Iskra
이스크라
The all-Russian underground newspaper of the RSDLP. Founded abroad in December 1900 on Lenin's initiative, it was run by a six-member board (Lenin, Plekhanov, Martov, Akselrod, Zasulich, Potresov) with Krupskaya as editorial secretary managing the network inside Russia. Carrying the epigraph 'From a spark a flame will flare up' and distributed through smuggling routes, its agent network became the backbone of party-building: the national newspaper as 'collective propagandist, agitator and organizer' that Lenin theorized in What Is to Be Done? was Iskra itself. After the split at the Second Congress in 1903 Lenin resigned from the board, dividing the 'old Iskra' (through issue 51) from the Menshevik-led 'new Iskra' that ran until 1905.
In depth
Why was Iskra made outside Russia?
Iskra (Искра, "The Spark") was the underground newspaper of the Russian Social Democrats, published from December 1900 to October 1905. A newspaper usually means something that reports the news, but for the people who made Iskra it was a tool for building a party that did not yet properly exist. To see why such a paper was needed, start with the state of the Russian socialist movement around 1900.
In 1898 the First Congress of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party met in Minsk and proclaimed the party, but the central bodies it set up were soon broken by the police and never rebuilt. In Lenin's words there was in fact no united party: unity was "still only an idea". Workers' circles and local committees in each town worked separately, each putting out its own leaflets and small papers, and each collapsed at the next wave of arrests. The movement was also divided over its line. Economism, which wanted to concentrate on the workers' struggle over wages and hours and leave the political fight against the tsarist autocracy to the liberals, was gaining ground in many local organisations.
When his Siberian exile ended in early 1900, Lenin began to carry out a plan to change this. A regular revolutionary paper could not be published inside Russia, so it would be printed abroad and smuggled in. In February 1900 Lenin negotiated with Vera Zasulich, who had come illegally to St. Petersburg, about the participation of Plekhanov's Emancipation of Labour group. At the Pskov conference in April he discussed the draft editorial declaration of the newspaper Iskra and the theoretical magazine Zarya ("Dawn") with Martov, Potresov and S. I. Radchenko, and with Struve and Tugan-Baranovsky, then "legal Marxists". In August, in Switzerland, he and Potresov negotiated with the Emancipation of Labour group over the editorial board, contributors and place of publication.
The "Declaration of the Editorial Board of Iskra", which Lenin wrote in September 1900, set out the paper's character: "Before we can unite, and in order that we may unite, we must first of all draw firm and definite lines of demarcation." The paper would not be a storehouse of various views but would stand for a definite tendency, Marxism, rejecting the "corrections" made fashionable by Bernstein and Struve. Even so, it promised space for open polemics between comrades, and it offered its columns not only to socialists and workers but to everyone oppressed by the political system, to expose the abominations of the autocracy.
The epigraph on the masthead, "From a spark a flame will flare up", is a line from Alexander Odoevsky's reply to the poem Pushkin sent to the Decembrists exiled in Siberia. It claimed the legacy of the revolutionaries who had risen against the autocracy in 1825 and been crushed.
How could a newspaper become the skeleton of a party?
In "Where to Begin?", published in Iskra No. 4 in May 1901, Lenin summed up the paper's role: "A newspaper is not only a collective propagandist and a collective agitator, it is also a collective organiser." He likened it to the scaffolding round a building under construction, which marks the contours of the structure and lets the builders communicate, divide the work and see the common results of their labour. The mere task of supplying the paper with copy and distributing it regularly would require a network of agents who kept in touch with one another and knew the general state of affairs, and that network would form the skeleton of an organisation embracing the whole country.
The editorial board had six members: the veterans of the Emancipation of Labour group, Plekhanov, Akselrod and Zasulich, and the younger generation, Lenin, Martov and Potresov. The paper moved wherever Lenin lived. The first issue was printed in Leipzig in December 1900, and the following ones in Munich. In April 1902 the editors moved to London, where the British Social Democrat Harry Quelch arranged the printing and the paper was made in a small office on Clerkenwell Green. In the spring of 1903 they moved again, to Geneva, where living was cheaper and contact with Russia easier. Iskra appeared monthly at first and fortnightly from 1902, in runs of about 8,000 copies. Trotsky later recalled that "the political leader of the Iskra was Lenin. Martov was the literary power."
