Panfilov's Twenty-Eight Guardsmen
판필로프의 28인
Panfilov's Twenty-Eight Guardsmen were 28 soldiers of the 316th Rifle Division (later the 8th Guards Panfilov Division) who, according to the Soviet army newspaper Krasnaya Zvezda, all died stopping German tanks near the Dubosekovo railway halt west of Moscow on 16 November 1941. Together with the words attributed to political officer Vasily Klochkov, "Russia is vast, but there is nowhere to retreat: Moscow is behind us", they became a wartime symbol of resistance, and in July 1942 all 28 were made Heroes of the Soviet Union. A 1948 military prosecutors' inquiry found that the 4th Company of the 1075th Regiment had fought there that day and lost over a hundred men, but that the fight of the 28 and its details were invented by journalists, and that six men on the list were alive. The finding was long buried, and the story remains contested in Russian memory politics.
In depth
What actually happened at Dubosekovo?
Major General Ivan Panfilov's 316th Rifle Division was raised in Alma-Ata in the Kazakh republic and Frunze in the Kirghiz republic, and in October 1941 joined Konstantin Rokossovsky's Soviet 16th Army defending Volokolamsk. In the October fighting the 1075th Rifle Regiment lost its 1st Battalion and was left with two. The 4th Company of the 2nd Battalion was also thought to have been destroyed and was formed again; a few days later about 30 survivors of the old company broke out of encirclement and were merged with the roughly 100 men of the new one. Its commander was Captain Pavel Gundilovich and its political officer Vasily Klochkov. According to the Central Archive of the Ministry of Defence, on 16 November the 1075th Regiment had 1,534 men, and the regimental commander Ilya Kaprov testified that the 4th Company had 120 to 140. Its anti-tank weapons were 11 anti-tank rifles for the whole regiment (four of them in the 2nd Battalion), anti-tank grenades and petrol bombs.
On the morning of 16 November the German 2nd Panzer Division attacked in three combat groups to improve the start line for the V Corps offensive due two days later. The strongest, Kampfgruppe 1, led by a tank battalion, came against the left flank held by the 2nd Battalion, north of the Dubosekovo halt. According to the 316th Division's reports, the Germans attacked at 8 a.m. and by 10 had taken Nelidovo and Petelino. In Kaprov's account, 10 to 12 tanks first came at the battalion's sector and withdrew after the regiment knocked out five or six, but at 2 to 3 p.m., after heavy shelling, more than 50 tanks came again, aimed mainly at the 2nd Battalion. The regiment was broken in 40 to 50 minutes, and one German tank reached the regimental command post; Kaprov escaped thanks to the railway embankment and gathered the survivors. "The 4th Company, Gundilovich's, suffered most," he said: "only 20 to 25 men with the company commander survived out of 140." The division reported on 19 November that in the fighting of 16-18 November the regiment had destroyed four tanks and up to 1,200 infantry; political reports mentioned nine tanks.
German operational documents record no heavy tank losses or unusually stubborn resistance in this sector, and the German combat groups reached their objectives for the day early. Dubosekovo stayed in German hands until 20 December. Smirnova, chair of the Nelidovo village soviet, told the 1948 investigation that in early February 1942 three bodies were found on the battlefield and buried, and that in March, after the thaw, soldiers brought three more, Klochkov's among them, so that six men lay in the village's common grave. Yet in the wider battle the Panfilov division's sacrifice was not in vain. By 18 November the 316th Division's three rifle regiments were down to 120 to 200 men each, but the German 2nd Panzer Division was still 25 kilometres short of that day's objective, and the plan to take Klin by 20 November failed.
How did the newspapers create the story of "the Twenty-Eight"?
The first report was close to the facts. G. Ivanov of Izvestia, in "The 8th Guards Division in battle", written on 18 November and published on 19 November, described a company of Kaprov's regiment fighting in encirclement and knocking out nine tanks and burning three. On 24 November Vasily Koroteev, a war correspondent of the army newspaper Krasnaya Zvezda, went to 16th Army headquarters to see Rokossovsky and there heard from Sergei Egorov, commissar of the division's political department, about a group of soldiers who fought to the last against 54 German tanks and shot two comrades who wanted to surrender. Egorov had not been present and had heard the story from another political officer.
