The operations chief who briefed Stalin every day, later a Chief of the General Staff removed three times
November 1943, on Stalin's train to Tehran: Shtemenko briefed him from the maps three times a day. By his own account, the German division counts he kept rechecking were what Stalin used on the first day of the conference to press for the second front.
Born into a poor Don Cossack family, he was called up into the Red Army in 1926, served in the artillery and armoured troops, and on finishing the General Staff Academy in 1940 was posted to the Operations Directorate of the General Staff. During the war with Germany he headed the Near East direction and worked on the defence of the Caucasus; from May 1943 he was chief of the Operations Directorate, briefing Stalin every day, and he accompanied Stalin to the Tehran Conference. He became Chief of the General Staff in 1948, at 41, but was removed in 1952 and, after Beria's arrest in 1953, demoted by two ranks. Removed again as head of military intelligence in 1957, he worked his way back and in 1968 became chief of staff of the Warsaw Pact forces. His memoir The General Staff in the War Years is a standard source on the Soviet high command.
Also known as: Sergey Shtemenko
Activities and affiliations
-
1926–
Soviet Union state institutionsMilitary and defenceMain
Military command -
1930–
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Military command
Career Timeline
- 1926.10Called up into the Red Army
- 1937.12–1938.08Graduates from the Mechanization and Motorization Academy; commands a training tank battalion
- 1940Graduates from the General Staff Academy; senior assistant, Near East department of the Operations Directorate
- 1941.08–1942.06Deputy head of the Near East direction, Operations Directorate
- 1942.06–1943.04Head of the Near East direction (North Caucasus and Transcaucasian fronts)
- 1942.08Sent to Transcaucasia with the General Staff group attached to Beria
- 1943.04–05First deputy chief of the Operations Directorate; lieutenant general
- 1943.05–1946.03Chief of the Operations Directorate of the General Staff
- 1943.11Accompanies Stalin to the Tehran Conference
- 1946.03–1948.11Chief of the Main Operations Directorate and deputy chief of the General Staff
- 1948.11–1952.06Chief of the General Staff and deputy minister of the armed forces (from 1950, war minister); army general
- 1952.06–1953.03Chief of staff, Group of Soviet Occupation Forces in Germany
- 1953.03–07Deputy chief of the General Staff; demoted to lieutenant general in June
- 1953.11–1956.08Chief of staff, West Siberian (from 1956 Siberian) Military District
- 1956.08–1957.10Head of the Main Intelligence Directorate (GRU)
- 1958.05–1962.07First deputy commander, Volga and then Transcaucasian Military District
- 1962.07–1964.04Chief of the Main Staff of the Ground Forces
- 1964.04–1968.08Head of the Main Organization and Mobilization Directorate
- 1968.08–1976.04First deputy chief of the General Staff and chief of staff of the Warsaw Pact Joint Armed Forces
Related historical events
- 1941–1945The Great Patriotic WarStavka representative
- 1941–1945The Yugoslav Partisan WarHead of the Soviet General Staff Operations Directorate, memoiristAt the General Staff he handled the Soviet mission and the planning of the Belgrade operation, and wrote about the escape from Drvar and Tito's Moscow visit in his second volume of 1973, leaving out the 1948 split and the Soviet soldiers' crimes.
- 1941.12.26–1942.05.20The Battle of the Kerch Peninsula (1941–1942)Officer of the General Staff's Operations DirectorateResponsible for this sector in the General Staff, he read Mekhlis's reports and described the Crimean Front's collapse in his memoir.
- 1942–1943Battle of StalingradSection chief, General Staff Operations DirectorateIn 1942 he headed the Near East section of the General Staff Operations Directorate and was sent to the Transcaucasian Front in August-September; he became chief of the directorate only in May 1943. His memoir The General Staff in the War Years describes the staff's work in this period.
- 1942.07.25–1943.10.09The Battle of the Caucasus (1942–1943)Head of the Caucasus direction, General Staff Operations DirectorateOrganised the defence in Tbilisi with Bodin in August-September 1942, took down Stalin's directives in January 1943 and went to the Kuban with Zhukov in April-May; described the battle in detail in his memoirs.
