«Кузница» · 1920–1931

Kuznitsa

쿠즈니차

Kuznitsa ("The Smithy") was a group of proletarian writers formed in 1920 by worker poets who had left the Moscow Proletkult. In October that year it convened the First All-Russian Congress of Proletarian Writers, which founded the All-Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (VAPP), and its poetry of labour, machines and world revolution on a cosmic scale typified proletarian verse of the Civil War years. It lost the lead when its best-known poets, disappointed by the NEP, left the party and the group, and when the October group split off in December 1922. Revived in 1928 as an all-Union society that competed with the Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (RAPP), it split in two in 1930, and both halves joined RAPP.

In depth

Why did the worker poets leave Proletkult?

In the years right after the revolution an enthusiasm spread across Russia that workers could, and should, write poetry. The organisation that channelled it was Proletkult, the proletarian culture organisation. Factory workers gathered in literary circles to learn to write, and some of them quickly became well-known poets. But Proletkult was above all a school for teaching the masses, and its frame was too narrow for poets who had already found their own voice. Kuznitsa was the group in which such "graduated" worker poets came together as professional writers.

According to the Soviet Literary Encyclopedia of 1931, they left the Moscow Proletkult in 1920, set up a section for proletarian literature in the Literary Department of the People's Commissariat for Education opened that year, and began to publish the journal Kuznitsa, whose name passed to the circle. Russian Wikipedia dates their departure from Proletkult to January 1920, the founding of the journal to May and the choice of the group's name to December. The first members included Vasily Aleksandrovsky, Sergei Obradovich, Mikhail Gerasimov, Grigory Sannikov, Vasily Kazin, Nikolai Poletaev and Semyon Rodov, and Vladimir Kirillov from the Petrograd Proletkult soon joined them.

What did Kuznitsa achieve?

The young group quickly moved to the centre of the proletarian literary movement. In May 1920 it gathered some 150 people at the first conference of proletarian writers, and on its initiative the First All-Russian Congress of Proletarian Writers met on 18–21 October 1920 and founded the All-Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (VAPP). More than half of the association's board elected by the congress were Kuznitsa members, and its first chairman was Kirillov. This VAPP was the root of the Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (RAPP) that later dominated Soviet letters.

The Kuznitsa poets' verse is regarded as typical of proletarian poetry in the Civil War. The Literary Encyclopedia summed it up as a passion for the collapse of the old world, internationalism and collectivism, a cult of labour and industry, and revolutionary romanticism. The Great Russian Encyclopedia explains that their poetry celebrated the creative might of the collective and the person confidently cutting a path into the future, was strong in planetary and cosmic motifs of labour changing the face of the earth and the universe, and used rich metaphor and allegory. The same encyclopedia notes that, unlike the theorists of Proletkult, Kuznitsa defended freedom of artistic search, stressed the importance of "form" and literary craft, and put its hopes on the professional writer.

What did the 1923 declaration proclaim?

Kuznitsa's ideas appear most sharply in a declaration printed in Pravda in 1923. It insisted that artistic style comes from class: "Style is class."

Стиль — это класс.

Writers formed before the revolution, it argued, had neither the worldview nor the technique to handle the material that the October Revolution had turned up. Symbolism, futurism and imaginism were all dismissed as littermates raised by the capitalist order. The declaration called the artist the medium of his class and set out the task: "Our aim and task is to grasp and bring out the image of the builder of communist society."

Наша цель и задача — осознать и выявить образ строителя коммунистического общества.

It also showed its attitude to the New Economic Policy. The declaration said literature under the NEP was surrounded by "art resembling the tricks of gorillas", and it dismissed the work of the Serapion Brothers, then active in Petrograd, as "smut thinly covered with revolutionary phrases". At the same time it called itself "the only association standing wholly on the programme of the revolutionary vanguard of the working class and the RKP" and a "shock detachment" of the ideological and artistic front.

Объединение рабочих писателей «Кузница» — есть единственное объединение, стоящее всецело на программе революционного авангарда рабочего класса и РКП.

The declaration is signed by the chairman Ivan Filipchenko, the deputy chairman Nikolai Lyashko, the secretary Sannikov and others.

Why did the NEP shake the group?

When the New Economic Policy of 1921 brought back markets and private trade, many of the poets who had sung of world revolution took it as a retreat of the revolution. The Literary Encyclopedia wrote that Kuznitsa's biggest poets, Kirillov and Gerasimov, "did not accept" the NEP and left the party, and that in the poetry of Sannikov and Obradovich too the NEP appeared as the death of the revolution. Russian Wikipedia sums up that the Kuznitsa writers declared the NEP a betrayal of the principles of world revolution. Gerasimov's biography says he left the party in 1921, and Kirillov's says that, after a deep crisis in the early and mid-1920s, he left Kuznitsa (1924), VAPP and the party. The overview of the group records the two leaving together in November 1923.