Koroteev's article of 27 November said that a group from "the 5th company" under "Commissar Diev" held off 54 tanks until all had died, and that the enemy lost 800 men and 18 tanks. It gave no date, place or number of men. The next day a front-page editorial in Krasnaya Zvezda, "The Testament of the 28 Fallen Heroes" by the literary secretary Aleksandr Krivitsky, supplied the number: of 29 men one lost his nerve and was shot by the others, and the remaining 28 destroyed 18 tanks and all died. According to evidence given in 1948, the editor David Ortenberg asked Koroteev how many men had fought; Koroteev guessed that the company was under strength, about 30 men including the two who wanted to surrender, and Ortenberg, finding two traitors too many, reduced them to one.
When the editorial was well received by the leadership, Stalin among them, names were needed. In late December, when the division was withdrawn to re-form, Krivitsky visited the 1075th Regiment with men from the divisional political department. According to Kaprov's 1948 testimony, Krivitsky said there had to be 28 guardsmen who had fought German tanks; Kaprov replied that the whole regiment, especially the 4th Company of the 2nd Battalion, had fought tanks, but that he knew nothing of a fight of 28. The names were given from memory by Captain Gundilovich. On 22 January 1942 Krivitsky published "About the 28 Fallen Heroes", which for the first time fixed the date and place as 16 November at Dubosekovo and the unit as the 4th Company. "Diev", he wrote, was Klochkov's nickname, and Klochkov's last words were "Russia is vast, but there is nowhere to retreat: Moscow is behind us!" The guardsmen had destroyed 70 submachine gunners and 18 tanks, and the last survivor, Ivan Natarov, had told the story before dying in a field hospital. According to the 1075th Regiment's combat report, however, Natarov had been killed two days before the battle, on 14 November. Gundilovich was killed in April 1942 and could not testify in later inquiries.
The story spread fast. In March 1942 the poet Nikolai Tikhonov wrote a verse on the 28 guardsmen, and at the request of the Western Front command a decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of 21 July 1942 posthumously made all 28 men named in the article Heroes of the Soviet Union. Kaprov testified that in April 1942 he signed award papers already drawn up and sent down by divisional headquarters. In 1942, during the fighting at Stalingrad, the political officer P. V. Logvinenko wrote "Fight like the Twenty-Eight!", and the phrase and Klochkov's words later entered Soviet school textbooks. Rokossovsky too repeated the official story in the 1988 edition of his memoir A Soldier's Duty.
On that very day, near the Dubosekovo halt, twenty-eight heroes of the Panfilov division led by political officer Vasily Klochkov performed their world-famous feat.
Именно в этот день у разъезда Дубосеково совершили свой всемирно известный подвиг двадцать восемь героев из панфиловской дивизии во главе с политруком Василием Клочковым.
What became of the survivors?
At least six of the 28 on the list were alive. In May 1942 the NKVD arrested a Western Front soldier, Danil Kuzhebergenov, for allegedly trying to surrender. He said he was the man on the list: on 16 November he had been knocked unconscious by an explosion, picked up by a German burial detail, and had escaped to the woods that evening and joined Lev Dovator's cavalry. Other veterans recognised him, but the investigator made him sign a confession that he was an impostor who had taken the story from the newspapers; he later said the statement was obtained under threats. The regimental commissar replaced the name on the list with Askar Kuzhebergenov, who joined the division only in January 1942 and was killed soon after, and so could not have been at Dubosekovo.
Ilarion Vasilyev and Grigory Shemyakin had been badly wounded and evacuated; after the posthumous decree they made themselves known and, after checks, received their Hero stars on 7 November 1942. Dmitry Timofeev and Ivan Shadrin were taken prisoner and survived. Shadrin was freed by American troops in 1945 and received his Hero papers in 1947; Timofeev received his star quietly shortly before his death in 1950.
