Ludvík Svoboda

Czechoslovakia state institutions Marxism–Leninism Czechia Czechia 1895.11.25.–1979.9.20. ○ Natural causes

A national hero of two world wars who became an unlikely last bastion of the Prague Spring

In Moscow in August 1968, when Brezhnev demanded he install a 'workers'-peasants' government,' Svoboda replied that he would put a bullet in his own head unless Dubček and the reformist leaders were released.

A World War I veteran who deserted the Austro-Hungarian army for the Czechoslovak Legion, Svoboda organized the 1st Czechoslovak Army Corps in the USSR during World War II and emerged a national hero, liberating his homeland from the east. As Minister of Defense, he declared in February 1948 that 'the army will not march against the people,' enabling the Communist takeover, only to be purged and spend the 1950s imprisoned and in obscurity. Elected president in March 1968 on Dubček's recommendation, he consented to the Prague Spring reforms; after the Warsaw Pact invasion that August, he flew to Moscow and threatened to shoot himself in Brezhnev's presence unless the kidnapped reform leaders were freed. During normalization he passively acquiesced to the muzzling of the press and Dubček's removal, remaining in office until a constitutional provision forced him out in 1975.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

How did a Moravian farmer become a soldier in Russia?

Ludvík Svoboda was born on 25 November 1895 in Hroznatín, a highland village on the border of Bohemia and Moravia in Austria-Hungary, the third child of a farming family. His father was killed by a horse's kick when Ludvík was one, and he grew up with a stepfather after his mother remarried. After the town school he studied agriculture at the provincial agricultural school in Velké Meziříčí and trained at a vineyard in Austria. He was set to become a farmer.

In 1915 he and his elder brother Josef were conscripted into the Austro-Hungarian army; Josef went to the Serbian front and Ludvík to the Russian. That September he was taken prisoner by the Russians near Tarnopol in Galicia. Many Czech soldiers in the Austro-Hungarian army saw no reason to fight for the Habsburgs and surrendered or were captured. He worked in the Kiev city fire brigade and in August 1916 volunteered for the Czechoslovak Legion.

The Legion was formed from Czech and Slovak prisoners and émigrés in Russia to fight on the Entente side, with Czechoslovak independence as its aim. Svoboda fought at Zborov in July 1917 and at Bakhmach in Ukraine against the Germans in March 1918. The Legion then moved east along the Trans-Siberian Railway, intending to reach the Western Front, and clashed with the Bolshevik government; Svoboda took part in the fighting with the Red Army over the railway. This revolt of the Legion was one of the triggers that turned the Russian Civil War into full-scale war. In the Legion he was promoted to lieutenant and captain in 1919.

He came home in 1920 on one of the last transports, via Japan, the Pacific, the Panama Canal and the United States. During the war his brother Josef had died in the Austrian army after being punished for disobedience by being hung by his bound hands in the burning sun. Svoboda took over the farm, but in 1921, when the deposed Emperor Charles tried to regain the Hungarian throne, he was mobilised again and as a result stayed on in the new Czechoslovak army.

Between the wars he served with the 3rd Infantry Regiment in Kroměříž and, from 1923 to 1931, with the 36th Regiment in Uzhhorod in Subcarpathian Ruthenia, then the eastern end of Czechoslovakia. There he learned Hungarian, passed an examination at the university in Bratislava, and taught Hungarian at the Military Academy in Hranice from 1931 to 1934. In 1923 he married Irena Stratilová; they had a son, Miroslav, and a daughter, Zoe. Promoted to lieutenant colonel in 1934, he returned to Kroměříž, and during the Munich crisis of 1938 he led a mobilised battalion to the border. When German troops occupied the Czech lands on 15 March 1939, he had to hand over the Kroměříž barracks to a German colonel.

How did he build a Czechoslovak army on Soviet soil?

After the German occupation Svoboda joined the resistance organisation Defence of the Nation and in June 1939 crossed secretly into Poland. Few officers of his age and rank left wives and children behind in this way. As the oldest and most senior officer he led the exiled soldiers in a camp at Kraków, and within three months 1,200 airmen had been sent on to France. When Germany crushed Poland in September 1939, he led more than 700 officers and men, unarmed and in civilian clothes, into asylum in the Soviet Union; going to Romania risked being handed over to the Germans.

Because the Soviet Union then had a non-aggression pact with Germany, the unit was interned. The camps were neither prisoner-of-war camps nor labour camps, and the men lived by Czechoslovak army regulations. For two years, with no Czechoslovak diplomatic mission on Soviet soil, Svoboda in effect conducted negotiations with the Soviet authorities. He kept the unit together and, with Soviet help, sent 662 men as well as women and children in twelve transports to Czechoslovak forces in France, Britain and the Middle East.

