Taiwanese Cultural Association
대만문화협회
The cultural enlightenment society of Taiwanese intellectuals founded in Taipei on 17 October 1921 by Lin Hsien-tang, Chiang Wei-shui and others. Under the aim of "raising Taiwanese culture" and with the Taiwan Minpao as its organ, it ran lecture meetings, newspaper reading rooms, plays and film shows, and was also a political body nurturing Taiwanese collective consciousness. When the left won in January 1927 and introduced a chairman system, the right left to found the Taiwanese People's Party, and the "New Cultural Association" led by Lien Wen-ching and Wang Min-chuan turned to the workers' and farmers' movements. It collapsed in 1931.
In depth
The association rose where armed resistance had ended. After twenty years of armed risings from 1895 came to a close in 1915, young Taiwanese studying in Japan began to see colonial rule as one case of the world's colonial question. Taishō democracy had loosened speech inside Japan and national self-determination was in the air after the First World War; the Chinese Wikipedia writes that what moved the students to act was Korea's March First Movement of 1919. In January 1920 the New People's Society was formed in Tokyo with Lin Hsien-tang as president and published the monthly Taiwan Youth, and from the end of 1920 a movement began to petition the Imperial Diet for a Taiwanese parliament. The Cultural Association took up this current on the island.
Its members were doctors, lawyers, teachers and businessmen. It grew from the search for a new road by intellectuals who judged, after the Tapani rising of 1915, that the price of armed struggle was too high. Its founding meeting was held at the Jingxiu girls' school in Dadaocheng, and around its founding Chiang Wei-shui's "Clinical Lecture" diagnosed Taiwan as a patient suffering from intellectual malnutrition.
The founding meeting was attended by 1,031 people. Asked by the head of the Government-General's police bureau whether any members were connected with political movements, Chiang Wei-shui answered that the association would "absolutely not engage in such conduct", and so won approval. Lin Hsien-tang became president and Chiang managing director. Because many people could not read, lecture meetings were the main activity, and the audiences of 1925 and 1926 together came to 230,000. The association kept newspaper reading rooms in some ten places, among them Taipei, Hsinchu, Taichung and Tainan, ran a summer school at Lin Hsien-tang's mansion from 1924, and in 1925 Tsai Pei-huo bought educational films in Tokyo and formed a travelling film unit.
Though barred from politics, the association was the parent body of social movements on and off the island. Its members led, as individuals, the petition movement for a Taiwanese parliament, and on 16 December 1923 the Government-General charged that movement's league under the Public Order and Police Law and detained, searched or summoned 99 people (the Public Order Police Incident). Well-known Japanese lawyers crossed over to defend them, and Chiang Wei-shui and Tsai Pei-huo were sentenced to four months; but the public trial increased the signatures on the petition, the audiences at lectures and the sales of the Taiwan Minpao. As the association's work spread to the villages, the cane farmers of Erlin founded Taiwan's first farmers' union in June 1925, and the member and physician Li Ying-chang gave their dispute his full support.
The seed of the split was the socialism that came in from Japan and China. The Chinese Wikipedia sums up four currents that shaped socialism in Taiwan in the 1920s: Yamakawaism and Fukumotoism from Japanese communism, the Three Principles of the People from the Kuomintang, and Leninism from the Chinese Communist Party. Lien Wen-ching corresponded with Yamakawa Hitoshi and met him secretly in Tokyo in 1924; Chiang Wei-shui was most influenced by the Three Principles; and Weng Tse-sheng and Cai Xiaoqian, who had studied at Shanghai University, were members of the Chinese Communist Party. The left wanted the association to support social movements directly and move towards a party, while the right around Lin Hsien-tang and Tsai Pei-huo wished to keep to cultural enlightenment. The left won at the extraordinary congress in the Taichung Public Hall on 3 January 1927. On the very next day the police bureau wrote, in a "Policy on the Cultural Association" submitted to the Governor-General, that pressure from outside would only unite it and that the best course was to let internal strife bring it to break apart by itself. The New Cultural Association went on to back the Farmers' Union's disputes and, with the founding of the Taipei Machinists' Union in March 1927, turned to the labour movement.
After the split, Lien Wen-ching, close to Yamakawa Hitoshi's line, and the Taiwanese Communist Party fought over union strategy inside the New Cultural Association, and Lien was expelled in November 1929. Wang Min-chuan became chairman in January 1931, but the crackdown that year destroyed the organisation.
The sharpest issue between Lien Wen-ching and the Taiwanese Communist Party was union strategy. Lien wanted a Taiwan General Labour Union that would first unite the left unions from above against the Taiwan Workers' General Federation aligned with the Taiwanese People's Party; Wang Min-chuan argued for a unity league joining left and right unions from below. The label fixed on Lien differs by source. The Chinese Wikipedia article on the association assigns Lien to Yamakawaism and Wang to Fukumotoism, but its article on Lien says that the Communist Party's 1928 programme first criticised him as a "Fukumotoist" and that, after the Japanese party's correction and the change of line following the Comintern's Sixth Congress, it called him a "left social democrat" and a "Yamakawaist" instead. The vocabulary of the Japanese left's debate thus served directly as a weapon in Taiwan's factional fight. Lien, once expelled, left the social movement for good, and the association became a front organisation of the Taiwanese Communist Party.
Su Xin, a leading member of the Communist Party, looked back on the split late in life.
The Cultural Association was by nature a mass organisation of the anti-Japanese united front of every stratum in Taiwan, not a political party.
It should not, he wrote, have been split by "theoretical struggle" over Marxism and left or right social democracy in an attempt to dress it in a political coat of a single colour.