- 1943.01.13–03The Battles for Kharkov and the Donbas (January–March 1943)Head of operations, Soviet General StaffWrote in his memoirs that the General Staff overestimated its prospects.
- 1943.08.26–12.23The Battle of the DnieperOfficer of the General Staff Operations DirectorateHis memoirs describe the Voronezh Front's plan, the failure of the Bukrin airborne operation and the directive moving the main effort to Lyutezh.
- 1944–1948Poland: From the Lublin Committee to the United Workers' PartyHead of the Soviet General Staff Operations Directorate, memoiristDealt with the Polish formations and the Polish operations at the General Staff, and recorded Anders' Army, the Kościuszko Division and the formation and arming of the 1st and 2nd Polish Armies in volume 2 of his memoir.
- 1944–1949Bulgaria: From the Fatherland Front to the Kostov TrialHead of the Soviet General Staff Operations Directorate, memoiristHe followed the Bulgarian operation and Biryuzov's mission from the General Staff and described them along the Soviet official line in his second volume of 1973. With Antonov he signed the telegram of 26 September 1944 banning arrests in Bulgaria and Romania.
- 1944.02.12–11.15The Finnish front in 1944Head of General Staff operations, military adviser at the talksWorked on the plans for the northern offensives and sat in on the March and September talks with Finland as military adviser; he described this front in the chapter "A Secondary Direction" of his memoirs.
- 1944.03–1945.03Hungary under German occupation: from Operation Margarethe to the siege of BudapestHead of the Soviet General Staff’s Operations DirectoratePlanned the Hungarian operations at the General Staff and described the armistice talks and the Budapest decisions in his memoirs.
- 1944.04.08–05.12The Crimean Offensive (1944)Head of the General Staff Operations DirectorateSent to the Separate Coastal Army with Voroshilov on behalf of the General Staff.
- 1944.08–10Warsaw UprisingHead of the Soviet General Staff Operations DirectorateHandled the directives, air supply and liaison with the insurgents at the General Staff, and recorded the Soviet side in his memoir.
- 1944.08.20–09.12The Jassy–Kishinev Offensive and Romania's 23 AugustHead of the General Staff Operations DirectorateCoordinated the two fronts' plans; first argued for a main blow towards Kishinev, then accepted the Kitskany plan on fresh intelligence, and left a detailed account in his memoirs.
- 1944.08.29–10.28The Slovak National Uprising and the Carpathian–Dukla OperationHead of the General Staff Operations DirectorateReviewed the plans for aiding the uprising and recorded the General Staff's view in his memoirs.
- 1945.01.12–02.03The Vistula–Oder OffensiveHead of the General Staff Operations DirectorateHis memoir describes the planning of the winter offensive, the earlier start, and the contradiction between the two fronts' Berlin plans and their boundary.
- 1945.03.16–04.27The Vienna offensive and the Renner government: Austria in the spring of 1945Head of the Soviet General Staff’s Operations DirectorateHelped plan the Vienna operation and described the Kremlin’s handling of Renner in his memoirs.
- 1945.05.05–12The Prague Uprising and the Prague OffensiveHead of the General Staff Operations DirectoratePrepared the operation at the General Staff and described it in his memoir.
- 1945.08The Soviet Entry into the War against JapanManchurian operation plannerAs chief of the General Staff Operations Directorate, he planned the Manchurian operation.
- 1968The Prague SpringWarsaw Pact Combined Staff chiefAppointed Chief of the Warsaw Pact Combined Staff in August 1968, about two weeks before the invasion; the appointment was part of the preparations for the invasion of Czechoslovakia (Operation Danube).