Germany's invasion of the USSR in June 1941 changed everything. On 18 July the government-in-exile and the Soviet Union signed an agreement allowing a separate Czechoslovak unit to be raised in the USSR. Shortly before, Svoboda had been detained by Soviet counter-intelligence and accused of espionage over contacts with a diplomat of the Slovak puppet state, then cleared. Some historians speculate that he committed himself to cooperate with Soviet intelligence at this time, but according to the state of research summarised in the Czech Wikipedia no evidence for this has been found. In 1942 he co-signed a report on Czechoslovak citizens held in Soviet camps, and he clashed sharply with the Soviet side for delaying the agreement and with the pro-Soviet ambassador Zdeněk Fierlinger.

In early 1942 at Buzuluk in the southern Urals he formed an independent field battalion from volunteers gathered from all over the USSR. He accepted not only Czechs and Slovaks but Rusyns from Subcarpathian Ruthenia, Jews, German and Hungarian anti-fascists with Czechoslovak citizenship and, against regulations, women. With Rusyns released from Soviet camps, Slovaks captured while fighting on the German side and Volhynian Czechs, the battalion grew into a brigade and then an army corps. It was the largest Czechoslovak unit abroad and fought longest on the Eastern Front.

In March 1943 his battalion made its name holding off a German counterattack at Sokolovo near Kharkov. In November his brigade took part in the liberation of Kiev, and he was made a brigadier general. In September 1944, after the first attempt to force the Dukla Pass in the Carpathians failed, Soviet Marshal Konev made him commander of the 1st Czechoslovak Army Corps. Dukla was the largest battle in the history of the Czechoslovak army, and at heavy cost the corps set foot on home soil in October 1944. Around then he learned that his only son, Miroslav, not yet eighteen, had been murdered in the Mauthausen concentration camp; his wife's brothers and mother also died in the camps. His wife and daughter, hunted by the Gestapo after sheltering parachutists in 1941, spent the rest of the war in hiding in Moravia.

What did the defence minister's 'neutrality' in February 1948 mean, and why was he purged?

When President Beneš formed the first post-liberation government at Košice in eastern Slovakia on 4 April 1945, Svoboda became Minister of National Defence as a non-party figure. Welcomed as a hero of the Eastern Front, he was to build a new army from the home and foreign resistance under the Košice Government Programme. The programme took the Red Army as a model, and, unlike before the war, party politics entered the army. In the 1946 elections the Communists became the largest party with about 38 percent.

On 20 February 1948 twelve non-Communist ministers resigned over Communist control of the police. They expected President Beneš to refuse their resignations and sympathetic army commanders to back them. Instead the Communists brought tens of thousands of supporters and the armed People's Militias onto the streets and organised a general strike. Svoboda kept the army out of the political dispute; he is reported to have said that "the army will not march against the people". On 25 February Beneš accepted Gottwald's Communist-dominated cabinet, and the Communist takeover was complete without bloodshed.

How to judge this "neutrality" is still argued. Critics hold that by not moving the army he in effect abetted a Communist coup. Czech researchers point out that the army could act only on orders from the defence minister and the president, that both Beneš and Svoboda held to the principle of keeping the army out of domestic politics, and that individual units acting on their own would have risked civil war. The extent of Communist influence already inside the army is also taken into account. Svoboda joined the Communist Party in November 1948. It has been claimed that he was a secret member earlier, but the historian Karel Kaplan stated that his name is not on the list of secret members.

After February a sweeping "purge" of the army followed. By February 1949, 2,965 of some 13,000 officers had been dismissed, most of them guilty of nothing. The man who actually drove it was Bedřich Reicin, from military counter-intelligence. Svoboda objected to Rudolf Slánský's plan to make Reicin his deputy, calling him "a dictator and an evil, vindictive man", but was overruled. Reicin himself later testified that Svoboda had been the "main brake" on the purge, complaining that he protected Western-trained soldiers and old Legion comrades. Some historians, on the other hand, criticise him for not standing up for his long-time comrades in arms and hold that as minister he bore political responsibility for the purge.

In April 1950 he was removed as defence minister and made deputy prime minister and head of the sports committee, and in September 1951 he lost that post as well. Slánský reported to Moscow in 1951 that it had been a mistake to leave him so long in key positions and that he had been removed "on the urgent advice of Comrade Stalin". In November 1952, during the Slánský trial, he was arrested on material assembled by Reicin, but was released in December after intervention from Moscow. Meanwhile his stepbrother's family and his mother were evicted from their home village. He worked on the local collective farm. After Stalin's death he was rehabilitated in 1954 at Khrushchev's wish and headed the Klement Gottwald Military Academy from 1955 to 1958. He then wrote his memoirs and petitioned for the rehabilitation of soldiers who had been unjustly punished. In 1965 he was made a Hero of the Soviet Union.

What did the president do in the face of the invasion of August 1968?

