The Battles for Kharkov and the Donbas (January–March 1943)
Why did the Red Army, victorious at Stalingrad, lose Kharkov again within two months?
In January and February 1943 Soviet troops broke the Hungarian and Italian armies on the middle Don, retook Kursk, Belgorod and Kharkov in Operation Star, and drove deep into the Donbas in Operation Gallop. But exhausted units and broken supply lines went unheeded, and on 20 February Manstein's Army Group South struck back, destroyed the Popov group and retook Kharkov on 15 March and Belgorod on 18 March. Kharkov changed hands for the third time in the war, and the SS troops who retook it massacred the wounded in a hospital.
What was the Stavka aiming for after Stalingrad?
In January 1943, while the German 6th Army was collapsing at Stalingrad, the Soviet Supreme High Command (Stavka) set out to widen that success across the whole southern front. According to Russian Wikipedia the aim was to destroy German Army Group B and win back the Kharkov industrial region. The first step was the Ostrogozhsk–Rossosh operation of 13 to 27 January, carried out by the Voronezh Front under Filipp Golikov together with the 6th Army of the Southwestern Front. It broke the main forces of the Hungarian 2nd Army and the Italian 8th Army holding the middle Don; 15 divisions were destroyed outright and six more badly beaten. Soviet troops advanced about 140 kilometres west and recovered the railway from Liski to Kantemirovka, opening a supply route for the armies further south. For Hungary on the Axis side this defeat was its greatest catastrophe of the war. 1 2
Further north, the Voronezh–Kastornoye operation from 24 January encircled and drove back the main forces of the German 2nd Army. In the south, Nikolai Vatutin's Southwestern Front began Operation Gallop toward the Donbas on 29 January, and on 2 February the Voronezh Front opened Operation Star toward Kharkov. Sergei Shtemenko, then head of operations in the Soviet General Staff, wrote in his memoirs that Stalin approved the Star plan around midnight on 23 January. He recalled that the General Staff then believed it could cut off the whole southern wing of the enemy before the Dnieper, yet admitted that "unfortunately we overestimated the prospects that had opened before us and did not take everything into account." The demand to reach the Dnieper before the spring thaw drove both operations on together. 3 4 5 6
How far did Operations Star and Gallop get?
Operation Star moved fast at first. Pavel Rybalko's 3rd Tank Army, Kirill Moskalenko's 40th Army and the 69th Army headed for Kharkov, while on the northern wing Ivan Chernyakhovsky's 60th Army took back Kursk on 8 February. The 40th Army seized Belgorod on 9 February, and on 16 February Soviet troops entered Kharkov. Further south, the Southern Front retook Rostov-on-Don on 14 February. According to English Wikipedia, however, the longer the advance ran the weaker the units became; divisions of the 69th Army were down to 1,000 to 1,500 men. Russian Wikipedia writes that units of the Voronezh Front were up to 300 kilometres from their supply bases, and with only 1,062 lorries for the whole front supplies could not be brought up in time. 5 7 8 2
The spearhead of Operation Gallop was a mobile group under Lieutenant General Markian Popov. According to Russian Wikipedia it set out with four tank corps and 137 tanks; Shtemenko wrote of about 180 tanks with, on average, a single load of fuel. Popov's group crossed the Donets and pushed as far as Krasnoarmeyskoye to cut off the Germans in the Donbas from the west, but after two weeks of fighting it had only 53 tanks and 13,000 men left. Meanwhile the eastern wing of the German Army Group Don under Field Marshal Erich von Manstein fell back to the line of the Mius river by 17 February and set up a new defence there. The German 1st Panzer Army, which had pulled out to the lower Don after the Battle of the Caucasus in early 1943, had by this time been moved into the Donbas. 6 4 9 10
How did Hitler and Manstein argue over ground to give up?
