Materialism (philosophy)
유물론
The philosophical position that the basis of the world is matter, and that mind and consciousness arise from or depend on matter. It is not the everyday "materialism" of craving money and goods. It runs from ancient atomism through eighteenth-century French materialism and Feuerbach to the dialectical materialism of Marx and Engels.
In depth
What question does materialism answer?
Under anaesthesia consciousness vanishes, and on waking it returns. A brain injury can change a person's character. Are my thoughts and feelings then the doing of a soul apart from the body, or the activity of the matter that is my body? Were there mountains and seas before people appeared on earth? Materialism answers that matter comes first. The world exists in its own right whether or not anyone thinks about it, and thinking beings arose at the end of the long development of the material world.
The word must not be confused with its everyday sense. The greed for money that people call "materialism" has nothing to do with the philosophical position. In philosophy materialism and idealism simply name answers to the question of which comes first, the question Engels called the basic question of philosophy in Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy: "Depending on whether this question was answered one way or the other, the philosophers split into two great camps."
Je nachdem diese Frage so oder so beantwortet wurde, spalteten sich die Philosophen in zwei große Lager.
How did ancient materialism explain the world?
In the fifth century BC the Greeks Leucippus and Democritus held that nature consists of two things, atoms and void. If tiny indivisible grains collide and gather to form all things, the world can be explained without calling on the will of the gods. Epicurus took over the idea and put it plainly: "The whole consists of bodies and void."
τὸ πᾶν ἐστι σώματα καὶ κενόν
He allowed atoms to swerve slightly from their paths, leaving room for freedom. The Roman poet Lucretius set this philosophy out in the long poem On the Nature of Things. The young Marx wrote his doctoral dissertation on the difference between the natural philosophies of Democritus and Epicurus. Lenin called the fight running through the history of philosophy "the tendencies or lines of Plato and Democritus".
Тенденций или линий Платона и Демокрита в философии?
Why was modern materialism revolutionary?
In The Holy Family Marx sketched the lineage of modern materialism: "The real progenitor of English materialism and all modern experimental science is Bacon."
Der wahre Stammvater des englischen Materialismus und aller modernen experimentierenden Wissenschaft ist Baco.
With Hobbes matters changed. In Marx's words materialism became "one-sided" and turned into the geometer's abstraction. Locke prepared the road of empiricism, which crossed to France and passed to Condillac and Helvétius. A second strand came from Descartes's physics. Descartes divided mind from matter, but in his physics matter was the sole ground of being and of knowing, and Marx named this as the source of French mechanical materialism.
In eighteenth-century France materialism became a weapon against the Church and absolute monarchy. In Man a Machine (1747) La Mettrie argued that people, like other animals, have no separate soul. In the dialogue around D'Alembert's Dream Diderot likened people to pianos endowed with sensation and memory: our senses are the keys, and the surrounding world strikes them. Lenin quoted the passage at length as a model of materialism against Berkeley. In The System of Nature (1770) d'Holbach built atheist materialism into a system: "There is not and cannot be anything outside the enclosure that holds all beings."
Il n’est & il ne peut rien y avoir hors de l’enceinte qui renferme tous les êtres.
Marx held that this materialism's teaching that people are products of experience, habit, education and surroundings is necessarily connected with communism and socialism. If a person forms all knowledge and feeling from the world of the senses, the task is to arrange that world so that he experiences in it what is truly human.
Wenn der Mensch aus der Sinnenwelt und der Erfahrung in der Sinnenwelt alle Kenntnis, Empfindung etc. sich bildet, so kommt es also darauf an, die empirische Welt so einzurichten, daß er das wahrhaft Menschliche in ihr erfährt
How does Marxist materialism differ from the old materialism?
Marx named the old materialism's weakness at the opening of the Theses on Feuerbach. It saw the world only as an object to be looked at and not as human activity. It was idealism that developed the active side: "Hence the active side was developed abstractly, in opposition to materialism, by idealism, which of course does not know real, sensuous activity as such."
Daher die tätige Seite abstrakt im Gegensatz zu dem Materialismus vom dem Idealismus - der natürlich die wirkliche, sinnliche Tätigkeit als solche nicht kennt - entwickelt.
In Ludwig Feuerbach Engels named the limits of eighteenth-century materialism concretely. The first was mechanism: "The materialism of the last century was predominantly mechanical, because of all the natural sciences only mechanics had by then reached any completion."
Der Materialismus des vorigen Jahrhunderts war vorwiegend mechanisch, weil von allen Naturwissenschaften damals nur die Mechanik
Chemistry and biology were still in their infancy, so people too were explained like clockwork. The second was the failure to grasp the world as a process forming itself historically. With no geology or evolutionary theory yet, nature seemed to circle eternally on the same track, and Engels adds that this was unavoidable at the time. He also distinguished all this from the shallow, vulgarised materialism that Büchner, Vogt and Moleschott preached around the country in the 1850s. He went on to say that materialism too had to change its form with every epoch-making discovery in natural science, and held that Feuerbach, a materialist about nature, remained an idealist about people's social relations. Dialectical and historical materialism try to fill this gap. They grasp the world as moving and developing, and consciousness as arising in social labour. So Engels says the unity of the world cannot be secured by declaration: "The real unity of the world consists in its materiality, and this is proved not by a few juggler's phrases but by a long and protracted development of philosophy and natural science."
Die wirkliche Einheit der Welt besteht in ihrer Materialität, und diese ist bewiesen nicht durch ein paar Taschenspielerphrasen, sondern durch eine lange und langwierige Entwicklung der Philosophie und der Naturwissenschaft.
What is matter? Does materialism fall when physics changes?
When the electron and radioactivity were discovered in the early twentieth century, people said that the atom could be split and so "matter had vanished". In Materialism and Empirio-criticism Lenin answered by separating physical theories of matter from the philosophical concept: "Matter is a philosophical category designating the objective reality which is given to man in his sensations, and which is copied, photographed and reflected by our sensations, while existing independently of them."
Материя есть философская категория для обозначения объективной реальности, которая дана человеку в ощущениях его, которая копируется, фотографируется, отображается нашими ощущениями, существуя независимо от них.
Whether matter is made of atoms or of fields, the only condition materialism sets is that it lies outside consciousness. Lenin's definition offers matter as a category of the theory of knowledge, defined through its relation to consciousness. Section 2 of chapter 4 of Stalin's Short Course stated the doctrine as a few theses, the primacy of matter and the knowability of the world among them, and these became the frame of Soviet textbooks, within which Soviet philosophers such as Ilyenkov asked anew about consciousness and activity.
What does materialism look like today?
In contemporary Anglo-American philosophy the name "physicalism" is more common: the position that everything that exists is ultimately physical, including not only matter but spacetime, energy and forces. Neuroscience of consciousness and the debate over artificial intelligence have become testing grounds for it. In the Marxist tradition, however, materialism does not end with claims about brains and atoms. It seeks to explain as a material process the activity in which people produce and change society, and in this its interest differs from physicalism's.