Three Years in the Operations Directorate, 1940–1943
At first Shtemenko did not want to work at the General Staff. In his memoir The General Staff in the War Years (1968–1973) he recalls that at the graduation party of the General Staff Academy in autumn 1940, Aleksandr Vasilevsky (then deputy chief of the Operations Directorate) announced that graduates who had worked at the General Staff during the Soviet-Finnish War would probably be posted there. The next day Shtemenko applied to be sent instead to the mechanized corps then being formed. The request was refused, and he became senior assistant to Mikhail Sharokhin, head of the Near East department of the Operations Directorate. That autumn and winter went into a military-geographical study of the Near East theatre, and in May and June 1941 he helped run command-staff exercises in the Transcaucasian and Central Asian military districts. Back in Moscow on the morning of 21 June, he was called out by an alarm at 2 a.m. on the 22nd and was at the General Staff half an hour later.
Once the war began, the Operations Directorate replaced its regional departments with "directions", one for each front. Shtemenko became deputy head of the Near East direction in August 1941, but the shortage of hands kept him mostly on the South-Western and Western directions. When Moscow came under air attack, the Directorate moved onto the platform of Kirovskaya metro station: a communications centre in one corner, Stalin's office in another, rows of desks in between. After the Battle of Moscow he took charge of the Near East, which included the three Soviet armies that had entered Iran together with the British in August 1941, reporting on them to the Chief of the General Staff, Boris Shaposhnikov.
In August 1942 he reported in Stalin's office for the first time. By his account Stalin heard him out without interruption on the Terek line and the weakly held passes of the Caucasus range, then asked what troops could be taken from Central Asia and Iran. On 22 August he flew to the Transcaucasian Front with the new head of the Operations Directorate, Pavel Bodin, and worked on the defence lines covering Baku and on the defence of the passes. The memoir presents the mission only as Bodin's group and does not say that the group was attached to Lavrentiy Beria, the State Defence Committee member sent to the Caucasus. Russian Wikipedia and the letter Shtemenko wrote to Khrushchev in July 1953 make that clear. In the letter he says he spent about two months in Transcaucasia (the memoir has the group back in Moscow after a month), that all his tasks came from Bodin, and that he had no direct dealings with Beria. Vasilevsky, as recorded by Konstantin Simonov, said that when Beria asked for someone from the General Staff, Shtemenko was recommended as a young and able staff officer, and that the months he spent with Beria later shaped much of his fate and his conduct.
Head of the Near East direction from June 1942, he became first deputy chief of the Operations Directorate in April 1943 and its chief in May.
Chief of Operations: Briefing Stalin and Planning 1944–1945
As chief of the Operations Directorate, Shtemenko lived by the timetable Stalin had set. By his account he was allowed to rest only from 2 p.m. to 6 or 7 p.m. Between 10 and 11 a.m. Stalin rang the directorate on a direct line, and Shtemenko reported front by front, walking between tables spread with maps and starting with the most critical sector. After 11 p.m. he and the deputy chief of the General Staff, Aleksei Antonov, drove to the Kremlin or to Stalin's "Near Dacha" at Kuntsevo with the summary report for the day; they were back at 3 or 4 a.m. Though he visited the office hundreds of times, he wrote, he never saw Stalin use the globe there to discuss operations. The working day is described in more detail under Soviet General Staff.
In November 1943 he accompanied Stalin to the Tehran Conference, taking only his maps and a cipher clerk. On a train whose destination he had not been told, he linked up with Moscow by high-frequency telephone at each stop and reported in Stalin's carriage three times a day; in Tehran he reported in the morning and after the evening sessions, and got Stalin's signature on draft directives sent by Antonov. Stalin, he wrote, made him check again and again the number of German and satellite divisions on each front, and used the figures on the first day of the conference to press for the second front.
In 1944 he was often at the front. In February and March he served as chief of staff to the Stavka representative Semyon Timoshenko with the 2nd Baltic Front; in June he went with Georgy Zhukov to the 2nd Belorussian Front to prepare the Mogilev offensive; in July he helped the 3rd Baltic Front with the Pskov-Ostrov offensive. By his account the plan for Operation Bagration was completed on 14 May, written out by hand by his deputy Anatoly Gryzlov and signed by Antonov on the 20th, and Stalin gave it its name. On the night of 31 December 1944 he and Antonov were summoned without maps to the Near Dacha and saw in the New Year with Stalin and the Politburo. At the Stavka meeting of 1 April 1945, as he remembered it, Stalin crossed out on the map the boundary line that cut the 1st Ukrainian Front off from Berlin, stopped it at Lübben and said, "Whoever breaks in first, let him take Berlin." In summer 1945 he took part in planning the Manchurian operation.
