Философская дискуссия 1947 года · 1947.01–06.25

1947 Soviet philosophy discussion

1947년 철학 토론

A nationwide philosophy discussion held twice in 1947 by the Soviet Communist Party over Georgy Aleksandrov's textbook History of West European Philosophy. When the January session was judged inadequate, Andrei Zhdanov himself reopened it from 16 to 25 June, and his speech fixed the task of Soviet philosophy and the framework for writing the history of philosophy. Aleksandrov lost his post as head of Agitation and Propaganda, and the journal Voprosy filosofii was founded with the record of the discussion as its first issue.

In depth

Why did one philosophy textbook become a political event?

Imagine that within months of a textbook winning a major prize, a leading figure of the ruling party comes forward to rebuke its author before 500 people. One would suspect some reason beyond the book's being wrong. The 1947 Soviet philosophy discussion was such an event. Moreover it did not stop at one author: it settled how the history of philosophy was to be written in the Soviet Union.

The author, Georgy Aleksandrov, was head of the Central Committee's Directorate of Propaganda and Agitation and stood at the top of Soviet ideological management. His History of West European Philosophy came out in early 1946 in 5,000 copies and was approved as a university textbook; it won a Stalin Prize that November, and he soon became a full member of the Academy of Sciences. But a mine already lay in the philosophical world. In May 1944 the Central Committee had condemned volume 3 of the History of Philosophy, edited by Aleksandrov and others, for gross errors in assessing classical German philosophy. On 18 November 1946 the philosophy professor Zinovy Beletsky wrote to Stalin charging that this textbook too ignored the 1944 decision. Stalin's criticism came in December.

How did the two sessions proceed?

In January 1947, on Aleksandrov's instruction, his deputies Mikhail Iovchuk and Pyotr Fedoseyev organised a discussion at the Institute of Philosophy, with Stalin's secretary Poskrebyshev in the presidium. In April the Central Committee judged this discussion inadequate and entrusted a new one to Zhdanov. As Zhdanov put it, the first had been pale and ineffective, so people from the republics and large cities as well as from Moscow had to be brought in.

The second session was held from 16 to 25 June with about 500 present, including the Central Committee secretaries Alexei Kuznetsov and Mikhail Suslov. Zhdanov spoke on the 24th. According to the published material he sent the draft to Stalin in advance, and Stalin returned it, saying "It came out not badly", telling him to divide it into two chapters, on the textbook and on the philosophical front, and correcting phrases. So the speech was not Zhdanov's personal word but an official position that had passed through Stalin's approval.

Вышло не плохо.

Personnel changes after the discussion were quick. On 17 September Suslov became head of Agitation and Propaganda, and Fedoseyev's post went to Dmitri Shepilov. Five days later Aleksandrov became director of the Institute of Philosophy. So it was a demotion and not ruin. He served as Soviet minister of culture in 1954–1955.

What did Zhdanov demand?

Zhdanov's criticism concerned the framework of the history of philosophy more than specific errors of the textbook. The textbook treated Marx and Engels as a continuation of earlier philosophical schools. He criticised this as a "history of one school replacing another". With Marxism, he held, philosophy entered a new period: "With the appearance of Marxism as the scientific world view of the proletariat, the old period of the history of philosophy ends."

С появлением марксизма как научного миросозерцания пролетариата кончается старый период истории философии

He held that the history of philosophy must be written as the history of the origin of the scientific materialist world view. Aleksandrov's error was to borrow the eye of bourgeois historians who see a philosopher first as a colleague and only then as an opponent; that is, "objectivism". Lenin, he said, had taught that materialism includes partisanship. This claim connects directly with the entry "Partisanship in philosophy".

He also turned his fire on Soviet philosophers as a whole: "Is our philosophical front like a real front?" It was more like a bivouac far from the battlefield. The weapons were rusting and the soldiers fought at their own risk, he said.

А разве наш философский фронт похож на настоящий фронт?

A short passage on physics also had a large later influence. After criticising Arthur Eddington and Arthur Milne, he said that the "Kantian contortions of modern bourgeois atomic physicists" led to the "free will" of the electron and to attempts to depict matter only as a collection of waves.

кантианские выверты современных буржуазных атомных физиков

He added that philosophers should analyse and generalise the results of natural science, following Engels. Alexei Kojevnikov's study points out that Western Sovietology misread this passage as proof that Soviet ideology opposed quantum mechanics itself (see "Soviet debate on the interpretation of quantum mechanics"). Sergei Suvorov, acting head of the Central Committee science section and a physicist by education, had warned in advance that the expression could be misread.

How did Voprosy filosofii come about?

There is a paradox in Zhdanov's speech. Answering those present who said a philosophical journal was needed, he expressed "a certain doubt", citing the sad experience of the prewar Under the Banner of Marxism.

Есть известное сомнение в необходимости создания такого журнала.

Yet the journal soon appeared. Kojevnikov counts the founding of Voprosy filosofii as the discussion's immediate consequence. Appearing from July 1947, its first issue printed the record of the discussion verbatim, and its second carried Moisei Markov's article on the philosophy of physics. The founding editor was the chemist-turned-philosopher Bonifaty Kedrov, whom Leonid Kogan described as a philosopher of a freer way of thinking. But in 1949 Kedrov and several editors had to leave, and the journal under its new editor Dmitri Chesnokov threw its effort into "the struggle against cosmopolitanism". Ilyenkov's "The Problem of the Ideal" later appeared in this journal too.

Why did Zhdanov step in, and how has it been judged?

Interpretations of the cause divide. The philosopher Ogurtsov held that the discussion was far from scholarly and was dominated by a style of abuse and political labels. He held that the outcome was to destroy the last island of philosophical work. Kamensky judged that the speech played a "deeply reactionary" role for Soviet history of philosophy: three new dogmas, that philosophy became a science only with Marxist philosophy, that philosophy's object changes, and that all other sciences branched off from philosophy, were added and became standards for university teaching and articles.

There are opposing judgements too. The public Russian post used in this entry for quoting the speech calls Zhdanov a "great Soviet Bolshevik" and thinks highly of the speech. The discussion remains an object of divided judgement.

It can also be compared with similar events of the late Stalin period: the cultural controls called "Zhdanovshchina", "Lysenkoism" in genetics in 1948, and the "1950 Soviet linguistics debate". Among these the linguistics debate proceeded as an open discussion whose conclusion was not known in advance, in contrast to this one.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (RU)
  2. vk.ru
  3. teletype.in
  4. history.ubc.ca
  5. Wikipedia (RU)
  6. Wikipedia (RU)
  7. Wikipedia (RU)