising power. She gave other examples. In rape cases it matters not at all what the raped woman perceives or wants so long as the man can claim not to have noticed, an ignorance in which male sexuality receives careful education. In the AIDS years employers who fired people with HIV could win in court precisely by showing ignorance of the medical facts of transmission. Rereading the introduction in 2020, the British gender scholar Clare Hemmings noted that all three examples show ignorance working not only as a mechanism of homophobia but as the way homophobia structures other social contexts.

What did Sedgwick argue?

The book was published by the University of California Press in 1990. Part of it was written as early as 1983–84, most of it in the mid- and late-1980s, in the midst of the AIDS crisis, during what Sedgwick called an "open season on gay men" in public discourse. It consists of an introduction, "Axiomatic," and five chapters.

At the outset Sedgwick wrote that many of the major nodes of thought and knowledge in twentieth-century Western culture have been structured, indeed fractured, by a chronic, now endemic crisis of homo/heterosexual definition, indicatively male, dating from the end of the nineteenth century. On the same page she argues that

an understanding of virtually any aspect of Western culture must be, not merely incomplete, but damaged in its central substance to the degree that it does not incorporate a critical analysis of modern homo/heterosexual definition.

This definition, she wrote, intersects every issue of power and gender and transforms the other languages and relations by which we know. She focused on the late-nineteenth-century moment when sexual orientation became as important a definer of personal identity as gender had been for centuries. According to the art historian Whitney Davis, Sedgwick largely took over Michel Foucault's perspective on the period from about 1890 to 1990, in which homosexuality came to be conceived as a human "species," a way of being a person, though she added critical remarks on that framing.

The American critic Douglas Crimp, in a blurb for the publisher, called the book "a theory of the closet": by showing that the closet is no place but a structural relation, in our culture the primary structural relation of knowledge/ignorance, Sedgwick had sharpened the edge of Foucault's work on sexuality and power.

Why is the closet an "open secret"?

Sedgwick called the homosexual closet "the defining structure for gay oppression in this century." The closet, or the "open secret," she argued, has been basic to lesbian/gay life for the last century, even after Stonewall in 1969; this regime, with its contradictory and constraining rules about privacy and disclosure, public and private, knowledge and ignorance, has shaped how many questions of value and epistemology were understood in modern Western society as a whole.

Nor is coming out done once and for all. Because of the elasticity of heterosexist presumption, Sedgwick wrote, every encounter with a new class of students, a new boss, social worker, loan officer, landlord or doctor erects new closets, demanding new calculations of secrecy or disclosure. What is in the closet is something everyone dimly knows but no one says, so who knows and who pretends not to know becomes a question of power.

What were Sedgwick's axioms?

As the title "Axiomatic" suggests, Sedgwick set out seven axioms as starting points:

  1. People are different from each other.
  2. The study of sexuality is not coextensive with the study of gender; correspondingly, antihomophobic inquiry is not coextensive with feminist inquiry. But we can't know in advance how they will be different.
  3. There can't be an a priori decision about how far it will make sense to conceptualize lesbian and gay male identities together. Or separately.
  4. The immemorial debates on nature versus nurture take place against a very unstable background of tacit assumptions and fantasies about both nature and nurture.
  5. The historical search for a Great Paradigm Shift may obscure the present conditions of sexual identity.
  6. The relation of gay studies to debates on the literary canon is, and had best be, tortuous.
  7. The paths of allo-identification are likely to be strange and recalcitrant. So are the paths of auto-identification.

Under the first axiom she listed commonsense knowledge of sexual difference that people accept in practice: that even identical genital acts mean very different things to different people, that many people have their richest mental and emotional involvement with sexual acts they don't do, or don't even want to do. She also valued the "nonce taxonomies" produced by gossip and other undervalued knowledges, which Hemmings described as survival knowledge about whom to trust and how to read and navigate a social landscape.

Why is the definition of homosexuality "incoherent"?

Sedgwick held that the modern definition of homosexuality contains two pairs of contradictory views at once. The first concerns sexual definition. A "minoritizing" view holds that there is a distinct population of persons who really are gay, whom alone the matter concerns; a "universalizing" view holds that homosexuality matters to people across the spectrum of sexualities and that sexual desire is an unpredictably powerful solvent of stable identities. The second concerns gender. A "transitive" view sees homosexuality as a liminal zone between the sexes, as in "a woman's soul trapped in a man's body"; a "gender-separatist" view holds that it is most natural for people of the same gender to bond together.