The case with the greatest consequences was that of the squad leader Ivan Dobrobabin. Lightly wounded and captured, he escaped and went home to the village of Perekop in the Kharkov region under German occupation, where he served in the auxiliary police and for a time headed it. Arrested by the Soviets in March 1943, he escaped and returned to the German police, and was accused of taking part in arrests of Soviet citizens and the deportation of forced labourers to Germany. He re-enlisted in the Red Army in 1944, and in November 1947 was arrested by the military prosecutor of the Kharkov garrison; a book about the 28 was found at his home, and it emerged that he was one of the story's main heroes. In 1948 he was sentenced to 15 years, in February 1949 his Hero title was revoked, and in 1955 his sentence was cut to seven years and he was released. His plea for rehabilitation was rejected in 1989; Ukraine's Supreme Court rehabilitated him in 1993, a ruling without force in Russia. He died in 1996. Some, like the historian Georgy Kumanyov, think he was unjustly punished and led the men for several hours that day.
What did the 1948 investigation find?
The Dobrobabin case led to an investigation of the story of the 28 itself. On 10 May 1948 the Chief Military Prosecutor, Lieutenant General Nikolai Afanasyev, reported the results to the Prosecutor General of the USSR, Grigory Safonov, and on 11 June a summary over Safonov's signature went to the party secretary Andrei Zhdanov. Kaprov, Krivitsky, Ortenberg and Koroteev were questioned. Kaprov testified:
That day, near the Dubosekovo halt, the 4th Company of the 2nd Battalion fought German tanks, and truly fought heroically. More than 100 men of the company died, not 28 as the newspapers wrote.
В этот день у разъезда Дубосеково в составе 2-го батальона с немецкими танками дралась 4-я рота, и действительно дралась геройски. Из роты погибло свыше 100 человек, а не 28, как об этом писали в газетах.
Krivitsky admitted that he had made up most of the details of his articles, including Klochkov's last words and the dying Natarov's tale; Ortenberg and Koroteev said they had published Egorov's story to raise the troops' morale. The report concluded that the fight of the 28 as the newspaper described it had not taken place and was "literary fiction". On 28 August of the same year Sergei Shtemenko of the General Staff reported to the armed forces minister Nikolai Bulganin that no operational or political documents had been found that mentioned 28 men fighting and dying heroically at Dubosekovo, only one confirming the death of political officer Klochkov, so that the first reports had been the Krasnaya Zvezda articles, which had served as the basis for the awards.
The report was not published and the official story stood. Memorials went up across the Soviet Union, and the Moscow city song "My Dear Capital" came to mention its "twenty-eight bravest sons". There were attempts to reconcile the official story with the facts: the official six-volume History of the Great Patriotic War edited by Pospelov placed the 28 in the 1077th Regiment, which did hold its ground that day, but 20 kilometres from Dubosekovo.
Who questioned the story, and when?
The first to raise doubts in public was the critic E. V. Kardin, whose article "Legends and Facts" in the literary monthly Novy Mir in February 1966 questioned Krivitsky's articles and the canonical version and named survivors. Leonid Brezhnev rebuked him personally: "Some of our authors even say that ... there were no 28 Panfilov men, ... that Klochkov did not exist, and neither did his appeal", calling this a slander against "the heroic history of our party and Soviet people".
During perestroika Dobrobabin's plea for rehabilitation drew press attention, and the 1948 material resurfaced. The Chief Military Prosecutor's Office re-examined the case in 1988, and Chief Military Prosecutor Aleksandr Katusev published "Another's Glory" in the Military History Journal in 1990. He concluded that irresponsible journalists had reduced "the mass feat of the whole company, the whole regiment, the whole division to the scale of a mythical platoon". In 1997 Nikolai Petrov and Olga Edelman printed the text of the 1948 report in Novy Mir.
массовый подвиг всей роты, всего полка, всей дивизии безответственностью не совсем добросовестных журналистов преуменьшили до масштаба мифического взвода
What controversy did the 2015 release cause?