The editorial secretary was at first I. G. Smidovich-Leman; from the spring of 1901 the post passed to Nadezhda Krupskaya, who handled all the correspondence with the organisations in Russia. The letters were written in code. According to Krupskaya's memoirs, "handkerchiefs" meant passports, "beer" or "warm fur" illegal literature, and towns were called by personal names beginning with the same letter (Osip for Odessa, Pasha for Pskov). Krupskaya herself later found these secrecy methods remarkably naive.
Inside Russia the paper had its agents: the Krzhizhanovskys and Lenin's sister Maria Ulyanova in Samara, Lydia Knipovich in Astrakhan, Lepeshinsky in Pskov, Nikolai Bauman in Moscow working closely with Ivan Babushkin, Yelena Stasova linked with the St. Petersburg organisation, and travelling agents such as Ivan Radchenko and Silvin who carried the paper all over the country. They received and distributed the paper, sent in local reports and won local committees over to the Iskra line. Lenin read every letter that came in, and the editors knew in detail what each agent was doing.
Getting the paper into Russia was dangerous and wasteful. The 3,000 copies of the first issue were seized at the border. Routes through Vilna and Stockholm, through cooks on ships sailing from Marseilles to Batum, through Alexandria and Persia, and through Kamenets-Podolsk and Lvov were tried one after another. On the Batum route the parcels were wrapped in tarpaulin and dropped overboard at an agreed spot, where comrades fished them out. Literature was also hidden in double-bottomed trunks and in bookbindings. Krupskaya reckoned that probably not more than a tenth of what was sent ever reached its destination. The "beer" shipped to Stockholm was believed to have reached St. Petersburg; only in 1905, returning to Russia through Sweden, did they find it still stacked in a cellar of the Stockholm People's House.
Secret presses inside Russia that reprinted the paper therefore mattered a great deal. Presses in Kishinev and Uman, and the "Nina" press in Baku, managed by Leonid Krasin with the Yenukidze brothers working in it, printed Iskra. Money came from supporters' donations; the Moscow industrialist Savva Morozov is named among those who financed the paper. Agents were often arrested. In the summer of 1902 a group of Iskra workers held in Kiev prison, among them Bauman, Litvinov and Blumenfeld, tied up the guard during exercise, climbed the wall with ropes and made their way to London.
Whom did Iskra fight, and over what?
Iskra's main opponent was Economism. The Economists held that the movement had to start from the demands workers felt directly in the factory, and that the political struggle against the tsarist government could wait or be left to the liberals. The Union of Russian Social-Democrats Abroad with its organ Rabocheye Delo ("The Workers' Cause"), and the St. Petersburg paper Rabochaya Mysl ("Workers' Thought"), represented this trend. Iskra replied that a labour movement confined to economic demands could overcome neither the autocracy nor capitalism, and it put the struggle for political freedom at the front together with the cause of socialist revolution. An attempt to merge with the Union Abroad at Zurich in June 1901 failed.
Lenin's What Is to Be Done?, published early in 1902, gathered this polemic into one book. Reissuing it in 1907, he wrote that "What Is to Be Done? is a summary of Iskra tactics and Iskra organisational policy in 1901 and 1902. Precisely a 'summary', no more and no less." Its central argument, that the spontaneous labour movement by itself stays at trade-union consciousness and that an organisation of professional revolutionaries is needed to lead a nationwide political struggle, was first worked out in the paper's columns. Lenin took up organisation again in "A Letter to a Comrade" (1902). According to Krupskaya, it helped break down the Economist structure that split local organisations into a workers' committee for the economic struggle and an intellectuals' committee for "high policy", and drew workers into deciding the party's policy.
Economism was not Iskra's only target. It also attacked the Socialist Revolutionaries, who made individual terror a revolutionary tactic, and the liberals who sought a deal with the autocracy. The southern Yuzhny Rabochy ("Southern Worker") group, while seeking closer ties with Iskra, objected to the sharp tone of its polemics with the liberals. The editors also drafted a party programme, published in Iskra No. 21. In drafting it Lenin and Plekhanov clashed so sharply that they nearly broke, but in the end they merged their work into a single draft.