Manstein wrote in his memoirs that he repeatedly demanded that the eastern salient be shortened to the Mius, arguing that the whole southern wing could not be lost for the sake of holding the Donbas. In his account Hitler summoned him on 6 February to Lötzen in East Prussia (today Giżycko in Poland). The meeting ran four hours, from 17:00 to 21:00, and Hitler countered that the war economy could not do without Donbas coal. Manstein wrote that he answered with what he had heard just before from Paul Pleiger, head of the Reich coal association, who had visited his headquarters and told him that the Shakhty coalfield east of the Mius was not decisive and that its coal was fit neither for coking nor for locomotives, an objection Hitler could not answer. In the end Hitler allowed the withdrawal to the Mius line. Manstein also wrote that at that meeting Hitler began by acknowledging, without reservation, his personal responsibility for the fate of the 6th Army. According to German Wikipedia, Army Group Don was renamed Army Group South on 12 February. 10 11
Over Kharkov the clash was sharper. Hubert Lanz's army detachment, responsible for the Kharkov sector, was ordered by Hitler to hold the city as a fortress and to counterattack southward, and on 13 February Hitler again insisted that the city be held at all costs. But Paul Hausser's SS Panzer Corps inside the city faced encirclement. According to German Wikipedia, Hausser pressed his superior Lanz on 14 February to allow a withdrawal, then backed down at 21:30 after repeated orders from Lanz and Manstein and agreed to hold. On 15 February, however, he ordered the withdrawal on his own authority, and the next day Soviet troops entered the city. Hitler dismissed Lanz rather than Hausser and put Werner Kempf in his place, and the Oak Leaves to the Knight's Cross meant for Hausser were held back until July. Manstein wrote in his memoirs: "Had Kharkov been abandoned on the order of some army general, Hitler would undoubtedly have sent him before a court martial." 7 12 13 10
How did the Zaporozhye meeting and the counteroffensive begin?
Right after Kharkov was lost, Hitler came south in person. Manstein's memoirs say he arrived at the army group's headquarters in Zaporozhye on the evening of 17 February; some Russian sources give the 18th. Talks continued the next day, and on the 19th Ewald von Kleist, commander of Army Group A, joined them. According to English Wikipedia, Soviet tanks were by then about 30 kilometres from the Zaporozhye airfield, and Hitler left in haste on the 19th. Instead of the immediate recapture of Kharkov that Hitler wanted, Manstein carried his plan to strike first at the Soviet forces that had driven deep in the south and only then turn on Kharkov. He called this approach the "backhand blow", striking back after letting the enemy strike first. 10 8 2 7
The order for the counteroffensive was issued on 19 February and the troops moved the next day. The SS Panzer Corps struck south-east from Krasnograd, while Hermann Hoth's 4th Panzer Army and the 1st Panzer Army hit the Soviet flank toward Pavlograd and Krasnoarmeyskoye. Wolfram von Richthofen's 4th Air Fleet raised its daily sorties from an average of 350 in January to 1,000 in February. Vatutin, commander of the Southwestern Front, refused Popov's request to withdraw on 20 February, and Shtemenko wrote that the next day Vatutin still believed the enemy was hurrying to retreat. Popov's group was surrounded and broken by about 24 February, and Theodor Eicke, commander of the SS Totenkopf division, was shot down and killed on a reconnaissance flight near Lozovaya on 26 February. On 1 March the Voronezh Front also went over to the defensive. 7 8 4 6 2
Why did the Soviet command not foresee the counterblow?
Aleksandr Vasilevsky, then Chief of the General Staff, wrote in his memoirs that the error was not the front commanders' alone: "Thus both the Stavka and the General Staff made the same mistake as the commanders of the Southwestern and Voronezh Fronts: they did not expect offensive operations by the enemy, considering him beaten here." Shtemenko likewise drew the lesson that the enemy's strength had been underrated and that the exhausted troops should have been halted and refitted at the end of January. The Soviet side read the German pull-back as a retreat across the Dnieper, when it was in fact a regrouping for a counterblow. 14 4
Russian Wikipedia, following the British historian John Erickson, sums up that the decisions of Vatutin and Golikov stemmed from overestimating their own strength, misreading intelligence on the enemy, and pressure from the Stavka. According to English Wikipedia, Soviet over-extension and losses meant that when the counteroffensive began, Manstein's roughly 350 tanks outnumbered Soviet armour almost seven to one at the point of contact and were far better supplied with fuel. Vasilevsky wrote that after this defeat Golikov was removed from the Voronezh Front and Vatutin took it over. 6 8 14
How did Kharkov and Belgorod change hands again?
