Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism
제국주의론
A Marxist political-economic work written by Lenin in Zurich in 1916, arguing that capitalism had transitioned into imperialism, its monopoly stage. It formalized five defining features of imperialism (monopolies, finance capital, capital export, international cartels, and the territorial division of the world) while refuting Karl Kautsky's theory of 'ultra-imperialism' and defining imperialism as 'the highest stage of capitalism' and 'the eve of socialist revolution.' It analyzed the World War as an imperialist war and provided the theoretical foundation for the revolutionary defeatist line.
Primary text
- Предисловие
- Предисловие к французскому и немецкому изданиям
- I. Концентрация производства и монополии
- II. Банки и их новая роль
- III. Финансовый капитал и финансовая олигархия
- IV. Вывоз капитала
- V. Раздел мира между союзами капиталистов
- VI. Раздел мира между великими державами
- VII. Империализм, как особая стадия капитализма
- VIII. Паразитизм и загнивание капитализма
- IX. Критика империализма
- X. Историческое место империализма
- 주석
In depth
Why did Lenin set out to redefine imperialism in 1916?
Lenin did not coin the word "imperialism". From the late nineteenth century British and German newspapers used it for the policy of great powers that expanded their colonies. What makes his book stand out is the new meaning it gave to a familiar word: imperialism is not a foreign policy that some government chooses, but the shape the whole economic system takes once capitalism reaches a certain stage of development.
Why this argument was needed becomes clear from when the book was written. When the First World War broke out in August 1914, most socialist parties of the Second International, in Germany, France and elsewhere, backed their own governments' war. To Lenin this was a betrayal of socialism, and to explain it he first had to explain where the war came from. If the war was the wrong choice of a few politicians, appeals for peace would be enough; if it came from the structure of capitalism itself, the war could not be ended without fighting capitalism.
Lenin wrote the book in Zurich, in Swiss exile, between January and June 1916. The immediate occasion was a commission from Parus, the publishing house Maxim Gorky had set up in Petrograd, and the manuscript had to pass the tsarist censor. In the 1917 preface Lenin admitted that he had to confine himself strictly to economic analysis and voice his few political remarks by hints, in "that cursed Aesopian language". Where he criticised annexations he used Japan instead of Russia as his example, adding that the attentive reader would easily put Russia in place of Japan, and Finland, Poland, Ukraine and the other non-Russian lands of the Russian Empire in place of Korea.
The book came out in Petrograd in mid-1917 from the Zhizn i Znaniye publishers under the title Imperialism, the Newest Stage of Capitalism, with part of the criticism of Kautsky cut by the publisher. In 1920 Lenin added a new preface to the French and German editions that spelled out the political conclusions the censor had kept him from stating. This dictionary has a complete translation from the Russian among its reference documents, so this entry does not retell the chapters; it covers where the book's argument came from, what it argued against, and how it has been read since.
What was different about Lenin's imperialism?
In chapter VII Lenin wrote that if imperialism had to be defined as briefly as possible, one would say that "imperialism is the monopoly stage of capitalism". Its core is the change of free competition into monopoly. Free competition lets big firms drive out small ones, and when production and capital are concentrated in a few hands monopolies arise: cartels, syndicates and trusts. Free competition gives birth to its own opposite. Lenin divided the process into three periods: the 1860s and 1870s as the peak of free competition, the spread of cartels after the crisis of 1873, and the boom of the late nineteenth century and the crisis of 1900-1903, after which cartels became one of the foundations of all economic life.
Since a short definition is not enough, he named five basic features. First, the concentration of production and capital has created monopolies that play a decisive role in economic life. Second, bank capital has merged with industrial capital into "finance capital", on which a financial oligarchy rests. Third, the export of capital, as distinct from the export of commodities, acquires exceptional importance. Fourth, international monopolist combines of capitalists share the world among themselves. Fifth, the territorial division of the whole world among the biggest capitalist powers is complete.
The fifth feature is the key to his theory of war. While there was still unclaimed land, each power could expand into empty space. Once the division is complete, a country that wants more can only take someone else's share. Lenin added that countries grow at uneven speeds. Germany, insignificant beside the Britain of half a century earlier, had grown strong enough to threaten Britain; the balance of strength keeps shifting while the shares already divided stay fixed. Under capitalism, he concluded, the only way to resolve that mismatch is redivision by war.