The result showed in the balance of local organisations. In the winter of 1902-03 there were fierce struggles between tendencies in the committees, and the Iskra supporters steadily won ground. By the time an organising committee had been formed and the Second Congress met in 1903, most Social Democratic organisations in Russia accepted Iskra as their leading organ, and the congress formally adopted it as the central organ of the party.
How did the old Iskra and the new Iskra come apart?
At the Second Congress in the summer of 1903 the Iskra camp itself split in two. The course of the congress is told in detail in the event "The Second Congress of the RSDLP and the Bolshevik–Menshevik Split"; here only what happened to the paper is summarised. The congress reduced the six-member board to three, Lenin, Plekhanov and Martov, and Martov refused to sit on a board without the old editors. Issues 46 to 51 were therefore edited by Lenin and Plekhanov alone.
After the congress the minority (the Mensheviks) refused to cooperate with the party bodies and demanded that the old board be restored. When Plekhanov decided to bring the old editors back for the sake of party peace, Lenin left the board on 19 October (1 November, new style) 1903. Plekhanov edited No. 52 alone, opening it with his conciliatory article "What Should Not Be Done". On 13 (26) November he co-opted Akselrod, Zasulich, Martov and Potresov back onto the board, and the party's central organ passed into the minority's hands. From then on the Bolsheviks called the issues up to No. 51 the "old Iskra" and those from No. 52 on the "new Iskra".
The new Iskra became the platform for a frontal attack on Lenin's ideas of organisation. In articles including one in No. 57, Akselrod argued that from the start the Russian movement had harboured two opposite trends, the proletarian aim and the influence of a radical intelligentsia alien to the workers, and likened Lenin's centralism to Jacobinism. In 1904 Plekhanov, too, declared that he differed from Lenin in principle on spontaneity and consciousness. Lenin replied in One Step Forward, Two Steps Back (1904), one section of which he titled "The New Iskra. Opportunism in Questions of Organisation". When the Russo-Japanese War broke out in 1904, the paper called for using the war to hasten the collapse of the regime. That autumn the editors sent party organisations a plan for workers' demonstrations before the meetings of zemstvo (local self-government) liberals; Lenin, who saw the plan as bound by fear of alarming the liberals, attacked it in the pamphlet "The Zemstvo Campaign and Iskra's Plan". From then on the two factions differed not only on organisation but on revolutionary tactics.
In December 1904 the Bolsheviks founded their own paper, Vpered ("Forward"), in Geneva, and in the spring of 1905 the two factions held a separate congress and conference. The new Iskra ceased with No. 112 in October 1905.
How has Iskra been judged, and how did its name live on?
Judgements differ sharply depending on who is speaking and which Iskra is meant. Lenin and the official Soviet party histories treat the old Iskra as the starting point of Bolshevism. In 1907 Lenin wrote that "Iskra fought for an organisation of professional revolutionaries", that it vanquished Economism, created that organisation in 1903 and preserved it through the split and the upheavals of the revolution. To the charge that Iskra had exaggerated the idea of an organisation of professional revolutionaries, he answered that this was like reproaching the Japanese, after the Russo-Japanese War, for having exaggerated the strength of Russia's armed forces beforehand. In the same text he admitted that the controversies of that time were heated, at times bitter and destructive quarrels among circles abroad, and added that the circles had been necessary under the autocracy and had played their part, but were now obsolete. The Short Course of 1938 wrote that Lenin's Iskra prepared the ideological and organisational consolidation of the party, and labelled the new Iskra an opportunist Menshevik organ.
The classic critical judgement is Trotsky's Our Political Tasks (1904). Trotsky had sided with the minority at the congress but drifted away from the Menshevik leaders in the spring of 1904 and formally left the minority that September. In the book he wrote that the two Iskras were "separated by an abyss". He granted that the mission of the old Iskra, to win the democratic intelligentsia over to the working class with incisive Marxism, had been effectively carried out. But he warned that if the methods hardened in that period, committees thinking and deciding in place of the working class, were carried on, they would lead to "the Party organisation 'substituting' itself for the Party, the Central Committee substituting itself for the Party organisation, and finally the dictator substituting himself for the Central Committee". This critique of "substitutionism" was later often quoted in interpretations of the Soviet system. Trotsky himself joined the Bolsheviks in 1917, and in his 1930 autobiography My Life he changed his verdict, holding that Lenin had been right to judge the older editors incapable of directly leading the militant organisation in the coming revolution.