Sedgwick did not try to resolve the contradiction by declaring one side right. There were, she said, no epistemological grounds for adjudicating between them; what matters is to study how the incoherence itself works. Davis stressed her point that the "versus" organising each pair is itself misleading: what is real is a complex cycling of reciprocities between the supposed poles. The distinctions became basic vocabulary of queer theory.

Which other binaries does the definition split?

Sedgwick held that the homo/heterosexual binary is even more contagious than other hierarchical binaries and fractures many cultural systems. The Mexican reviewer Adriana González Mateos listed among her pairs national/foreign, revolutionary/reactionary, kitsch/art, urban/provincial, natural/unnatural/artificial, sincerity/sentimentality, health/pathology, wholeness/decadence and abstraction/figuration. The French publisher presented the book as treating the binaries of contemporary epistemology, from knowledge/ignorance to private/public and health/illness. The pair kitsch/art recalls Clement Greenberg's 1939 essay "Avant-Garde and Kitsch," which set avant-garde art against kitsch.

Which works did Sedgwick read?

The five chapters read literature of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Chapter 1 shares the book's title. Chapter 2, "Some Binarisms (I)," treats Herman Melville's Billy Budd: Sedgwick read the relations among Billy, Claggart and Captain Vere as representations of male homosexual desire and the mechanisms prohibiting it. She took Claggart's "natural depravity," defined tautologically as "depravity according to nature," and the accumulation of equivocal terms ("phenomenal," "mystery") explaining his character as marks of his status as the text's central homosexual figure, and read the mutiny scare aboard the ship as a portrayal of homophobia.

Chapter 3, "Some Binarisms (II)," reads Oscar Wilde and Friedrich Nietzsche together through "the sentimental relations of the male body"; Wilde's The Picture of Dorian Gray is among the works discussed. Chapter 4, "The Beast in the Closet," reads Henry James's 1903 novella "The Beast in the Jungle" as a writing of "homosexual panic." Its protagonist, John Marcher, believes his life is to be defined by some catastrophic or spectacular event lying in wait for him like a beast in the jungle, and ignores the love of May Bartram, the woman who knows his secret. "Homosexual panic" was a term coined in 1920 by the American psychiatrist Edward J. Kempf. Chapter 5, "Proust and the Spectacle of the Closet," treats Marcel Proust's In Search of Lost Time. Maxime Cervulle, prefacing the French translation, called the project a set of "perverse readings" of the Western canon that track down sexual disturbance and definitional crisis in modern masterpieces.

How was the book received?

The book was soon counted a classic of queer theory and, with Judith Butler's Gender Trouble, one of its founding texts. In Between Men (1985) Sedgwick had analysed "homosocial" male bonding accompanied by fear or hatred of homosexuality; Epistemology of the Closet carried that work forward. The Nation called it "a remarkable work of mind and spirit." An edition with a new preface appeared in 2008, and the book has been translated into Portuguese, Bulgarian, French and other languages; there is no Korean translation yet.

There were criticisms too. The 1990 Publishers Weekly review found her thesis that the homo/hetero distinction, together with gender, class and race, determines "all modern Western identity and social organization" overstated and unproven, and her prose obtuse and cumbersome. Geographers asked how useful "the closet" is in national contexts where the homo/hetero binary is not the primary way of understanding sexuality. Hemmings saw a "defensive white reading mode" in a long footnote that merely lists women-of-colour theorists and directs readers to white theorists' overviews.

Sedgwick herself later looked back on the reading practices of this period. In "Paranoid Reading and Reparative Reading" (1997) she reexamined her own writing of the 1980s and that of other critics, asking how paranoia passed from being an object of antihomophobic theory to its uniquely sanctioned method, and wrote that the link between queer thought and paranoia might be less necessary than earlier writing, "very much including my own," had assumed. That reflection on exposure-oriented reading is treated under "Paranoid Reading and Reparative Reading."

Related people

Sources

  1. post45.org
  2. evekosofskysedgwick.net
  3. representations.org
  4. debatefeminista.cieg.unam.mx
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. evekosofskysedgwick.net
  7. publishersweekly.com
  8. periodicos.sbu.unicamp.br
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. gaynewsingreek.blogspot.com
  11. fr.wikipedia.org
  12. Wikipedia (EN)
  13. Wikipedia (EN)
  14. aladin.co.kr
  15. Wikipedia (EN)
  16. Wikipedia (EN)
  17. Wikipedia (EN)
  18. evekosofskysedgwick.net
  19. aladin.co.kr
  20. archive.org