When Antonín Novotný stepped down in March 1968 during the Prague Spring, the party's First Secretary Alexander Dubček put Svoboda forward for president on the recommendation of the Union of Anti-Fascist Fighters. On 30 March he was elected with 282 of 288 votes, the first Communist-era president chosen by secret ballot rather than acclamation. A war hero who had also been a victim of the purges of the 1950s, he was acceptable to Czechs and Slovaks alike. After his election he laid flowers at the graves of Masaryk and Beneš as well as Gottwald's.

The presidency had no direct power over domestic or foreign policy, but he used its authority to support the Dubček leadership's reforms, especially the rehabilitation of those unjustly punished in the 1950s. As pressure from the other Warsaw Pact states grew, he attended the Soviet–Czechoslovak talks at Čierna nad Tisou at the end of July; according to Soviet premier Kosygin, he warned that military intervention would damage relations between the two peoples for years. Meeting Soviet ambassador Stepan Chervonenko on 17 August, he again said an invasion would be a "catastrophe".

On the night of 20 August, when Chervonenko informed him that Warsaw Pact troops were entering the country, he protested that he had not invited them and that all responsibility lay with the Soviet Union. The next morning Dubček, premier Černík, parliamentary chairman Smrkovský, Kriegel and others were seized by Soviet organs and taken to the USSR. As the only state leader left, Svoboda backed defence minister Martin Dzúr, who ordered the army not to resist; against more than half a million heavily armed troops, military resistance was unthinkable.

The same day pro-Soviet figures including Alois Indra demanded that the president appoint a new "workers' and peasants' revolutionary government", which would have lent credence to the Soviet claim that Czechoslovak Communist hardliners had requested the invasion. Svoboda refused, and also refused a variant in which he himself would head the government. Instead he proposed to negotiate directly in Moscow and made the release of the arrested leaders and their inclusion in the delegation his condition for sitting down at the table. According to English-language accounts, he threatened to shoot himself in Brezhnev's presence unless they were freed. His demand was met, and the Soviets had to negotiate with the legitimate pre-invasion leadership rather than a puppet government. When the talks ended he refused to return to Prague without Kriegel, who had refused to sign, and had him brought along.

The result, however, was the Moscow Protocol. Kept secret, it allowed the "temporary stay" of Warsaw Pact troops and halted the reforms. Some members of the delegation criticised Svoboda for pressing too hard, out of fear of bloodshed, for quick acceptance of Soviet terms. Others point to a letter from parliament, the government and the emergency party congress in Prague warning that tension between the occupiers and citizens had reached a dangerous level and asking for a swift settlement. He believed to the end that his choice had saved many lives.

Was the president of the normalisation years a resister or a conformist?

Back from Moscow, Svoboda believed that even with the protocol accepted, part of the reform could be saved. He gathered reform-minded experts in economics, law, international relations and culture as presidential advisers. In his speech for the republic's fiftieth anniversary on 28 October 1968 he honoured Masaryk, Beneš and Štefánik, and on 30 October at Bratislava Castle he signed the law federalising the state into Czech and Slovak republics. Federalisation was almost the only Prague Spring reform to survive normalisation.

When the student Jan Palach set himself on fire in January 1969 demanding an end to censorship, Svoboda said in a radio address that as a soldier he respected Palach's courage but could not agree with expressing political views in this way, and begged young people to stop such acts.

When Dubček was replaced by Gustáv Husák as party First Secretary in April 1969, Svoboda supported the change. He expected that Husák, himself imprisoned in the 1950s, would prevent new political trials, complete the rehabilitations and preserve part of the reforms. English-language accounts judge that he helped muzzle the press and contributed to Dubček's replacement. But Husák asserted the party's leading role and reduced the president to a second-rank partner. In early 1970 the presidential advisory body was dissolved on Husák's instructions; a new edition of his memoir Cestami života (Paths of Life) was banned and the prepared second volume pulped. When the party vetting expelled more than 400,000 members, he tried to save some of them without success.

He was re-elected in March 1973, but he had already suffered a stroke in 1972, and a pulmonary embolism and further strokes in 1974 left him unable to carry out his duties. Some historians say he clung to office; according to his daughter Zoe, it was Husák who refused his resignation, citing the lack of a successor. In 1975 a constitutional act (No. 50/1975) allowed parliament to elect a successor if the president had been unable to serve for more than a year, and Husák himself became president, reviving the combination of the top party and state posts so criticised in 1968.

Svoboda died in Prague on 20 September 1979. He was given a state funeral, and although the public was not mobilised, thousands of citizens came to see him off. To the end he argued that his submission before Brezhnev had saved many lives from "immense consequences", invoking the horrors of the two world wars. Czech scholars remain divided: some see him as sharing responsibility for normalisation, others hold that he had no power to change it in the face of the party apparatus. After the Velvet Revolution most Communist-era leaders' names were removed from the streets, but squares and streets in the Czech Republic and Slovakia still bear his.