The political meaning follows at once. If imperialism is a stage of the economic system, opposing the war means opposing capitalism. The revolutionary defeatism Lenin argued for while writing the book, the line that socialists should not fear the defeat of their own government and should turn the imperialist war into a civil war, was the political translation of this analysis.
What did it share with Hobson, Hilferding, Bukharin and Luxemburg, and where did it differ?
In the introduction Lenin named two earlier studies: Imperialism (1902) by the English economist J. A. Hobson and Finance Capital (1910) by the Austrian Marxist Rudolf Hilferding. The usual judgement is that the five-feature definition came from Hilferding with elements added from Hobson. Lenin praised both but drew a line: Hobson stood on the ground of "bourgeois social reformism and pacifism", and Hilferding had erred on the theory of money and leaned towards reconciling Marxism with opportunism.
Other Marxists were theorising imperialism at the same time. Nikolai Bukharin wrote Imperialism and World Economy in 1915-1916, and Lenin read the manuscript and wrote a preface for it. Rosa Luxemburg argued in The Accumulation of Capital (1913) that capitalism could not go on with expanded reproduction without drawing in non-capitalist regions. Lenin thought her theory mistaken and prepared a critique but never published it, and he did not debate her separately in Imperialism.
| Author | Main work | What imperialism was | Relation to Lenin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hobson | Imperialism (1902) | Surplus capital going abroad because home consumption is too low; a disease reform can cure | Facts and description praised, reformist conclusion rejected |
| Hilferding | Finance Capital (1910) | The policy of finance capital, the fusion of bank and industrial capital | Concept of finance capital taken over, opportunist leanings criticised |
| Bukharin | Imperialism and World Economy (1915) | The clash between the internationalisation of production and the concentration of capital within states | Lenin wrote a preface to the manuscript; both opposed Kautsky |
| Luxemburg | The Accumulation of Capital (1913) | A system that survives only by consuming non-capitalist regions | Lenin thought the theory wrong but did not debate it in this book |
| Lenin | Imperialism (1916) | A stage of capitalist development, the monopoly stage |
Lenin's book became the most widely read theory of imperialism less because it was the most original than because it tied the earlier studies together into the concept of a historical stage and connected that to the conclusions of revolutionary politics. Where earlier writers treated imperialism as the policy of particular states, Lenin treated all imperialist policies as features of one stage.
What was the quarrel with Kautsky's "ultra-imperialism"?
The book's sharpest opponent was Karl Kautsky, considered the leading Marxist theorist of the Second International era. The difference starts with the definition. Kautsky saw imperialism as the drive of industrial nations to annex agrarian regions, a particular policy that finance capital "prefers". A policy can be swapped for another policy. Lenin objected that this definition severs politics from economics: it implies that non-monopolist, non-violent politics is possible on top of an economy ruled by monopoly. Even Hobson, he added, had grasped better than Kautsky that several empires compete with one another and that finance dominates commerce.
In an article in Die Neue Zeit in September 1914 Kautsky went a step further. Just as firms form cartels to limit competition, the great powers might form a cartel of states, end the arms race and exploit the world jointly; such "ultra-imperialism" was, he said, not impossible from a purely economic point of view. The idea was not Kautsky's alone. Hobson had spoken in 1902 of an "inter-imperialism" based on a combination of great powers, and Karl Liebknecht had mentioned in 1907 the possibility that colonial rivalry might be settled the way trusts settle competition.
Lenin answered on two levels. In the abstract, development does tend towards a single world trust, but saying so is as empty as saying that food will one day be produced in laboratories. In the concrete reality of the early twentieth century finance capital increases rather than reduces the unevenness between countries. Alliances between the powers, whatever their form, are therefore only "breathing spells" between wars: peaceful alliances prepare wars and in their turn grow out of wars. The quarrel was more than a dispute between doctrines because of its political conclusion. If one believed in ultra-imperialism, the labour movement would become a reform movement asking for peace within capitalism and could reunite with the social chauvinists who had backed the war. That reunification was exactly what Lenin wanted to prevent.
The debate has not ended. Some Marxists saw the cooperation of Western capitalist states under the United States during the Cold War, without war among them, as Kautsky's forecast come true; their opponents reply that rivalry between the powers grew again after the Cold War. Commentators have also compared Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri's theory of "Empire" with Kautsky's, a comparison the authors reject.
What were the theses on parasitism and the labour aristocracy meant to explain?