Sources put the stress differently on Kuznitsa's relation to the party. Russian Wikipedia writes that they did not recognise the party's leadership of cultural development. The Literary Encyclopedia of 1931 diagnosed a tendency, already visible in Kuznitsa, to break away from the everyday political practice of the proletariat and its party, linked to the never fully overcome influence of Alexander Bogdanov. Bogdanov was the Proletkult theorist who held that proletarian culture should grow by itself, independently of the party and the state. The 1923 declaration, by contrast, called the group, as seen above, an organisation standing wholly on the programme of the Russian Communist Party.

The conflict spread to questions of organisation. According to the Literary Encyclopedia, Kuznitsa held that only fully mature writers should be admitted to proletarian writers' organisations, which clashed with those who wanted to take in young people just starting to write in factory literary circles. In December 1922 Semyon Rodov, A. Dorogoichenko and Semyon Malashkin left Kuznitsa to found the October group, which soon pushed Kuznitsa out of the front rank of the proletarian literary movement.

From alliance with Voronsky to war with RAPP

After the poets left, the centre of Kuznitsa moved to its prose writers. Around 1923 G. Yakubovsky became chairman of the board, and writers such as Fyodor Gladkov, Vladimir Bakhmetyev, Nikolai Lyashko and Aleksei Novikov-Priboi joined the leadership. Gladkov's novel Cement appeared in Krasnaya Nov, nos. 1–6 of 1925, in this period.

To stand up to the October group and the VAPP it had taken over, Kuznitsa joined hands with an unexpected partner. In autumn 1924 Kuznitsa and Pereval, the group led by Alexander Voronsky, held a joint conference against the Moscow Association of Proletarian Writers (MAPP). At the Central Committee press department meeting of 9 May 1924, Voronsky, answering the attacks of Na postu, said he spoke for the literature that worked "in Krasnaya Nov, in Krug, in Kuznitsa, in the young people's circle Pereval". But at the All-Union Conference of Proletarian Writers at the start of 1925 Kuznitsa abruptly took MAPP's side.

In May 1928 Kuznitsa united its regional groups in an all-Union society with individual membership, the All-Union Society of Proletarian Writers "Kuznitsa" (VOPP), and the same month it entered the All-Union Federation of Associations of Proletarian Writers (VOAPP), created by the First All-Union Congress of Proletarian Writers, as an independent member alongside the republican associations. It was an attempt to become a mass organisation able to rival RAPP. Its first all-Union conference in April 1930 adopted a new declaration that defined the style of proletarian art as "the realism of proletarian struggle". But Kuznitsa lost the fight with RAPP that ran through 1929. In December 1929 its central council announced that it was ready to give in on conditions, and while those conditions were being discussed in October–November 1930 the group split into a Moscow central group led by Bakhmetyev and a "New Kuznitsa" led by Ivan Zhiga. Both halves applied to join RAPP and were admitted after a preliminary purge. The Literary Encyclopedia of 1931 wrote that Kuznitsa groups then remained as creative groups inside the local associations of proletarian writers, and the Great Russian Encyclopedia records that Kuznitsa merged into RAPP in 1931. RAPP itself was dissolved by the resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organisations" of 23 April 1932.

How is Kuznitsa judged?

The Literary Encyclopedia of 1931 called Kuznitsa "a true concentrate of the best forces of proletarian poetry" but held that its verse stayed in the abstract, symbolist style of the Civil War and could not keep up with the new tasks after the NEP. It explained Kuznitsa's failure to become a mass organisation by the fact that writers of different creative methods and class character had gathered in it only out of opposition to RAPP. This verdict is close to the viewpoint of RAPP, which absorbed Kuznitsa.

Later scholarship looks at other sides. The Great Russian Encyclopedia, as seen above, stresses that Kuznitsa, unlike Proletkult, valued form and craft, and Russian Wikipedia sums up the central motif of Kuznitsa lyric poetry as the idealisation of labour and the proletariat, metal and machines. The group's path was the first chapter of the fight within the proletarian literary movement over who represented the literature of the working class. The October group took over the VAPP that Kuznitsa had founded, and that VAPP, become RAPP, swallowed Kuznitsa.

Gerasimov and Kirillov met a tragic end. Gerasimov was arrested in May 1937 and shot. His rehabilitation certificate stated that he died in custody in 1939, and many encyclopedias follow that year, but according to the recollections of Kirillov's widow the two friends were shot on the same day, 16 July 1937. Kirillov was arrested in Penza on 30 January 1937 and sentenced on 15 July; another record has him dying in 1943.

Related people

Sources

  1. feb-web.ru
  2. web.archive.org
  3. Wikipedia (RU)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. web.archive.org
  6. Wikipedia (RU)
  7. Wikipedia (RU)
  8. Wikipedia (RU)
  9. Wikipedia (RU)
  10. Wikipedia (RU)