In early March the Germans turned north toward Kharkov. On 8 and 9 March at Sokolovo, south of the city, the 1st Czechoslovak Independent Battalion under Ludvík Svoboda went into battle for the first time and held off German tanks. Hoth and Manstein meant to encircle the city from the west and north, but according to English Wikipedia Hausser ignored this and on 11 March sent the SS Panzer Corps straight into the city. Four days of house-to-house fighting followed, and once taken, Dzerzhinsky Square in the city centre was renamed "Leibstandarte Square". According to German Wikipedia the Kharkov tractor works district was cleared on 15 March, and that night the Stavka allowed the remaining troops to withdraw. Manstein's memoirs say the SS Panzer Corps took Kharkov on 14 March and that "the city fell without major fighting", which contradicts the other accounts of street fighting. 15 8 7 10
On 18 March the Germans retook Belgorod. North of it, however, Ivan Chistyakov's 21st Army barred the way before Oboyan, and the Stavka sent Mikhail Katukov's 1st Tank Army to fill the line. Manstein wrote in his memoirs that he had wanted to clear the Kursk salient together with Army Group Centre, but Army Group Centre declined, and soon the thaw came and the mud brought operations to a halt. By the end of March the front had set along a line north of Kharkov and along the Donets and the Mius. 8 2 10
What did the people of Kharkov go through?
Kharkov changed hands four times in this war. German troops took it on 24 October 1941; Soviet troops recovered it on 16 February 1943; it fell to the Germans again on 15 March; and it was finally liberated on 23 August 1943. During the first occupation, between December 1941 and January 1942, the Germans massacred an estimated 15,000 Jews in the Drobytsky Yar ravine outside the city. According to English Wikipedia about 80,000 people died of hunger, cold and disease under the occupation, and when the city was liberated in August 1943 fewer than 200,000 inhabitants remained. Seventy percent of the city had been destroyed. 16 17
The recapture in March led to massacres. According to Russian Wikipedia, on 13 March soldiers of the SS division Leibstandarte Adolf Hitler burned alive about 300 wounded Red Army men who had not been evacuated from the military hospital at 5 Trinklera Street, and over the next few days shot the remaining wounded, killing more than 400 in all. German Wikipedia writes that the Leibstandarte killed large numbers of wounded and prisoners in Kharkov, and that the troops under Hausser committed numerous war crimes against Red Army soldiers and civilians. After the city was retaken for good, the world's first trial of German war criminals was held in Kharkov from 15 to 18 December 1943. 17 18 13
What were the losses, and how did the Kursk salient come about?
Loss figures differ by source. By the official Soviet count cited in German Wikipedia, the Kharkov defensive operation of 4 to 25 March cost 86,496 men (45,219 of them killed or missing), and the preceding Voronezh–Kharkov offensive 153,561 (55,475 killed or missing). English Wikipedia states that Army Group South's Donets campaign cost the Red Army over 80,000 casualties, and its article on Manstein reports the German claim of 23,000 Soviet dead and 615 tanks destroyed by 2 March. German losses were not small either: according to English Wikipedia the SS Panzer Corps lost some 160 officers and about 4,300 men, around 44 percent of its strength. 7 8 12
Judgments of the battle differ too. According to English Wikipedia the military historian Bevin Alexander called it "the last great victory of German arms on the Eastern front", while Robert Citino called it "not a victory at all". Citino saw it as a successful counteroffensive against an overextended and overconfident enemy that did not amount to a strategic victory. Where the counteroffensive stopped, a Soviet salient centred on Kursk was left jutting far to the west. The German command prepared Operation Citadel to cut it off, while the Soviet side read the plan in advance and built deep defences. The result was the Battle of Kursk in July 1943. 8 19
Consequences
The Germans retook Kharkov and Belgorod, but a Soviet salient jutting west around Kursk remained, and it became the stage for the Battle of Kursk in July 1943. Kharkov was finally liberated on 23 August 1943.
Timeline & Map
- 11943.01.13Ostrogozhsk–Rossosh operation begins
The Voronezh Front struck the Hungarian 2nd and Italian 8th Armies on the middle Don and destroyed 15 divisions.
- 21943.01.24Voronezh–Kastornoye operation begins
Soviet troops encircled the main forces of the German 2nd Army and drove them west.
- 31943.01.29Operation Gallop begins
The Southwestern Front advanced into the Donbas led by Popov's mobile group.