In 2015 Sergei Mironenko, director of the State Archive of the Russian Federation, said that "there were no 28 Panfilov heroes; it is one of the myths the state implanted", and the archive put Afanasyev's report online. The report had not been classified even before, but its release caused a great stir. Mironenko did not dispute that the Panfilov division played an outstanding part in the defence of Moscow or that most of its men fell on the approaches to the city. Culture Minister Vladimir Medinsky rebuked him sharply, and Mironenko was soon removed from his post. In October 2016 Medinsky said that even if the story had been invented from start to finish, even if there had been no Panfilov and nothing at all, it was a "sacred legend" that must not be touched, and called those who did so by a crude insult. He compared the 28 to the 300 Spartans and said the difference between legend and fact was that no one knows, or needs to know, whether it was 28, 30, 38 or perhaps 48 of the company's 130 men.
The defenders of the official version have their arguments. Marshal Dmitry Yazov published a letter criticising Mironenko in 2011, citing the historian Georgy Kumanyov's study "Feat and Forgery". They say that Zhdanov, on receiving the 1948 report, judged the investigation excessive and sent the file to the archive, and they cite Krivitsky's recollection in the 1970s that during the 1948 inquiry he was told he would end up on the Pechora or in Kolyma if he did not testify that he had invented the battle, and so called it his "literary fiction". In 2012 K. S. Drozdov, acting head of the archive of the Institute of Russian History of the Russian Academy of Sciences, published transcripts of interviews with veterans recorded in 1942-47 by the Commission on the History of the Great Patriotic War, and asked why the 1948 investigation had not questioned surviving participants such as Vasilyev and Shemyakin, and why Kaprov had sent up award papers in 1942 and denied the fight in 1948. He suggested the inquiry may have been aimed at Georgy Zhukov, a leading sponsor of the awards. In the interview with Vasilyev of 22 December 1942 that Drozdov published, Vasilyev recalled Klochkov saying "there is nowhere to retreat, Moscow is behind us" and described being wounded while fighting off two tank attacks; this interview, however, came after the January article. In 2018 the Russian Military Historical Society released NKVD and SMERSH counter-intelligence files of 1942-44, including the testimony of the regimental commissar Mukhamedyarov that the fight of the 28 did take place, and of the regimental staff officer Vetkov that the paperwork had been rushed but that the mass heroism at Dubosekovo was an irrefutable fact.
What did the 2016 film show?
On 24 November 2016 the Russian film Panfilov's 28 Men («Двадцать восемь панфиловцев») was released. It was started with crowdfunding and also received Russian government funding, and Russian state media showed President Vladimir Putin watching it with Kazakhstan's President Nursultan Nazarbayev. The film presented the newspaper story as historical fact again and, together with Medinsky's "sacred legend" remarks of the same year, became the centre of a debate on how the state handles the memory of the war. The names of the 28 are still carved on many memorials, among them Heroes-Panfilovtsy Street in Moscow (named in 1966), the memorial at Dubosekovo (1975) and the Park of the 28 Panfilov Guardsmen in Almaty.
What is confirmed, and what was made up?
What the documents confirm is this. On 16 November 1941, around Dubosekovo, the 4th Company of the 2nd Battalion of the 316th Rifle Division's 1075th Regiment fought tanks of the German 2nd Panzer Division; the regiment was overrun and the company lost more than a hundred men. Over the same three days the whole Panfilov division, at great cost, slowed the German advance along the Volokolamsk road.
What was judged a newspaper creation is the number 28, the death of all 28, the 18 tanks and the dying Natarov's testimony. The 1948 investigation regarded Klochkov's last words as Krivitsky's invention, though some argue from later interview records that Klochkov said something similar. What followed is a history of memory politics: the findings were buried for over forty years, the writer who raised doubts was publicly rebuked by the country's leader, and the archive director who released the documents in 2015 lost his post. The conflict over the story comes from the fact that honouring the real soldiers' sacrifice and defending a legend the state made for its own needs are not the same thing.