The name lived on. From September to December 1917 the Menshevik-Internationalists published an organ under the same title until the Bolshevik government closed it. Communists in other countries also took "The Spark" as a title: the Romanian Communist Party's Scînteia ("The Spark") was named in homage to Iskra, founded underground in 1931 and published until 1989. In the Soviet Union Iskra was commemorated with postage stamps and monuments, streets in many cities were named after it, and films such as the Soviet-Bulgarian The First Courier (1968), about smuggling the first issues into Russia, were made.
Related terms
Related people
Related historical events
Sources
- Wikipedia (RU) founding, editorial board, smuggling network, old/new Iskra split
- Wikipedia (EN) English overview, 1900 Leipzig founding, 1903 split
- Marxists Internet Archive What Is to Be Done?: the newspaper as collective organizer
- Wikipedia (RU) Pskov conference, Munich/London/Geneva, 3,000 copies of No. 1 seized at the border, circulation about 8,000, Plekhanov co-opting the old editors, No. 56 on the war, last issue No. 112 (October 1905), Menshevik-Internationalist Iskra of 1917, Uman/Kishinev/Baku presses, memorials and films
- Wikipedia (EN) Leipzig first issue, London office at 37a Clerkenwell Green arranged by Harry Quelch, Odoevsky epigraph, polemics against Economists and Socialist Revolutionaries, Savva Morozov among its financiers
- Marxists Internet Archive Lenin, Declaration of the Editorial Board of Iskra (September 1900): lines of demarcation, a definite Marxist tendency, open polemics, columns open to all oppressed by the autocracy
- Marxists Internet Archive Lenin, Where to Begin? (Iskra No. 4, May 1901): newspaper as collective propagandist, agitator and organiser, scaffolding, network of agents; editors' note on the founding, the six editors, Krupskaya as secretary from spring 1901, Nos. 46-51, Lenin leaving on 19 October (1 November) 1903, No. 52, co-optation on 13 (26) November
- Marxists Internet Archive Krupskaya, Reminiscences of Lenin, London 1902-1903: code words, Iskra agents in Russia, the Nina press in Baku, smuggling routes and losses, Stockholm "beer", Kiev prison escape, Letter to a Comrade, Yuzhny Rabochy
- Marxists Internet Archive Lenin, Preface to the Collection Twelve Years (1907): no united party after 1898, failed Zurich merger of June 1901, What Is to Be Done? as a summary of Iskra tactics, the Japanese analogy, circle spirit, Zemstvo campaign plan
- Marxists Internet Archive Lenin, One Step Forward, Two Steps Back, section Q "The New Iskra. Opportunism in Questions of Organisation": Axelrod in Iskra No. 57 on two opposite trends and Jacobinism
- Marxists Internet Archive Plekhanov, Collected Works vol. 13: "What Should Not Be Done" opening the new Iskra, his conciliatory position after Lenin left
- Marxists Internet Archive Trotsky, Our Political Tasks (1904), ch. 2: two Iskras separated by an abyss, the old Iskra's mission among the intelligentsia
- Marxists Internet Archive Trotsky, Our Political Tasks (1904), ch. 3: substitutionism, the organisation substituting itself for the party up to a dictator
- Marxists Internet Archive Trotsky, My Life, ch. 12: Lenin the political leader and Martov the literary power of Iskra, move to Geneva, Lenin's judgement of the older editors
- Marxists Internet Archive Trotsky, My Life, ch. 13: inactive in the minority from April 1904, renounced it in September 1904
- Marxists Internet Archive Short Course (1938), ch. 2: Lenin's Iskra prepared the ideological and organisational consolidation of the party; draft programme disputes with Plekhanov; old and new Iskra
- Wikipedia (EN) Romanian Scînteia ("The Spark"), named in homage to Iskra; Odessa 1919, Romanian Communist Party organ 1931-1989
- Wikipedia (RU)