- 41943.02.02Operation Star begins
The Voronezh Front opened its offensive toward Kharkov.
- 51943.02.06Meeting at Lötzen
Hitler accepted Manstein's demand and allowed the withdrawal to the Mius line.
- 61943.02.08Soviet troops retake Kursk
Chernyakhovsky's 60th Army retook Kursk.
- 71943.02.09Soviet troops retake Belgorod
Moskalenko's 40th Army took Belgorod and turned on Kharkov.
- 81943.02.15Hausser leaves Kharkov against orders
The SS Panzer Corps pulled out of the city against the order to hold it.
- 91943.02.16Soviet troops liberate Kharkov
Soviet troops of Operation Star entered Kharkov.
- 101943.02.17Hitler at Zaporozhye
Hitler came to Army Group South headquarters and heard Manstein's plan for a counterstroke.
- 111943.02.20German counteroffensive begins
The SS Panzer Corps struck the Soviet flank south-east from Krasnograd.
- 121943.02.24Popov group destroyed
Popov's group near Krasnoarmeyskoye was encircled and broken.
- 131943.03.08Battle of Sokolovo
Svoboda's Czechoslovak battalion held off German tanks in its first battle.
- 141943.03.11SS Panzer Corps attacks into Kharkov
Hausser ignored the encirclement plan and sent his troops into the city.
- 151943.03.13Massacre at the Kharkov military hospital
Soldiers of the SS Leibstandarte burned about 300 wounded men who had not been evacuated.
- 161943.03.15Germans retake Kharkov
The tractor works fell and the Stavka allowed the remaining troops to withdraw.
- 171943.03.18Germans retake Belgorod
The Germans retook Belgorod, but their advance stopped north of it.
Related people 20
Soviet forces (with the Czechoslovak battalion)12
Leadership4
Approved Operation Star on 23 January and demanded an advance to the Dnieper.
Chief of the Soviet General StaffAleksandr Vasilevsky1895–1977Admitted in his memoirs that the Stavka and the General Staff had not expected a German counteroffensive.
Commander of the Southwestern FrontNikolai Vatutin1901–1944Led Operation Gallop and, believing the Germans were retreating, refused Popov's request to withdraw.
Commander of the Voronezh FrontFilipp Golikov1900–1980Led the Ostrogozhsk–Rossosh operation and Operation Star, retaking Kharkov, but was removed after the counteroffensive.
Implementers & commanders6
Drove deep into the Donbas, then lost most of his tanks and was encircled.
Commander of the 3rd Tank ArmyPavel Rybalko1894–1948Was the main force in liberating Kharkov and was badly hit by the March counterstroke.
Commander of the 40th ArmyKirill Moskalenko1902–1985Took Belgorod on 9 February and drove on Kharkov from the north.
Commander of the 60th ArmyIvan Chernyakhovsky1907–1945Retook Kursk on 8 February.
Commander of the 21st ArmyIvan Chistyakov1900–1979Stopped the German advance north of Belgorod in late March.
Commander of the 1st Czechoslovak Independent BattalionLudvík Svoboda1895–1979Led the battalion in its first battle at Sokolovo on 8 and 9 March.
Participants1
German and Axis forces8
Leadership2
Won Hitler's consent to fall back to the Mius and led the counteroffensive from 20 February that retook Kharkov and Belgorod.
German Führer and Supreme CommanderAdolf Hitler1889–1945Ordered Kharkov held, and at Zaporozhye on 17 to 19 February accepted Manstein's plan for a counteroffensive.
Implementers & commanders3
Abandoned Kharkov against orders on 15 February and in March retook it by street fighting instead of the planned encirclement.
Commander of the German 4th Panzer ArmyHermann Hoth1885–1971Led the main force of the counteroffensive against the Soviet flank and north to Kharkov.
Commander of the SS Leibstandarte divisionSepp Dietrich1892–1966His division retook Kharkov and massacred the wounded in the military hospital.
Participants3
Replaced Lanz in the Kharkov sector after the city was lost.
Commander of Army Group AEwald von Kleist1881–1954Joined the meeting at Zaporozhye on 19 February.
Commander of the SS Totenkopf divisionTheodor Eicke1892–1943Was killed when his reconnaissance plane was shot down near Lozovaya on 26 February.
Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19