In chapter VIII Lenin named parasitism as another face of imperialism. A rentier layer living on interest and dividends from capital invested abroad grows, and a few rich countries become "rentier states" that plunder the world by "clipping coupons" rather than by production. He cited figures showing that Britain's income from abroad was five times its income from foreign trade.
This analysis leads to an explanation of the betrayal of 1914. In the 1920 preface Lenin stated the conclusion he had had to hide from the censor. The superprofits monopolists draw from other countries go beyond what they squeeze out of workers at home, and part of them can be used to bribe labour leaders and the upper layer of workers. This "labour aristocracy", bourgeois in its way of life, its earnings and its outlook, was the mainstay of the Second International and the social root of opportunism within the labour movement. The socialist parties' support for their governments' war then appears not as the defection of individuals but as the product of objective conditions.
Where, then, would revolution begin? In the 1917 preface Lenin wrote that "imperialism is the eve of the socialist revolution", and in chapter X he characterised imperialism as capitalism in transition, more precisely "moribund capitalism". The 1920 preface pointed to the more than a thousand million people of the colonies and semi-colonies as the weak link of the imperialist system. This idea underlay the Comintern line that made the national liberation movements of the colonies one pillar of world revolution.
How was the book read and criticised afterwards?
In Soviet political economy the book was treated as a fundamental work that continued Marx's Capital for a new era, and its theory of uneven development was also used to argue that revolution could win first in a single country. As a side effect, some historians judge that once Lenin's book became orthodoxy the Marxist theory of imperialism stood noticeably still until the 1940s.
Its influence spread far beyond the communist parties. Kwame Nkrumah, the first president of Ghana, picked up Lenin's book directly in Neo-Colonialism, the Last Stage of Imperialism (1965), analysing economic domination that outlives political independence. Paul Baran and Paul Sweezy's theory of monopoly capital, and dependency and world-systems theory with their question of the relation between core and periphery, found a starting point in the division between core and periphery that Lenin had sketched.
The criticism is substantial too. The British economist Anthony Brewer points out that the book, a "popular outline" by Lenin's own subtitle, has been treated as a "sacred text", and that some of its arguments, such as the claim that industry needs capital export to survive, are less developed than in the work of his contemporaries. Contrary to the diagnosis of "moribund capitalism", capitalism survived the whole twentieth century, and current research mostly either criticises the book or treats it as a starting point for further analysis.
Even so, the question it posed, whether war and domination between states can be explained by the structure of the world economy rather than by the choices of individual politicians, remains at the centre of the debate on imperialism. Kautsky's forecast of an age of cooperation and Lenin's of recurring rivalry and redivision face each other again over the world after the Cold War.
Related people
Related historical events
Sources
- Wikipedia (EN) Summary of the work: ten-chapter structure, five features of imperialism, critique of Kautsky and ultra-imperialism, publication history
- Wikipedia (RU) Russian Wikipedia: original title, writing history in Zurich (Jan–June 1916), influences from Hobson and Hilferding, relationship to Bukharin's work, publication through Gorky's Parus
- Wikipedia (KO) Korean Wikipedia: confirms Korean title 제국주의론, original Russian title, the work's role as a foundational Marxist-Leninist text
- Marxists Internet Archive Marxists Internet Archive: full text in English, preface to French and German editions, ten-chapter structure, Lenin's Notebooks on Imperialism comprising ~800 pages of preparatory materials from 148 books and 232 articles
- Wikipedia (KO)
- ru.wikisource.org Lenin, Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism (PSS 5th ed., vol. 27): 1917 preface (Zurich spring 1916, tsarist censor, Aesopian language, Japan/Korea standing for Russia/Finland etc., eve of socialist revolution), introduction (Hobson 1902, Hilferding 1910), ch. VII (shortest definition, five features, Kautsky's definition and ultra-imperialism), ch. VIII (parasitism, rentier state), ch. IX (inter-imperialist alliances as truces), ch. X (transitional, moribund capitalism), 1920 preface (superprofits, labour aristocracy)
- Wikipedia (EN) Kautsky's ultra-imperialism (Die Neue Zeit, September 1914), earlier ideas of Hobson (1902) and Karl Liebknecht (1907), Lenin's preface to Bukharin, later debates on Cold War inter-capitalist cooperation
- Wikipedia (EN) Hobson's underconsumption theory, Hilferding, Bukharin, Luxemburg, Lenin's five features, Brewer on the "sacred text", Baran and Sweezy, dependency and world-systems theory, Hardt and Negri compared with Kautsky