His memoir portrays Stalin's high command as an orderly machine, and in places it clashes with other commanders' memoirs. He wrote that around 7 November 1944 Tolbukhin, Rokossovsky, Konev and Chernyakhovsky worked at the General Staff and that the Stavka then discussed the plan for the 1945 campaign as a whole. Zhukov, in a passage restored in the later uncut edition, replied that although he was in Moscow at the time he "knew of no such meeting", and that Stalin never discussed a whole campaign with front commanders. On Bagration's two main blows, Shtemenko says the Operations Directorate accepted Rokossovsky's idea; Rokossovsky remembered that on 22 and 23 May Stalin and his deputies insisted on a single main blow and twice sent him into the next room to think again.
Chief of the General Staff and Repeated Falls, 1948–1976
After the war Shtemenko became chief of the Main Operations Directorate and deputy chief of the General Staff in March 1946, and in November 1948, at 41, Chief of the General Staff and deputy minister of the armed forces, with the rank of army general. His memoir says little about these years beyond noting that the General Staff kept its wartime routine, finishing work at 3 or 4 a.m., until Stalin's death.
Shtemenko's first fall began while Stalin was still alive. In June 1952, after nearly four years as Chief of the General Staff, he was abruptly removed and exiled to the post of Chief of Staff of the Group of Soviet Forces in Germany. Stalin reportedly told Vasilevsky: "We removed Shtemenko because he keeps writing and writing denunciations of you — we got tired of it" (as quoted by Konstantin Simonov in his memoirs, citing Vasilevsky's account).
Immediately after Stalin's death in March 1953, Shtemenko was recalled to Moscow and appointed Deputy Chief of the General Staff. But his fortunes reversed again in June when Beria was arrested. Defence Minister Bulganin accused Shtemenko of having "reported various slanders about leading military figures to Stalin through Beria." On 29 June 1953, Shtemenko was demoted two full ranks, from Army General to Lieutenant General, a punishment almost without precedent in the Soviet officer corps.
Desperate, Shtemenko wrote a long personal letter to Nikita Khrushchev on 23 July 1953. "I have served honestly and conscientiously for 27 years," he wrote. "The Party's decision is law, but the shadow of the vile criminal Beria has been cast over my honest name as a communist." He laid out in meticulous detail every meeting he had ever had with Beria, beginning with the Caucasus mission in 1942, and insisted he had "never, not once, orally or in writing, reported to Beria any facts concerning the work of this or that military leader." The letter did not save him. After some months without a post he was dispatched to Siberia in November 1953 as Chief of Staff of the West Siberian Military District.
Ironically, Shtemenko had reportedly been listed as an intended victim of Stalin's final purge, the Doctors' Plot, just months earlier, and it was only Stalin's death that may have saved him. Beria's fall spared his life, but came close to destroying his career.
In August 1956 Defence Minister Zhukov made him head of the Main Intelligence Directorate. According to Russian Wikipedia, in October 1957 he warned Zhukov, then visiting Yugoslavia, that his removal was being prepared, and on 28 October, right after Zhukov's fall, he was removed himself. He then served as first deputy commander of the Volga and Transcaucasian military districts, rising again to chief of the Main Staff of the Ground Forces in July 1962 and head of the General Staff's Main Organization and Mobilization Directorate in 1964. He was made army general for the second time in February 1968, and on 3 August was appointed first deputy chief of the General Staff and chief of staff of the Warsaw Pact Joint Armed Forces. English Wikipedia sees the appointment as part of the preparations for the Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia, which began two weeks later. He held the post, writing his memoirs and military articles, until his death in 1976.