Harich affair
하리히 사건
The 1957 show trials in which the Socialist Unity Party leadership, treating as treason a 1956 discussion among East German intellectuals about reforming Stalinism and reuniting Germany, punished those involved in two public proceedings. The central evidence was the "Platform" written by the philosopher Wolfgang Harich, who was sentenced to ten years in prison; the publisher Walter Janka received five. The East German Supreme Court reversed the verdicts in 1990.
In depth
What question did the affair pose?
Suppose colleagues at dinner agree that the company's head has to go, and one of them writes the idea down and hands it to the head's superior. Is that offering an opinion, or a plot? In East Germany in 1956 exactly this question came to court. How far could communists debate among themselves how to fix the political system, and who decided where that line ran?
The affair is tied up with philosophy too. Its central figure, Wolfgang Harich, was a professor of philosophy and editor-in-chief of the Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie. Those caught with him were intellectuals influenced by Ernst Bloch and Georg Lukács. The very idea that Marxism could be rescued from Stalinism came to court.
What did Harich and his colleagues want?
After Khrushchev's secret speech of February 1956, hopes of a thaw spread into East Germany too. On the initiative of Bloch, Harich and Klaus, a philosophical conference on the problem of freedom met at the Academy from 8 to 10 March, and at its party conference that March the Socialist Unity Party itself spoke of similar lessons. As in Poland and Hungary, informal discussion groups formed. In Leipzig there was a circle around Bloch; in Berlin the "Circle of the Like-Minded" (Kreis der Gleichgesinnten) gathered around Walter Janka, head of the Aufbau publishing house, and Gustav Just of the weekly Sonntag.
Harich, reckoned the ablest writer among them, summed up their discussions as the "Platform for the Special German Road to Socialism". Its demands: remove Ulbricht as head of party and state; guarantee free elections, freedom of opinion and the rule of law; win full sovereignty for East Germany and the withdrawal of Soviet troops; reform the economy to give producers more responsibility; bring the Socialist Unity Party and the West German Social Democrats closer, so that Germany might reunite as a neutral, demilitarized state of socialist character.
The Platform did not present itself as anti-communist. Its authors identified themselves as party functionaries and wrote: "We do not want to break with Marxism-Leninism, but we want to free it from Stalinism and dogmatism."
Wir wollen nicht mit dem Marxismus-Leninismus brechen; aber wir wollen ihn vom Stalinismus und vom Dogmatismus befreien
How did it come to arrests and a trial?
The Platform was meant for discussion in the party's theoretical journal Einheit. But Harich handed a copy to the Soviet ambassador Georgi Pushkin, expecting Soviet backing against "the Stalinist" Ulbricht; Pushkin told Ulbricht. Ulbricht summoned Harich on 7 November and warned him. Without his comrades' knowledge, Harich also contacted Rudolf Augstein of Der Spiegel and the Social Democrats' Eastern Bureau.
At just that moment Soviet troops crushed the Hungarian uprising. On 27 November 1956, five days after the second Soviet entry into Budapest and the arrest of Nagy, the Politburo resolved to arrest Harich. On 29 November Harich, the economist Bernhard Steinberger and the journalist Manfred Hertwig were arrested; a week later Janka followed. Meeting from 18 to 20 December, the Politburo instructed the Stasi to speed up the trial and judged the group's activity to be "treason against the state". In effect the verdict came before the hearing.
The trial ran from 7 to 9 March 1957 at the Supreme Court, led by Prosecutor General Ernst Melsheimer. The writers Anna Seghers and Willi Bredel and the actress Helene Weigel sat among the spectators. On the second day Just, Sonntag's editor Heinz Zöger and the radio commentator Richard Wolf, called as witnesses, were arrested in the courtroom. A second trial, with Janka as main defendant, followed from 23 to 26 July.
The sentences: Harich ten years, Janka five, Just and Steinberger four each, Wolf three, Zöger two and a half, Hertwig two. The charge was forming a conspiratorial group hostile to the state.
Why did Harich and Janka behave so differently in court?
This is the longest-disputed scene of the affair. In court Harich called the Platform a liquidationist programme that would in the end have restored capitalism in East Germany. In his final statement he went further: "It is clear to me that the Stasi is to be thanked, that it has protected our state from greater harm."
Mir ist es klar, dass der Staatssicherheit zu danken ist, dass sie also unseren Staat vor größerem Schaden bewahrt hat
At Janka's trial he appeared as the main prosecution witness and gave heavily incriminating evidence.
Janka did the opposite. He refused to the end the claim that he had come to hate and betray the workers' and peasants' power, and said he would rather be torn to pieces than make concessions to capitalism.
Judgements differ, for they contain a judgement of what Harich was. Karl Wilhelm Fricke holds that Harich underwent something like brainwashing at the hands of Stasi interrogators, yet calls his statements against colleagues a less than glorious role. Other accounts place his conduct under the threat of a death sentence. After seeing his Stasi files, Fritz Raddatz called him a "traitor". When Janka's memoir Difficulties with the Truth (1989) brought the trial back into public memory, Harich answered in 1993 with No Difficulties with the Truth, redescribing events as a "national-communist opposition". The two men never reconciled.
What should we say was on trial?
The East German leadership's account at the time was clear. In a radio interview before the trial, Erich Mielke said investigation had proved treason and links to the Social Democrats' Eastern Bureau, an agent centre financed by the intelligence services of capitalist states. On the front line of the Cold War, demanding Soviet withdrawal and reunification and making contact with people in the West was a security matter from the regime's point of view. What had just happened in Hungary was a warning to the leadership too.
Later studies based on the opened records mostly see it differently. According to Fricke there was neither conspiracy nor a plan to overthrow the state; the trial was a "ritual" that merely gave legal form to the Politburo's conclusion, and what Ulbricht wanted was an example. Just himself recalled that "ideas became plans, plans became intentions, intentions became measures."
Die Sache wurde einfach hochgeschaukelt. Aus Ideen wurden Pläne, aus Plänen wurden Absichten
Yet Fricke names one exception. The contacts with the Soviet ambassador, the Eastern Bureau and Der Spiegel, made without his comrades' knowledge, were Harich's alone, and in the regime's eyes they were serious. Whether the Platform was a workable project at all is another question. Fricke saw something closer to an abstract war game, and the label "national communist" follows the project to this day.
Where did it lead?
The affair ended a period of East German philosophy. The editorial board of the Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie was dissolved without comment, and Bloch was forced into retirement at Leipzig in 1957. In the party, Karl Schirdewan and others who had opposed Ulbricht were driven out, while Kurt Hager, Johannes Becher and others survived by public self-criticism.
Harich was freed by amnesty at the end of 1964. Janka was released early in December 1960 after international protests. On 5 January 1990 the East German Supreme Court rehabilitated the defendants, at a time when East Germany itself was disappearing. A West German study of 1977 traced the line of intellectual opposition in East Germany through the names of Bloch, Harich and Robert Havemann together.