post-truth · 1992–present

Post-truth (politics)

탈진실 (정치)

A term for circumstances in which appeals to emotion and personal belief are more influential than objective facts in shaping public opinion. The American playwright Steve Tesich is thought to have first used it in 1992; it spread widely through the 2016 referendum on Britain leaving the European Union (Brexit) and the US presidential election, and was named Oxford Dictionaries' word of the year. Beyond meaning that there are more lies, it points to a state in which telling true from false has itself come to matter little in politics. Its causes are debated: social media and political marketing, distrust of institutions, and the responsibility of philosophies that have spoken of truth as socially constructed.

In depth

What question does it answer?

At election time a claim is shown to be false again and again by newspapers and experts, yet the side that made it keeps repeating it, and its supporters believe it all the more. There were lies before too. But if nothing happens when a lie is exposed, is this the same thing as before or something different?

"Post-truth" names this changed situation. Oxford Dictionaries defines it as "relating to and denoting circumstances in which objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief." The "post-" here means less that truth has vanished than that this is an age after truth stopped mattering.

relating to and denoting circumstances in which objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief.

When and how did the term spread?

According to Oxford Dictionaries, the first to use the term may have been the Serbian-American playwright Steve Tesich. In a 1992 essay in The Nation, looking back after Watergate on press coverage of the Iran–Contra affair and the Gulf War, he wrote that "we, as a free people, have freely decided that we want to live in some post-truth world". In 2004 Ralph Keyes published a book titled The Post-Truth Era.

The term spread widely in 2016. In Britain's referendum on leaving the European Union, the Leave campaign kept repeating the claim that EU membership cost £350 million a week despite repeated rebuttals. The justice secretary Michael Gove said in an interview that the British people had "had enough of experts". In the US presidential election of the same year Donald Trump was elected. Oxford Dictionaries named the term its word of the year, citing a twentyfold increase in use over the previous year, and the Society for the German Language chose "postfaktisch" as its word of the year the same year. In January 2017 Trump's White House counsellor Kellyanne Conway caused a stir by defending a false statement about the size of the inauguration crowd as "alternative facts".

How does it differ from lying?

Philosophers have noted that post-truth differs from simple lying. In On Bullshit, written in 1986 and published as a book in 2005, Harry Frankfurt distinguished the liar from the "bullshitter". The liar knows the truth and tries to hide it, so still cares about the truth. The bullshitter has no interest at all in whether what he says is true or false.

The philosopher Byung-Chul Han calls this a "new nihilism". Lying is possible only where the distinction between true and false is intact. Fake news, however, is not lying; it attacks facticity itself. He held that when Trump says whatever suits him, he is not a classic liar knowingly distorting reality but is indifferent to the truth of facts.

Earlier, in "Lying in Politics", published in The New York Review of Books in November 1971 and collected in Crises of the Republic the next year, an essay on the thoroughgoing political deception unveiled by the leaking of the Pentagon Papers in 1971, Hannah Arendt analysed "defactualisation", the inability to tell fact from fiction. She stressed how vulnerable factual truth is: "Factual truths are never compellingly true." Facts carry no necessity to be as they are, so they easily give way before organised lying.

Factual truths are never compellingly true.

Does philosophy bear some responsibility?

Some critics have charged that philosophies doubting truth laid the intellectual foundations of post-truth. Friedrich Nietzsche, who held that truth arises from the human will that sets values, is often called a forerunner, and Bruno Latour, who held that scientific facts stand on the network of institutions and practices that produce them, has been criticised for contributing to post-truth's intellectual foundations. English Wikipedia notes that Latour, and Foucault too, drew attention to the institutional and practical conditions under which knowledge is produced. But it also reports the rejoinder that it is a misreading to say Latour does not believe in reality or holds truth to be relative. Asking under what conditions knowledge arises is not the same as saying facts do not matter.

The question connects with other entries on this site. Foucault's power/knowledge and standpoint theory say that knowledge is not free of power and social position, but they did not abandon the distinction between fact and falsehood. Sandra Harding's "strong objectivity", put forward in place of relativism, is an example.

Where do the causes lie?

Causes cited for post-truth include distrust of parties, governments, news media and social media, and a media environment in which anyone can produce and spread writing that looks like news. In Post-Democracy (2004) Colin Crouch analysed a politics in which elections exist but public debate has become a spectacle managed by teams of professional persuaders, and he attributed the crisis of trust and the charges of dishonesty to the "advertising industry model" of political communication. Some research places post-truth politics in the context of "promotional capitalism".

There are other views too. Gillett points out that the term "post-truth" conflates empirical and ethical judgements, and sees the supposed post-truth movement as in fact a rebellion against "expert economic opinion becoming a surrogate for values-based political judgements". On the side of those worried about post-truth, the historian Timothy Snyder's warning is often quoted: "Post-truth is pre-fascism."

Post-truth is pre-fascism

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. de.wikipedia.org
  4. fr.wikipedia.org
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. nybooks.com
  9. Wikipedia (EN)